What companies are actively doing BSD developement? reddit / BSD ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ohet · 2013-01-07 21:56 Is there any list of companies doing actual *BSD developement? What are these companies and what are they using *BSDs for? [LWN.net](https://lwn.net/Articles/507986/) and [Linux Foundation](http://go.linuxfoundation.org/who-writes-linux-2012) has released such statistics quite a long time for Linux for example. I found a lists of commercial entities providing some sort of support for [FreeBSD](http://www.freebsd.org/commercial/) (many of the links are down like usual) but nothing about actual developement. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- DexManus · 2013-01-07 23:05 https://signup.netflix.com/openconnect/software ---------------------------------------------------------------------- vext01 · 2013-01-08 00:25 A company called 'conformal systems' maintain a fork of openbsd called bitrig. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- brynet · 2013-01-08 00:33 There is no formal list of corporate contributors, but they number in the thousands. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ohet · 2013-01-08 00:46 Contributors in what sense? There doesn't seem to be terribly much developement going on in any of the major *BSD code wise so "thousands of corporate contributors" is quite clearly out of the question. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ohet · 2013-01-08 00:49 Interesting. I always wondered what the deal with Bitrig was but never took the time to look into it. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- eberkut · 2013-01-08 01:00 Nothing as detailed as Linux exists as fair as I know but take a look at these regarding FreeBSD: http://www.freebsdfoundation.org/testimonials.shtml http://www.freebsdfoundation.org/donate/sponsors.shtml ---------------------------------------------------------------------- X-Istence · 2013-01-08 01:24 Please define "much development" ... ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ohet · 2013-01-08 02:45 Looking at release notes from various BSD projects, checking [Ohloh](h ttps://www.ohloh.net/p/compare?project_0=FreeBSD&project_1=NetBSD&proj ect_2=DragonFly+BSD) stats, the news buzz, the adoption and innovation happening in the scene I find it hard come in to any other conclusion. The possible lack of knowledge on my part is the reason why I asked the question here in the first place. I mean even if some companies are actually doing substantial developement on some of the BSD operating systems it sure ain't visible. Saying that *BSDs do not get "much developement" might be bit harsh but in comparison to Linux for example it's putting it lightly. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- NancyReaganTesticles · 2013-01-08 03:27 > it sure ain't visible. how do you reckon? by source commits? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ohet · 2013-01-08 03:41 No. Just that there doesn't seem to be any "FreeBSD company" (aside from maybe iXsystems) for example like there are many for Linux (Red Hat, SUSE, Canonical, Google...). The corporate presence isn't clear when I visit the sites nor when I quickly try to Google it up. When I actually end up in a site that has somewhat related information the links are dead... and so on. I though about going through some commits but asked here instead. The thing is that no one here has came up with a list either. I guess the links from eberkut is something to start from but hardly what I'm looking for. I for one could list something like twenty major companies doing active Linux developement right now from top of my head because the companies are "visible". I don't have to look for them. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- NancyReaganTesticles · 2013-01-08 03:50 why are you asking here instead of the maintainers of net/free/open/firefly wtfbsd? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- rz2000 · 2013-01-08 03:59 In addition to the monetary donations, there are many that contribute code back into the project. Apple is notable among them, and the FreeBSD security officer on Hacker News [it's appreciated](https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4921093). ---------------------------------------------------------------------- senses3 · 2013-01-08 04:40 This is awesome, I had no idea that existed. Thanks for the link. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- BitingChaos · 2013-01-08 05:03 Hmm. I guess that's incentive to donate more next year - I can get my name higher up on the list. :D ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ashemedai · 2013-01-08 07:11 Depends on what you call BSD development. It comes in many shapes and sizes, some based their product on a specific kernel or the majority of userland (now or in the past), like NetApp or MacOS X. In the past Microsoft used the entire stack and tools for Windows. Video game companies routinely use various include headers, library code or other code segments in order to cut on development cost (e.g. Sony's PlayStation and PlayStation Portable). The main difference is due to the license that clouds use of BSD code in mystery since companies are not obliged to disclose their products use BSD code (as long as documentation has the required information, e.g. http://www.scei.co.jp/ps3-license/index.html ) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- eviltwinkie · 2013-01-08 07:48 This is totally wrong. The reason you dont see a formal list is mainly because unlike the linux model, you are free to do whatever you want with bsd and never be forced to say anything. Everyone from juniper, cisco, netflix, etc, etc use it and develop/contribute. I contract with a few fortune 500's that use it and if you look thru the source you will occasionally see credits. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- phessler · 2013-01-08 08:33 .vantronix funds quite a bit of OpenBSD development. Examples include the ix(4) driver, quite a bit of relayd development, routing domains, af-to, and a bunch of other things. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- AerateMark · 2013-01-08 08:33 Logged in to upvote this comment, you brilliant person! May your path cross with many lovers. [My reaction to it.](http://i.imgur.com/ifYUt.gif) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- phessler · 2013-01-08 08:42 Based on discussions I have had with Conformal employees: while there is significant overlap between Conformal and bitrig, there is no official tie between them, and bitrig contributions happen in their spare time. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- phessler · 2013-01-08 08:52 I know of several OpenBSD committers, where their employer (or self- employment) is directly related to their development efforts. I however, will not out them, as it is not my story to tell. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- vext01 · 2013-01-08 10:35 I stand corrected :) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ohet · 2013-01-08 11:02 Well I think you answered your own question right there. It's a llot easier and less formal. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- icantthinkofone · 2013-01-08 11:34 You don't hear about it as much because most Linux development is on desktop software while most FreeBSD development is for the server. Most anything Linux runs, FreeBSD can also run and, in most cases, run it faster than Linux can due to architectural differences. But server development isn't as sexy as bells, whistles, blinking lights and explosions. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ohet · 2013-01-08 11:34 You don't have to do upstream Linux developement or say anything either but last year over four hundred companies decided to do so anyway. Only thing you _have_ to do is release the kernel sources when you _distribute_ the binaries. Companies have and can have their own inhouse propietary solutions based on Linux if they so desire. Are you honesly saying that there are thousands of companies doing *BSD developement when all of the *BSD projects combined haven't had so many contributors in their life time? How do you come to this number? I'm personally aware of about a ten. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ohet · 2013-01-08 11:42 You are completely misinformed. Most of the Linux developement last year were for embedded systems and servers. IBM, Oracle, Intel, Google and Red Hat have for years been among the largest if not largest contributors to Linux kernel. All of them focus on servers and to some extent embedded system. Red Hat does pretty much everything but desktop is hardly a focus. The rising stars have been Texas Instuments, Samsung and Linaro for their work on ARM. The area of embedded systems huge thanks to Android, home electronics and IVI systems where Linux dominates. You kinda have to come with a source for you claim that that it can run faster because of some hypothetical architectual differences. I know that it was said in early 2000s but things have changed, a lot. If FreeBSD ever was faster than Linux it probably isn't anymore because the sheer difference in developement activity and in the fact that Linux is the dominant operating system in servers, especially on stock markets and supercomputers. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ohet · 2013-01-08 12:06 Thanks. That was exactly what I was looking for. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- mO4GV9eywMPMw3Xr · 2013-01-08 12:09 "$250,000+" from an "Anonymous Donor" ---------------------------------------------------------------------- liveoneggs · 2013-01-08 12:52 juniper, google, and sony I know for sure ---------------------------------------------------------------------- eviltwinkie · 2013-01-08 13:00 You get sued if you release anything touching linux and dont go screaming "LINUX LINUX LINUX LINUX". Yes, thousands of people and companies worldwide use/develop under BSD. You simply are not required to say so. Since I have to develop products in both platforms, I see and know personally contributors for both linux and BSD. Just because you have thousands of tiny undocumented changes or a chaotic development by thousands of amateur contributors does not a mean its any better. Linux cant even get its man pages to remain correct or keep compatibility with well known standards. BSD on the other hand is the basis for not just products such as realtime OS's for example, but commonly used in academia, product development, and other venues which require stability, code correctness, well documented, and standards adhering development. This is why they get money whenever they want. Thousands of people and companies support it because thousands of people and companies develop and rely on it. Difference is you dont have to be a fanboy trying to troll for linux and can instead be quiet about it. I for example pass my code contributions along to the main commiters which will push the changes into the tree with their name instead of mine. The grown ups in that community simply dont seek attention like the kids in the linux sandbox is all. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- eviltwinkie · 2013-01-08 14:10 Nor would they appreciate it probably. Thanks for that. Good man. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ohet · 2013-01-08 15:20 >You get sued if you release anything touching linux and dont go screaming "LINUX LINUX LINUX LINUX". No you don't. What you have to do is make the source code for the kernel accessible. >Yes, thousands of people and companies worldwide use/develop under BSD There _might_ be thousands of companies using BSD, sure. Developing is a completely different matter. It's absolutely clear from a glance that none of the major BSD operaiting system get even near such ammount of developement. >Just because you have thousands of tiny undocumented changes or a chaotic development by thousands of amateur contributors does not a mean its any better. Get your facts straight. Roughly 85% of Linux developement is done by commercial entities as displayed on the documents I linked in the first post. Linux is probably the best example of higly efficent developement model where hundreds of companies and thousands of people are working in coordination to produce new feature releases every 70 days or so. Here are highlights from the releases from only this year [3.7](http://kernelnewbies.org/Linux_3.7), [3.6](http://kernelnewbies.org/LinuxChanges), [3.5](http://kernelnewbies.org/Linux_3.5), [3.4](http://kernelnewbies.org/Linux_3.4), [3.3](http://kernelnewbies.org/Linux_3.3) and [3.2](http://kernelnewbies.org/Linux_3.2). >BSD on the other hand is the basis for not just products such as realtime OS's for example, but commonly used in academia, product development, and other venues which require stability, code correctness, well documented, and standards adhering development. Altough parts of BSDs are used on realtime operaiting systems Linux is actually capable of realtime [itself](https://rt.wiki.kernel.org/index.php/CONFIG_PREEMPT_RT_Patch) unlike the BSD OSes. There's also [RTLinux](http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RTLinux) and [Xenomai](http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xenomai) that provide different kind of approach to realtime support on Linux. Linux is also run very widely in systems that require absolute stability like 75% of world's [stock exchanges](http://www.efytimes.com/e1/creativenews.asp?edid=71273), [aircrafts](https://lwn.net/Articles/522065/), [USA Navy's unmanned dr ones](http://www.theregister.co.uk/2012/06/08/us_navy_linux_drones/), [industrial robotics](http://www.linuxcnc.org/), [IVI systems](http://www.genivi.org/) and pretty much everything you could ever imagine. If you do [searches](http://academic.research.microsoft.com/) on publications that feature words like Linux, FreeBSD, NetBSD, BSD and so on you will see that almost all academic research focuses on Linux. >This is why they get money whenever they want. Who gets the money? The foundations around *BSD operaiting systems seem small and the financial backing for [FreeBSD](http://www.freebsdfoundation.org/donate/sponsors.shtml) is nothing in comparison with [Linux Foundation](http://www.linuxfoundation.org/about/members) for example. >Difference is you dont have to be a fanboy trying to troll for linux and can instead be quiet about it. Could you enlighten what you mean by that? Who is trolling what? And you lead with this: >The grown ups in that community simply dont seek attention like the kids in the linux sandbox is all. You gotta be kidding me... ---------------------------------------------------------------------- orangetoaster · 2013-01-08 16:15 [iXsystems](http://www.ixsystems.com/), makers of FreeNAS/TrueNAS and PC-BSD contributes to FreeBSD and I believe has some of the FreeBSD RE team on their payroll. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- deelowe · 2013-01-08 16:46 I'm not sure about Google. I thought they are pretty much 100% linux. Do you have anything that gives more info on this? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- vaiii · 2013-01-08 18:41 [genua](http://www.genua.eu) has actively been committing to OpenBSD for quite some time, and still does. Basically anything that goes into their products goes upstream (mostly network related, like socket splicing (sosplice(9)). edit: pm me if you're interested in details ---------------------------------------------------------------------- DexManus · 2013-01-08 21:15 What exactly was the purpose of this whole thread? You don't seem to be interested in the answer to your question at all. Every response has been you defending your position that Linux is better developed than BSD. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- cjg_ · 2013-01-08 21:28 and netapp, isilon ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ohet · 2013-01-08 21:39 So I'm not allowed to correct the misinformation spread about Linux when someone baits for it? Is it so horrible that there's some activity in this subreddit sometimes? I am seemingly not the only one curious about the question anyway. But yes I have the expression that Linux is vastly better developed than BSD. That doesn't mean that I wouldn't be interested in what companies are doing BSD developement. I have checked each and every company pointed out here unless I knew it from before... and no, not every of my responses here have been about defending Linux; please don't exaggerate. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- whetu · 2013-01-08 22:11 I had a Google Mini die on me, it was out of warranty so I pulled the hard drive and hooked it up to my workstation. It was RedHat under the hood. Kace KBOXes are/were BSD based ---------------------------------------------------------------------- DexManus · 2013-01-08 22:14 I'm not trying to say that you are right or wrong, that is a discussion I don't really have time to get in to. I'm just trying to understand what you are trying to accomplish by this thread? Are you trying to make a business case for (or against) BSD? Why do you need/want to know what companies are developing for it. I will say that I think you need to understand a fundamental difference between the BSDs and linux though. Linux is a kernel and only a kernel. Each distribution (Redhat, ubuntu, etc) is merely a combination of numerous pieces of software developed by numerous entities tied together via the kernel. FreeBSD (et al) is actually an entire operating system developed and maintained by the same group of people. They maintain their own core utilities (ls, ping, grep, etc...) and all of the ports/packages are specifically engineered to work with the OS. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- deelowe · 2013-01-08 22:16 I'm not sure I follow. Are you agreeing with me that Google pretty much run's Linux, because RedHat is a linux distro? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- whetu · 2013-01-08 22:28 Yes, I'm backing you up. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ohet · 2013-01-08 22:40 Curiousity. Pure and Simple. I will use the information I have learned here if I ever end up in a discussion conserning the commercial developement and adoption of BSDs. It also helps me understand where BSDs stand in comparison to Linux and other operaiting systems. I'm aware of the key technical differences but the "politics" are still bit blurry to me. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- icantthinkofone · 2013-01-08 23:09 Other than phones, you don't hear about that development either. Same for FreeBSD but FreeBSD doesn't dominate desktops. > You kinda have to come with a source for you claim that that it can run faster because of some hypothetical architectual differences. [It's mentioned here (4.7)](http://www.freebsd.org/doc/en/articles/explaining- bsd/comparing-bsd-and-linux.html) and, iirc, I first read it in The Design and Implementation of the FreeBSD Operating System by McCusick. >I know that it was said in early 2000s but things have changed, a lot. If FreeBSD ever was faster than Linux it probably isn't anymore because the sheer difference in developement activity So you think FreeBSD has just been sitting on its laurels since then? Why would you think FreeBSD has made no improvements? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ohet · 2013-01-08 23:25 >It's mentioned here (4.7)[1] and, iirc, I first read it in The Design and Implementation of the FreeBSD Operating System by McCusick. Yes and where are the benchmarks; the evidence? What Linux distribution was used? What FreeBSD version was used? With what kind of hardware? In what kind of conditions? What tests were used? When were the test concluded? Were there any twin studies? Was the test concluded by a neutral party? Were the results available in the open? You are linking me to a document on a FreeBSD site that says that the operaiting system is better than the competition without any references. It reads as an advertizement. >So you think FreeBSD has just been sitting on its laurels since then? Why would you think FreeBSD has made no improvements? Of course not. The scale of developement just hasn't been nearly as fast as it has been for Linux and unlike FreeBSD Linux has gained a lot market share in supercomputing (94%) and extreme setups like stock exchanges (75%). ---------------------------------------------------------------------- icantthinkofone · 2013-01-09 00:07 You presume too much. Because the fastest computers use Linux you think FreeBSD is unable to achieve the same (it does but don't let that bother you). You also complain that my link to the handbook is an advertisement so there's no satisfying you right away. I'd bet you think only Linux can run search engines because Google uses Linux. I'd bet you think Google chose Linux cause it was better, too. (Sergey or Larry said they chose Linux cause they were familiar with it in school.) Where is your documentation that development on FreeBSD hasn't been nearly as fast? Where are your benchmarks to prove me wrong? Obviously you didn't see Phoronix article either that says [FreeBSD runs Linux games faster.](http://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=article&item=linu x_games_bsd) I can play that game, too. Let's put it this way: 1) I don't have benchmarks myself because I know it's true from past performance tests of my own. 2)People DO say FreeBSD runs Linux faster and people do NOT say it doesn't. 3) Oh blah. This is like a Windows forum...... ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ohet · 2013-01-09 00:25 “That which can be asserted without evidence, can be dismissed without evidence.” -Christopher Hitchens I have gone this trough with you before. The Phoronix test was completely flawed because Ubuntu was running Unity with Compiz and the other was running KDE with KWin. In another Phronix benchmark it was shown that KWin is a lot more efficent that Unity. This is so obvious that can't understand how it can be so hard for you. Here's coupe of benchmarks. [Oracle 6.1 vs FreeBSD 9.0](http://openbenchmarking.org/result/1112113-AR-ORACLELIN37) [DragonFly 3.2 vs FreeBSD 9.0 vs Scietific Linux 6.1](http://lists.dra gonflybsd.org/pipermail/users/attachments/20121010/7996ff88/attachment -0002.pdf) Linux is clearly superior. Altough the benchmarks hardly complete or professional it's still much more to go on that the nothing you have provided so far. Also it doesn't matter what masses say; if they can't provide evidence they are very likely wrong. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- icantthinkofone · 2013-01-09 03:17 >Linux is clearly superior. Altough the benchmarks hardly complete or professional And then you go and diss McKusick's book as without evidence and Phoronix is flawed and then you try and use a test that tests a program, not the OS. That's the struggle I face with you. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ohet · 2013-01-09 10:22 You see books from early 2000s are not "proof" on anything in fast moving markets such as operaiting system. First of all the data is dated. Second of all it also has to have references and if the benchmarks are not available it doesn't mean anything. The [PostgreSQL](http://lists.dragonflybsd.org/pipermail/users/2012- October/017536.html) tests show pretty well how the operaiting system performs compared to others. That's why they are using the same software version on all operaiting systems... You do understand that all test are always done by running some software on top of the operaiting system? Like the flawed gaiming benchmark you linked; it tested games such as Unigine Heaven and OpenArena. Like I said this stuff is _plain obvious_ and I shouldn't need to tell you this. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- liveoneggs · 2013-01-09 17:33 android libc (Bionic) is a derivative of BSD libc, standardizing on NetBSD's libc going forward. I would imagine that most components of android, aside from the kernel, are BSD-derived. much of google's released code is BSD-licensed: (v8 is a good example) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ohet · 2013-01-09 17:59 >I would imagine that most components of android, aside from the kernel, are BSD-derived. I don't think that's the case. Google wrote most of the stuff themselves and those parts are usually licenced under Apache 2.0 like the init system, bootchart, some network stuff, HALs... Then there's few things from the "GNU/Linux" stack like Bluez for bluetooth (they are moving away from it in 4.2 to some new solution). Android doesn't ship with many commandline tools and people tend to install busybox for that so those are mostly ruled out too. There's also some oddities like the fact that Binder (a extension to Linux kernel) originates from BeOS. [Here](https://android.googlesource.com/) is the source code though if you are interested to take a look.