Free Pascal / Lazarus Foundation lazarus / 8-Other ---------------------------------------------------------------------- trev · 2019-06-27 01:55 Does the "Free Pascal and Lazarus Foundation" exist? Its website does not appear to get updated and there's no annual accounts/reports or anything that would indicate activity or life. And contact via Google+ (by invitation) seems a tad out of date. My donation a couple of weeks ago went through via PayPal ostensibly to the "Lazarus Foundation" which I'm assuming is the same entity. Is it? The Wiki was not any more enlightening than the Foundation web site. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- skalogryz · 2019-06-27 02:20 previous discussions on the topic: https://forum.lazarus.freepascal.org/index.php/topic,40770.0.html Per this post from April 2018 https://lists.lazarus-ide.org/pipermail/lazarus/2018-April/234427.html QuoteNo, it is not dead. Why would people suggest that ? For example, Pas2js is actively developed by the foundation. So the foundation's primary target is Javascript! I guess one might think that a foundation is some big- corp-(sponsored)-entity. Yet it in fact it might be quite small group of people. With it's own boundaries on resources. Thus while the foundation does exist it might seem to be as active as any other foundations in software world. Yet, one have to accept, that neither (F)Pascal(C) nor Lazarus are popular either. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- trev · 2019-06-27 05:14 I found something under Legalese on the Foundation website: "The bylaws and official statutory documents of the foundation will be published here, as soon as they have been translated to english." But apparently this has not happened since its founding in 2016. So, transparency zero. Apparently none of the Foundation members participate in the forum either, despite saying on its website: "Get in touch with us:     On the foundation Google+ community, on invitation.     Lazarus/Free Pascal forum   <<<<--------------------     Mail us at: foundation@freepascal.org     Use the contact form" Under News > Accountancy on the site I find: "The foundation will publish the accountancy report at the end of the first three months of 2019 or earlier if possible." No report, of course, and it's now within days of being the end of 6 months of 2019. No reports for 2016, 2017 or 2018 either. To qualify for foundation status in most countries there are certain legal reporting requirements that must be met. Indeed, I just checked the law on Dutch Foundations and they are subject to similar requirements. All very disturbing. Given all this, and the posts on the forum referred to above, I'm not intending to make any further donations to an entity that is unaccountable. No wonder I was not alone in querying whether the Foundation was dead or not. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- skalogryz · 2019-06-27 05:34 Quote from: trev on June 27, 2019, 07:14:13 amAll very disturbing. Given all this, and the posts on the forum referred to above, I'm not intending to make any further donations to an entity that is unaccountable. No wonder I was not alone in querying whether the Foundation was dead or not. send an email to "foundation@freepascal.org". ask. I'd think it's not so bad, it's more lack of resources to keep PR up to date. Michael Van Canneyt and Mark Weustink are active participants of mailing list (for both Lazarus and freepascal) Detlef Overbeek is an editor of Blaise Pascal magazine. I don't think he has an account here. As this page suggests. Pas2js is the primary concern of the foundation. The last of Pas2js was 3 days ago (june 24 2019). So it's happening. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ssliackus · 2019-06-28 20:00 Very good question. I am sending 2 eur monthly donation over paypal and if there is no actual foundation, anyone can take my money and use them for personal purposes (I am not saying that anyone doing this, but it would be much easier). I would not be happy if that happens, but that is very common problem (not having organisation and structure behind) for many open source projects, even strong ones. By not having formal organisation, project looses many financial and organisational benefits. This means, that there is less transparency, less control or effectiveness pursuing goals. Corporate donors are not willing to donate if there is no organisation, because they will loose tax relief that many countries provide for donors (for UK that is 25% of your donation). Additionally, organisations can apply for many local and international grants, easier participate in school/university programs, make use of many alternative funding sources. Continuation of projects activities if something happens to key project members. Case with Voidlinux when one single person had all project passwords and he is simply gone (https://itsfoss.com/void- linux-crisis/). I would strongly advise to have such organisation with separate web page or if that is too complicated, ten join several project under one umbrella organisation. Thank you. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Akira1364 · 2019-06-28 21:35 My issue with the foundation is that several of the things listed on it (such as anonymous functions and attributes) were never funded by foundation donations in the first place, and on top of that are known to be nearly (or entirely) complete already. The most recent patch for attributes was "assigned" to Sven Barth over a year ago on the bugtracker: https://bugs.freepascal.org/view.php?id=33384 Since then, there's been nothing but radio silence on the subject. Stuff like the web assembly backend has made no progress whatsoever, either. The branch for it was essentially created, and then never worked on at all. Basically, there's no way that donating to the foundation is actually helping or going to help any of the listed features get implemented faster (except for Pas2JS, which is an admirable project but not something I'd spend money on.) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- MvC · 2019-06-28 23:01 I can speak for the foundation. It is correct that the foundation website is the least of our priorities. Despite asking several times for volunteers, so far no-one has stepped forward to actually do the work of creating a nice-looking website. I am not a designer of websites. But we're definitely actively working on the progress of FPC/Lazarus - pas2js is taking a lot of resources. Currently generics are under development.   It is generating a small amount of money, but not enough to cover the development costs.   There was a meeting with Mattias about it only yesterday. - We agreed with Karoly Balogh (Charlie) that he will be working on WebAssembly fulltime this summer.   There is still an outstanding bounty for this. - As it happens, I will be posting a new bounty tomorrow. - We're actively looking for someone to finish the work on attributes.   If you know people, tell them to contact us. - if the upcoming Lazarus book sales generates some income, it will be used to further FPC/Lazarus. If you need more transparancy: ask, and you will get answers. There are plenty of invitations to contact us. It's up to you to do so. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- MvC · 2019-06-28 23:14 Quote from: ssliackus on June 28, 2019, 10:00:25 pmVery good question. I am sending 2 eur monthly donation over paypal and if there is no actual foundation, anyone can take my money and use them for personal purposes (I am not saying that anyone doing this, but it would be much easier). I would not be happy if that happens, but that is very common problem (not having organisation and structure behind) for many open source projects, even strong ones. By not having formal organisation, project looses many financial and organisational benefits. This means, that there is less transparency, less control or effectiveness pursuing goals. Corporate donors are not willing to donate if there is no organisation, because they will loose tax relief that many countries provide for donors (for UK that is 25% of your donation). Additionally, organisations can apply for many local and international grants, easier participate in school/university programs, make use of many alternative funding sources. Continuation of projects activities if something happens to key project members. Case with Voidlinux when one single person had all project passwords and he is simply gone (https://itsfoss.com/void- linux-crisis/). I would strongly advise to have such organisation with separate web page or if that is too complicated, ten join several project under one umbrella organisation. Thank you. Your money is being received every month, for which my heartfelt thanks! I can assure you it is not being used for personal gain. Anyone thinking that the moneys are being used for personal gain: this is not so. None of the founders of the foundation get any money. Not a cent. Besides time, we only spend personal money on it, to improve FPC/Lazarus. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- greymont · 2019-06-28 23:37 Those are good answers, @MvC. However, the lack of active presence on the web is only a symptom of a lack of organizational substance. Seems there is no one in the foundation who is skilled at running an organization like this, or perhaps, no one ready and willing to do so. I can think of several reasons this is so. One is the rigidity the principle participants have about conducting business the way they always have. For example, nearly all the rest of the world has moved to embrace git. But you guys say it is not desirable. Well, if I was thinking of joining the effort this position would make me think more than twice. (Moving to use git would help make the project look fresh and alive.) A second reason you may not be getting the help you need is the project looks very wobbly. Many comments made over the years make it look like it is barely getting by, "living of a shoestring", and therefore may be shut down soon. No one wants to join such an effort. (Updating the web site so the project looks successful and alive would help with this a lot!) A third reason you may not be getting the help you need may be because the image of the group is that a small number of principals control nearly all of the project. Without more transparency of process it looks like a tight circle that is hard to break into and not friendly to outsiders. This is where having someone coordinate who is good at explaining what is going on would help enormously. These are just some observations. You have probably heard them before. You will probably reply with the same statements as before. And nothing will change. What, then, will it take to produce meaningful change? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Peter H · 2019-06-29 11:26 I think they dont do good marketing. Because I am a beginner with lazarus (I did Turbopascal 30 years ago, but never delphi), I wanted a good book for introduction. At amazon, most books about lazarus are "currently not available". There are some offers, but these where not what I wanted. I dont buy a book, if I cannot have a look inside, if I cannot see the contents and dont kow the number of pages. Finally I found "Learn to program using Lazarus", which was what I wanted. Now, there was a previev offered, but the link was broken and so I did not buy. At some miracle day, the preview (which was hard to find) worked, I looked inside and purchased the pdf, which I have not regretted. Possibly they should offer their books via Amazon print on demand service, where amazon does the logistic the advertising and offer the "look inside book" and does the print (on demand) and the shipping and has the cost of web traffic and administration. I think they could reach a much larger amount of customers there, beause the offered content is good. If I look to this upcoming new book (which I want to get when ready) I shudder a little bit over 25€ "flatrate shipping". For this price I can order overseas by priority air mail!  For 25€ I can get a 250 sheet (500 pages) Din A4 printed and shipping is free here: https://www.drucksofa.de/preise/ Finally this was the only way for me to get a printed copy of  "Learn to program using Lazarus" I would be glad to support them by purchasing their offerings, but they make it difficult and expensive for me and other customers. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- wp · 2019-06-29 11:32 Quote from: Peter H on June 29, 2019, 01:26:59 pmI dont buy a book, if I cannot have a look inside, if I cannot see the contents and dont kow the number of pages. I just stumbled across a pdf preview of the new Lazarus Handbook which Michael mentioned above: https://www.blaisepascalmagazine.eu/preview- of-the-pdf-file-of-the-lazarus-handbook/ ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Peter H · 2019-06-29 11:36 Yes, but the preview for  "Learn to program using Lazarus" is gone.... They must improve their marketing. Its not about the products, these are good. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ssliackus · 2019-06-29 12:08 Thank you @Mvc, for response. I am not blaming anyone or saying that anyone is doing something wrong. I much appreciate your hard work and even try to help as I can. I just wanted to express concerns, that many donors  would, probably, have. As @greymont said, there are many areas of the project that needs to be improved and refurbished, to gain more synergy in modern world. That is true, entire project looks like frozen in 90s. My other concern would be the price of the book - are you sure it is priced correctly (image attached)? Even being supportive and earning enough, I wouldn't, probably buy this book. I may understand authors, they've spent so much time and effort, but this book would be not affordable for the most who are willing to buy it. May be there exist less pricey options for publishing and shipping? I heard lulu.com are quite good on that. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Editor · 2019-06-29 12:13 Maybe you don't know but there are very few people that are working on all of this stuff. We have a lot to do. I will make a list of all activities I do on the several sites. Because I forgot about the Foundation, it is me to blame. I will  finalize the administration next week, so it will b up to date. I had started it but not finalized. Sometimes one needs to do urgent things first. People that have a lot of comments should come and help us to fulfill all of our tasks. PLEASE COME AND HELP. If your interested simply send an email to me: Detlef Overbeek = editor @ blaisepascal.eu or send it to: foundation @ freepascal.org or to professionals @ lazarusfactory.org For all we do the development of FPC, Lazarus,pas2JS, Web-assembly, all the websites and writing and publish the books: Lazarus Handbook, Learning to program Lazarus and Blaise Pascal Magazine. I have 100% daytime/nighttime job because of this, so if you have any questions please send them to me directly and I will answer instantly. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Editor · 2019-06-29 13:03 In reply to the book Lazarus Handbook(?) I suppose you have taken that info from our website? If this is the book you mentioned then please note the following: first of all there are three versions. So I don't think you are well informed: There is a pocket version and a hardcover, which makes a pricing difference. Further On there is a PDF version: then you do not need to pay shipping cost. If you want more details let me know. One extra thing you should know: 50 % of the PROFIT will be reinvested into the Lazarus FPC project. We very much need that. So it is not only a commercial project. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- k1ng · 2019-06-29 17:16 Quote from: greymont on June 29, 2019, 01:37:58 amOne is the rigidity the principle participants have about conducting business the way they always have. For example, nearly all the rest of the world has moved to embrace git. But you guys say it is not desirable. Well, if I was thinking of joining the effort this position would make me think more than twice. (Moving to use git would help make the project look fresh and alive.) Indeed and FPC could also include the bugtracker in git as other projects do and patches can easily be created as merge-req where devs can directly comment on code lines, syntax problems, other ideas, etc. Like you do nowadays in 2019 Sometimes you have to break old habits and start over using more modern concepts Quote from: greymont on June 29, 2019, 01:37:58 amA second reason you may not be getting the help you need is the project looks very wobbly. Many comments made over the years make it look like it is barely getting by, "living of a shoestring", and therefore may be shut down soon. No one wants to join such an effort. (Updating the web site so the project looks successful and alive would help with this a lot!) You could also host a fresh website via github which could maintained by everyone through commits for spelling errors etc. That would pretty awesome!  But seems FPC/Lazarus likes it more to be the monthly #1 on a dead website... Quote from: greymont on June 29, 2019, 01:37:58 amA third reason you may not be getting the help you need may be because the image of the group is that a small number of principals control nearly all of the project. Without more transparency of process it looks like a tight circle that is hard to break into and not friendly to outsiders. This is where having someone coordinate who is good at explaining what is going on would help enormously. That's true, sometimes the tone is very harsh to new contributors in my eyes. Most of them will just disappear and join another community where the old devs are more warmly and welcome everyone with respectful tone. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- marcov · 2019-06-29 17:31 Quote from: k1ng on June 29, 2019, 07:16:22 pmYou could also host a fresh website via github which could maintained by everyone through commits for spelling errors etc. Any self-respecting non American large project stays away from github (the site and its hosting, not necessarily running the services yourself) because of legal aspects. So that will never happen. Git and github are totally unrelated discussions, and the "I already have a github account" argument is useless. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Martin_fr · 2019-06-29 17:40 Quote from: k1ng on June 29, 2019, 07:16:22 pmIndeed and FPC could also include the bugtracker in git as other projects do and patches can easily be created as merge-req where devs can directly comment on code lines, syntax problems, other ideas, etc. Like you do nowadays in 2019 Personally, I am a git fan. But the bugtrackers on githup/lab... not my cup of tea. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- skalogryz · 2019-06-29 18:06 Quote from: Martin_fr on June 29, 2019, 07:40:05 pmQuote from: k1ng on June 29, 2019, 07:16:22 pmIndeed and FPC could also include the bugtracker in git as other projects do and patches can easily be created as merge-req where devs can directly comment on code lines, syntax problems, other ideas, etc. Like you do nowadays in 2019 Personally, I am a git fan. But the bugtrackers on githup/lab... not my cup of tea. Let's face the fact. The Foundation doesn't really influence the management of neither FPC, nor Lazarus projects. The Foundation can only choose the repository for the projects its funding. And thus: Quote from: marcov on June 29, 2019, 07:31:25 pmGit and github are totally unrelated discussions. +1 ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Bitbeisser · 2019-06-29 19:56 Quote from: MvC on June 29, 2019, 01:01:15 amI can speak for the foundation. It is correct that the foundation website is the least of our priorities. Despite asking several times for volunteers, so far no-one has stepped forward to actually do the work of creating a nice-looking website. I am not a designer of websites. But we're definitely actively working on the progress of FPC/Lazarus ... If you need more transparancy: ask, and you will get answers. There are plenty of invitations to contact us. It's up to you to do so. Well, Michael, with all respect (I "know" and appreciate you and most of the others for up to 25 years by now), I think as far as the "Foundation web site" is concerned, it is a typical case of "information over presentation". Even a simple but regular "blog style" entry on a "news" section, with a date and the full name of the person posting would be sufficient. There are no bylaws posted (not even in Dutch) but at least the foundation memorandum lists a financial report needs to be published with in 6 months of the end of the fiscal year, and there is stated at least in two different places thatQuoteThe foundation will publish the accountancy report at the end of the first three months of 2019 or earlier if possible.In two days, it is July 2019, that's another 3 months past that. I hate accounting myself and much rather spend time programming or other technical stuff, but paying a bit more detail on the transparency when money is involved serves only to cover your own butts in case someone would get really pissed... Ralf ---------------------------------------------------------------------- PascalDragon · 2019-06-29 20:11 Quote from: Akira1364 on June 28, 2019, 11:35:44 pmThe most recent patch for attributes was "assigned" to Sven Barth over a year ago on the bugtracker: https://bugs.freepascal.org/view.php?id=33384 Since then, there's been nothing but radio silence on the subject.So? I'm not getting payed by anyone for my work and in fact I don't want to. I'm working on FPC on my own free time when I feel like it. Getting payed for it (especially with specific goals) puts me under pressure. I already have that at work, I don't need that at my free time as well. Quote from: k1ng on June 29, 2019, 07:16:22 pmQuote from: greymont on June 29, 2019, 01:37:58 amOne is the rigidity the principle participants have about conducting business the way they always have. For example, nearly all the rest of the world has moved to embrace git. But you guys say it is not desirable. Well, if I was thinking of joining the effort this position would make me think more than twice. (Moving to use git would help make the project look fresh and alive.) Indeed and FPC could also include the bugtracker in git as other projects do and patches can easily be created as merge-req where devs can directly comment on code lines, syntax problems, other ideas, etc. Like you do nowadays in 2019 Sometimes you have to break old habits and start over using more modern conceptsChanging the repository doesn't change the fact that patches, especially larger ones that introduce new features need to be carefully groomed and tested. A developer needs to apply them to their own, local checkout anyway to test them, to ensure that nothing broke. That is not something that would change by "using more modern concepts" and that is in fact the bulk of the work. Quote from: MvC on June 29, 2019, 01:01:15 am- We agreed with Karoly Balogh (Charlie) that he will be working on WebAssembly fulltime this summer.   There is still an outstanding bounty for this.Good to know, then I can cross that off my infernal todo list ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ssliackus · 2019-06-29 20:38 Probably I could help a little bit, but not sure what could I do for you. My skill and experience are not related to programming, project management, development or anything. I am an accountant, so there is little use of me. Quote from: Editor on June 29, 2019, 02:13:49 pmMaybe you don't know but there are very few people that are working on all of this stuff. We have a lot to do. I will make a list of all activities I do on the several sites. Because I forgot about the Foundation, it is me to blame. I will  finalize the administration next week, so it will b up to date. I had started it but not finalized. Sometimes one needs to do urgent things first. People that have a lot of comments should come and help us to fulfill all of our tasks. PLEASE COME AND HELP. If your interested simply send an email to me: Detlef Overbeek = editor @ blaisepascal.eu or send it to: foundation @ freepascal.org or to professionals @ lazarusfactory.org For all we do the development of FPC, Lazarus,pas2JS, Web-assembly, all the websites and writing and publish the books: Lazarus Handbook, Learning to program Lazarus and Blaise Pascal Magazine. I have 100% daytime/nighttime job because of this, so if you have any questions please send them to me directly and I will answer instantly. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- greymont · 2019-06-30 02:01 Quote from: SlightlyOutOfPhase on June 30, 2019, 02:12:57 amNo, they don't. This is a ludicrous statement to make. OK, there are plenty of exceptions. But let's not get caught in the weeds. I think @marcov simply meant that some people will not want to jump completely into the git universe even though they might like git itself. So he overstated the situation. Let's move on. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Akira1364 · 2019-06-30 04:10 Quote from: greymont on June 30, 2019, 04:01:53 amOK, there are plenty of exceptions. But let's not get caught in the weeds. I think @marcov simply meant that some people will not want to jump completely into the git universe even though they might like git itself. So he overstated the situation. Let's move on. Honestly, I'd say it is more like "there is almost nothing but exceptions, and SVN is an objectively dying technology with no real benefits to speak of". SVN is much slower. It's less reliable. And so on and so forth. There is a very real technical reason that major projects keep moving away from it, and it is not for any non-existent ideological purpose. It is because Git is objectively better technology with far more to offer. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- lucamar · 2019-06-30 04:25 Quote from: Akira1364 on June 30, 2019, 06:10:55 amIt is because Git is objectively better technology with far more to offer. That is simply not true. At all. Git is a different technology with its strengths and its weakness, like any technology. Doing standard, central version control with Git, compared to SVN, is a nightmare and doubles the work load for all, developers, maintainers and admins, alike. Whether a central or distributed version control system is best for a project depends on lots of variables and Gt doesn't always comes out as "the better", even technically. And we are now way out of topic. Sorry ---------------------------------------------------------------------- k1ng · 2019-06-30 08:50 Quote from: marcov on June 29, 2019, 07:31:25 pmQuote from: k1ng on June 29, 2019, 07:16:22 pmYou could also host a fresh website via github which could maintained by everyone through commits for spelling errors etc. Any non American large project stays away from github (the site, not necessarily running the serves yourself) because of legal aspects. Sorry but you're talking bullshit! Seems to me you never browsed on the github webpage... And to be honest, I wouldn't call FPC a large project with the few contributions compared to other real large projects. Quote from: marcov on June 29, 2019, 07:31:25 pmQuote from: k1ng on June 29, 2019, 07:16:22 pmYou could also host a fresh website via github which could maintained by everyone through commits for spelling errors etc. So that will never happen. Git and github are totally unrelated discussions, and the "I already have a github argument" is useless. Even if you personally don't like github, its the #1 and used for ~95% of every open source project. Gitea/Gitlab can be hosted yourself but its not that popular as Github and will never be. Quote from: PascalDragon on June 29, 2019, 10:11:34 pmQuote from: Akira1364 on June 28, 2019, 11:35:44 pmThe most recent patch for attributes was "assigned" to Sven Barth over a year ago on the bugtracker: https://bugs.freepascal.org/view.php?id=33384 Since then, there's been nothing but radio silence on the subject.So? I'm not getting payed by anyone for my work and in fact I don't want to. I'm working on FPC on my own free time when I feel like it. Getting payed for it (especially with specific goals) puts me under pressure. I already have that at work, I don't need that at my free time as well. Quote from: k1ng on June 29, 2019, 07:16:22 pmQuote from: greymont on June 29, 2019, 01:37:58 amOne is the rigidity the principle participants have about conducting business the way they always have. For example, nearly all the rest of the world has moved to embrace git. But you guys say it is not desirable. Well, if I was thinking of joining the effort this position would make me think more than twice. (Moving to use git would help make the project look fresh and alive.) Indeed and FPC could also include the bugtracker in git as other projects do and patches can easily be created as merge-req where devs can directly comment on code lines, syntax problems, other ideas, etc. Like you do nowadays in 2019 Sometimes you have to break old habits and start over using more modern conceptsChanging the repository doesn't change the fact that patches, especially larger ones that introduce new features need to be carefully groomed and tested. A developer needs to apply them to their own, local checkout anyway to test them, to ensure that nothing broke. That is not something that would change by "using more modern concepts" and that is in fact the bulk of the work. That also sounds like year 2000. Compilers should have tests (as FPC has afaik) which should be executed after every commit to see if something is broken. Very easy with e.g. Travis CI to run tests on x targets or you install a set of own servers to run the tests. This does also work for merge requests on github, no need to test everything locally if this setup has been done once. Just check in merge request if compiling/tests passed, also very helpful for new contributors which might break a thing even without noticing as you cannot setup 30 different targets at home just for one single commit.... ---------------------------------------------------------------------- PascalDragon · 2019-06-30 09:03 Quote from: Akira1364 on June 30, 2019, 06:10:55 amSVN is much slower. It's less reliable. And so on and so forth. There is a very real technical reason that major projects keep moving away from it, and it is not for any non-existent ideological purpose. It is because Git is objectively better technology with far more to offer. Git does not provide externals to files (we use that feature at work), sub module handling is also more complicated than SVN externals. Shallow checkouts are also unheard of (those where you checkout only some directories, not the ones with reduced history; I know Git supports those). The latter two features are used by some of FPC's infrastructure (automatic testsuite runs, release generation). Also the workflow we use for compiler development is not as nicely useable on Git as it is on SVN (and we do prefer a linear history, though we've already found solutions for that). So yes, Git has advantages (and I use Git with FPC through git-svn myself), but it also has disadvantages. Switching a version control system is neither an easy decision nor task as there are mechanisms that rely on it. We are researching it, but we are under no pressure to do it "right now, like 5 days ago". Quote from: k1ng on June 30, 2019, 10:50:50 amQuote from: marcov on June 29, 2019, 07:31:25 pmQuote from: k1ng on June 29, 2019, 07:16:22 pmYou could also host a fresh website via github which could maintained by everyone through commits for spelling errors etc. So that will never happen. Git and github are totally unrelated discussions, and the "I already have a github argument" is useless. Even if you personally don't like github, its the #1 and used for ~95% of every open source project. Gitea/Gitlab can be hosted yourself but its not that popular as Github and will never be.We've already decided that if we should switch to Git that our main repository will be a Gitea repository on one of the servers owned by the FPC development team. Github will get a mirror, but that's it. Quote from: k1ng on June 30, 2019, 10:50:50 amQuote from: PascalDragon on June 29, 2019, 10:11:34 pmQuote from: Akira1364 on June 28, 2019, 11:35:44 pmThe most recent patch for attributes was "assigned" to Sven Barth over a year ago on the bugtracker: https://bugs.freepascal.org/view.php?id=33384 Since then, there's been nothing but radio silence on the subject.So? I'm not getting payed by anyone for my work and in fact I don't want to. I'm working on FPC on my own free time when I feel like it. Getting payed for it (especially with specific goals) puts me under pressure. I already have that at work, I don't need that at my free time as well. Quote from: k1ng on June 29, 2019, 07:16:22 pmQuote from: greymont on June 29, 2019, 01:37:58 amOne is the rigidity the principle participants have about conducting business the way they always have. For example, nearly all the rest of the world has moved to embrace git. But you guys say it is not desirable. Well, if I was thinking of joining the effort this position would make me think more than twice. (Moving to use git would help make the project look fresh and alive.) Indeed and FPC could also include the bugtracker in git as other projects do and patches can easily be created as merge-req where devs can directly comment on code lines, syntax problems, other ideas, etc. Like you do nowadays in 2019 Sometimes you have to break old habits and start over using more modern conceptsChanging the repository doesn't change the fact that patches, especially larger ones that introduce new features need to be carefully groomed and tested. A developer needs to apply them to their own, local checkout anyway to test them, to ensure that nothing broke. That is not something that would change by "using more modern concepts" and that is in fact the bulk of the work. That also sounds like year 2000. Compilers should have tests (as FPC has afaik) which should be executed after every commit to see if something is broken. Very easy with e.g. Travis CI to run tests on x targets or you install a set of own servers to run the tests. This does also work for merge requests on github, no need to test everything locally if this setup has been done once. Just check in merge request if compiling/tests passed, also very helpful for new contributors which might break a thing even without noticing as you cannot setup 30 different targets at home just for one single commit.... This hasn't necessarily to do with some patch breaking the build. This has also to do with finding out whether the developer of the patch has thought of all potential problems that might arise. There were often patches in the past where a new feature could be easily broken or where the developers decided to use an approach that was unmaintainable in the long run and thus should be rewritten. Only because a patch compiles and does not break the testsuite does not mean that it's good. Also we have both nightly test suite runs as well as some systems that do continous integration (mainly to detect compilation errors for the more seldom developed targets like the Amiga family). Running the testsuite takes time (on current x86 systems it's rather quick with a few minutes, but on less powerful targets it can take an hour or longer), so running it on each commit is not necessarily feasable for all targets. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- marcov · 2019-06-30 11:50 The whole pro git discussion is pointless. An inquiry was done in early 2018, and nearly directly release branch management was the problem point. Over christmas the discussion started again, and it seems the majority of FPC seem to wanti git actually, but somehow solutions are slow coming (or are weak like "separate software has to be written for that"). Nearly anything that is a oneline in SVN is suddenly a separate script(*) in git, and requires workarounds like stuffing metadata in commit messages. THOSE hack SOLUTIONS IS WHY WE FLED FROM CVS, IT IS GOING BACKWARDS  ! Note that the GIT vs SVN factions are nearly 100% split over compiler vs other devs, with the exception of Michael whose employer uses GIT already. If you want to promote git, come up with workflow solutions for release and stable branch management somewhat equal, because that what the migration is hinging on for 1.5 years now. p.s. Personally I favor staying with SVN, simply because it works, and because I think the migration and solving the problems git outweigh the fairly minor benefits. And yes, if I started a new project I would probably chose GIT. But for many things we already have its advantages via the SVN+GIT bridge, and I don't want the project taking a sabbatical year to recover from a VCS migration The fact that popularity arguments have to be made to cover up that GIT is so deficient in the current situation, and that it can't simply win on merits (even after people studying 2 years on the issue of those release branches) is IMHO telling. It is simply not versatile enough, too much a "my way or the highway" philosophy. And the popularity arguments, like the language feature ones, never deliver on their promises. The big unwashed masses never come because of such changes, it is all hot air. Like many of the propose language features: solutions in search of a problem (*) and scripts are problems, since FPC is not an *nix only project, and everything has to work on multiple systems. And no, requiring a mingw install for *nix scripting emulation is not acceptable. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- k1ng · 2019-06-30 12:27 Quote from: marcov on June 30, 2019, 01:50:23 pmOver christmas the discussion started again, and it seems the majority of FPC seem to wanti git actually, but somehow solutions are slow coming (or are weak like "separate software has to be written for that"). Nearly anything that is a oneline in SVN is suddenly a separate script(*) in git, and requires workarounds like stuffing metadata in commit messages. (*) and scripts are problems, since FPC is not an *nix only project, and everything has to work on multiple systems. And no, requiring a mingw install for *nix scripting emulation is not acceptable. Can you give an example? Why not writing the "script" in FPC or bash+batch? Quote from: marcov on June 30, 2019, 01:50:23 pmIf you want to promote git, come up with workflow solutions for release and stable branch management somewhat equal, because that what the migration is hinging on for 1.5 years now. Where is the problem? Use master branch as trunk, fork it into a beta-branch for a new version which then gets forked into release-branch when its finished. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ssliackus · 2019-06-30 12:50 Yes, I didn't realise these three exist. I do not thinks it is good thing to include donation in book price. First of all, it makes book to be more expensive, therefore it will be less affordable for some. Second, not all who are willing to donate, would like to buy a book (ok, these can do this), but those who want just to buy a book, must donate. That is not very right. I would keep those to separate. Authors would still have an option to donate if they want from their profits, not from sales revenue. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- marcov · 2019-06-30 13:04 Quote from: k1ng on June 30, 2019, 02:27:43 pmWhere is the problem? Use master branch as trunk, fork it into a beta-branch for a new version which then gets forked into release-branch when its finished. If you want to advocate GIT, first study how SVN is used by FPC. And check the git migration item in the wiki. Just study how FPC makes releases, and maintains a stable branch and merges back revisions. Note that not all revisions might be merged, and not in order. IOW merge tracking. Making random branches and doing some manual cherrypicking works in any non ancient VCS. It is in the long term maintenance and associated administration that is the deciding difference ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ssliackus · 2019-06-30 13:08 If that is true, then what is the purpose of keeping organisation? From this discussion I see, that even the foundation exist, it is not functioning, but how is then project being managed? Who is taking decisions a where and how to lead the project? I presume, it is down to small group of enthusiasts and some users, but then it lacks overall strategy and project would stay at that level. Interesting. Quote from: skalogryz on June 29, 2019, 08:06:02 pmQuote from: Martin_fr on June 29, 2019, 07:40:05 pmQuote from: k1ng on June 29, 2019, 07:16:22 pmIndeed and FPC could also include the bugtracker in git as other projects do and patches can easily be created as merge- req where devs can directly comment on code lines, syntax problems, other ideas, etc. Like you do nowadays in 2019 Personally, I am a git fan. But the bugtrackers on githup/lab... not my cup of tea. Let's face the fact. The Foundation doesn't really influence the management of neither FPC, nor Lazarus projects. The Foundation can only choose the repository for the projects its funding. And thus: Quote from: marcov on June 29, 2019, 07:31:25 pmGit and github are totally unrelated discussions. +1 ---------------------------------------------------------------------- marcov · 2019-06-30 13:18 QuoteFrom this discussion I see, that even the foundation exist, it is not functioning, It is not very active, but the sums are not very large either. And functioning for what? Its intended goal, or some goal you THINK they should have? Quotebut how is then project being managed? Open source projects are generally not top-down managed, but collaborative. QuoteWho is taking decisions a where and how to lead the project? I presume, it is down to small group of enthusiasts and some users, but then it lacks overall strategy and project would stay at that level. Keep in mind it is a volunteer driven project. Dictating policy without actually providing the resources to do so is pointless, since there will simply be no volunteers to implement the policy. It has managed fine doing so for 25 years, and we are definitely further than back then. Yes, goals are murky, but the main reason for that is that the resources are likewise murky. The foundation was meant as a front for donations to work around that by using donations to fund things. Quote from: ssliackus on June 30, 2019, 03:08:25 pmIf that is true, then what is the purpose of keeping organisation? Originally? Create a visible, respectable front for corporate donations and make them tax deductible, and provide a route for fundamental and quicker development by funding projects. IOW it is fundraising only. However the practical results are a bit strange. They seem to fund "nextgen" (pas2js) development which is more a new project, parallel to lazarus/FPC rather than a part of lazarus/fpc. IOW what they are spending most funding on is not what is on the top ten request list (which are mostly Delphi features like attributes and anonymous methods). So personally, I don't understand the foundation's policy either. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ssliackus · 2019-06-30 14:44 QuoteIt is not very active, but the sums are not very large either. And functioning for what? Its intended goal, or some goal you THINK they should have? It is not about sums, but rather the the overall project coordination - what it should be in 5 years, what features should be implemented first, what should come later, what can be done using volunteers, where we should get help from external resources etc. I understand foundation as brain or as main coordination center. QuoteOpen source projects are generally not top-down managed, but collaborative. That's is good, but how then disagreements are being solved when there is no structure and subordination? Not saying that it has to be anything like corporate, but it should exist at some scale. QuoteDictating policy without actually providing the resources to do so is pointless. I didn't mean anything like dictating, but rather then prioritising and keeping development aligned with these priorities. QuoteIt has managed fine doing so for 25 years, and we are definitely further than back then. Yes, goals are murky, but the main reason for that is that the resources are likewise murky. Project is alive, that is a good thing, but if it is doing fine, that depends on how do you measure that . Since I am not very familiar with this project, my samples may sound stupid, but this could be: - X commercial projects switched to FP and saved Y in cash/time or achieved A, B or C with it - users base or active FP projects figure grew up from z to Z - project has been extended into several independed commercial projects which now are funding development of main project 25-years it is a long time and few generations of technologies has changed over that period. Now I started to think if I could contribute to project somehow. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- k1ng · 2019-06-30 14:50 Quote from: marcov on June 30, 2019, 03:04:09 pmQuote from: k1ng on June 30, 2019, 02:27:43 pmWhere is the problem? Use master branch as trunk, fork it into a beta-branch for a new version which then gets forked into release-branch when its finished. If you want to advocate GIT, first study how SVN is used by FPC. And check the git migration item in the wiki. Seems to have some wrong infos inside... Quote from: marcov on June 30, 2019, 03:04:09 pmQuote from: k1ng on June 30, 2019, 02:27:43 pmWhere is the problem? Use master branch as trunk, fork it into a beta-branch for a new version which then gets forked into release-branch when its finished. Just study how FPC makes releases, and maintains a stable branch and merges back revisions. Note that not all revisions might be merged, and not in order. IOW merge tracking. 'git cherry-pick' And as patches should be as small as possible, it'll work fine all time. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- marcov · 2019-06-30 15:13 Quote from: k1ng on June 30, 2019, 04:50:03 pm 'git cherry-pick' And as patches should be as small as possible, it'll work fine all time. And how does the tracking of that work? And what if it was originally a commit in a forward branch that got merged into masters? And does it work out of order, even if e.g. earlier or later revs touch the same lines. We all believe the vanilla case works, the devil is in the details. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- skalogryz · 2019-06-30 15:30 Quote from: SlightlyOutOfPhase on June 30, 2019, 02:12:57 amThere's compilers out there written by literally one person entirely within the last five years that at the very least equal FPC in scope minus the "literally do all of the codegen yourself" part. It has always been this way. Creating a compiler/language is one of the basic practices in any higher education Computer Science courses. Hobbyists are always more than welcome to create new languages but... Quote from: SlightlyOutOfPhase on June 30, 2019, 02:12:57 amFPC is an impressive open source project, but it is no longer in a position where anything it does is especially technically interesting or unprecedented. do you know any OTHER open source compiler that's compatible with other Pascal dialect? Most important with Delphi codebase, that's the greatest of all pascal (dialect) languages. Plus add a set of libraries open source libraries for those. "Technically Interesting". From what I can see, the technical interest of any language typically ends on the ability to interface a C-library. A lot of modern language typically rely on the external library to back them up where the performance in critical. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- skalogryz · 2019-06-30 15:40 Quote from: ssliackus on June 30, 2019, 03:08:25 pmIf that is true, then what is the purpose of keeping organisation? From this discussion I see, that even the foundation exist, it is not functioning, but how is then project being managed? Who is taking decisions a where and how to lead the project? I presume, it is down to small group of enthusiasts and some users, but then it lacks overall strategy and project would stay at that level. Both projects started long before the foundation. Both FPC and Lazarus projects are being managed by their respective core teams. (btw, getting into a core team is not complicated) The team members are (as described on the wikipedia) "volunteers". It's hard to build and cultivate any sort of "strategy" when you don't have any guaranteed resources. Maybe the Foundation could be the organization to fund the resources, so it could decide the strategy. But it's not there yet (and it doesn't seem to be there in any near future). ---------------------------------------------------------------------- marcov · 2019-06-30 15:52 Quote from: SlightlyOutOfPhase on June 30, 2019, 02:12:57 amQuote from: marcov on June 29, 2019, 07:31:25 pmAny non American large project stays away from github (the site, not necessarily running the serves yourself) because of legal aspects. No, they don't. This is a ludicrous statement to make. E.G. OCaml is not that popular in the grand scheme of things, but still significantly more popular than FPC, based in Europe, and uses Github: https://github.com/ocaml/ocaml So does Nim (a direct FPC descendant!) that I'm pretty sure more people have heard of at this point (unfortunately) than FPC (also based in Europe): https://github.com/nim-lang/Nim Good luck to them. I hope they don't have an Embarcadero looming over their shoulder.  QuoteRuby (very popular, originating in Japan): https://github.com/ruby/ruby Ruby is a different ballpark and has corporate backing. Apple already delivered Ruby with OS X one year after inception. Different class. (and it doesn't matter if that is rightfully so or not). QuoteAnd so on. Git (and not necessarily Github, but maybe Github... Gitlab and such are good too though!) are just the way to go nowadays and simply what people the vast majority of people expect. Nonsense. Just some very vocal minorities. Quote I'm sick of always hearing this "what FPC does is definitely totally normal and common" reasoning because it's increasingly becoming blatantly untrue. Well, that is the lot of people that know everything best, yet refuse to heavily participate. QuotePeople aren't stupid, and some of us actively contribute to other projects and are entirely aware of the reality of things. I take the fifth on that one. QuoteFPC is an impressive open source project, but it is no longer in a position where anything it does is especially technically interesting or unprecedented. There's compilers out there written by literally one person entirely within the last five years that at the very least equal FPC in scope minus the "literally do all of the codegen yourself" part. I always see FPC against such projects a bit as FreeBSD vs Linux in philosophy. What is Linux? A kernel. What is FreeBSD? A complete project, with the entire base in development plus release management. IOW FreeBSD=Linux+(a distro). So no. It is not just having an own backend, but also massive libraries, an RAD based IDE (Lazarus) that has the same philosophy, the utils, the release engineering and everything. Comparing that to some graduate thesis work that compiles to some other backend is ludicrous. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ssliackus · 2019-06-30 20:58 Quote from: Bitbeisser on June 29, 2019, 09:56:35 pmI hate accounting myself and much rather spend time programming or other technical stuff, but paying a bit more detail on the transparency when money is involved serves only to cover your own butts in case someone would get really pissed... Ralf I am accountant, probably I could help you a little bit with that. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- marcov · 2019-07-01 07:39 Quote from: ssliackus on June 30, 2019, 04:44:53 pmQuoteIt is not very active, but the sums are not very large either. And functioning for what? Its intended goal, or some goal you THINK they should have? It is not about sums, but rather the the overall project coordination - what it should be in 5 years, what features should be implemented first, what should come later, what can be done using volunteers, where we should get help from external resources etc. I understand foundation as brain or as main coordination center. Yeah. So that basically doesn't exist. That is top-down thinking.  There is a very rough sense of shared direction among committers, and that's it. QuoteQuoteOpen source projects are generally not top-down managed, but collaborative. That's is good, but how then disagreements are being solved when there is no structure and subordination? Not saying that it has to be anything like corporate, but it should exist at some scale. Basically? More active committers pull rank. But there was some conflict avoidance by only making people (general) committers when they have done a lot of supervised work in multiple areas of the project. In the last 5 years that flux of new committers has dried up. Some blame it on the commitment of more recent generations, but most think like I do, there are simply more detractions and possible directions for young people. I also think that the waning pascal in education is killing our influx. QuoteQuoteDictating policy without actually providing the resources to do so is pointless. I didn't mean anything like dictating, but rather then prioritising and keeping development aligned with these priorities. I meant dictating as the instruments to actually do that. If you can't tell anybody what to do, how do you steer? QuoteQuoteIt has managed fine doing so for 25 years, and we are definitely further than back then. Yes, goals are murky, but the main reason for that is that the resources are likewise murky. Project is alive, that is a good thing, but if it is doing fine, that depends on how do you measure that . Since I am not very familiar with this project, my samples may sound stupid, but this could be: - X commercial projects switched to FP and saved Y in cash/time or achieved A, B or C with it - users base or active FP projects figure grew up from z to Z - project has been extended into several independed commercial projects which now are funding development of main project These things are hard to measure. Even download counters (as vague as they are) are opague because it is done a lot via mirrors. Moreover, student downloads probably dwarf anything else, but nearly all but a very small percentage stop after their one quarter/trimester/semester structured programming class. I would guestimate the userbase now is smaller than say 7 years ago, but more serious. (iow really working with Lazarus/FPC, rather than just doing a class) What did noticeably changed is the attitude of Delphians towards Lazarus. It is taken much more serious. Quote25-years it is a long time and few generations of technologies has changed over that period. Now I started to think if I could contribute to project somehow. I think that steadfast direction should be considered a strength.  Count the number of open source tools to make a Windows desktop application. There is not much if you discount the various half ported *nix offerings. IMHO that is strength to build on, much more than e.g. what the Foundation does, trying to implement the umpteenth typed javascript dialect. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ssliackus · 2019-07-01 09:39 Quote from: marcov on July 01, 2019, 09:39:14 amWhat did noticeably changed is the attitude of Delphians towards Lazarus. It is taken much more serious. That is interesting topic, I will open separate discussion on that. Thank you. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- PascalDragon · 2019-07-02 07:34 Quote from: marcov on July 01, 2019, 09:39:14 amIn the last 5 years that flux of new committers has dried up. Some blame it on the commitment of more recent generations, but most think like I do, there are simply more detractions and possible directions for young people. I also think that the waning pascal in education is killing our influx.We do however have a few promising candidates currently (J. Gareth Moreton, Ryan Joseph). ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Webdrifter · 2019-07-03 16:16 I stumbled here because I wanted to read into the status of Pascal, which used to be my favourite language in the earlier years. I ‘ve read this thread with great interest. Maybe as an old fart I might be able to advice. Mind you, as said, I only know Pascal from the early years, so you have to forgive me that I don’t know yet how far it has come in all those years. I’ve been poking around a bit among reviews and experiences of users of SVN and Git. And as it comes to me right now, it doesn’t seem such a bad idea that you work in SVN with Git bridge. It’s a bit like like getting best of both worlds. What I would advise however is to build Freepascal and Lazarus as modular as possible, both with a good workining package system for extentions. Pascal used to be great in this sense (proper compartmentalisation) so I suppose you guys have already accomplishes that.  Git seems great for smaller and more decentral projects like modules and extensions. And the younger generations can be found more on git nowedays than on SVN. So you could stimulate the younger generation to work on those in Git. That way you would keep the core into the hands of those who have been given the status of fullblown committers and give the rest in the hands of the other devs. So your goal could be to migrate modules and extensions that need a lot of extra development towards Git and pull them into the core package on SVN as soon they are mature and are expected to need only limited future improvements (off course taking into account whether you can also turn their committers into SVN proper committers) And as you noted that “the GIT vs SVN factions are nearly 100% split over compiler vs other devs”, it seems to me thsat my that solution would also please both faction in your community. I would consider (if not already present) to give users of Freepascal and Lazarus the opportunity to choose which hardware platform they which to support with their Pascal programming environment. That way it will keep things lean. Also I would start making a clear and timely difference between Planned Releases (LTS), Planned Updates on Releases and Unplanned (emergency) Updates/Fixes. (Releases having major improments, with less stress on backwards compatibility or even purposly breaking away off old hardware platforms etc.) (Updates on Releases having minor improments, with High stress on backwards compatibility compared to the original Release, no breakage allowed unless for security reasons) Thus enabling you to better communicate your development proces and the risks involved for users. At least communicate wihich improvements and compatibility issues they can expect in the Planned Releases and which in Planned Updates on Releases. And off course try to put a time limit on it, taking in account what commitments people are willing to make promises on. (I know this is a hard thing with volunteers but you have to strive to it noneteless, the moment you stop doiing that is the moment you start setting yourself up for a slow death of your project). By better planning and communicating this planning, you enable users to plan and take timely action on their own code or hardware base. Thus creating a market environment for Pascal in which users are more able and willing to evolve their code confrming to the evolution  path of Pascal. This will enable Pascal to get rid off (archive) old code and get lean not only for users but also for its developers (you guys), Which, as far as I can see with my limited knowlegde, seems very necesserry to give Pascal development more dynamics considering Pascal had a very slow pace of release over the last years, and does not seem to be able to keep up the pace in this ever faster chaging world, whith less and less programmers interested in maintaining age old platforms.    Also I would advise to make the contributions to and the allocation of those donations by the foundation as transparent as possible. At least present quarterly numbers on this website/forum, and create a donation page for do digital payments (once or automatic periodically), where people can see what budget is needed to realize certain projects (with links to detsailed info on these projectsl), and choose for which Pascal Project they donate their money. Also the foundation might consider starting to sell merchandise to fund things (off course for that you need to have nerd and youngster friendly fashionable logo’s). Just the two pennies of an old fart, take it for what it’s worth. Hope it helps, succes. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- marcov · 2019-07-03 22:44 Quote from: Webdrifter on July 03, 2019, 06:16:55 pmI’ve been poking around a bit among reviews and experiences of users of SVN and Git. And as it comes to me right now, it doesn’t seem such a bad idea that you work in SVN with Git bridge. It’s a bit like like getting best of both worlds. What I would advise however is to build Freepascal and Lazarus as modular as possible, both with a good workining package system for extentions. Pascal used to be great in this sense (proper compartmentalisation) so I suppose you guys have already accomplishes that. You can try. There are multiple such efforts like fppkg and lazarus packagesmanager Quote Git seems great for smaller and more decentral projects like modules and extensions. Current afaik they simply use zips, and leave the version system decision wholly to the packages maintainers themselves, rather than force something on them. QuoteAnd the younger generations can be found more on git nowedays than on SVN. So you could stimulate the younger generation to work on those in Git. The problem is that this is often small potato experience in relative small projects on github. This experience doesn't really translate to larger projects with some quality control. Catering too much for this difference will lower thresholds, but at the cost of procedures (and possibly quality), which will create an even bigger management problem in the central administration.  I therefore don't share the thought that advocating GIT changes so much. It is now overly focussed on because it is an easy target. The reality however, it is the problem between having procedures and standards for acceptance and not. That can't be washed away with technology. FPC and Lazarus have always accepted contributions in patch format. You can just as well generate them from git if the quality of your repo's contents is enough. And if it isn't, the fact that both you and FPC use git isn't going to help either. It only changes the blame game to the next easy argument. (probably some procedure. Why don't you simply pull it from my git? A: because i wouldn't touch that shit with a bargepole because you reformatted everything) And too much modularization will also create a support issue due to versioning. (at least now the release packages are forced synchronized) QuoteThat way you would keep the core into the hands of those who have been given the status of fullblown committers and give the rest in the hands of the other devs. So your goal could be to migrate modules and extensions that need a lot of extra development towards Git and pull them into the core package on SVN as soon they are mature and are expected to need only limited future improvements (off course taking into account whether you can also turn their committers into SVN proper committers) This is a really bad idea. Package dependencies are not static, and some packages would have to move to and from the distribution. Having internal modularization is good, but the repos would need to remain linked. QuoteAnd as you noted that “the GIT vs SVN factions are nearly 100% split over compiler vs other devs”, it seems to me thsat my that solution would also please both faction in your community. The compiler devs wanting GIT, and the target maintainers and RTL, FCL developers prefering SVN? (or at least not being in favor of the migration. You can still favor GIT and consider conversion and the subsequent lost year not worth it) QuoteI would consider (if not already present) to give users of Freepascal and Lazarus the opportunity to choose which hardware platform they which to support with their Pascal programming environment. That way it will keep things lean. What hardware problem? Users don't chose. They have to take what is there, or be developers. Most target maintainers started development that way (including me, wanting to run CGIs on my FreeBSD account and ending up porting FPC to FreeBSD) QuoteAlso I would start making a clear and timely difference between Planned Releases (LTS), Planned Updates on Releases and Unplanned (emergency) Updates/Fixes. Release planning is very limited and very fluid in time. We have been trying to change this for about 20 years now, and it only gets worse :-) Quote(Releases having major improments, with less stress on backwards compatibility or even purposly breaking away off old hardware platforms etc.) I don't really understand all this, but quite often fixes don't let them sort easily in multiple categories, simply because they are related. Also targets often lose support for older OS versions, so porting them back to the LTS versions of those targets is no longer possible. Quote(Updates on Releases having minor improments, with High stress on backwards compatibility compared to the original Release, no breakage allowed unless for security reasons) Sometimes security fixes are done by Linux distros. But the number of incident is still low enough to not even have policy on this. QuoteAnd off course try to put a time limit on it, taking in account what commitments people are willing to make promises on. (I know this is a hard thing with volunteers but you have to strive to it noneteless, the moment you stop doiing that is the moment you start setting yourself up for a slow death of your project). You simply won't get promises you can hold anybody too, which makes it pointless. Quote By better planning and communicating this planning, you enable users to plan and take timely action on their own code or hardware base. Thus creating a market environment for Pascal in which users are more able and willing to evolve their code confrming to the evolution  path of Pascal. If some users would start working on continuous releases and feed back info into the project (and maybe even become members over time) maybe something would happen here. The problem is that releasing is only a side task for most of the devs too, and to change anything, you would need a (more) continuous release manpower. It is the only way. But with modularization, lazarus packagemanager, fpcdeluxe etc, this might grow organically over time.  It would help if fpc and lazarus used the same package system for modularization internally, and externally, so that packages could move more fluid between them. But then first people must work on that, and grow it, and only then you can start the big redivide. There is movement, but it is glacial. QuoteThis will enable Pascal to get rid off (archive) old code and get lean not only for users but also for its developers (you guys), Not really. Most of such attempts miserably failed, because the users generally are not interested in maintaining, except for a few popular focal points. The few exceptions make developer anyway. So this is probably betting on manpower that simply is not there. QuoteWhich, as far as I can see with my limited knowlegde, seems very necesserry to give Pascal development more dynamics considering Pascal had a very slow pace of release over the last years, and does not seem to be able to keep up the pace in this ever faster chaging world, whith less and less programmers interested in maintaining age old platforms.    In my opinion it is betting the bank on some magical influx of devels, and requiring a lot of investment up front that will be mostly only have complicated things (and the work void) if that fails. I've heard it many times, and the argument is flawed, simply because if those hordes were really out there, they would not be hampered by simple things like git vs svn, or some minor ease of use. They would simply get in touch and start working. Note btw that the number of submissions for some of the retro platforms is higher than of many popular targets. Having old targets is not the problem, getting people to work on the new ones is. Quote Also I would advise to make the contributions to and the allocation of those donations by the foundation as transparent as possible. At least present quarterly numbers on this website/forum, and create a donation page for do digital payments (once or automatic periodically), where people can see what budget is needed to realize certain projects (with links to detsailed info on these projectsl), and choose for which Pascal Project they donate their money. That irks me somewhat too, that people donated for FPC/lazarus process, and it got invested in a new product, a standalone pas2js with own RTL/libs etc. QuoteAlso the foundation might consider starting to sell merchandise to fund things (off course for that you need to have nerd and youngster friendly fashionable logo’s). Works only for projects with very high visibility. And if we get major attendance from some major company, the mugs stuff would be the small potato. QuoteJust the two pennies of an old fart, take it for what it’s worth. They abolished cents in the Netherlands  :-) Seriously. Lots of open doors, and optimistic to extreme optimistic scenarios that are not really supported by fact (all IMHO of course) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ssliackus · 2019-07-15 14:06 Hello again  I've checked that Free Pascal foundation has got three members, so basically it is just a nominal organisation to utilise some funds (if there are any). That means, that project is driven by its developers mostly, isn't? And how many active developers FP/Lazarus project has got at the moment? Just rough estimate Thanks ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Thaddy · 2019-07-15 15:40 It has three board members and is governed under Dutch law. That makes it very, very safe... ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Martin_fr · 2019-07-15 15:46 Quote from: ssliackus on July 15, 2019, 04:06:08 pmAnd how many active developers FP/Lazarus project has got at the moment? Just rough estimate For Lazarus, check the openhup link at the bottom of the forum. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ssliackus · 2019-07-15 15:51 Quote from: Thaddy on July 15, 2019, 05:40:24 pmIt has three board members and is governed under Dutch law. That makes it very, very safe... Whether you are badly informed or there is a wrong information: https://foundation.freepascal.org/about/about And what do you mean by saying it is very safe? What can be unsafe in your understanding? Thanks S ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ssliackus · 2019-07-15 20:14 Quote from: Martin_fr on July 15, 2019, 05:46:22 pmQuote from: ssliackus on July 15, 2019, 04:06:08 pmAnd how many active developers FP/Lazarus project has got at the moment? Just rough estimate For Lazarus, check the openhup link at the bottom of the forum. Found it, thanks S ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Martin_fr · 2019-07-15 21:49 And there is also https://wiki.lazarus.freepascal.org/Developer_pages