Is there a "Don't rip me off" open source license? lazarus / 8-Other ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Dr.Theopolis · 2015-10-21 23:46 I've decided to fork Lazarus and Free Pascal and copy it in its entirety to my own website and change the name of the project to CodaZaurus. No licenses or copyrights will be violated, but as much as possible any links in source code or documentation will be changed to go to my website. I'm not really going to do that. I'm extremely supportive of the Lazarus team and contributors. But for several years I've been working on my own application project and I would love to make it as freely available as possible while at the same time being able to monetize it a little bit so I don't starve. On one hand it would be nice to one day see my project included in major Linux software repositories which would require my to license my software under certain permissive licenses. But then a similar scenario as I described above might happen to my project. So what are your ideas on how to be free and open with your hard work but being able to monetize it too without someone ripping off your work? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- taazz · 2015-10-22 00:25 there is none that I'm aware that protect the authors rights no. In short the most used approach to this problem is don't open source everything. You open source the absolute minimum required for your application and sell support and commercial addons on top of that but you have to make sure that nobody else can take the same application re brand it. Thats only leave you with one choice freeware. Do not share your code but let everyone try it. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Handoko · 2015-10-22 01:27 It is sad to know the truth, the disadvantage of releasing code to open source. I wrote some (I think) useful tools using Lazarus, such as tools for ease debugging, opengl visual controls, visual list controls and some others. I'm an open source supporter, I want to release them to open source. I don't mind others to use it, change it even monetize it, unfortunately recent discussion makes me think I should not. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Leledumbo · 2015-10-22 05:49 Quote from: Dr.Theopolis on October 22, 2015, 01:46:27 amSo what are your ideas on how to be free and open with your hard work but being able to monetize it too without someone ripping off your work? Make the source free, but make the precompiled binaries/installer, possibly additional addons that are hard to build/find commercial. That's legal in any existing open source license. This approach has already been taken by several projects such as Ardour and some PDF editor I found years ago. If you want to be a little more evil, not giving documentation (i.e. compilation/installation instructions) is also a legal approach. I don't suggest making the product documentation itself commercial, though. That will make people totally runaway. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- taazz · 2015-10-22 06:00 Quote from: Leledumbo on October 22, 2015, 07:49:00 amIf you want to be a little more evil, not giving documentation (i.e. compilation/installation instructions) is also a legal approach. I don't suggest making the product documentation itself commercial, though. That will make people totally runaway. On the other hand you might want to drive those people away. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- x2nie · 2015-10-22 06:14 Anyway, direct selling is (perhaps) a genius idea.   You sells your CodaSaurus to customers, and in the same time opensource it with another name in another repository/website, let say name it as Anacondus for OSS community, and sell it in completely different name. --Well, I am not a lawyer, I am not sure if it can satisfy everybody-- ---------------------------------------------------------------------- x2nie · 2015-10-22 06:26 Quote from: x2nie on October 22, 2015, 08:14:58 amAnyway, direct selling is (perhaps) a genius idea.   You sells your CodaSaurus to customers, and in the same time opensource it with another name in another repository/website, let say name it as Anacondus for OSS community, and sell it in completely different name. I mean, for your special need. You have forked and modified a lot of Lazurs+FreePascal, this mixed work should be published right? Publish is as NameA/Anacondus. And in the same time you sell it to customer as CName/Codasaurus, but hey, how easy your customer to find the NameA? I think by direct selling and good contract you got monetized. Okay, its a naive approach that after several years your customer will finally know that NameA=CName, but at least it make money. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Eugene Loza · 2015-10-22 07:45 Make some essential part of the software closed source and run it at your own protected server ... to be totally evil  And when you're ready, just release the source and submit to free repositories. However, AFAIK free software gets its revenue not from direct sales of the product, but from support fees & donations (not just donations, but aimed at software further development & support). ---------------------------------------------------------------------- taazz · 2015-10-22 16:31 Quote from: Eugene Loza on October 22, 2015, 09:45:40 amMake some essential part of the software closed source and run it at your own protected server ... to be totally evil  And when you're ready, just release the source and submit to free repositories. However, AFAIK free software gets its revenue not from direct sales of the product, but from support fees & donations (not just donations, but aimed at software further development & support). the need for an active internet connection to use the application is the deal breaker for me. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ykot · 2015-10-22 17:58 On the other hand, if you sell your software product, you need to take piracy into account, which has much more powerful marketing channels (many web sites, blogs and so on, which drive great search engine traffic) and talented people to crack whatever protection you can come up with. So, unless you are a very big company with strong marketing momentum, as soon as your product becomes the target for pirates, it might just make your whole effort worthless. This is something you should consider before commercializing your product (and of course, don't believe in myth, where they say that "people who use pirated products would not have bought them anyway", which is just a fallacious assumption). My suggestion would be: just give the software for free, either open- source or not, but accept donations and sell services, e.g. consulting, extensions, porting of projects and so on. Sure, there are people that rip even open-source projects and are quite annoying to deal with; in this case, as others suggested, just keep some parts of the project closed-source and/or give it on request to people you trust. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Dr.Theopolis · 2015-10-23 06:52 Thank you for all the very thoughtful replies. I was reading this article about the creator of the Linux kernel. I don't think he has any regrets. Maybe he's just content that the project has stayed in his control and is universally known still by the name he gave it which will forever attribute credit back to him, where it is due.