Is there any of Delphi patents that could use to sue FCP/Lazarus lazarus / 8-Other ---------------------------------------------------------------------- motaz · 2014-05-11 05:52 After Oracle has won the sue case against Google of using Java in Android, it comes to my mind: does the same scenario could happen for FPC/Lazarus, if Delphi has patents? I wanted to be sure before going more deep in investing in FPC/Lazarus applications in my future projects. Also I want to know is the legal representation of FPC/Lazarus community, is it belong to any body? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Blaazen · 2014-05-11 09:35 Software patents are in fact invalid in EU and AFAIK in Brasil too. Don't know about Russia. Those countries are home of majority of FPC and Lazarus developers. Patent wars are domain of USA. But Lazarus is not owned by any company, it's a community project (just like Wine, ReactOS etc.). IMO using Lazarus for (commercial) development is safe. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Leledumbo · 2014-05-11 11:07 Up to today, there was only one copyright infringement case and has been resolved using clean room implementation approach of affected APIs. But Borland/Embarcadero never claims any patent to FPC/Lazarus. Using my business mind, they won't do it. In fact, they've used FPC once, so I think they actually gets benefit from FPC/Lazarus. Maybe they don't distribute any part of the projects, but they might get ideas how things are implemented and include that instead, using their own implementation. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- BeniBela · 2014-05-11 11:20 That lawsuit was not about patents It was about copyright on APIs And yes, it means fpc/lazarus are already violating Borland's copyright for e.g. having an IntToStr function or a max function, instead having other names for these function, so they could be sued out of existence ---------------------------------------------------------------------- motaz · 2014-05-11 11:31 QuoteAnd yes, it means fpc/lazarus are already violating Borland's copyright for e.g. having an IntToStr function or a max functionThat means most of Object Pascal libraries and components are subject to this violation, e.g: - DataSet.First, Next, etc - typed, untyped files functions - file streams - String Lists - Math unit That could represent 80% of Object Pascal functions/procedures/Units ---------------------------------------------------------------------- jwdietrich · 2014-05-11 11:38 Well, that is a very important question. In fact, Embarcadero owns a lot of patents, and that for the two-way-tools method could also affect Lazarus. However, this is also the case for most other IDEs, including Microsoft Visual Studio, Apple's Xcode and even most HTML editors. Furthermore, Lazarus is quite mature now. When the two-way-tools method was patented in 2001 there were already three development versions of Lazarus released (see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lazarus_(IDE)#Versions for a detailed version history), and Lazarus itself is based on older software, first of all Free Pascal that started in 1993 and older IDEs like Megido and OpenSibyl that were predecessors of Lazarus. Additionally, as Leledumbo pointed out, even Embarcadero employed Free Pascal for mobile development before they implemented their own solution. It would be difficult to argue against a project which they relied on previously. Lazarus, Free Pascal, Delphi, RAD Studio, Appmethod, PocketStudio etc. are all part of the same ecosystem. It would be contra-productive for all sites to wage war against each other rather than to cooperate. I wouldn't expect that Embarcadero's sales would go up if they sued the Lazarus project. To the contrary, Lazarus / FPC is also an inexpensive and very effective advertising method for Embarcadero's products. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- marcov · 2014-05-11 13:22 Quote from: BeniBela on May 11, 2014, 01:20:16 pmThat lawsuit was not about patents It was about copyright on APIs And yes, it means fpc/lazarus are already violating Borland's copyright for e.g. having an IntToStr function or a max function, instead having other names for these function, so they could be sued out of existence APIs/interfaces are not covered by copyright. Unlike C, Pascal headers don't contain code (inline functions or macros). The fact that they publish the documentation on the internet, and all their users publish parts (even implementations) without being remanded will make it extremely hard to enforce. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- marcov · 2014-05-11 13:36 Quote from: jwdietrich on May 11, 2014, 01:38:15 pmWell, that is a very important question. In fact, Embarcadero owns a lot of patents, and that for the two-way-tools method could also affect Lazarus. However, this is also the case for most other IDEs, including Microsoft Visual Studio, Apple's Xcode and even most HTML editors. Not Microsoft, which afaik paid 80+ million in the early noughties for a cross-license agreement. If I apply 20 years after first filing (as per wikipedia for patents with first filing after '95), that means it terminates in 2016. The google overview  page ( http://www.google.com/patents/US6185728 ) seems to count only 12 "fee" based years till now though. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- BeniBela · 2014-05-11 14:35 Quote from: marcov on May 11, 2014, 03:22:17 pm APIs/interfaces are not covered by copyright They are now That is the point ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Leledumbo · 2014-05-11 14:52 Quote from: BeniBela on May 11, 2014, 04:35:19 pmQuote from: marcov on May 11, 2014, 03:22:17 pm APIs/interfaces are not covered by copyright They are now That is the point Oh really? Any references? That's too damn dangerous to happen ---------------------------------------------------------------------- jwdietrich · 2014-05-11 14:56 Quote from: BeniBela on May 11, 2014, 04:35:19 pmQuote from: marcov on May 11, 2014, 03:22:17 pm APIs/interfaces are not covered by copyright They are now That is the point Yes, you are right. However, 17 U.S. Code § 107 defines limitations on exclusive rights (fair use): QuoteNotwithstanding the provisions of sections 106 and 106A, the fair use of a copyrighted work, including such use by reproduction in copies or phonorecords or by any other means specified by that section, for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching (including multiple copies for classroom use), scholarship, or research, is not an infringement of copyright. In determining whether the use made of a work in any particular case is a fair use the factors to be considered shall include the purpose and character of the use, including whether such use is of a commercial nature or is for nonprofit educational purposes;the nature of the copyrighted work;the amount and substantiality of the portion used in relation to the copyrighted work as a whole; andthe effect of the use upon the potential market for or value of the copyrighted work.The fact that a work is unpublished shall not itself bar a finding of fair use if such finding is made upon consideration of all the above factors. I have marked the points that I think to be important for Lazarus and Free Pascal in bold. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Rails · 2014-05-11 14:57 Quote from: BeniBela on May 11, 2014, 04:35:19 pmQuote from: marcov on May 11, 2014, 03:22:17 pm APIs/interfaces are not covered by copyright They are now That is the point One appeals court has ruled that they are subject to copyright, going against all prevailing legal theory and shocking just about everyone. They also ruled the case must go back to a jury to decide if Google can claim a fair use exemption. This is far, far from over. The US Supreme Court is almost certain to get involved at some point, and there is a building consensus here that the patent wars have gone too far and are hurting just about everyone, except the patent trolls driving them. When you add copyrightable APIs to the mix, it will force the US Congress to put a stop to this nonsense. Even it it doesn't the Supreme Court still has to rule. It will be years before it is all decided. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Rails · 2014-05-11 15:09 Here is a fair use  quote from gigaom:  "As the comments on Twitter suggest, the controversy may focus renewed attention on the role of the Federal Circuit, which is responsible for all patent appeals in the country but, in this case, issued a rare copyright ruling. The court has been criticized as “rogue” and has been repeatedly overturned 9-0 by the Supreme Court." https://gigaom.com/2014/05/09/tech-world-stunned-as-court-rules- oracle-can-own-apis-google-loses-copyright-appeal/ ---------------------------------------------------------------------- jwdietrich · 2014-05-11 15:13 Quote from: Rails on May 11, 2014, 04:57:04 pmThey also ruled the case must go back to a jury to decide if Google can claim a fair use exemption. Google is one the five largest American technology companies, a highly profitable multinational corporation, owner of a multitude of internet services including the most powerful search engine on earth, and although they made a net income of nearly 13 billion dollars in 2012 they pursue various tax avoidance strategies. If it is in question if Google can claim a fair use exemption then there shouldn't be any earnest doubt that the Lazarus and Free Pascal projects may. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- motaz · 2014-05-12 14:03 Thank you all for that information, but I'm more confused now  it seems that API copyright is a very dangerous thing in software development, I thought that only patents are evil. All that could make software development tools/language industry to be more monopolized by big companies. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- marcov · 2014-05-13 06:58 Quote from: jwdietrich on May 11, 2014, 05:13:25 pmIf it is in question if Google can claim a fair use exemption then there shouldn't be any earnest doubt that the Lazarus and Free Pascal projects may. We don't have that kind of money to find the loopholes. But we are generally not US based, and can simply remove the sf.net account if we get a cease and desist. (or contact EFF and let them calculate chances on other actions). ---------------------------------------------------------------------- jwdietrich · 2014-05-13 14:48 Quote from: marcov on May 13, 2014, 08:58:03 amWe don't have that kind of money to find the loopholes. But we are generally not US based, and can simply remove the sf.net account if we get a cease and desist. (or contact EFF and let them calculate chances on other actions). That is correct, but what I wanted to say is that we should have the right to claim a fair use exemption. The limitations on exclusive rights as defined in 17 U.S. Code § 107 are well consistent with the principles of the Lazarus / Free Pascal projects.