How to have more bugs fixed on BugTracker? lazarus / 8-Other ---------------------------------------------------------------------- typo · 2013-12-01 21:48 Simple answer: pay people to do so. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Bart · 2013-12-01 22:59 Give me all your money I have a daytime job that pays my bills, all Lazarus development is done in my sparse freetime. Some of that freetime I like spending on programming: developing my own apps, some of that time I spend on my mountainbike. So, if you pay my bills, I can spend my working hours developing Lazarus, just for you. Bart ---------------------------------------------------------------------- marcov · 2013-12-02 07:54 Quote from: typo on December 01, 2013, 10:48:22 pmSimple answer: pay people to do so. Simpler answer: submit a correct patch that fixes it. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- typo · 2013-12-02 08:43 Maybe a donation button just beside download button on the Lazarus website. http://pt-br.libreoffice.org/home/ https://donate.libreoffice.org/pt/ ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Timewarp · 2013-12-02 09:09 Quote from: marcov on December 02, 2013, 08:54:21 amSimpler answer: submit a correct patch that fixes it. Some patches need feedback/help. For example, it was asked (twice) what else should do 21916 Very hard to contribute, if get zero help.  That bug BTW was fixed in Delphi many years ago, even old versions got new dcu. If I use Lazarus instead of Delphi, I need to apply own patches first. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- BigChimp · 2013-12-02 09:43 @Timewarp: you're right, that bug does look bad. Added a reminder, for the reassign request. Let's hope an FPC dev takes a look at it soon. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- BigChimp · 2013-12-03 13:15 @Timewarp: FPC dev Michael Van Canneyt just fixed issue 21916 in FPC trunk... Thanks a lot, Michael! ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Edson · 2013-12-03 16:35 IMHO, we could do: * Make the bugs more visible. I know there is a link at the left, but people won't see. Would be better add some banner at the top of the forum page, saying "Hey, we have 3000 bugs waiting  for you", "10 bugs where closed today", "20 bugs where reported today", "The bug-killer of the week is ...", "This bug have a reward of $1000 dead or alive", This bug have: Like 100 people" (Facebug). * Priorize the bugs solution. Keep some new features stand by, while bugs are fixed. Put objetives: We have to fix 100 bugs this month. * Bugtrucker should be simpler (I still don't know how to use it). I don't see any link for help on the Mantis page. Probably it should be multilanguage. * Make more people interested. There is always new people who are motivated, and come with new ideas. We can motivate them too for helping on bugs, and consider their ideas. * Help, people who are fixing bugs. Probably we are not going to fix the bug, but we can make it easy for them, giving information, testing or even giving hardware. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- marcov · 2013-12-03 17:23 Quote from: Edson on December 03, 2013, 05:35:46 pmIMHO, we could do: * Make the bugs more visible. I know there is a link at the left, but people won't see. Would be better add some banner at the top of the forum page, saying "Hey, we have 3000 bugs waiting  for you", "10 bugs where closed today", "20 bugs where reported today", "The bug-killer of the week is ...", "This bug have a reward of $1000 dead or alive", This bug have: Like 100 people" (Facebug). Totally useless fluff. People fix a bug because they think they have an idea how to solve it. Monetary rewards are typically given for issues that require large amounts of code written, not for stuff that can be solved by 2 lines. The money can then sway them to spend some serious time on it. But who is going to donate the $1000 per bug? (with 2300 Lazarus bugs and 700 FPC bugs open?) Quote* Priorize the bugs solution. Keep some new features stand by, while bugs are fixed. Put objetives: We have to fix 100 bugs this month. Objectives are useless without committing resources to actually achieve them. Quote* Bugtrucker should be simpler (I still don't know how to use it). I don't see any link for help on the Mantis page. Probably it should be multilanguage. Those are issues for the mantisbt project, not the freepascal/lazarus project. We don't develop the bugtracker Quote* Make more people interested. There is always new people who are motivated, and come with new ideas. We can motivate them too for helping on bugs, and consider their ideas. Go ahead. Quote* Help, people who are fixing bugs. Probably we are not going to fix the bug, but we can make it easy for them, giving information, testing or even giving hardware. Bug fixing is hard by nature, requiring both serious time and skill. Whatever you do to polish it up, this doesn't fix the real bottleneck with bugfixing. See a similar discussion in the "future of Lazarus" thread about docs. There is no serious lack in tools.  Yes, a lot could be done to make some aspects more polished, but actually effort doing that is badly spent, since previous efforts haven't really increased response ratios. The only thing I have seen a clear effect on getting more people solving bugs, is general quality and versatility of the FPC and Lazarus releases. It's only a very tiny percentage of users that does bugfixing, but a magnitude more users will also bring one or two more core members or regular bugfixers. (read people that post bugs with a quality analysis and patch) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- skalogryz · 2013-12-03 17:28 Do not allow an issue to be reported without * sample project; * patch to fix the bug; * detailed explanation on the issue and the patch itself; btw, I'm totally unserious at the moment, but I have to admin that some of the bugs reported satisfy the requirements above 100% ---------------------------------------------------------------------- JuhaManninen · 2013-12-03 22:05 I must say I share Marco's irritation for this non-sense. This forum has a regular flow of different hocus-pocus methods to speed up development. They are always presented by people who have no intention to do the development themselves. Always somebody else should do it but they only want to give their expert advice about how to proceed. There was a time when many "experts" explained how Lazarus project would get substantial amount of new contributors if only it supported distributed development model using Git. Those people had no intention to contribute any code of course but still they were worried about the poor quality of our tool chain. Well, distributed development using Git has been possible ~ a year but still nobody has contributed anything using it.   http://wiki.freepascal.org/Creating_A_Patch#Using_a_forked_Git_repos itory_directly Quote from: Edson on December 03, 2013, 05:35:46 pm[...] * Make more people interested. There is always new people who are motivated, and come with new ideas. We can motivate them too for helping on bugs, and consider their ideas. * Help, people who are fixing bugs. Probably we are not going to fix the bug, but we can make it easy for them, giving information, testing or even giving hardware. No, we don't need ideas from new people. We have enough ideas. We need program code instead. Why it must be somebody else fixing the bugs and not you? Yes, YOU! Read and learn the source code, make a change, debug. You will notice you didn't understand enough of the code yet. Then learn more, make a better change, debug ... and so on ... hours and hours and hours ... That's what I did. I am not especially clever, so if I can do it, most people with some programming skills can do it. There is no hocus- pocus, just devote your brain capacity and time to the task. Understood? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- typo · 2013-12-03 22:21 Quote from: JuhaManninen on December 03, 2013, 11:05:42 pmNo, we don't need ideas from new people. We have enough ideas. We need program code instead. I don't want to polemize, but if you want workers, you need to pay them. Someone has said ealier that divide his free time between Lazarus and a mountain bike. This is the reality. The more boring Lazarus becomes, the more the mountain bike wins. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Giu · 2013-12-03 23:09 To get more committers, you need a greater dev base. To increase dev base, promotion is needed. One thing I noticed is the low quantity of blogs about lazarus development. Main lazarus blog is not updqted frequently, either official twitter. This things are the first i search when look a languaje/framework. Its a symbol of comminity. Maybe a planet of lazarus and delphi developers couldmbe interesting ---------------------------------------------------------------------- marcov · 2013-12-03 23:11 Quote from: typo on December 03, 2013, 11:21:56 pmI don't want to polemize, but if you want workers, you need to pay them. People are asking questions how to force growth beyond the natural.  That's the polemic. The answer from core is that the the current baseline is targeted at natural, autonomic growth, with the occasional (paid) sponsorship directed at fundamental projects that are not necessarily end-user visible. Note that sponsorships received often carry conditions that are not automatically in the direction towards more users, or even just user visible (*). More likely they are sponsorships that strengths an area that the sponsor needs. (*) think of stuff like    - ARM codegeneration improvements   - LLVM improvements   etc. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- JuhaManninen · 2013-12-03 23:14 Quote from: typo on December 03, 2013, 11:21:56 pmI don't want to polemize, but if you want workers, you need to pay them. Lazarus developers are doing it for free. Nobody pays them. At least I didn't get any money. I did get other benefits like 2 nice meetings with fellow developers, and I appreciate it, but that is still not a payment. QuoteSomeone has said ealier that divide his free time between Lazarus and a mountain bike. This is the reality. The more boring Lazarus becomes, the more the mountain bike wins. Why would Lazarus get more boring? I feel it gets more interesting when it matures and works well most of time. Quote from: Giu on December 04, 2013, 12:09:51 amTo get more committers, you need a greater dev base. To increase dev base, promotion is needed. One thing I noticed is the low quantity of blogs about lazarus development. Main lazarus blog is not updqted frequently, either official twitter. This things are the first i search when look a languaje/framework. Its a symbol of comminity. That is true. PR would be important. I feel there should be somebody responsible for promotion. He/she should not be a core SW developer. It needs a little different mind set. How to organize it in practice, I have no idea. I already announced a position for a web page author once and it lead to a chaos. Now I am not planning to announce anything. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Timewarp · 2013-12-04 09:19 Quote from: BigChimp on December 03, 2013, 02:15:14 pmFPC dev Michael Van Canneyt just fixed issue 21916 in FPC trunk...Thanks for the help! There are ofcourse more issues needing feedback/little help. Some bugs are simple, but most too hard to fix properly on your own.. Also anyone can help testing old bugs. Some are already fixed, duplicates, or no way to test.. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- typo · 2013-12-04 13:58 Quote from: marcov on December 03, 2013, 06:23:22 pmBut who is going to donate the $1000 per bug? (with 2300 Lazarus bugs and 700 FPC bugs open?) Why $1000 per bug? Why not $1? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- marcov · 2013-12-04 14:41 Quote from: typo on December 04, 2013, 02:58:00 pmQuote from: marcov on December 03, 2013, 06:23:22 pmBut who is going to donate the $1000 per bug? (with 2300 Lazarus bugs and 700 FPC bugs open?) Why $1000 per bug? Why not $1? Why $1 then? And not $0 ?   If you spend 3 days tracking issues, and fix a bug and a related reported, you get two whole dollars. I would say that is more demotivating than motivating. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- typo · 2013-12-04 15:05 Well, why not  -$1, why not to pay to fix a bug? This way bugs are fixed and you have more donations too. lol ---------------------------------------------------------------------- JuhaManninen · 2013-12-04 15:34 Quote from: typo on December 04, 2013, 04:05:40 pmWell, why not  -$1, why not to pay to fix a bug? This way bugs are fixed and you have more donations too. lol Typo, why are you so worried about the project's donations? Why don't you fix bugs yourself? Are you waiting somebody to pay you? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- typo · 2013-12-04 15:38 I am an old retired man and have a family which consumes all my energies for the moment. And you, why are you so worried about forum ideas? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- JuhaManninen · 2013-12-04 18:19 Quote from: typo on December 04, 2013, 04:38:33 pmI am an old retired man and have a family which consumes all my energies for the moment. And you, why are you so worried about forum ideas? Right, sorry, I am not worried of ideas, but many people try to explain how OTHER people could fix bugs. Maybe I am just little tired of that. In fact my own energy goes now to my work. I try to return to Lazarus code later with more energy. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- typo · 2013-12-05 14:09 Programming is declining, the environment is not so good as it was on the beginning of the internet. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- JuhaManninen · 2013-12-05 18:35 Quote from: typo on December 05, 2013, 03:09:04 pmProgramming is declining, the environment is not so good as it was on the beginning of the internet. Don't worry. Some things decline but other things rise. Think of Android as an example. The first Android phone was sold in October 2008, just 5 years ago! Now it is the dominant operating system in many market segments. Did anybody predict this in 2007? No, Google was a search engine company and such a prediction would have sounded ridiculous. The whole OS scene in boiling. MS has already lost its dominance. Android is surely not the last word in this game. More systems will come, based on Linux or some other kernel. We have yet only seen the beginning. I did not use word "mobile" so far because such definitions loose their meaning soon. All computers will be "mobile" in near future. A "personal computer" will be a small gadget in your pocket, just like a cell phone, but with easy connections to an external monitor, mouse and keyboard. The current PC boxes with their multiply noisy propellers will be history soon. Let's make this a more philosophical issue: We are real pioneers of programming at this time of history. Please think of the time scales. Agriculture was invented 10000 years ago but still people are constantly improving it. Metal refinement was also invented thousands of years ago but still it is constantly improved. But programming... damn it was invented less than a hundred years ago! All the development so far has been just initial cooking to find good ideas and this process still goes on. Will Object Pascal survive? Of course not, it is just part of the initial cooking. My predictions however is that it will survive longer than C++. They will both live longer than I, so I cannot witness it unfortunately. Still more perspective: My country (Finland) was very primitive when other European countries had already high cultures. I visited an out-doors museum in Lieksa, North-East of the country.   http://www.lieksa.fi/Resource.phx/sivut/sivut- lieksa/sivistys/museo/museum.htx It was mind-blowing. The oldest houses + yards were from 1600's. Just 400 years ago there were neither window glass nor chimneys in this country. Houses were heated with fire below a big pile of stones. The smoke came in and people had to be outside while the house was heated. The heating is important as it gets very cold in winter (below -35 Celsius). Earth floors were normal but "better people"'s houses had wooden floors. One such house had earth floor in only one corner for a horse. There were no glass windows but a small opening was covered with a cow's bladder, so a bit of light came in. It was less that 400 years ago. Genetically the people were identical with me. How well would I survive there? Uhhh! Think of the contrast between now and 300-400 years ago. Then think of how the world will look like after another 300-400 years? The difference will be mind-bowing again. I can imagine my computer box in a museum then. People will laugh at its noisy propellers and ridiculous computing power. How will the now infant programming techniques improve? Up to now there has been only one fundamental improvement. It was the move from assembly to high level languages. Since then languages have refined but the changes were not fundamental. Not GC nor Object Orientation. They help but they do not change the problem solving process fundamentally. After 400 years the scene will show at least some maturity. Artificial intelligence will be part of compilers. Languages will resemble more human languages than current programming languages. Ambiguities are allowed just like in human languages. The compiler will guess the programmer's meaning from context and will prevent any potential nasty bugs. This was very much out of topic. Sorry. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Dick, from the internet · 2013-12-05 18:51 QuoteThis was very much out of topic. Sorry. Maybe, but I found it very interesting.  Thank you for this perspective.   regards,       geno ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Timewarp · 2013-12-05 20:16 Quote from: JuhaManninen on December 05, 2013, 07:35:07 pmit gets very cold in winter (below -35 Celsius).Well, that may be little exaggerating ofcource depends much where you live. I've never experienced that.. in my lifetime. Looking outside, it's dark, little snow, around 0 degrees, sea is completely open no ice, western Finland ---------------------------------------------------------------------- typo · 2013-12-05 21:32 This reminds me a film I have saw one day: portuguese people has discovered China and Nordic people -- why not? -- has discovered the sun. Now the problem here is the heat: 26 Celsius degrees inside my house. At least now is raining and this cools the air. Air-conditioner is highly needed here. AI probably will improve compilers and it will not be needed any programming language. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Bart · 2013-12-05 21:46 Quote from: typo on December 05, 2013, 10:32:08 pmAI probably will improve compilers and it will not be needed any programming language. This will be the ultimate FreePascal program. No need for any other program anymore. (And it cannot be done in C) Code: [Select]Program GUP;  //Grand Unified Program begin   Fpc.Compiler.ReadMyMind;   Fpc.Compiler.BuildWhatINeed;   Fpc.Compiler.RunExternal(Self); end. Bart ---------------------------------------------------------------------- typo · 2013-12-05 22:42 Here is an image of the house where brazilian pioneers have lived. http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/8/84/Casa_do_Bandeirante _01.JPG There was a wall around the house to protect it from indian invasions. Note that this is the house where rich people has lived. The poor ones have lived in houses like this: http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/8/88/Serra-Talhada-Casa- de-taipa.jpg From these to that http://img.archiexpo.com/images_ae/photo-g/contemporary-ecological- prefab-micro-houses-70395-3299411.jpg was a long way, of course. I still have a PC, but all people I know don't have it anymore. They use smartphones for the internet. I have begun using internet as a revolutionary in 1995 and now I am a dinosaur. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- avra · 2013-12-06 08:03 There is a new Linux magazine emerging on the horizon, with quite a unique idea of funding open source projects. It is mostly ex- LinuxFormat team, so they are serious players. Here is what they say: We want to give something back. 50% of our profits will go back to Free Software and Linux communities, and our readership will choose where the money goes. Our content will be published for free after 9 months. This might be an opportunity for Lazarus/FPC funding that should not be missed. http://www.raspberrypi.org/archives/5366 ---------------------------------------------------------------------- JuhaManninen · 2013-12-06 10:59 Quote from: Timewarp on December 05, 2013, 09:16:36 pmQuote from: JuhaManninen on December 05, 2013, 07:35:07 pmit gets very cold in winter (below -35 Celsius).Well, that may be little exaggerating ofcource depends much where you live. I've never experienced that.. in my lifetime. It is ~ the lowest temperature I have experienced, but in north near Lieksa it happens more frequently. That is the area where people used to die for starvation in masses when crops were destroyed by bad weather. It is too cold climate for agriculture IMO. We have the independence day now, history comes to mind inevitably. Sorry about out of topic again... ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Edson · 2013-12-08 19:09 I have been some busy doing a Lazarus documentation and a patch, so I couldn't answer at time. Quote from: marcov on December 03, 2013, 06:23:22 pmBut who is going to donate the $1000 per bug? (with 2300 Lazarus bugs and 700 FPC bugs open?) I was doing an exaggerated example. It hasn't to be literal. Quote from: JuhaManninen on December 03, 2013, 11:05:42 pmNo, we don't need ideas from new people. We have enough ideas. We need program code instead. This is what I say to my employees, because I pay them. But I don't thing this could apply here. This is something that we cannot avoid. There will always be people coming up with new ideas, and that's no reason to bother. Someone ask how to have more bugs fixed and I respond with my ideas. Is that bad? We have to be careful, because expression like this can disappoint people for continue contributing. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- typo · 2013-12-08 20:15 Quote from: Edson on December 08, 2013, 08:09:50 pmSomeone ask how to have more bugs fixed and I respond with my ideas. Is that bad? We have to be careful, because expression like this can disappoint people for continue contributing. Yes, I agree. That is not true. We do need donations, more bugs fixed and we need ideas too. Thanks. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- JuhaManninen · 2013-12-09 06:40 Quote from: Edson on December 08, 2013, 08:09:50 pmI have been some busy doing a Lazarus documentation and a patch, so I couldn't answer at time. ... We have to be careful, because expression like this can disappoint people for continue contributing. I am sorry, I did not realize you were already doing that. The fact still is that have much more ideas than there are people willing to implement those ideas.