Why I changed from MySQL to MariaDB in Lazarus? lazarus / 8-Other ---------------------------------------------------------------------- jepafi · 2013-05-17 13:21 (Translated with Google) I'll report my experience with MariaDB in Lazarus and my sadness with the owners of MySQL Recently I wrote the following for Oracle (see also images attached): " I wonder if my software can have the name "JPDB Admin for MySQL" and use the logo shown in the attached file logojpdb.png? I wonder, also, if I can use the MySQL software in my official logo and website software, this way: The images in attached, and img1.png img2.png, Manda how i intend to use the MySQL logo on the site. The intention is just que the user has a visual reference que my software accesses and manipulates databases, tables, indexes and other structures of the MySQL que I am well aware, in the texts of the website and the software, I never Dou any indication que the Oracle or MySQL supports, recommends or is co- author of my software. In the images in attached, and img3.png img4.png, you will find red circles highlighting yellow icons of database. I would like to use in place of these icons, the MySQL dolphin in size 16x16 and 32x32, respectivamente. The icons in 16x16 que Indicate the software is Accessing the MySQL The 32x32 icon Indicates that the MySQL database is being created. In Conclusion, i believe que Encouraging the development of software such as JPDB Admin, Contributes to the large and growing popularity of any product from Oracle here in Brazil and worldwide. Sorry my Inglês. I am Brazilian and I speak only English. I used Google to translate this text. Thanks for the attention of gentlemen! Best regards, Jean Patrick Independent Software Developer. " Oracle The answer is as follows: " Thank you for coming and contact us with your inquiry. While we appreciate your support brand MySQL, Oracle generally does not allow the use of their logos third-party trademark. As I'm sure you understand, trademarks of Oracle are valuable assets that must be protected against uses that could create the false impression that Oracle or endorse products and services of other parties. Therefore, Oracle can not grant permission for the proposed use of the logo on your MySQL software. For more information, please refer to our guidelines on using third-party logo on Oracle: http://www.mysql.com/about/legal/trademark.html http://www.oracle.com/us/legal/third-party-logos/third-party- logos-078569.html According to the guidelines for use of the logo, the logo of MySQL can be used on a website offering the logo be a link "clickable" which leads directly to http://www.mysql.com/ Oracle does not provide specific logos for members of our Oracle PartnerNetwork Oracle and other programs, including authorized providers of training programs Oracle Certified Professional and Oracle certified. For more information about these programs, please contact us or see Oracle.com. Thank you for checking with us on this. Do not hesitate to contact us if you have any questions, please. Sincerely, Oracle Trademarks and Copyrights Group " Well, as you may have read I can not use even the dolphin alone in size 16x16 or 32x32 in the places indicated in the attached images. Also, no one gave permission that I can use the name "JPDB Admin for MySQL". But before that, who has a version of JPDB Premium Admin can see that I use the icon focuses MariaDB. In addition, the library distributed with the JPDB Admin Premium to access MySQL and MariaDB MariaDB is what is under the LGPL license. If I distribuise the MySQL library (both MariaDB as MySQL has the same name libmysql.dll) along with my application would violate the law. Therefore, the version of JPDB Admin access only to MariaDB and MySQL table is called "Admin JPDB for MariaDB." Some advantages compared to MariaDB MySQL: is faster, supports sub query's, supports calculated fields (type computed by the Firebird), the embedded version and LGPL, etc.. Good news to show that one need not be as rigid as the Oracle: Recently, I sent the same email to "Firebird Foundation Incorporated" and they answered me thus: " (Translated with Google) Hello again Jean, At 11:31 08/05/2013, you wrote: > Good night Helen! > > As requested, I am sending, attached the pictures showing how I intend to make use of the Firebird logo on my site software and software (JPDB JPDB Admin Admin Premium and Firebird). > > Images, and img1.png img2.png, I intend to demonstrate how to use the Firebird logo on the site. The intention is that the user only has a visual reference that my software accesses and manipulates databases, tables, indexes and other structures of the Firebird. I am well aware that, in the texts of the website and the software, I will never give any indication that the Firebird Foundation supports, recommends or is co-author of my software. > > In the image, and img3.png img4.png, you will find red circles highlighting icons with the figure of a flame of fire. I would like to use in place of these icons Firebird logo in size 16x16 and 32x32, respectively. The icons in 16x16 indicate that the software is accessing the Firebird. The 32x32 icon indicates that a Firebird database is being created. That usage is just fine. You are welcome to use the logo as you Demonstrated. Good luck with your project. Helen Borrie, Secretary Firebird Foundation Incorporated. " So next release JPDB Admin in connection icons on the screen and the Firebird database to create, we have the official logo of the Firebird. Also, recently asked the following questions to Fast-report on the Open Query Builder I converted to Lazarus: " I created a modified version of the Open Query Builder to compile in Lazarus. It's working perfectly, with all the resources in Windows and Linux GTK2 and QT. Also I created an enginer to connect with a suite of components ZEOS. Download: http://github.com/jepafi/Laz_Query_Builder/archive/master.zip I wonder if you have any objections to what I did? And what you allow me to the with the modified code? Can I use the code converted to Lazarus in commercial software? " The response of Den Zubov was: " Hello, We do not have any objections it's an open source software you can use it whatever you want. " Therefore, the Open Query Builder will be part of JPDB Admin. The next version of JPDB Admin screen "About ...", will contain copies of all licenses (LGPL, MIT, etc.), copyright notices, as used in the code, authors and links to all third-party libraries and icons I used the code. And that's it! ---------------------------------------------------------------------- BigChimp · 2013-05-17 15:16 Sorry to hear about the mysql response but it's not unexpected. Why do you think you are in legal trouble when you distribute a mariadb LGPL client connector called mysql.dll and allow connection to a mysql database? I don't really see any problem with that!? Thanks for the great work digging out confirmation for free use of open query builder and I appreciate your asking the relevant companies/entities about use of their logos: very professional! thanks, BigChimp ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Leledumbo · 2013-05-17 16:23 Good to hear that you've moved to MariaDB. Poor for Oracle because of their vanity. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- jepafi · 2013-05-17 19:42 Quote from: BigChimp on May 17, 2013, 05:16:20 pmWhy do you think you are in legal trouble when you distribute a mariadb LGPL client connector called mysql.dll and allow connection to a mysql database? I don't really see any problem with that!? I think it's a little confusing the Google translation. I was referring to the MySQL library. I know i can use the free library of MariaDB, provided that, within the terms of the LGPL. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- BigChimp · 2013-05-18 05:20 Ah ok, that clears it up. Thanks - obrigado! ---------------------------------------------------------------------- cpalx · 2013-06-08 14:37 And why didt you change to PostgreSQL? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- taazz · 2013-06-08 15:37 how an admin application for MYSQL would benefit from changing to PostgreSQL? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- BigChimp · 2013-06-10 05:23 Well.. make it a cross-db admin application ---------------------------------------------------------------------- a.atalla · 2013-08-24 22:12 I want to use MariaDB  in a closed source commercial application , i will install the GPL mariadb server for my  customer , i will use  The LGPL client libirary (libmariadb.dll) - sqldb MySQL component  doesn't recognize  libmariadb.dll and keep asking for libmysql.dll , if i rename it  the 5.1 component  and 5.5 refuse to connect as the mariadb version is 5.3 what is the legal and right way to use Mariadb server and client lib ???? thanks