TButton & TRadioButton don't trigger TEdit OnExit or OnEditingDone. Workaround! lazarus / 31-LCL ---------------------------------------------------------------------- lor · 2015-03-27 19:42 Here's a workaround I devised to overcome the problem described further below: In coming up with this I discovered that an OnClick event occurs before the OnEnter event for same control, (perhaps this is explained somewhere in the documentation but I hadn't seen it) and the OnEndEditing event for the prior control is not triggered until the OnEnter occurs for the new control. What I did was add an OnClick action to every button and radio button; and put an extra button on the form, shown below as ButtonSemaphore; and made a form class method, to be shared by all the OnClicks, that assigns the form.ActiveControl to be ButtonSemaphore, which occurs before the OnEnter following the OnClick. The assignment to ButtonSemaphore causes the OnEndEditing to occur for the previously vacated TEdit, then the new control is resumed at its OnEnter entry point. Here are examples of the click and shared procedures: procedure TForm1.RadioTxINIClick(Sender: TObject); begin     ForceEditingDoneOnTEdits(Sender);     ... other process, if any... end; procedure TForm1.ForceEditingDoneOnTEdits (Sender :TObject); begin     ButtonSemaphore.Show;     ActiveControl := ButtonSemaphore;     ButtonSemaphore.Hide; end; The Show and Hide render the semaphore button invisible to the user. It should be defined as not visible to start with. The Show allows the assignment to occur, because focus assignments are forbidden to invisible and/or disabled controls. Original Problem: When a TButton or TRadioButton control is clicked, the previously changed TEdit control .OnExit or .EditingDone actions do not occur. They do occur if another TEdit control is entered, however. How can I change this behavior so that the TEdit controls get exit and/or done actions activated when a button os pushed? I'd rather not have to monitor edit fields and change the entry of every button to call the edit control exit actions. Thanks for enlightening me! Now here I've added the requested test case program. Lazarus 1.2.6  FPC 2.6.4  Mac OSX 8.5  i386-darwin-carbon So below is a little test program for TEdit. It shows two TEdit controls, a TButton control with no action, a TButton that terminates the program, and a TRadioButton that has no action.  Changes to Edit1 are reflected in Edit2 when Edit1 actions are EditingDone and/or Exit. When Edit1 gets focus with a mouse click, it's Text is saved and then set to be empty in anticipation of the entry of new data by the user. When the Exit or EditingDone occur: if the text is still empty it is restored from the saved datum, and the text value, either new or restored, is copied to the Edit2 control. The QUIT button closes the program. The EditingDone or Exit actions occur for Edit1 when the user clicks on the form field or on the Edit2 control, but the actions do not occur when the TButton or TRadioButton is clicked, indicating that Edit1 has not lost focus. I suggest there could be an option for TEdit to either lose or regain focus when any kind of button is used. unit Unit1; {$mode objfpc}{$H+} interface uses   Classes, SysUtils, Forms, Controls, Graphics,   Dialogs, StdCtrls; type   TForm1 = class(TForm)     Button1: TButton;     ButtonQuit: TButton;     Edit1: TEdit;     Edit2: TEdit;     Label1: TLabel;     Label2: TLabel;     RadioButton1: TRadioButton;   procedure ButtonQuitClick(Sender: TObject);   procedure Edit1Click(Sender: TObject);   procedure Edit1EditingDone(Sender: TObject);   procedure Edit1Exit(Sender: TObject);   private   public end; var   Form1: TForm1; implementation {$R *.lfm} var  saveEdit :shortstring; procedure updateEdit2; begin      Form1.Edit2.Text := Form1.Edit1.Text; end; procedure TForm1.ButtonQuitClick(Sender: TObject); begin     Close; end; procedure TForm1.Edit1Click(Sender: TObject); begin     saveEdit := Edit1.Text;     Edit1.Text := ''; end; procedure TForm1.Edit1EditingDone(Sender: TObject); begin     if Edit1.Text = '' then Edit1.Text := saveEdit;     updateEdit2; end; procedure TForm1.Edit1Exit(Sender: TObject); begin     Edit1EditingDone(Sender); end; end. object Form1: TForm1   Left = 766   Height = 319   Top = 385   Width = 371   Caption = 'Form1'   ClientHeight = 319   ClientWidth = 371   LCLVersion = '1.2.6.0'   object Edit1: TEdit     Left = 162     Height = 22     Top = 55     Width = 44     OnClick = Edit1Click     OnEditingDone = Edit1EditingDone     OnExit = Edit1Exit     TabOrder = 0     Text = 'X'   end   object Edit2: TEdit     Left = 162     Height = 22     Top = 90     Width = 44     TabOrder = 1   end   object Button1: TButton     Left = 162     Height = 25     Top = 144     Width = 75     Caption = 'Button 1'     TabOrder = 2   end   object ButtonQuit: TButton     Left = 162     Height = 25     Top = 225     Width = 75     Caption = 'QUIT'     OnClick = ButtonQuitClick     TabOrder = 3   end   object RadioButton1: TRadioButton     Left = 138     Height = 18     Top = 183     Width = 68     Caption = 'Radio 1'     TabOrder = 4   end   object Label1: TLabel     Left = 90     Height = 16     Top = 57     Width = 36     Caption = 'Edit 1'     ParentColor = False   end   object Label2: TLabel     Left = 90     Height = 16     Top = 93     Width = 36     Caption = 'Edit 2'     ParentColor = False   end end ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Mike.Cornflake · 2015-03-27 19:55 G'day, This doesn't sound like expected behaviour to me.  Either you've found a bug, or you're not doing something correct. Try to reduce your code to a simple test case that reproduces the issue, then post the code here.  Others will likely attempt to run your code and let you know if it's your code or LCL code that's at fault. Also, please remember that the code you're running will change depending on platform, and depending on what version of the LCL you're running.  You will need to let us know these details as well. If it turns out to be a bug in the LCL, then please read this; http://wiki.lazarus.freepascal.org/How_do_I_create_a_bug_report Our bugtracker is at: http://bugs.freepascal.org/view_all_bug_page.php?project_id=1 In fact, looking in there, what you post sounds suspiciously like: http://bugs.freepascal.org/view.php?id=20057 In which case, the issue just well may be resolved in the trunk version of the code base.  Trunk is the latest development version, I'm guessing you're running an older stable release... Which raises your next question ;-)  How do I get Trunk? There are two known easy ways, and the official harder way.  Google (or search these forums) for fpcup and getlazarus for the easy two :-) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- lor · 2015-03-27 20:19 Thanks. I'll put something together and edit my query. I am using the current distribution versions. The bug you mentioned is similar, but only addresses the use of the Return key. I think I've found a bug, having tried many ways with extra code to trap or detect the situation. I can understand that some applications would not want the text editing to be terminated while the user presses some kind of button as part of the edit (copy something, etc.), but that should be a controllable option I would think. --Lor ---------------------------------------------------------------------- zeljko · 2015-03-27 20:28 Quote from: lor on March 27, 2015, 08:42:30 pmWhen a TButton or TRadioButton control is clicked, the previously changed TEdit control .OnExit or .EditingDone actions do not occur. They do occur if another TEdit control is entered, however. How can I change this behavior so that the TEdit controls get exit and/or done actions activated when a button os pushed? I'd rather not have to monitor edit fields and change the entry of every button to call the edit control exit actions. Thanks for enlightening me! If your button is TSpeedButton then it's obvious that OnExit won't trigger, since TEdit is still focused. If you clicked eg TBitBtn (and it takes focus) and TEdit.OnExit does not trigger then it's bug. What lazarus version do you use ? Operating system ? Widgetset ? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- lor · 2015-04-03 04:45 Please see additions to the original post. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Mike.Cornflake · 2015-04-03 18:10 If I'm understanding you correctly, then this issue is resolved in Trunk already.  I'm running Windows 7, SVN48027, win32/win64.  I did wonder if Bart's patch in http://bugs.freepascal.org/view.php?id=20057 would also fix this issue. Running your code, if I make a change in Edit1, then click either the Tbutton or TRadioButton, my changes are immediately copied to the second Edit2. There is currently a release candidate for the next version of Lazarus.  Looking at the timings, this should have issue 20057 resolved in it.   You can either try the RC, or wait until 1.4 is formally released... QuoteLazarus 1.2.6  FPC 2.6.4  Mac OSX 8.5  i386-darwin-carbon Ahh.  We need someone else on that operating system to double check.  Might be working under windows only... ---------------------------------------------------------------------- lor · 2015-04-04 03:19 Many thanks for taking the time to check into this.  I will wait for someone on Mac to verify if the newer version fixes it. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- lor · 2015-04-10 11:38 Please see my workaround placed at the top of the original post.