Lazarus compatible Linux ? lazarus / 31-LCL ---------------------------------------------------------------------- zacheus · 2012-04-10 12:30 Hello, Why is it impossible to obtain the same effects under Linux and Windows ? Ex. Create and change the Color and TextColor of a disabled TEdit : With Windows : OK but with Linux : resolved with an improbable do-it- yourself. HideCaret in a ReadOnly TMemo. With Windows : easy. With Linux : I still search. I know well that the management of messages is different in 2 OS but why the problem is not adjusted with Linux ? Why Lazarus Linux is less evolved than Lazarus Windows or why Lazarus is more compatible Windows then Linux and Linux then Mac ? Apparently, in Lazarus, the management of the events is optimized for Windows and not for Linux. Is it due to the so called compatibility Delphi? It is all the same curious that on elementary objects there is so much difference. So my question. And why this effects are not "native" in Lazarus ? I have the feeling that these components are not finished as TStaticTexts. Try the BorderSpacing !... or Caption := StaticTex1 with  height = 45 and width = 232 : Result -> "StatictText" on the first line end "t1" on a second ! Curious... With some TMemo, Tedit and TStatictText  that I wanted to use in a ergonomic way and in the same way under Windows and Linux, I shall have been able to make at least 6 reports of bugs. It is normal for this kind of components? Never anything met of similar QT / C ++. Or then it is necessary to use Lazarus with QT? It is absolutely not professionel. If widgets developed apparently for Windows misses entry points of management of the events under Linux, it is necessary to change them... CustownDrawn perhaps, but it is necessary to develop it. We must be able to use Lazarus without losing too much hours to try to adjust this kind of internal mechanics. Regards. Zacheus ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Leledumbo · 2012-04-10 13:06 QuoteI know well that the management of messages is different in 2 OS but why the problem is not adjusted with Linux ?Something that is unknown would never get fixed, report whenever you found bugs. QuoteWhy Lazarus Linux is less evolved than Lazarus Windows or why Lazarus is more compatible Windows then Linux and Linux then Mac ?Actually, not really. Even AFAIK most of the development is done on Linux. It's just Linux doesn't have native GUI subsystem like Windows (Windows API is integrated into the OS). You are allowed to choose the available GUI backends. I use Qt on Linux and AFAIE (As Far As I Experience) everything is much better than GTK(2). Lazarus Mac gets native support since about a year ago or so. Prior to that, the situation is more or less the same as Linux. The current Carbon interface is already usable, and the Cocoa interface is on development. Nothing is left behind or abandoned as long as maintainers exist. QuoteApparently, in Lazarus, the management of the events is optimized for Windows and not for Linux. Is it due to the so called compatibility Delphi?Why do you think so? It's not optimized for Windows, but it's Delphi VCL compatibility that makes it so (which in turn wraps Windows API). Even so, Delphi doesn't expose Windows-ism too much at its highest level (VCL). Which parts do you think are too Windows-ish? QuoteSo my question. Why this effects are not "native" in Lazarus ?Define "native". Some people think "native" means to use whatever the GUI backend provides, some other think of it as "must be handled at the highest level as possible, apart from the underlying GUI backend". Which one is in your mind? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Blaazen · 2012-04-10 13:25 QuoteI have the feeling that these components are not finished as TStaticTexts. Try the BorderSpacing !... or Caption := StaticTex1 with  height = 45 and width = 232 : Result -> "StatictText" on the first line end "t1" on a second ! Curious... Coincidence, I reported this today, it is GTK2 issue. http://bugs.freepascal.org/view.php?id=21697 ---------------------------------------------------------------------- zacheus · 2012-04-10 13:28 You use Qt on Linux and Win32 or 64 on Windows... It is not very portable! And, if I use QT, I know another solution which works cleanly but I learnt to develop in Pascal... I like Lazarus but it is necessary to be serious... Then Lazarus is mainly developed under Linux. Then, why all these limitations which do not exist with Windows Lazarus ? Because the ancestor it is Delphi ? With the arrival of Windows 8, it's time to put back it in question and to renew the approach of components. What is the slogan of Lazarus...  I have difficulty in reading or translating... "Write once, run anywhere"  The problem is not to know if we can develop on Linux and Windows  with Lazarus. With a common code, we can obtain something solid. Now is it normal that I can not eliminate the Caret of TMemo under Linux? Is it normal under Windows that I can change the color of a disabled TEdit but not the TextColor ? Is it normal that I stack 2 StaticTexts to manage BorderSpacing on Windows and on Linux ? If your answer is yes, to defend from such position, we can understand the so restricted number of lazarus developers. Am I too much requiring ? Then, there is another problem. The way are built some widget prevents from being able to modify them in a significant way. Things so basic as the selection multilines not contigue are not integrated into TStringgrids.  Any developer does not use it? Ah, it is necessary to derived its owned stringgrid. I made it but I consider that it is not adapted to the current professional development. Regards. Zacheus. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Blaazen · 2012-04-10 13:44 @ "Write once, run anywhere" No. Lazarus is "Write once, compile anywhere" "Write once, run anywhere" is Java.  Lazarus tries to be as native as possible. Therefore you sometimes cannot change some basic properties like colors of Edit text or whatever. You should always properly test your project on all platforms where you expect it will run. It is the same for all cross platform IDE/RAD. Adventage of fpc/Lazarus is that you don't need to install any runtime environment (like JRE) or any framework (like GTK or Qt). Applications are native. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- zacheus · 2012-04-10 13:49 Quote from: Blaazen on April 10, 2012, 03:44:01 pm@ "Write once, run anywhere" No. Lazarus is "Write once, compile anywhere" "Write once, run anywhere" is Java.  Yes it was a joke as the problems which I meet at present with Lazarus... That i's certainly why I could not do it: it was wrong language ! Quote from: Blaazen on April 10, 2012, 03:44:01 pmAdventage of fpc/Lazarus is that you don't need to install any runtime environment (like JRE) or any framework (like GTK or Qt). Applications are native. You are very optimistic...  Really RegEx without external librairies for exemple. I would like to see... Recently met problem : located a MAC address in a string...  And, you connect to databases without external libraires ? So it's very relative. Well I am not there to shoot down Lazarus but I do not use Lazarus to tinker incomplete components or bugged components.  The problem is not Linux and its so-called limits but how lazarus widgets are interfaced with this OS. Other languages ​​can get what I want to do with Lazarus on Linux. Regards. Zacheus ---------------------------------------------------------------------- BigChimp · 2012-04-10 13:58 Quote from: zacheus on April 10, 2012, 03:28:30 pmYou use Qt on Linux and Win32 or 64 on Windows... It is not very portable! And, if I use QT, I know another solution which works cleanly but I learnt to develop in Pascal... I like Lazarus but it is necessary to be serious... What Blaazen said. Also, if you don't like the use of various widgetsets, have a look into the customdrawn widgetset or e.g. LCL+fpgui... For many people, Lazarus is a perfectly usable cross platform tool. Instead of complaining in a general sense, indicating what's wrong on a more detailed level will more quicly lead to improvement. Quote from: zacheus on April 10, 2012, 03:28:30 pmThen Lazarus is mainly developed under Linux. Then, why all these limitations which do not exist with Windows Lazarus ? Because the ancestor it is Delphi ? With the arrival of Windows 8, it's time to put back it in question and to renew the approach of components. No idea what you're talking about here. Lazarus is being developed on/in Windows, Linux, FreeBSD, OSX, Solaris... One of the goals is that transition from Delphi/VCL is fairly simple. The arrival of a new GUI - Windows 8 - does not mean everybody needs to follow that - especially in a cross platform environment. What about GTK, Qt, Cocoa? Do you want to rewrite the entire LCL when KDE4/qt would switch to KDE5? If you don't like the LCL, why not use the FPGUI or MSEIDE products (separate from Lazarus) that also use FPC. Quote from: zacheus on April 10, 2012, 03:28:30 pmWhat is the slogan of Lazarus...  I have difficulty in reading or translating... "Write once, run anywhere"  The problem is not to know if we can develop on Linux and Windows  with Lazarus. With a common code, we can obtain something solid. As Blaazen indicated: write as much common code as possible, compile on many platforms. There will ALWAYS be differences between platforms, regardless of the approach you take, if you go further than basic applications. Quote from: zacheus on April 10, 2012, 03:28:30 pmNow is it normal that I can not eliminate the Caret of TMemo under Linux? Is it normal under Windows that I can change the color of a disabled TEdit but not the TextColor ? Is it normal that I stack 2 StaticTexts to manage BorderSpacing on Windows and on Linux ? If your answer is yes, to defend from such position, we can understand the so restricted number of lazarus developers. No idea. As people said, check the bug tracker and please report new bugs so they can get fixed. If possible with a simple example program; a patch would of course be better. Quote from: zacheus on April 10, 2012, 03:28:30 pmAm I too much requiring ? You seem to be a bit aggressive but that might be a cultural thing. In essence, having similar behaviour across platforms is a design goal of Lazarus. Quote from: zacheus on April 10, 2012, 03:28:30 pmThen, there is another problem. The way are built some widget prevents from being able to modify them in a significant way. Things so basic as the selection multilines not contigue are not integrated into TStringgrids.  Any developer does not use it? Ah, it is necessary to derived its owned stringgrid. I made it but I consider that it is not adapted to the current professional development. Don't understand the last part, sorry. Anyway, thanks for speaking up and trying to improve things by reporting what you think is wrong with the tool. Because it's open source, you can influence Lazarus for the better. If you can, I would strongly suggest opening bugs for any problems that have not yet been reported, along with sample progams, indication of platform/widgetset, Lazarus version etc and hopefully an idea for a solution/code/patch. Thanks, BigChimp ---------------------------------------------------------------------- BigChimp · 2012-04-10 13:59 Quote from: zacheus on April 10, 2012, 03:49:13 pmQuote from: Blaazen on April 10, 2012, 03:44:01 pmAdventage of fpc/Lazarus is that you don't need to install any runtime environment (like JRE) or any framework (like GTK or Qt). Applications are native. You are very optimistic...  Really RegEx without external librairies for exemple. I  ask to see... Recently met problem : located a MAC address in a string... Please search before you complain. Have a look through the forums, wiki, and FPC help. There is a built in regex unit without any external dependency (in fact there are more than one). Good luck. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- zacheus · 2012-04-10 15:55 Quote from: BigChimp on April 10, 2012, 03:59:40 pmPlease search before you complain. Have a look through the forums, wiki, and FPC help. There is a built in regex unit without any external dependency (in fact there are more than one). Good luck. There is a built in regex unit without any external dependency. Yes it doe's... BUT not rather complete (developped) to accept a Regular Expression for MAC Address I complain but get off your cloud, please. The problems mentioned are real or not ? if not, itemize me the solution .... including MAC address lookup. I complain but I'm curious. I notice once again that when one sets out facts, we complaint or we are aggressive; This is in total contradiction to your soothing rhetoric. "Just to report the malfunction". Yes I do regularly. I sometimes even offers. But here, the history of widgets Linux, the initial approach is corrupted. You like it or not ... Who complaints that it is the fault of Linux ? Quote from: BigChimp on April 10, 2012, 03:59:40 pmFor many people, Lazarus is a perfectly usable cross platform tool. Instead of complaining in a general sense, indicating what's wrong on a more detailed level will more quicly lead to improvement. Yes. But in the recent facts : http://bugs.freepascal.org/view.php?id=21533. I can't print.  Bug ridiculous. Nobody uses Property stretched ? There is another native solution? This is an "agressive" constraint for professional development. And still, there was another bug on the alignment of simple field of which I  found a (proposed) solution because we can not  wait 4 weeks to obtain the correction. But why am I obliged to modify the code of lazreport ?  This is the approach of "many People of Lazarus". One line of code for the application and one to correct the used component ? It is my current practice with 50% of the time for the application and 50% of the time  for the components... when I can solve problems (see the two problems mentioned initially). Regards. Zacheus ---------------------------------------------------------------------- BigChimp · 2012-04-10 16:44 Quote from: zacheus on April 10, 2012, 05:55:09 pmQuote from: BigChimp on April 10, 2012, 03:59:40 pmPlease search before you complain. Have a look through the forums, wiki, and FPC help. There is a built in regex unit without any external dependency (in fact there are more than one). There is a built in regex unit without any external dependency. Yes it doe's... BUT not rather complete (developped) to accept a Regular Expression for MAC Address I complain but get off your cloud, please. The problems mentioned are real or not... if not, itemize me the solution .... including MAC address lookup. I complain but I'm curious. Yes, it IS complete. There's just not a sample of every possible regular expression possible included.... That's the point (of regular expressions). To be fair, the regex unit I'm talking about does not support all possible features of other engines... so some tweaking might be required. Go and write/look up a MAC regex and try and run it. If you can't get it to run, get back in a new post with specific code. Quote from: zacheus on April 10, 2012, 05:55:09 pmI notice once again that when one sets out facts, we plainte or we are aggressive; This is in total contradiction to your soothing rhetoric. Just to report the malfunction. Yes I do regularly. I sometimes even offers. But here, the history of widgets Linux, the initial approach is corrupted. You like it or not ... Who complaints that it is the fault of Linux ? Well, you asked and *I* think you're coming across as to aggressive, certainly in your first couple of messages. Also, the English you're using is far from perfect; e.g.: QuoteI  ask to see... Recently met problem : located a MAC address in a string... does not make sense. What do you ask to see? How was I meant to understand you meant existing regex units couldn't support looking up MAC addresses? That's why I mentioned my impression could be because of cultural issues. You might notice I'm refraining from using soothing rhetoric in this post. Quote from: zacheus on April 10, 2012, 05:55:09 pmQuote from: BigChimp on April 10, 2012, 03:59:40 pmFor many people, Lazarus is a perfectly usable cross platform tool. Instead of complaining in a general sense, indicating what's wrong on a more detailed level will more quicly lead to improvement. Yes. But in fact : http://bugs.freepascal.org/view.php?id=21533. I can't print.  Bug ridiculous. Nobody uses Property stretched ? There is another native solution? This is an "agressive" contraint for professional development. And still, there was another bug on the alignment of simple field of which I  found a (proposed) solution because we can not  wait 4 weeks to obtain the correction. But why am I obliged to modify the code of lazreport ?  This is the approach of "many People of Lazarus". One line of code for the application and one to correct the component ? It is my current practice with 50% of the time for the application and 50% of the time  for the components... when I can solve problems (see the two problems mentioned initially). If you don't want to use it, don't and use something else. If this is such a big problem for you in your professional development, why not pay somebody to maintain Lazarus/FPC to your standards? Alternatively, why don't you provide patches with your bug reports so these things can be fixed once and for all? On the other hand: QuoteBut why am I obliged to modify the code of lazreport ?  ... perhaps you're better off buying a commercial product if you think submitting a patch to a completely free cross-platform IDE+compiler suite is too much to ask... Regards, BigChimp ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Leledumbo · 2012-04-10 16:56 QuoteYou use Qt on Linux and Win32 or 64 on Windows... It is not very portable! And, if I use QT, I know another solution which works cleanly but I learnt to develop in Pascal...It's perfectly portable for me, I've got some applications written and compiled and tested using those backends and they run with no problems at GUI side. I got better interface on Linux when I use Qt, and Lazarus with Qt interface has a smoother execution. Which backend toolkit used doesn't really matter actually, it's a matter of changing an option from the IDE. Or are you talking about using Qt directly? QuoteThen Lazarus is mainly developed under Linux. Then, why all these limitations which do not exist with Windows Lazarus ? Because the ancestor it is Delphi ? With the arrival of Windows 8, it's time to put back it in question and to renew the approach of components.As I've stated before, if nobody ever reports such a bug, and nobody knows how to fix it (if it can be fixed), it would never be fixed. There's no relation with Delphi regarding this. It's simply because of what I said, or widgetset limitation (what if the backend toolkit doesn't really allow doing what you want?). I don't think there would be any problem with Windows 8. What do you think M$ would do against its API and GUI elements? It would still be forms, buttons, edit boxes, comboboxes, etc. QuoteNow is it normal that I can not eliminate the Caret of TMemo under Linux? Is it normal under Windows that I can change the color of a disabled TEdit but not the TextColor ? Is it normal that I stack 2 StaticTexts to manage BorderSpacing on Windows and on Linux ?Explained above. Anyway, before you go any further, state what widgetset you use. GTK(2)? Qt? CustomDrawn? QuoteThings so basic as the selection multilines not contigue are not integrated into TStringgrids.  Any developer does not use it? Ah, it is necessary to derived its owned stringgrid. I made it but I consider that it is not adapted to the current professional development.Either: file a feature request or: implement it yourself and send it as a patch. Welcome to open source development. QuoteYou are very optimistic...  Really RegEx without external librairies for exemple. I would like to see... Recently met problem : located a MAC address in a string...  And, you connect to databases without external libraires ? So it's very relative. There is a built in regex unit without any external dependency. Yes it doe's... BUT not rather complete (developped) to accept a Regular Expression for MAC Address Code: [Select]uses   regexpr; type   TStringArray = array of String; var   r: TRegExpr;   s: String; begin   r:=TRegExpr.Create;   r.Expression:='^([0-9A-F]{2}[:-]){5}([0-9A-F]{2})$';   r.ModifierI:=true;   for s in TStringArray.Create('3D:F2:C9:A6:B3:4F','3D:F2:C9:A6:B3:4F' ,'127.0.0.1','localhost:8080') do begin     r.Exec(s);     if r.MatchPos[0]>=0 then       writeln('success, found '+r.Match[0])     else       writeln('failure');   end;   r.Free; end.Enough? First two should output success, along with the MAC address string. The last two would output failure. QuoteOther languages ​​can get what I want to do with Lazarus on Linux.And can those languages / frameworks do on more than 10 different combinations of CPU - OS - widgetset? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- LA.Center · 2012-04-10 17:36 Quote from: zacheus on April 10, 2012, 02:30:04 pmIt is absolutely not professionel... Lazarus can be really annoying at the beginning, but once you know your way around it is a superb tool. We use it professionally and we created professional tools with it and we are very happy with Lazarus. I agree, you sometimes have to make small adjustments but you would need to do that with any other tools/library too. wxWidgets for example is almost 15 years old, and there too you need to make sometimes adjustments or wait for fixes. Even Qt which is considered the most advance library has its flaws and is updated/fixed very frequently. This is the nature of cross platform development. I think comparing it with Delphi is just plain wrong, Lazarus although the concept is very similar Delphi 5 the underlying architecture is very different and better designed. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- zacheus · 2012-04-10 17:51 @Leledumbo Enough ? almost...   This may be because I have not the daily snapshot...  Quoteunit1.pas(43,25) Error: Illegal qualifier unit1.pas(43,24) Error: Cannot find an enumerator for the type "" unit1.pas(55) Fatal: There were 2 errors compiling module, stopping With Lazarus (like other), error is easy... and I stay on my position. When I tested -and this is not so long-, it was not working and was admitted. Besides the new unit is not a correction or an evolution of old units. But another. The old units still exist... with a new name It's not "as playable"... no more than installing snapshot every day (on linux) which correct the stable version ... which is no longer. But you have no choice ; the stable version buggy, or the latest snapshot. Like QT says PlusPlus. No, I don't agree. Management of updates and stable versions is different. Usual stable components, a doc update, a user feedback ... is it possible? I doubt it and I'm annoyed. I use Lazarus since version 0.9.26 ... and very few stable improvements are visible.. A TStaticText can work on Monday, be unable to manage BorderSpacing on Tuesday.  Has it done it one day? A TEdit must follow the needs of the developer, as well on Windows, on Linux, on Mac, on....  A TEdit ! a common and essential component ! That upsets you? I'm sorry. Not as much as me finishing a "long" program with details of ergonomics unmanageable. My client needs to read the contents of a TMemo without being allowed to "go inside". No scaret, no Drag&drop but ScrollBar active...as well in Windows, in Linux, or Mac !  Is this an exorbitant demand ?  We must make an inventory of basics components to see if we can make a TMemo inert while leaving it completely legible to the user? OS by OS ? I must think of my determination to use Lazarus. Is this reasonable? Regards. Zacheus ---------------------------------------------------------------------- LA.Center · 2012-04-10 19:22 You are judging something based on your needs, if you think that Lazarus is not for you then it is probably not. As for your problem (clients needs) this could be probably a better approach: Use a TLabel in a Scrollbox and set it properties so that it can autosize to multiline. Very simple and your problem would be solved working on all platforms. (this would be my approach anyway) That is what I meant with NOT to compare Lazarus with Delphi. There are things where you need to be creative and solve your problems a little different than you would with Delphi. For example: We use a TTreeView component as a TListView component in many cases because TListView has a focus border on Mac, but that has nothing to do with Lazarus, it is the underlying lib that causes the differences. If you post and describe your problems I am willing to help you anyway I can, and generally everyone in this forum is willing to do the same but please be kind and do not trash talk something that thousands of developers like and that was created and is maintained by people voluntarily and totally free. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Takeda · 2012-04-10 21:30 Hey, Mr. Zacheus. Note for you : 1. I came from C/C++ using Genuine Microsoft Visual Studio for over years ago. But, when I know "pascal" has IDE which has availability to work in several platform, so I decide to "porting" my app architecture to Lazarus. You know, it was successful ! My app which I produce using Lazarus was running properly on Windows OS without any complaint from client! 2. Six months ago, my client request to make the same app for Linux "openSuSE", since their company grownup rapidly then they need to expand their "business". They asked me "Would you mind to create 'exact app' but for Linux Platform". I said "Yes I could". You know, I only "need" small improvement to my codes to be compile-able + running-able on Linux. Until now, my app still running perfectly without complaint from them. 3. As I told you above, I came from C/C++. So in short, I was "C/C++" mind-set. So I'm "newbie' for Pascal. But when I tried Lazarus, there is no problems for me, even Lazarus make me feel comfort for migrate from C/C++ to Pascal. 4. In the past I also buy genuine De*phi 7 and continuing to 2006, and my Last De*phi was XE2. But you know, even for me Lazarus is still offering better solution for many ways. Trust me, EVERYTHING IS DEPEND ON YOU, Sir. (If you want to know "How strong Lazarus?", then I suggest you to buy the professional product which created using Lazarus http://gridplusplus.com you'll know that Lazarus has better solution for you!) Regards, takeda. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- JuhaManninen · 2012-04-10 21:46 zacheus, uhhh, so much whining! I also complain and whine sometimes when I am frustrated, but you just continue and continue and continue ... With the same energy you would have learned lots of code in Lazarus sources and maybe even fixed a bug there. Besides, who you try to convince exactly? You want to make everybody understand that Lazarus sucks. And then what? Make them all go away from this project. QuoteMy client needs to read the contents of a TMemo without being allowed to "go inside". How old is your client? Is he also 13 and lives next door to you? There are some companies that actually use Lazarus for critical commercial development. Often they support Lazarus development for example by letting a knowledgeable worker spend his paid working time for Lazarus. If Lazarus is critical for your business and you can't fix a bug yourself, you can also offer (a little) money, a bounty, for it. The signal/noise ratio of this kind of threads are very low. They take time and energy from everybody who reads them. It is amazing to see the opposite behavior of some long time developers. Their signal/noise ratio is very high. All energy is spent for constructive actions. Mail posts are dense and to the point. Lots of code commits, no noise. I am clearly not such a developer. Replying to this thread is a proof of it. QuoteI must think of my determination to use Lazarus. Is this reasonable? Yes. Nobody forces you to use Lazarus. Please use it only if you find it useful. Juha ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Leledumbo · 2012-04-11 02:28 QuoteEnough ? almost...   This may be because I have not the daily snapshot... Whoops, sorry. Looks like your compiler doesn't support dynamic array creation via .Create syntax. The regex still works fine. If you analyze the error, those lines point to dynamic array (TStringArray.Create) in the for-in loop. Simply change it to: Code: [Select]... var   i: Integer;   dsa: TStringArray; ...   SetLength(dsa,4);   dsa[0] := '3D:F2:C9:A6:B3:4F';   dsa[1] := '3D:F2:C9:A6:B3:4F';   dsa[2] := '127.0.0.1';   dsa[3] := 'localhost:8080'   for s in dsa do begin     ...   end; I do like to use svn/development/snapshot version because if everybody uses stable version, no one can report bugs in the development version, which could make the next stable version even buggier. Besides, I've got newer features QuoteWith Lazarus (like other), error is easy... and I stay on my position. When I tested -and this is not so long-, it was not working and was admitted. Besides the new unit is not a correction or an evolution of old units. But another. The old units still exist... with a new name It's not "as playable"... no more than installing snapshot every day (on linux) which correct the stable version ... which is no longer. But you have no choice ; the stable version buggy, or the latest snapshot. Like QT says PlusPlus. No, I don't agree. Management of updates and stable versions is different.Tell me any big software projects out there whose stable version is really stable (i.e. no bugs). And if you just want fixes, the daily snapshot contains download for stable version fixes only, no additional features, no additional bugs (except the ones that aren't yet fixed). QuoteUsual stable components, a doc update, a user feedback ... is it possible? I doubt it and I'm annoyed. I use Lazarus since version 0.9.26 ... and very few stable improvements are visible.. A TStaticText can work on Monday, be unable to manage BorderSpacing on Tuesday.  Has it done it one day? Again, report, that's what we have a bugtracker for. You've used Lazarus since 0.9.26, so why don't you report bugs since that time? Your number of posts here is also low, which I could understand that you don't really understand how the development process works. Don't expect everyone also experience the same thing as you because everyone has different needs when using this tool. I never use TStaticText, so I never know what's wrong with it. Whereas if you report it, a bug could be solved in a couple of hours/minutes (yes, I've reported bugs whose fixes available in a couple of minutes later). QuoteA TEdit must follow the needs of the developer, as well on Windows, on Linux, on Mac, on....  A TEdit ! a common and essential component ! That upsets you? I'm sorry. Not as much as me finishing a "long" program with details of ergonomics unmanageable. Aaaand... what' wrong with TEdit? I use it almost everytime, and it fulfills my need. Color changing, disable on certain condition, filtering characters allowed to enter, those are working. QuoteMy client needs to read the contents of a TMemo without being allowed to "go inside". No scaret, no Drag&drop but ScrollBar active...as well in Windows, in Linux, or Mac !  Is this an exorbitant demand ?  We must make an inventory of basics components to see if we can make a TMemo inert while leaving it completely legible to the user? OS by OS ? No, if you've ever asked for it. Haven't you? QuoteI must think of my determination to use Lazarus. Is this reasonable?Feel free to leave if you don't think Lazarus suits your needs. It suits me (VERY WELL), and I won't leave. So is with hundred thousands of hobbyist, professionals, students, teachers, etc. out there. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- braximo · 2012-04-11 03:34 He he he. In short IT WORKS!!! ---------------------------------------------------------------------- irfanbagus · 2012-04-11 05:32 come on guys, you know lazarus is not that perfect. it can't write code for me. it can't fix my bug. even worse, i have to click run button manually. it's only help when i have to create my demo application in 15 minutes and help me write my game(-like) framework so i can finish my games with 9 different variants in 2 weeks! you see, it's not that perfect. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Takeda · 2012-04-11 06:45 Quote from: irfanbagus on April 11, 2012, 07:32:00 amcome on guys, you know lazarus is not that perfect. it can't write code for me. it can't fix my bug. even worse, i have to click run button manually. it's only help when i have to create my demo application in 15 minutes and help me write my game(-like) framework so i can finish my games with 9 different variants in 2 weeks! you see, it's not that perfect. To IrfanBagus : 1. Are you serious? If yes, why you still be a member of this forum? 2. None perfect in this world! The only GOD is perfect! Are you GOD? 3. I think you NEVER wrote the codes at ALL ! So you can Say : Quote" .. you know Lazarus is not perfect.. ". If you're programmer then you'll know, FACT NO STABLE CODES IN THIS WORLD! That's the reason why exist "bug tracker" and "bug fixes". Quote... it's only help when i have to create my demo application in 15 minutes.. 4. By this way I'm so sure, you never wrote the codes! You only want to be called as "Computer Programmer" but your hand never have capable to be programmer!  5. I'm so sure you never buy genuine "development tool", so you never know the Lazarus is so amazing, even I guarantee Lazarus could be side by side to be compared with many commercial Development tool. DO YOU KNOW THE MEANING OF "DEVELOPMENT TOOL", HUH?  6. I'm curious, and I would like to ask you -> "HOW LONG YOU ALREADY STAYED AS COMPUTER PROGRAMMER??"     (AS NOTE FOR YOU, I STARTED MY PROGRAMMING SINCE BORLAND C++ 2.0  ) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- JuhaManninen · 2012-04-11 07:32 > To IrfanBagus : Are you serious? No Takeda, he was not serious. It may be a language or culture problem if you didn't notice it. Juha ---------------------------------------------------------------------- irfanbagus · 2012-04-11 07:35 Quote from: Takeda on April 11, 2012, 08:45:53 am1. Are you serious? If yes, why you still be a member of this forum? i believe that call sarcasm :p it's far from perfect, but i still used because lazarus MUCH BETTER than other alternative. my story is true, i use lazarus for quick and dirty coding and for well planned one. it's help a lot. my voip-like application event only need less than 10 lines change to port from linux to windows. Quote from: Takeda on April 11, 2012, 08:45:53 am I'm curious, and I would like to ask you -> "HOW LONG YOU ALREADY STAYED AS COMPUTER PROGRAMMER??" i don't quietly remember, but i think my first prog language is basic using gw-basic ---------------------------------------------------------------------- zacheus · 2012-04-11 08:57 Quote from: JuhaManninen on April 10, 2012, 11:46:36 pmHow old is your client? Is he also 13 and lives next door to you? Pupils [8-10 years]. The color codes, ergonomics are extremely important. I am a teacher and developer of an educational free software. Three other teachers are working with me. We deliberated,  hesitating between Java, QT / C++ and Lazarus. I have lobbied strongly for Lazarus... Quote from: JuhaManninen on April 10, 2012, 11:46:36 pmBesides, who you try to convince exactly? You want to make everybody understand that Lazarus sucks. And then what? Make them all go away from this project.No. Quote from: Leledumbo on April 11, 2012, 04:28:14 amYou've used Lazarus since 0.9.26, so why don't you report bugs since that time? Your number of posts here is also low, which I could understand that you don't really understand how the development process works. I used an other login. I in this time, I had the arrogance to assert that the invisibility of the columns of Stringgrids did not work. Worse, the contents of the column n+1 replaced that of the column n provoking of serious mistakes of programming. Obviously despicable for a 'professional' software. I have never seen it somewhere else. It was corrected in 0.9.28 ! at best !! (look at attachmemnt) . Two years to correct this bug with a lot of denial ! We guaranteed me that width: = 0 was the solution... except that we could not prevent the elargissement of these invisibled columns. Another problem of management of the events. The reaction of your forum was the one from what I benefit at present : the criticism is not allowed. As for StringGrid (0.924, 0.9.26), I say today that a lot of usual components do not answer my needs which do not seem to me extravagant. Which reaction for this simple reproductible assertion. You  want to persuade me that a Linux program cannot make as well as its Windows version. Look at Java, look at C ++ / QT! Quote from: JuhaManninen on April 10, 2012, 11:46:36 pmYes. Nobody forces you to use Lazarus. Please use it only if you find it useful. It's true. So goodbye... and definitively this time. I wish however a good continuation of your project. Sorry for my bad English and the lack of nuances  which translates 'brutally' my thought which seems aggressive. The only foreign language which I practise correctly is German. I' m french. Regards. Zacheus ---------------------------------------------------------------------- LA.Center · 2012-04-11 09:16 Of course you can criticize, that what makes the product better and better, and I do REALLY understand your frustration, and I am still willing to help you the best I can, but it is perfectly normal that the Lazarus community will be sensitive about the way it is criticized simply out of respect to the developers. I suggest that instead of saying: this and this does not work and that sucks ask a question: I could not make this and this work, please help. And here are many developers who will even create a patch for your problem right away to get you going. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- zacheus · 2012-04-11 10:13 Quote from: plusplus on April 11, 2012, 11:16:58 amOf course you can criticize, that what makes the product better and better, and I do REALLY understand your frustration, and I am still willing to help you the best I can, but it is perfectly normal that the Lazarus community will be sensitive about the way it is criticized simply out of respect to the developers. I fully understand that language as ambitious as Lazarus has problems and it takes longer to resolve. The community is smaller than that of C + +, Qt or Java. Before you leave, I want to focus not on a frustration but a simple statement... and without aggression What I resent most is how issues are addressed. The last response is significant and sums up the philosophy deployed. The problems I mentioned are real and reproductible. Dialogue is always the same: - Why would you do that? We must do otherwise - Yes but that does not give the result I want - This is normal because widgetset does not permit - ? - We will not rewrite  Lazarus for your case (TStringGrid, TEdit). So why CustomDraw (TEdit ,...)? - If you are not satisfied, look elsewhere .... Obviously during the dialogue, there will 'afficianodos' heartily: - Me, it works - It's great - There's no problem - I used all EDI in the world and they're all the same - Learn to program I program sometimes without obtaining the help of a forum : http://www .lazarus.freepascal.org/index.php/topic,15629.msg84222.html#msg84222  The subject was to create a component (Lin/Win and probably Mac (not tested) ) to retrieve the version of the project, component  interactive with the IDE (CsDesigning mode). Original and unexpected therefore impossible. This is my last message on this forum. Bye. Regards. Zacheus ---------------------------------------------------------------------- marcov · 2012-04-11 10:46 Quote from: zacheus on April 11, 2012, 12:13:33 pmI fully understand that language as ambitious as Lazarus has problems and it takes longer to resolve. The community is smaller than that of C + +, Qt or Java. These are mostly projects run with (lots of) fulltimers. The dynamics of such projects are totally different. Problems, if accepted resolve faster, but usually the developer that takes the decisions is hard to talk to, and directions other than the company funding the development are next to impossible. QuoteBefore you leave, I want to focus not on a frustration but a simple statement... and without aggression What I resent most is how issues are addressed. The last response is significant and sums up the philosophy deployed. The problems I mentioned are real and reproductible. The problem is you don't present them in a way that others can verify that easily. Where are the sources, the bugreports etc? You mostly present one-liner opinions and cryptic/vague bug descriptions. This causes forummembers to put you in the "ranter" category, and respond defensively accordingly, simply because the input is not really constructive. Specially if you did an earlier attempt to bring this to the attention, bugreports (from the bugtracker) are important, since their history might reveal why they were closed, and it can be checked if this is still valid. (specially since you seem to use a version way older than an year). Similarly, minimal example programs can be used by interested people to test if the problem still persist in current versions, and to narrow it down. The fact that you compare a lot with other systems doesn't really help either. Other systems have fundamental limitations too (and I bet in the QT forum the reaction will be similar if you touch them). Such comparisons are rarely constructive. Of course people could react nicer on all this, but on a forum like this with a high number of users coming from Delphi demanding immediate fixes for all their problems, forummembers devel a thick skin that can be sometimes mistaken for apathy or defensiveness.  But again, the attitude and low real fact/reproducability count doesn't help. There are several members in this thread know to debug database related functionality, and you haven't really compelled them to really look into the issue. That is a loss. For you, for the project, and for users like you that might come later. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Takeda · 2012-04-11 12:36 Quote from: JuhaManninen on April 11, 2012, 09:32:56 am> To IrfanBagus : Are you serious? No Takeda, he was not serious. It may be a language or culture problem if you didn't notice it. Juha I'm so happy to hear that. Thank you Mr. Juha to make it clear. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------------ to IrfanBagus (but pointed to zacheus ) : Quotei believe that call sarcasm :p No, I don't think so. Coz I'm not push or bullying anything + anyone. I just got mad condition with zacheus statement then continue read your statement! You know, coz I believe FreePascal + Lazarus is the best project around the world, even you allowed to produce Commercial + Closed Project using FreePascal + Lazarus (read the licenses). You know, that Lazarus is developed rapidly and well maintained. Quotei don't quietly remember, but i think my first prog language is basic using gw-basic If Yes and It's true, then you would know, FreePascal + Lazarus is the best ! Even you could use many "syntax" mode e.g. "delphi". So, you could adopt many codes which written using "delphi" paradigm of syntax. Lazarus provide flexible syntax handling. It's make myself comfortable. If you think Lazarus is not perfect then I believe you come from the wrong way! Please change your paradigm. Set it to normal and also set your paradigm into "cross-platform" paradigm. I believe you'll find like what I feel. Also as notice : I believe FreePascal + Lazarus was built by many hearts of developers of FreePascal + Lazarus. And this is would make FreePascal + Lazarus is "perfect". -Takeda- ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Leledumbo · 2012-04-11 13:20 @Takeda: What irfanbagus said is called irony figure of speech, talking something in a way that is contradictive with the truth ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Takeda · 2012-04-11 15:04 Quote from: Leledumbo on April 11, 2012, 03:20:23 pm@Takeda: What irfanbagus said is called irony figure of speech, talking something in a way that is contradictive with the truth Hihihihihi. Toi biet dieu do, Mr. Leledumbo, coz Mr. Juha already make it clear. -Takeda-