Sparta Docked Formed Editor Removed Without Discussion? lazarus / 21-General ---------------------------------------------------------------------- sysrpl · 2023-10-16 12:23 I have been happy using Lazarus without rebuilding the IDE from source for some time but yesterday I finally built a new version from GitLab source trunk. I noticed that the Sparta docked form editor was removed and there doesn't seem to be any discussion here on the subject. Is there an equivalent package to Sparta that is part of the default component or designer options that are currently part of the Lazarus source included in the official GitLab repository? For those who do not know this is a screen capture of the Lazarus IDE with the Sparta docker form editor installed. https://cache.getlazarus.org/images/docked-lazarus.png Please take note that the Lazarus form designer is docked within the code editor window using a code / designer tab. Some of you might be used to working with multiple monitors to split code editing and form design, but my vision is impeded. I do not have room on my desk for more than one very large monitor. I also often use large screen laptops where I only have just the one laptop screen. I realize there was a bit of drama and perhaps some "bad blood" between some of the core team working on Lazarus the original developer of Sparta docked form editor, but the removal of a functional package without a clear alternative seems perplexing, especially if it had utility for a segment of users. If there is no replacement, then given the choice of using Lazarus in multiple window mode versus using it in single window docked form, I will continue to use and encourage other people (along with my students) to use old versions of Lazarus.  To reiterate, while some users may prefer multiple window mode, it makes little sense to remove the ability for other people to use a working docked form editor mode. Yes there might have been conflicts with the Sparta generics unit, but those conflicts in no way impeded other code. As far as I can tell this is the only note I can find about the removal, which is lacks reasoning or a discussion context: https://gitlab.com/freepascal.org/lazarus/lazarus/- /commit/9964bfc872f8c2e3a0664153277d30ca945b3893 Thank you for your attention. Anthony ---------------------------------------------------------------------- marcov · 2023-10-16 12:42 For the others that don't read the maillist: Quote from: sysrpl on October 16, 2023, 02:23:58 pmI have been happy using Lazarus without rebuilding the IDE from source for some time but yesterday I finally built a new version from GitLab source trunk. I noticed that the Sparta docked form editor was removed and there doesn't seem to be any discussion here on the subject. Is there an equivalent package to Sparta that is part of the default component or designer options that are currently part of the Lazarus source included in the official GitLab repository? "dockedformeditor" The reason for removal was related to https://gitlab.com/freepascal.org/lazarus/lazarus/-/issues/40485 p.s. I'm no Lazarus devel, but iirc some of the sparta designer used slightly different docking algorithms, and are the originals, while the now current versions are variants that were more deeply integrated into lazarus (?!) . The problems that led to the removal might be related that over the last year lazarus was prepared for multiple designers (e.g. due to pas2js webform support), and possibly the sparta package didn't implement some of those newer integration for that. Anyway, even devels like me made mistakes installing them, so it was better to not have them active by default ---------------------------------------------------------------------- TRon · 2023-10-16 12:54 As mentioned by marcov AnchorDockingDsgn combined with DockedFormEditor. Been using that at least since 2.2.4 but probably have been around ... forever ? ---------------------------------------------------------------------- El Salvador · 2023-10-16 13:52 Quote from: sysrpl on October 16, 2023, 02:23:58 pmTo reiterate, while some users may prefer multiple window mode, it makes little sense to remove the ability for other people to use a working docked form editor mode. Yes there might have been conflicts with the Sparta generics unit, but those conflicts in no way impeded other code. As far as I can tell this is the only note I can find about the removal, which is lacks reasoning or a discussion context: https://gitlab.com/freepascal.org/lazarus/lazarus/- /commit/9964bfc872f8c2e3a0664153277d30ca945b3893From Lazarus Wiki: htt ps://wiki.freepascal.org/Lazarus_2.2.0_release_notes#DockedFormEditor QuoteNew package DockedFormEditor added. For more info see DockedFormEditor.     Replacement for Sparta_DockedFormEditor. All Sparta packages are now marked as deprecated and will be removed in a future Lazarus version.     Optional Anchor Designer included. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Martin_fr · 2023-10-16 14:18 I haven't used them myself, but afaik there had been repeated reports from people having problems with them. (though not sure if all of the sparta packages). Looking at the git log, they had no maintenance in years. (despite the issues). A replacement exists, and has been recommended to be used for some time now. The decision was made so people would no longer accidentally install sparta when they would be better of with DockedFormEditor. If anyone is indeed better off with Sparta, then the sources are still available from the git revision before they were removed. As for maintenance, well they didn't have that anyway. Maybe a compiler ifdef changed, when it was changed across all files and packages => Well (afaik) anyone can fork the sparta packages and maintain them as 3rd party.