GPL ,GTK,commercial application,Help needed on clarification lazarus / 13-General ---------------------------------------------------------------------- windy · 2008-03-04 00:26 HI I have developed a program that is nagware (i.e there is a nag screen on start up , but it does not expire), and  to avoid the start up nag screen, a registration is needed to be purchased. It is developed with Lazarus (and I have not changed the Lazarus code). It uses GTK 1 I have been told that to meet the requirements of the GPL for linking to the GTK libraries (and other libraries that a graphical Lazarus program uses), I need to release my souce code if I am going to make money from the program, or face very large fines from the open source community. Is this true? I never intended my source code to be made public, and I do not intend to either (its not pretty code for starters !) Thanks for help in getting this cleared up! Brian. ps, I have read the FAQ on the subject, but it did not say if the program was a terminal program or a full graphical (with forms) program (the FAQ said it is OK to produce commercial programs compiled with Lazarus) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- felipemdc · 2008-03-04 23:13 Quote from: "windy"I have been told that to meet the requirements of the GPL for linking to the GTK libraries The GTK libraries are not GPL but rather LGPL. QuoteIs this true? No, it's not Quoteps, I have read the FAQ on the subject, but it did not say if the program was a terminal program or a full graphical (with forms) program (the FAQ said it is OK to produce commercial programs compiled with Lazarus) The FAQ doesn't say that because it's irrelevant. The answer is the same on both cases. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- windy · 2008-03-05 00:04 Hi Ok, thanks, thats what I thought thats its OK. I got some rather unpleasant emails from a person that has caused alot of stress for a number of people, whereby that person claimed I was violating the GPL , and I was given 72 hours to either comply with that GPL (either release my source code (which I refeused to do) or make the program freely available (which I have now done to avoid people threatening me again (this has put me off the whole idea of open source I can tell you that)) or get heavly fined by the open source community. Of course I have stated that I have welcome donations to cover my time and costs etc. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Phil · 2008-03-05 03:56 Quote from: "windy"Hi Ok, thanks, thats what I thought thats its OK. I got some rather unpleasant emails from a person that has caused alot of stress for a number of people, whereby that person claimed I was violating the GPL , and I was given 72 hours to either comply with that GPL (either release my source code (which I refeused to do) or make the program freely available (which I have now done to avoid people threatening me again (this has put me off the whole idea of open source I can tell you that)) or get heavly fined by the open source community. Of course I have stated that I have welcome donations to cover my time and costs etc. Sounds like a scam artist at work on you. The "open source community" has no legal authority whatsoever to fine you. That's like saying the "bicycle community" can fine you. Thanks. -Phil