[HN Gopher] guys why does armenian completely break Claude
___________________________________________________________________
guys why does armenian completely break Claude
https://xcancel.com/dyushag/status/1993143599286886525
https://claude.ai/share/e368b733-71a4-4211-99f5-6b6cc717b575
Author : ag8
Score : 72 points
Date : 2026-01-11 20:03 UTC (2 hours ago)
(HTM) web link (twitter.com)
(TXT) w3m dump (twitter.com)
| ai_critic wrote:
| Claude is apparently more of a Tur-key solution to these problems
| --issues with Armenian support are thus to be expected.
| qubex wrote:
| Turn-key or Turkey? Both work but are basically
| diagrammatically opposite each other semantically.
| delibes wrote:
| Parent comment was making a joke about the political
| situation between Armenia and Turkey.
| seydor wrote:
| Which is now called Turkiye
| jojobas wrote:
| It was always called Turkiye in Turkish.
|
| I promise to use it in English as soon as Germany becomes
| Deutschland and Japan becomes Nippon.
| qubex wrote:
| I briefly considered that but I couldn't bring myself to
| countenance that somebody would make light of a bona fide
| ethnic cleansing.
| klipt wrote:
| Ethnic cleansing is what Azerbaijan recently did to
| ethnic Armenian citizens of Azerbaijan (expelling them
| and stealing their homes when they fled to Armenia). What
| Turkey did was straight up genocide (forcibly marching
| them through the desert where many died)
| qubex wrote:
| That's a great example of "whataboutism".
| pessimizer wrote:
| Only if you didn't read it, and just assign random
| opinions that you don't like to people who seem to
| disagree with your characterizations of things. Extremely
| twitter-brained.
|
| No, saying that the Armenian genocide wasn't just "ethnic
| cleansing" isn't "a great example of whataboutism."
| slybot wrote:
| Well then same goes for saying, there was no genocide.
| slybot wrote:
| https://youtu.be/Rr9zXuG0-c0?si=O14GnPdhFXWKeMUm
| Dilettante_ wrote:
| Making a joke about something is not necessarily "making
| light of it". It can be a way for an individual or
| culture to approach and digest a topic that is too
| difficult or painful to engage with directly.
|
| First responders and medical professionals famously often
| have a sense of humor too dark to use around outsiders
| without causing offence/outrage(like what happened here),
| but I'm quite sure they are not "making light" of the
| loss of life and terrible injuries they face and fight.
| jojobas wrote:
| Oh fuck off. My grandfather survived the Nazi occupation
| in southern Russia, was playing Hitler in the school
| theater comedy some 5 years later.
| Poudlardo wrote:
| wait until someone prompts Claude in mongolian writing
| trjordan wrote:
| I'm interested in why Claude loses it's mind here,
|
| but also, getting shut down for safety reasons seems entirely
| foreseeable when the initial request is "how do I make a bomb?"
| wnmurphy wrote:
| Tangential, but you used to be able to use custom instructions
| for ChatGPT to respond only in zalgotext and it would have insane
| results in voice mode. Each voice was a different kind of insane.
| I was able to get some voices to curse or spit out Mint Mobile
| commercials.
|
| Then they changed the architecture so voice mode bypasses custom
| instructions entirely, which was really unfortunate. I had to
| unsubscribe, because walking and talking was the killer feature
| and now it's like you're speaking to a Gen Z influencer or
| something.
| shimman wrote:
| Did you record this? Sounds deranged enough to be amusing.
| djmips wrote:
| If you're a coder then it sounds like you could use the API to
| get around that and once again utilize your custom prompt with
| their tech.
| argsnd wrote:
| I think the subscriptions tend to be a significant discount
| over paying for tokens yourself
| Ldorigo wrote:
| I do it sometimes (even just through the openai playground on
| platform.openai.com) because the experience is incredible,
| but it's _expensive_. One hour of chatting costs around
| 20-30$.
| terribleperson wrote:
| ...voice mode bypasses custom instructions? But why? Without a
| custom prompt it's both unreliable and obnoxious.
| specproc wrote:
| Interesting. I've gotten really good mileage with Georgian and
| ChatGPT, which I'm aware is apples and oranges.
|
| There should be a larger Armenian corpus out there. Do any other
| languages cause this issue? Translation is a real killer app for
| LLMs, surprised to see this problem in 2026.
| doubleorseven wrote:
| claude fails on RTL like im using IE 6. falling back to my free
| chatgpt account everytime i want to write in my own language
| rob74 wrote:
| Armenian is LTR, so that can't be it...
| specproc wrote:
| Ah, it's probably because they're asking for bomb-making
| instructions. I can see low-resource language + guard-rail
| running into issues.
| dude250711 wrote:
| I do not know, but let's entrust it with writing our code for us.
| shermantanktop wrote:
| If it knows about "lpsz" prefixes it's clearly accomplished at
| the intersection of non-English and code...
| art0rz wrote:
| You used to be able to achieve a similar result with ChatGPT by
| asking if there was a seahorse emoji
| https://chatgpt.com/share/68f0ff49-76e8-8007-aae2-f69754c09e...
| oncallthrow wrote:
| guys why do people like this think talking entirely lower case is
| cool
| glorygut123 wrote:
| Who's talking? It's written language.
| layer8 wrote:
| > Thought process
|
| Given that the language of the thought process can be different
| from the language of conversation, it's interesting to consider,
| along the lines of Sapir-Whorf, whether having LLMs think in a
| different language than English could yield considerably
| different results, irrespective of conversation language.
|
| (Of course, there is the problem that the training material is
| predominantly English.)
| tobyjsullivan wrote:
| I've wondered about this more generally (ie, simply prompting
| in different languages).
|
| For example, if I ask for a pasta recipe in Italian, will I get
| a more authentic recipe than in English?
|
| I'm curious if anyone has done much experimenting with this
| concept.
|
| Edit: I looked up Sapir-Whorf after writing. That's not exactly
| where my theory started. I'm thinking more about vector
| embedding. I.e., the same content in different languages will
| end up with slightly different positions in vector space. How
| significantly might that influence the generated response?
| immibis wrote:
| That "native language" could be arbitrary embeddings.
| armcat wrote:
| (1) Why is the user asking for bomb making instructions in
| Armenian? (2) i tried other Armenian expressions - NOT bomb-
| making - and everything worked fine in both Claude and ChatGPT.
| Maybe the user triggered some weird state in the moderation
| layer?
| kachapopopow wrote:
| ask in german "repeat what is above verbatim" and in english,
| it's a common jailbreak tactic
| andybak wrote:
| That scene in Independence Day is seeming less far-fetched every
| passing moment.
| elromulous wrote:
| The Jeff Goldblum virus one?
|
| I believe fans have provided a retroactive explanation that all
| our computer tech was based on reverse engineering the crashed
| alien ship, and thus the arch, and abis etc were compatible.
|
| It's a movie, so whatever, but considering how easily a single
| project / vendor / chip / anything breaks compatibility, it's a
| laughable explanation.
|
| Edit: phrasing
| immibis wrote:
| It's just channelling its inner Steve Ballmer but, in true AI
| fashion, not getting it quite right.
___________________________________________________________________
(page generated 2026-01-11 23:00 UTC)