[HN Gopher] Show HN: Smart Silence - Remind your iPhone to stay ...
       ___________________________________________________________________
        
       Show HN: Smart Silence - Remind your iPhone to stay quiet in quiet
       places
        
       Hi HN,  I built an iPhone app called *Smart Silence* after sitting
       in a quiet setting (a service, actually) where someone's phone rang
       loudly and interrupted everything. It wasn't intentional -- just
       one of those forgetful moments. I started wondering: what if our
       phones could gently remind us to stay silent when it matters?
       *Smart Silence* helps iPhone users do just that. It lets you:  -
       Mark places where silence is expected (like libraries, meetings,
       classes, or houses of worship) - Get a reminder when you enter,
       with an easy Shortcut to enable Do Not Disturb - Schedule quiet
       times (e.g. "Mondays 9-11am at this place") - Share Silent Places
       with others -- so your community, school, or workspace can use the
       same setup - Stay fully in control -- no auto-silencing, and no
       location tracking outside of defined zones  It's currently
       available via TestFlight:
       https://testflight.apple.com/join/47CJ31VK  I'd love feedback --
       especially around usability, edge cases, or features you'd expect.
       If you run or attend a place where silence matters, I'd love to
       hear your thoughts.
        
       Author : ebagsnave
       Score  : 50 points
       Date   : 2025-05-28 13:51 UTC (3 days ago)
        
 (HTM) web link (testflight.apple.com)
 (TXT) w3m dump (testflight.apple.com)
        
       | russelldjimmy wrote:
       | I apologise if I'm missing something, but isn't this already
       | achievable with a location-based Shortcut?
        
         | Brajeshwar wrote:
         | Yes, it is. There are so many tutorials but here is one simple
         | and straight to the point.
         | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kKzGThOFy1E
        
         | xprn wrote:
         | The app that could've been a blog post
        
           | wingerlang wrote:
           | Yes, and Dropbox could have been a handful of unix commands.
           | 
           | I don't think I would use an app for this, but as far as I
           | can tell, it aims to crowdsource silent locations, something
           | a shortcut couldn't realistically achieve.
        
         | ianburrell wrote:
         | How do you mark and share locations with a shortcut? Setting up
         | shortcut for one location is one thing, managing a bunch of
         | locations is another thing.
        
         | happyopossum wrote:
         | You don't even need a shortcut - iOS's native focus modes can
         | be triggered by location directly. It's one of the
         | configuration options that's been there since they launched
         | focus modes.
        
       | nytesky wrote:
       | I don't know why Apple and Google haven't published a geofencing
       | protocol where locations can publish DND or limit internet access
       | at these locations.
       | 
       | Basically the phone communicates with the venues via an AirTag
       | like network and enters DND or becomes a school mode device.
       | 
       | It can be on by default, and some users like on call doctors or
       | firefighter etc can override and take responsibility for managing
       | themselves.
       | 
       | I would love my phone to know I'm in Church for a wedding or at a
       | play and not have to remember to switch.
        
         | mike_d wrote:
         | Because we can't trust people to not be shitheads.
        
         | bigiain wrote:
         | > I would love my phone to know I'm in Church for a wedding or
         | at a play and not have to remember to switch.
         | 
         | I kinda have the opposite problem. I turn my phone to silent
         | because I'm at a restaurant or cinema or whatever, then 3 or 4
         | weeks later discover I never remembered to turn it back.
         | 
         | And I'm 100% OK with that, I've gotten good enough at turning
         | the ringer on when I'm expecting a call, and not worrying about
         | "missing calls" from people who aren't in my VIP list or who
         | don't leave voicemail.
        
           | staindk wrote:
           | I have 2 rules set on my Pixel -
           | 
           | First one sets my phone to silent when I arrive at work (500m
           | radius I think). It also sets it back to loud (or whatever
           | the previous state was) automatically when I leave that
           | radius.
           | 
           | Second one sets my phone to loud when my phone connects to my
           | home WiFi. This helps with the problem you describe - but
           | agreed, phone stuck on silent isn't generally an issue (until
           | I miss some courier's phone call and kick myself).
        
             | copperx wrote:
             | Where do you set these rules?
        
               | staindk wrote:
               | Pixel phone settings -> system -> rules
               | 
               | It may be Pixel-exclusive, though I used to use the
               | Google Assistant rules on my old phone and they mostly
               | worked IIRC.
        
           | layer8 wrote:
           | On iOS one could use an automation to automatically turn off
           | silent mode every morning or so.
        
         | 47282847 wrote:
         | Without assistance from the location, one could build this
         | based on location and openstreetmap data, for types of
         | buildings.
        
       | neepi wrote:
       | Is this a regional thing? I don't really hear phones ringing in
       | the UK any more. They're almost always on silent by default.
        
       | nico wrote:
       | Personally, my issue is alarms rather than ringing. Silent mode
       | doesn't silence the alarms, and I forget to check them. It would
       | be great if this would silence alarms
        
         | sitkack wrote:
         | I have no idea why the damn phone doesn't have a global silence
         | slider. No Noise!
        
         | ksenzee wrote:
         | Yep. I had an alarm go off during a funeral last year, when my
         | phone was on silent. There really needs to be an "I'm at a
         | funeral, dammit" mode.
        
         | anArbitraryOne wrote:
         | Maybe you could do what banks do and use silent alarms?
        
           | nico wrote:
           | I've tried it, and then I miss the alarms
        
         | hsbauauvhabzb wrote:
         | iOS doesn't support batch deleting alarms either. 'Siri set an
         | alarm for 45 minutes' leaves my alarm list littered with an
         | inactive alarm I once set, have no future use for, but is
         | annoying enough that I'll never delete them all. Is there an
         | alarm set to go off in the near future? Hold on, let me scroll
         | through 50 pages of pointless noise.
         | 
         | iOS. It just works (tm).
        
           | umbra07 wrote:
           | Can Siri batch delete alarms based on the name?
           | 
           | "hey Siri, create an alarm and name it $X"
           | 
           | "hey Siri, delete all alarms named $X"
        
             | layer8 wrote:
             | This actually works, except that upon "delete all $x
             | alarms", Siri asks back "do you want to delete _all_ your
             | alarms?", but after confirming only deletes the $x alarms.
             | 
             | Still, it's not very practical, as Siri often mishears
             | alarm names, and also you want to use different names to
             | know what each alarm is for.
        
           | chgs wrote:
           | Siri: delete all my alarms
        
             | hsbauauvhabzb wrote:
             | Thanks, I wasn't aware siri could delete alarms - this
             | requires iirc a swipe and a tap for each alarm from the
             | manual UI, that's still not great for the non-voice user
             | (alarms is the only thing I use Siri for)
        
               | layer8 wrote:
               | It's possible using a Shortcut: https://www.reddit.com/r/
               | shortcuts/comments/a2h6bf/comment/k...
        
         | layer8 wrote:
         | It doesn't silence alarms because then people would sleep
         | through it and be late for work. Probably there should be
         | "silencable" and "non-silencable" alarms, though I'm sure
         | people would mix them up and use the wrong one.
         | 
         | We really need AGI to solve that. ;)
        
       | matricaria wrote:
       | This is build into iOS DND already. It can automatically activate
       | based on location.
        
       | kurtis_reed wrote:
       | > your iPhone
       | 
       | This presupposes I have an iPhone. I don't.
        
         | hsbauauvhabzb wrote:
         | Did you click on the comments section of a post just to nitpick
         | at the title which clearly describes the purpose and OS
         | limitations of another users' pet project?
        
       | anArbitraryOne wrote:
       | I'd rather use a pencil and paper than be stuck using one of
       | apple's operating systems
        
         | throwaway314155 wrote:
         | Hot take.
        
       ___________________________________________________________________
       (page generated 2025-05-31 23:02 UTC)