[HN Gopher] Intentionally Making Close Friends (2021)
       ___________________________________________________________________
        
       Intentionally Making Close Friends (2021)
        
       Author : fi-le
       Score  : 305 points
       Date   : 2025-04-08 06:54 UTC (4 days ago)
        
 (HTM) web link (www.neelnanda.io)
 (TXT) w3m dump (www.neelnanda.io)
        
       | croisillon wrote:
       | Related (Nov 2022 - 307 comments):
       | https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33774353
        
       | Uzmanali wrote:
       | I used to wait for people to talk to me. But now I try first, and
       | it works!
        
         | mrexroad wrote:
         | Hi, what are your hobbies?
        
           | legerdemain wrote:
           | Do you come here often? I haven't seen you here before! I
           | LIKE YOUR SHOES!
        
             | bombcar wrote:
             | My name is Dug. I have just met you, and I love you.
             | 
             | SQUIRREL!
        
             | udev4096 wrote:
             | That's boring. How can someone start a conversation like
             | that? It leads to nowhere and the person is now way more
             | disinterested in talking to you. Best way is to talk about
             | books, games, TV shows, etc. It's something you can easily
             | expand upon once you find a common ground
        
               | lioeters wrote:
               | > That's boring.
               | 
               | How can you continue a conversation like that? It's
               | insulting and the person is now way more disinterested in
               | talking to you. Best way is to be curious about the other
               | person, whatever they're into. Gradually you can find
               | some shared interests and common ground for being
               | friends.
        
               | vinceguidry wrote:
               | > Best way is to talk about books, games, TV shows, etc.
               | It's something you can easily expand upon once you find a
               | common ground
               | 
               | I can't think of a duller conversation. I'd prefer the
               | one you're complaining about. At least there are feelings
               | invested, if a tad bit one-note. The last thing I want to
               | learn about a person is a laundry list of media they
               | watched and liked. I only enjoy talking culture with
               | someone who is in the industry or otherwise has a deeper
               | relationship with it than just watching / reading one
               | thing after another.
               | 
               | Just go join a discord if you want that.
        
               | 01HNNWZ0MV43FF wrote:
               | When was the last time a movie made you cry?
        
               | vinceguidry wrote:
               | That scene in Spiderman where they brought the other two
               | back and they were talking about loss. Bawled like a
               | baby.
               | 
               | Not that I watch a lot of movies, but when I do, they do
               | make me emotional from time to time. I'm a sucker for a
               | well-told, interesting good wins over evil tale,
               | especially with a female protagonist. Not like Hollywood
               | can do those anymore. Indies are usually the way. They
               | gotta make Superman into basically a villain. Thankfully
               | they haven't fucked with Spiderman yet. But I bet some
               | dipshit will in the near future.
               | 
               | Anime is better, but you asked for movies.
        
             | johnecheck wrote:
             | Okay story time.
             | 
             | A friend in college is sitting at a bus stop. Somebody sits
             | next to him, says "hey I like your shoes", strikes up a
             | conversation. Ends up inviting him to a business/networking
             | seminar.
             | 
             | My friend goes, comes back with a book and is saying all
             | kinds of stuff about passive income and how you gotta take
             | control of your finances.
             | 
             | I google the book name, the second result is a reddit
             | thread about how somebody at a bus stop had their shoes
             | complimented and then got recruited for the same thing.
             | Turns out it was Amway.
             | 
             | So, yeah. 'I like your shoes' works well enough as a
             | conversation starter that it's literally in the pyramid
             | scheme manual.
        
               | Uzmanali wrote:
               | I used to think this kind of conversation mostly worked
               | with girls--since they often appreciate when someone
               | notices and admires the little things about them.
        
           | Uzmanali wrote:
           | That's a good one.
        
       | orasis wrote:
       | I will second using "the 36 questions that lead to love" to
       | create close connections quickly.
       | 
       | Combine this with MDMA to supercharge the intensity and speed of
       | connection. This can also be done with a group of 3 to create a
       | tight group that instantly has each other's backs.
        
         | hackernewds wrote:
         | It seems like a really vapid unintentional and artificial way
         | to do this. why not just be high on life and try it?
        
           | mandmandam wrote:
           | > It seems like a really vapid unintentional and artificial
           | way to do this.
           | 
           | It's not like that.
           | 
           | Roughly speaking, MDMA doesn't exactly create an artificial
           | closeness, it's more like it breaks down artificial walls.
           | The effects can last far longer than the high - if you're
           | taking it in the right setting, with the right intention,
           | etc.
           | 
           | > why not just be high on life and try it?
           | 
           | There's a lot to be said for living life drug-free. However,
           | MDMA has genuine therapeutic potential. If a doctor
           | prescribed your friend Prozac, would you say, 'Have you tried
           | not being depressed?' - similar thing. (Yes, some doctors
           | prescribe MDMA.)
        
         | declan_roberts wrote:
         | I doubt any variation of buzz buddies will produce any
         | meaningful or enduring friendships.
        
           | barry-cotter wrote:
           | _There are more things in heaven and earth, Horatio, than are
           | dreamt of in your philosophy_.
           | 
           | There are 8.2 billion people alive on Earth ;getting drunk,
           | high or otherwise taking psychoactive drugs is universal
           | among human societies and you think _no one_ has _ever_ had a
           | meaningful or enduring friendship result therefrom?
        
         | justonceokay wrote:
         | Or you'll just find a group of three people that like
         | amphetamines
        
           | bckr wrote:
           | It takes time to develop relationships that have
           | 
           | 1. Longevity. The longer you've been friends the more likely
           | you'll be friends in the future.
           | 
           | 2. Trust. Trust in a relationship is anti-fragile. The more
           | times trust is partially damaged but restored, the stronger
           | it becomes.
           | 
           | 3. Meaning. The story "we met while looking for friends to do
           | MDMA with, and now we are attached" is cute when you're 23.
           | What those people mean to you is that you are lovable and
           | able to form bonds out in the world. Good! But shallow.
           | 
           | TLDR; it may be an effective way to have intense but shallow
           | and short-lived connections
        
             | orasis wrote:
             | Before I tried this process I would have agreed with you,
             | however, we focus on longevity when it's really _intimacy_
             | that leads to deep lasting connections. It's just that with
             | the decades long friendships there is more time and
             | opportunity for intimacy, vulnerability, and going through
             | some shit together.
             | 
             | MDMA + the 36 questions is deep intimacy, vulnerability,
             | and often going through some shit together.
             | 
             | We're also not seeking friends to do MDMA with. On a few
             | occasions, we've met interesting people that there is a
             | strong initial spark of connection with and let them know
             | about the practice. These friendships are now very deep and
             | loving even if only a year or 3 old. They are anything but
             | shallow.
             | 
             | As for short lived, only time will tell, but even if they
             | were to end tomorrow I will have deeply cherished the
             | present experience of these connections. I have one 10+
             | year friendship that is fading and while it breaks my heart
             | from time to time, I still love this person and would do it
             | all over again.
        
             | rglynn wrote:
             | Genuinely curious to hear more about (2.), has trust's
             | anti-fragility been studied and/or where did this view come
             | from?
        
               | bckr wrote:
               | I am speaking from experience. The first conflict is
               | always a picture of where a new relationship will lead,
               | and each conflict after that determines whether the
               | relationship will deepen or weaken.
               | 
               | I imagine it's the kind of thing that has been studied!
        
           | 01HNNWZ0MV43FF wrote:
           | I don't think MDMA is an amphetamine
        
             | hollerith wrote:
             | The A in MDMA stands for amphetamine.
        
             | foobarbecue wrote:
             | It is. Actually, it's a methamphetamine (MA)
             | 
             | https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/MDMA
        
           | phrotoma wrote:
           | It's true that the A in MDMA stands for amphetamine as noted
           | below, but saying that people who use MDMA like amphetamines
           | is like saying that people who use table salt like chlorine.
           | It's the best kind of correct, but misleading.
           | 
           | https://thisvsthat.io/amphetamine-vs-mdma
        
         | tempodox wrote:
         | Too bad the availability of MDMA is so limited.
        
           | LoganDark wrote:
           | Not really? If you know how to use TOR you can just order it
           | online. I do this with LSD all the time and it works fine.
        
             | xrraptr wrote:
             | In the US at least this seems pretty insane to me while we
             | have a fentanyl epidemic.
             | 
             | I am sure there are ways to test this but I wouldn't trust
             | myself. Not to mention the illegality of it.
             | 
             | At this point, it is simply criminal MDMA is not available
             | for therapy the way ketamine is.
        
             | __turbobrew__ wrote:
             | I would never put a drug ordered off the internet into my
             | body. Pure lab grade LSD which has been tested in an NMR --
             | I probably would. I only have one body and I wouldn't
             | entrust it to random people on the internet.
        
               | swee69 wrote:
               | I think you could estimate the risk in micromorts from
               | taking LSD from darkweb and find it's not that different
               | from other activities you do regularly (~multiple times a
               | year, if not more)
        
               | __turbobrew__ wrote:
               | You cannot estimate the risk of taking internet LSD, that
               | is the problem.
               | 
               | There is also a history of cutting drugs with other
               | substances to give them a unique effect which brings back
               | return customers (i.e. cutting heroin with fentanyl).
               | 
               | And then there is the possibility that whoever produced
               | the LSD screwed up and/or the end product is not pure.
        
         | renewiltord wrote:
         | Agreed to both. Works well in both cases. I suspect there is a
         | strong selection effect, though.
        
           | orasis wrote:
           | This could be. At this point in my life I doubt I'll become
           | close with anyone who is incurious about psychedelics as
           | there seems to be a strong dividing line in mindset between
           | pre-psychedelic and post-psychedelic humans.
        
         | globalise83 wrote:
         | Sure, until... https://youtu.be/8_BFMEQOH2Q?feature=shared
        
           | orasis wrote:
           | Do it during the day, properly dosed, don't mix with alcohol,
           | and get plenty of sleep that night and this is not a problem.
           | The MAPS studies have shown this again and again that the
           | Tuesday blues is related to partying and not intrinsic to the
           | medicine.
        
       | uoaei wrote:
       | Insofar as the "intention" is to expose yourself to multiple
       | varied communities where you might find commonalities, sure.
       | Other approaches carry a heavy whiff of manipulative behavior and
       | should be treated with the appropriate amount of skepticism.
        
         | yunusabd wrote:
         | The author literally asked if the people were willing to take
         | part in an experiment and clearly stated the goal. Doesn't
         | sound very manipulative to me.
        
       | ilrwbwrkhv wrote:
       | I wonder how much of it is just social upbringing I see a lot of
       | people who are from Asia or outside of America make a lot more
       | closer friends than Americans
        
         | stuxnet79 wrote:
         | Right on the money. After musing on this topic for a while and
         | drawing from a lifetime's worth of experiences I've come to the
         | conclusion that the social environment in America is very
         | hostile and does not encourage developing close relationships.
         | The prevalence of these articles really surprises me and makes
         | me wonder if the people who write them have ever experienced
         | living in a different (warmer) culture where the default mode
         | of interaction isn't transactional.
        
           | 01HNNWZ0MV43FF wrote:
           | Sadly I haven't. Travel is expensive, the US is a big wide
           | country, and other nations don't really want me hanging
           | around unless I marry someone or drop a lot of money
        
       | parpfish wrote:
       | As an introvert that's been consciously working to make new
       | friends, I've noticed a couple phenomena:
       | 
       | - I'd love to be friends with other introverts to enjoy quiet
       | times together. but... int-to-int pairs will rarely form in
       | nature, however extroverts are great for mediating the
       | connections. Make friends with the talkative outgoing types,
       | because through them you can meet the other quiet people they've
       | befriended but you'd never meet in the wild.
       | 
       | - however, there seem to be some common pitfalls to introvert-
       | extrovert friendships. From my (introvert) side, you can often
       | find yourself getting insecure or jealous of all the other social
       | connections that your extrovert friends have. There's an
       | asymmetry there that can feed lots of insecurities. I'm sure that
       | there's something equivalent from the other direction, but I dont
       | know what it is
        
         | aptj wrote:
         | Ah, you b--tard stealing my hard-earned friends! ;))
         | 
         | But seriously, is this how some _insecure_ introverts also bond
         | around those charismatic sociopaths and then help 'em ruin the
         | world while quietly working for the XYZ agencies? /s
        
           | parpfish wrote:
           | I think that's just insecure people in general, unless
           | extroverts have an ability I don't know about that makes them
           | immune to charming sociopaths
        
         | nothrabannosir wrote:
         | There's nothing equivalent from the other direction.
         | 
         | - extrovert
         | 
         | (/s ;))
        
         | kaashif wrote:
         | I used to feel insecure or jealous of the number of friends
         | these people have, but years ago I realized that I would find
         | their lives exhausting and terrible. And vice versa, they'd
         | hate the amount of time I spend on my own doing stuff.
        
           | blueflow wrote:
           | The deep Schadenfreude when you see your extroverted friend
           | rage about their phone ringing for the 8th time this hour.
        
             | y-curious wrote:
             | "What a fool I am," he said. "Here I am wearing myself out
             | to get a bunch of sour grapes that are not worth gaping
             | for."
        
               | blueflow wrote:
               | You implied: Having your phone ring several times per
               | hour is something desirable.
        
           | parpfish wrote:
           | For me it's not that I want to have a ton of friends like
           | they do, it's more that I worry about how we each perceive
           | the relative importance of the relationship. E.g., they are
           | one of five friends to me; I'm one of 50 friends to them.
        
         | ryangittins wrote:
         | > ...getting insecure or jealous of all the other social
         | connections that your extrovert friends have. There's an
         | asymmetry there that can feed lots of insecurities.
         | 
         | I wouldn't sweat this too much. Mathematically, most people
         | have fewer friends than their friends have.
         | 
         | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Friendship_paradox
        
           | fellowniusmonk wrote:
           | There is a fun but rare kind of humanist that doesn't think
           | they are special but are curious about others, see the value
           | in randos they meet and thinks that _others_ are special and
           | they really _listen_, you know?
           | 
           | Pretty sure its just that they all have superior statistical
           | intuition.
        
           | manmal wrote:
           | I don't fully understand how this is a paradox. I guess it's
           | based on the fact that there are ,,super nodes" in human
           | social networks, where one person has many friends, while
           | most others don't? Or is there anything more to it?
        
             | BobbyTables2 wrote:
             | Found the EE!
        
             | arduanika wrote:
             | It's the more expansive definition of paradox, meaning
             | something like "counterintuitive result". In expectancy, a
             | randomly chosen person has an average number of friends.
             | You might therefore think that a random person and their
             | friends, all of whom seem randomly chosen, would have the
             | same expected number of friends. But you'd be wrong,
             | because the friends weren't random after all: they had at
             | least one friend. Not a logical paradox, but a surprising
             | fact.
        
           | robocat wrote:
           | The counter-intuitiveness is partially to averaging. Averages
           | often deceive our intuitions.
        
         | red_admiral wrote:
         | Int-to-int pairs are more likely to form in nature at specific
         | watering holes.
         | 
         | For example, EA/rationalist is not quite my kind of community
         | (altough I think highly of many of their writings), but an ACX
         | meetup looks like a good place for introverts of a particular
         | kind to come together.
         | 
         | I guess the trick is to find the right kind of place first.
        
           | williamcotton wrote:
           | If you like reading HN then you'd probably enjoy an LW
           | meetup!
        
             | cma wrote:
             | These days they are more of racialist scientism meet &
             | greet
        
             | riehwvfbk wrote:
             | Who'd want to miss out on joining the next Zizians!
        
             | flawn wrote:
             | Ughh, LessWrong is a bit more of a rationalist cult than
             | anything - and I say that as somebody who is in the AIS &
             | EA space. It's a huge problem that fields like AI Safety
             | happen on that forum, as "normies" really get scared off by
             | the stuff that's on there.
        
           | aleph_minus_one wrote:
           | For those who are out of the loop:
           | 
           | EA: Effective Altruism
           | (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Effective_altruism )
           | 
           | ACX: Astral Codex Ten; see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ACX
           | https://www.astralcodexten.com/
           | 
           | LW (used at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43663979 ):
           | Less Wrong
        
         | jayd16 wrote:
         | >I'm sure that there's something equivalent from the other
         | direction, but I dont know what it is
         | 
         | There's a risk of becoming a people pleaser or letting people
         | down. People expect you to manage the party or the outing or
         | whatever.
         | 
         | There's fear that the many relationships you have are shallow.
         | Even in this post your suggestion is to simply use the
         | extrovert to get to a real friend you actually want.
         | 
         | Direct insecurity of what people "actually" think of you is
         | still there, I'm sure.
         | 
         | That said, people are usually thinking about their own problems
         | and what people think of them a lot more than what they think
         | of you so just relax a bit.
        
         | robrenaud wrote:
         | Find some nerdy social hobby, become part of a community. Board
         | games, killer queen arcade, and indoor rock climbing have all
         | been a bridge to some close friendships for me.
        
       | donatj wrote:
       | I have a small handful of people I would call my friend. Most of
       | them since grade school. Yet, in my life, I have had three people
       | I have really truly opened up to. One of them died suddenly, I
       | miss you Meka. One of them stopped talking to me for reasons I
       | don't understand. One of them cheated on me repeatedly.
       | 
       | I'm just frankly not sure I'll ever truly fully open up to
       | someone again. I have been seeing a therapist for a couple of
       | years now and I still go in with a pretty thick shell I have
       | trouble piercing. I'm so slow to warm up to people, I just really
       | doubt there will be another person in my life I'll ever be around
       | enough to get to that point with. Work from home for the last
       | five years has not helped that at all.
       | 
       | Being an adult just kinda sucks.
        
         | pjerem wrote:
         | I'm sorry for what happened to you.
         | 
         | I don't know if it can comfort you but personally I'm trying to
         | accept that it's ok to be "vulnerable" with mostly everyone.
         | Most of the time it creates interesting bonds with people.
         | Sometimes you are being "vulnerable" to authentic jerks and so
         | what ? Most of the time you can just ignore them.
         | 
         | I find that acting like this is actually an effective automatic
         | filter for my social interactions.
         | 
         | The only place I'm more protecting myself (without being
         | totally closed) is at work because, probably due to the
         | environment, people aren't acting normally at work.
        
           | KittenInABox wrote:
           | One of the things I've noticed is that there is a huge
           | discrepancy between people who can "bounce back" from someone
           | behaving inappropriately to them when they are in a
           | vulnerable position. People who are able to go "yeah fuck you
           | too buddy, anyways onto the next thing" are way more able to
           | handle things. People who end up dwelling on one person who
           | did something bad years ago and are unable to let go of that
           | pain end up closing themselves off for fear of exacerbating
           | it.
        
             | pjerem wrote:
             | Yeah but like I said, I'm just trying to do that. I've been
             | like the former people you described.
             | 
             | In my case, I feel it's just the wisdom of just being
             | older. I also have the luck of having a stable life, a few
             | friends and nice little family. I've never been more
             | emotionally stable than today so of course it's much easier
             | not to care when people randomly betray me.
        
         | QuantumGood wrote:
         | Sorry about your losses, especially Meka. Showing up for
         | therapy is courageous. That's not small.
        
         | user68858788 wrote:
         | It's an awful feeling to have a trusted friend distance
         | themselves with no explanation. It amplifies any insecurities
         | we have.
         | 
         | I hope you find someone you can connect with. I'm rooting for
         | you man.
        
         | gonzobonzo wrote:
         | > One of them stopped talking to me for reasons I don't
         | understand.
         | 
         | This is relatively common from what I've seen. People who just
         | ghost a friend, or ghost an entire groups of friends. A lot of
         | the times it's because they're unhappy with their life and
         | trying to make a clean break from what they were connected to
         | before.
        
         | aaarrm wrote:
         | It's not as hard as you think to get close to people, but you
         | have to be intentional about it.
         | 
         | First step would be to widen your "funnel" of new people in
         | your life before then filtering them down. Simply need to go to
         | social events, meetups, etc.
        
         | SoftTalker wrote:
         | Sort of the same. I've lost touch with or been sabotaged by the
         | people I used to be close to. Now I have acquaintances, people
         | I know and am fine hanging out with, but I don't have anyone
         | close that I'd really trust or open up to. And I'm fine with
         | that, the effort it takes and the risks of being very open with
         | someone are not worth it to me. And if someone tries to open up
         | to me, I'm immediately suspicious and will start to distance
         | myself. At this point in my life I'm not interested in taking
         | on someone else's emotional baggage.
        
         | 01HNNWZ0MV43FF wrote:
         | I believe there are lots of people I'd open up to, but it's
         | complicated because I would want to sleep with them
        
       | bhasi wrote:
       | I have a childhood friend that I went to school with for all of
       | my school days. Ever since school days, we find the same obscure
       | things funny and always end up in splits whenever we talk. To
       | this day, I don't have this with any other friend.
       | 
       | We had a few years' gap of not really being in touch during
       | undergrad but that changed as we had a few months' overlap at
       | post-grad university. It was easier to meet after that and we did
       | keep in touch, but I felt that he was holding back somewhat and
       | not really being free with his thoughts, letting the conversation
       | flag at times.
       | 
       | So at a friend's wedding a couple of years ago, I opened up to
       | him and plainly told him that it's a shame we don't talk as we
       | used to as we both are clearly on the same wavelength when it
       | comes to shared interests and sense of humour. And this worked -
       | our degree of friendship has increased an order of magnitude
       | since before that time. I would have lost a great friend to the
       | vagaries of life had I not taken that step to become vulnerable
       | for an instant then.
        
         | manapause wrote:
         | My first job out of college I was hired to follow around an
         | MSP/IT consultant and learn what he did, specifically to cut
         | the expense of having a MCSA/network engineer coming in weekly
         | for basic desktop support.
         | 
         | I met him in the server closet and asked "hey, I'm new here -
         | do you mind if I look over your shoulder?" He turned around and
         | smiled, "if you are here to help, then you should sit down and
         | I'll walk you through setting up Exchange mailboxes for these
         | doctors." Before he left, he walked me through a RAM upgrade
         | and gave me his lucky red screwdriver " you got this, just call
         | me if you have any issues."
         | 
         | Later in my career, I continue to learn lessons from this
         | interaction; lately the lesson has been one of "don't be
         | awesome in a vacuum" - a little bit of encouragement to the new
         | guy can go a long way to adding another person to your on-call
         | rotation that you trust.
         | 
         | 20 years later, I still have his screwdriver - and I bring it
         | every time we have lunch every once in a while.
         | 
         | Life is too short to not let the people who make life enjoyable
         | for us know so.
        
       | Dansvidania wrote:
       | being open, honest and as a consequence sometimes vulnerable in
       | conversations -1 to 1 or not- without overly filtering myself to
       | stay appropriate or to protect my ego or image has brought me to
       | having a number of close friendship that I would not have thought
       | possible.
       | 
       | Those people that I now consider my family made me a better
       | person and I would even argue made me into an adult.
       | 
       | I would simplify this in 1 don't be afraid to ask random
       | questions 2 be sincerely interested in knowing about the other
       | person's answer
       | 
       | I find this easier to do when the people are evidently
       | interesting, but more often than not people are interesting after
       | I exercise some curiosity about them.
        
       | MortyWaves wrote:
       | I've been trying to make friends, it's hard as an introvert.
       | Tried a few times online to meet a wider group of people but as
       | per other comments here people often "ghost" or don't return the
       | effort I've tried to put in.
       | 
       | I absolutely feel moving around as a child a dozen times meant I
       | never formed any lasting friendships from schools, which then had
       | knock on effects in college, and then university.
        
         | appleorchard46 wrote:
         | I'm in the same boat, friend. Being exposed to so much has its
         | upsides but ability to make lasting relationships is not one of
         | them.
        
         | conception wrote:
         | For me, as a non-introvert, I had to come to the realization
         | that most people just won't reciprocate at a level I want. That
         | you just have to make the stuff happen that you want to happen.
         | So, you really can't wait for people to reach out to you. If
         | you want to spend time with someone or if you want to have a
         | group outing you just have to be the one to do it. It's kinda
         | like any club Ive been a part in. There's usually a few people
         | that drive things, organize, etc and most freeload off that.
         | Your friendships will be like that too. You might find another
         | driver and that's great! But it won't be the case most of the
         | time. And it won't be because people don't want to do things,
         | it's just how people are. I wouldn't take offense. Just think
         | they aren't gonna be the vice president of your friend club and
         | they'll just be a member and that's okay too. Y'all still have
         | a good time.
        
         | sethammons wrote:
         | Growing up, it seemed the kids that moved a lot, aka military
         | brats, were often good at finding new friends. More practice I
         | assumed.
        
       | DeathArrow wrote:
       | I wonder if engineering close connections through structured
       | vulnerability truly leads to meaningful relationships. The best
       | friendships emerge organically through shared struggles and
       | mutual support, rather than scripted conversations.
       | 
       | The idea of forcing deep conversations might neglect the natural
       | dynamics that make friendships work.
       | 
       | Strong friendships aren't just about emotional sharing--they also
       | require shared responsibility, common interests, and personal
       | development.
       | 
       | Friendship isn't just a checklist of deep questions--it's
       | cultivated through shared experiences.
       | 
       | True friendships form through shared hardships, common pursuits,
       | and a natural alignment of values. There's something profoundly
       | meaningful about forging relationships through mutual struggle,
       | rather than intellectual exercises in vulnerability. If someone
       | wants deeper friendships, they might be better served by pursuing
       | meaningful challenges alongside others, rather than structuring
       | conversations.
        
         | mpalmer wrote:
         | Why waste everyone's time with this? We can generate facile LLM
         | responses ourselves.
        
         | SoftTalker wrote:
         | > The best friendships emerge organically through shared
         | struggles and mutual support
         | 
         | This is the basis for fraternity hazing and it does work but
         | the popular point of view is that it's a bad thing.
        
       | metalman wrote:
       | the way this is stated is troubling in that it proposes an
       | aysimetric idea of "close friend" which is just one more version
       | of hiarchical structure in human society, rather than something
       | based on seeing things from the same perspective and the trust
       | and understanding that comes.....after that discovery ie:
       | "intentionlly making", vs finding I would suggest that the
       | quality of the people that inhabit the mutual appreciation
       | societys that pass as friendships amongst the "popular"
       | extroverts is the impetus behind this sort of blind quest, the
       | unrecorded and hard to imagine blank realisation of the
       | inevitable "stalemates" in there social jockeing, no one there,
       | vulnerable, to anything at all....how dry and tedious, that must
       | be
        
         | aaarrm wrote:
         | Could you reword and reformat this? I'm interested in what
         | youre saying but am struggling to understand it fully.
        
         | globnomulous wrote:
         | This is incoherent.
        
       | stroz wrote:
       | Loved this. The shift from waiting for connection to
       | intentionally building it is everything -- and it's exactly why
       | we built Soonly (https://soonly.com). Most people rely on
       | serendipity, Soonly makes it a habit. It's an operating system
       | for intentional connections.
        
       | w10-1 wrote:
       | Mutual sacrifice is the glue that takes time to set.
       | 
       | Mutual interest propels activity, but reliable sacrifice is the
       | basis of trust and reliance.
       | 
       | But if you are perceived as welching on this, you will induce
       | real and lasting anger, justifiably in my mind because you've
       | just made it harder for people to trust for the rest of their
       | lives.
       | 
       | And this is not limited to close friends.
       | 
       | A girlfriend's mom's advice: trust your man only after he's
       | crawled over a mile of broken glass, and your boss when he's done
       | it underwater.
        
         | daymanstep wrote:
         | Following your girlfriend's mom's advice, you wouldn't trust
         | anyone.
         | 
         | Maybe that's why so few people have friends these days: they
         | set some crazy/impossible conditions that you have to meet
         | before they will trust you. As an autistic person it's
         | impossible for me to guess what kind of crazy requirements I
         | have failed to meet.
        
       | brianpan wrote:
       | Similar journey in book form: Sorry I'm Late, I Didn't Want to
       | Come. Introvert Jessica Pan spends a year being an extrovert.
       | 
       | https://bookshop.org/p/books/sorry-i-m-late-i-didn-t-want-to...
        
       | acsquared wrote:
       | I got into open source software back in 2023, and by far the best
       | part of it has been the community around the code. From irl to
       | irc, some of my closest friends I've made since then I've met
       | through programming.
        
       | rufus_foreman wrote:
       | >> up until about 4 years ago, I didn't have any close friends in
       | my life. I had friends, but struggled to form real emotional
       | connections. Moreover, it didn't even occur to me that I could
       | try to do this. It wasn't that I knew how to form close friends
       | but was too anxious to try, rather, 'try to form close
       | friendships' was a non-standard action, something that never even
       | crossed my mind
       | 
       | It's the same thing with enemies. If you're an introvert like me,
       | it's really hard to make true enemies, as opposed to people that
       | just vaguely dislike you. You might have to go pretty far out of
       | your comfort zone to do it. For many people, similar to what the
       | author says, it will never even cross their minds. But it can be
       | oddly rewarding.
        
       ___________________________________________________________________
       (page generated 2025-04-12 23:01 UTC)