[HN Gopher] Ask HN: Who's been hired through Hacker News?
       ___________________________________________________________________
        
       Ask HN: Who's been hired through Hacker News?
        
       Please comment here if you've ever gotten hired through HN and what
       your experience was like.
        
       Author : snow_mac
       Score  : 93 points
       Date   : 2024-07-11 01:09 UTC (21 hours ago)
        
       | ativzzz wrote:
       | Twice actually. One time thru who's hiring and once thru who
       | wants to be hired. Both were great jobs that I enjoyed. Good way
       | to get straight to the hiring manager
        
       | coding123 wrote:
       | One time through whos hiring. Applied to about 5.
        
       | banish-m4 wrote:
       | Some scammer "founder" invented a "job" to pick my brain while
       | pretending to be hiring. Absolute liar. One of those
       | customer/feedback chat widgets with video call features.
        
         | sureIy wrote:
         | Same thing happened to me. We had an "interview" and then
         | ghosted me. Shortly after, his product was Sherlocked and I was
         | ecstatic.
        
           | monocasa wrote:
           | Sherlocked?
        
             | pmarreck wrote:
             | https://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=sherlocked
        
             | gortok wrote:
             | Industry term for when Apple launches a product that does
             | substantially what yours does, or incorporates your product
             | features into their product.
             | 
             | https://www.howtogeek.com/297651/what-does-it-mean-when-a-
             | co...
        
           | banish-m4 wrote:
           | The startup was ServiceBell. It was a feature company in a
           | crowded market with little defensibility. They're still
           | around.
           | 
           | It's easy to get rich quick in business when you're dishonest
           | for a short time, but it's slightly more difficult to be
           | honest, trustworthy, and not a pathological liar. Karma,
           | reputation, and the law eventually catch up with shady people
           | who didn't learn anything about the social contract from
           | their parents.
        
             | JohnMakin wrote:
             | > Karma, reputation, and the law eventually catch up with
             | shady people who didn't learn anything about the social
             | contract from their parents.
             | 
             | This is comforting to believe but I'm not sure reality
             | aligns with that.
        
       | jaggederest wrote:
       | More times than I can readily remember. A number of contracts, a
       | number of full time jobs. Have attempted to hire on here a couple
       | times as well though I don't recall it working out. I've been on
       | here since 2007 though, so recent experience is substantially
       | different. It's as bad as the dotcom bust in 2001 the last year
       | or two.
       | 
       | I generally prefer YC companies and early stage startups, so it's
       | generally been good for me.
        
         | zer0sand0nes wrote:
         | Really? I wouldn't have thunk that this place would have
         | contract roles. Were they w2 or c2c or 1099? The last 2 are
         | super hard to come by. Got any tips to share on where to find
         | such roles?
        
           | yieldcrv wrote:
           | 2007 - 2014 was the heyday for contract roles
           | 
           | now companies are worried about that classification
        
           | jaggederest wrote:
           | There's a monthly "seeking freelancer" thread, or at least
           | there used to be. I also always mention my comfort working
           | contract with people even when I'm interviewing for full time
           | roles, in case that's helpful for them. "Any way that gets
           | the money from your bank account to mine".
           | 
           | Edit: Also, I do recommend the "startup match" system they
           | run, I've been having good success with that this year, found
           | my current role and a number of solid roles that were
           | candidates for acceptance. Be forewarned, that there are many
           | well-intentioned but unserious people on there, so you
           | definitely have to do a ton of legwork. Don't judge a book by
           | it's cover, some of the best roles were people who frankly
           | seemed somewhat unhinged but ended up being really
           | interesting and compelling.
        
             | snow_mac wrote:
             | Where is the startup match?
        
               | jaggederest wrote:
               | https://www.startupschool.org/cofounder-matching
        
       | Lokman wrote:
       | once, 2021 march
        
       | doctoboggan wrote:
       | I found my first job out of school and my current job both
       | through HN Who's Hiring. I have also hired 2 people myself from
       | posts I made to Who's Hiring.
        
       | marc_abonce wrote:
       | Happened to me once. I was only contacted by the company that
       | hired me (and like 2-3 spam emails) so I wouldn't really count on
       | HN as my main strategy.
       | 
       | By the way, here's a thread with the same question form last year
       | (June 2023): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36160198
        
       | smabie wrote:
       | got contacted by a trading firm when one of the founders saw one
       | of my Show HN posts. Was my breakthrough into the quant / hft
       | industry and I now run my own trading firm: that one event
       | massively changed the trajectory of my entire life.
        
         | zer0sand0nes wrote:
         | wowza - is it this post? [Show HN: Xs, a concatenative array
         | language inspired by kdb+/q and forth] https://cryptm.org/xs/
         | 
         | How is that life anyways? I know very little about it?
        
         | snow_mac wrote:
         | Please tell us more about the trading firm. Sounds interesting
        
       | rch wrote:
       | Twice. Both worked out well for me.
       | 
       | Neither was a startup though.
        
       | sdflksjdfertge wrote:
       | I used a throwaway account because I was hired through HN. The
       | work environment was terrible, extremely stressful, and led me to
       | become very depressed. It wasn't until I shared my experiences
       | with a friend, who was shocked and convinced me to quit, that I
       | realized how bad it had been.
       | 
       | This hasn't completely discouraged me from being hired through HN
       | in similar situations, but I will definitely do more research on
       | the company beforehand.
       | 
       | This comment was rewritten by AI to anonymize the writing style.
        
         | moomoo11 wrote:
         | What stage was the company at and what was your role?
        
       | djbusby wrote:
       | Ages ago, I found a player on here who was looking to move to
       | where my team was (Seattle).
       | 
       | They had a good "vibe" from their I want to get hired post.
       | 
       | Got them their first gig in the tech space. Now with me at
       | another tech play.
       | 
       | This place is great for connecting, the signal is way above
       | noise.
        
       | kxrm wrote:
       | I was hired, just reached out to the contact on a "Who's Hiring"
       | thread for a company doing work I had some experience with but
       | was looking to expand on. So far so good.
       | 
       | For background the hire before that was through a colleague and
       | the job I got before that was through a news list. I don't really
       | ever get any success through more traditional job seeking
       | services.
        
       | harlanji wrote:
       | I was extended a good opportunity to do entry level web dev but
       | left the interview because I felt the coding puzzle was too hard
       | for the role, even tho I could've solved it. Computer
       | Science/math heavy and easy if already familiar. I still feel bad
       | and entitled about that but I acted on the signal I felt and told
       | the truth.
       | 
       | Aside, I am all for suitably difficult challenges, and I
       | distinguish engineer from developer. Dev shouldn't get CS stuff,
       | Eng should. Mention it to benefit other hiring managers who may
       | be reading, if it rings fair.
        
       | shortstuffsushi wrote:
       | I was hired after interacting in a comment thread with a founder
       | that was building the same thing I was NIH-ing at my current job.
       | Easy fit to come on since I was currently doing it, but not
       | ultimately a great fit. It pulled me out of my first five year
       | gig at a huge corporation and helped me see the extreme opposite
       | of that, and paid hugely better. I don't think it was a huge
       | resume pad, as it wasn't a well known FAANG, but I appreciated
       | the perspective it gave me and the redirection of my career.
        
       | chc4 wrote:
       | I got my first job through Who Wants To Be Hired in 2019. An
       | engineer at the company reached out to refer me based on my
       | resume. It was very good for allowing me to break into the
       | industry, and it was a great place.
        
       | imroot wrote:
       | I've been hired through HN twice.
       | 
       | Once at Singly, in 2010-ish. Was a contractor for about 4 months,
       | they brought me on full time, and I spent about a year there,
       | left to go to one of the big 4 consulting companies, spent 7
       | years there.
       | 
       | The second was at Greenhouse (the ATS) in 2021 -- was there until
       | Jan of this year.
        
       | neom wrote:
       | I'd love to list the founders on here who reached out and totally
       | wasted my time trying to figure out how they should build the
       | team they are hiring for vs trying to hire me the couple of times
       | I posted on here about working with one of you. Totally overt
       | bait and switch. I'm pretty sure a bunch of you would go "hmm,
       | surprised those guys did that" given they're "known".
        
       | robin_reala wrote:
       | Not directly, but someone on HN reached out to me in 2014 to ask
       | if I had time to review their new app. Turned out it was a job
       | board (can't remember what the USP was) and among the scraped
       | initial data was a GOV.UK job ad that ended up being the single
       | most influential position to my career that I've ever had.
        
         | loa_in_ wrote:
         | That's kind of funny but I imagine it counts!
        
       | slashdev wrote:
       | I've found more jobs through HN than any other channel.
       | 
       | Not the ads, but the Who's hiring posts.
       | 
       | No regrets. I just found a new job, same way.
        
         | unnewsie wrote:
         | Yea the whos Hiring Posts are a great resource!
        
       | thrwymsss wrote:
       | Obvious throwaway account.
       | 
       | I had around 10 interviews via HN jobs, and around 50ish through
       | the startup match making thing.
       | 
       | 7/10 job interviews were fake jobs that actually didn't exist and
       | where there's not even a budget available for them. These jobs
       | were abused as early customer feedback and I didn't believe what
       | happened there. I was basically braindumped.
       | 
       | The interviews from the startup matchmaking site were also kind
       | of ridiculous. More bullshit consultants there than actual
       | founders or actual developers that could or want to be building
       | anything. These consultants want to hire you as a cheap
       | developer, not as a founder, and definitely not as a shareholder.
       | Happened so many times that I am not using this site for anything
       | startup related anymore.
       | 
       | In general I'd argue that HN has a huge vetting problem, and by
       | vetting I mean whether or not the intent of the people attending
       | there come with honest intentions as to both their experience
       | (which pretty much is almost always totally made up if you
       | discuss more technical problems) and the idea of putting a lot of
       | work into a problem to solve it (a _lot_ of people think that
       | having a startup gig on the weekend, but only afternoons, leads
       | to anything successful).
       | 
       | Most people come with so high expectations that it feels like
       | being inside a ponzi community. Startups are a percentage game of
       | luck, and you can only get an advantage if you have the right
       | team at the right time, which implies that teams have to be
       | absurdly motivated by a problem.
       | 
       | The people I found on this site are the opposite of that. They
       | see it as a way to make quick cash because "they heard this is
       | how to get rich fast".
       | 
       | I was very disappointed and am now much more involved in our
       | local startup related meetups and events, and found a lot of team
       | members through that.
        
         | thrwymsss wrote:
         | I wanted to add that I was talking about the HN inserted ads of
         | their YC related startups, not the who's hiring threads.
         | 
         | (Just in case there was a misunderstanding)
        
       | nfriedly wrote:
       | I got my current job by posting on a "who wants to be hired?"
       | thread. I was contacted by the person who ended up being my
       | manager and got fast tracked through the interviewing process.
       | It's at a company that I probably never would have heard of
       | otherwise (Fullstory), but I like it enough that I'm still there
       | ~4.5 years later.
       | 
       | On the flip side, I can think of three people who were hired via
       | "who's hiring?" posts I put up.
        
       | dqh wrote:
       | I was hired for my current role at Cortical Labs via a "Who wants
       | to be hired?" thread a year ago. First time I had tried via HN, I
       | had a great experience and I recommend trying it if you haven't.
        
       | slau wrote:
       | I wanted to move to Denmark and saw a startup looking for an
       | engineering lead. I applied, received a coding challenge, was
       | invited for some interviews with the engineering team, after I
       | came back home I had an online interview with the CEO (which to
       | me felt like the worst interview in my life), and was offered the
       | job along with a relocation package.
       | 
       | Stayed with the company for a couple of years.
        
       | 1vuio0pswjnm7 wrote:
       | As suspected, this long-running "Who is hiring" recurring
       | submission is mostly fake jobs and has a success rate for the
       | "applicants" of close to zero.
       | 
       | Perhaps the "Who wants to be hired" recurring submission is
       | similarly bogus.
       | 
       | Free information gathering at the expense of gulllible computer
       | users, here, "developers". Another page from the SillyCon Valley
       | playbook.
        
       | rcarmo wrote:
       | Got a few pings, but nothing of substance. Being in Europe, it's
       | not easy.
        
       | itsmemattchung wrote:
       | Yup: I had reached out to a small business owner (had to hunt
       | down his email) to pick his brain on CRMs. That one phone call
       | turned into me consulting for him for a short period of time.
        
       | junaid1460 wrote:
       | Me through monthly job posting thread
        
       | perklone wrote:
       | I did, from a YC startup based in SEA.
       | 
       | Who's Hiring hit-rate is much better than my LinkedIn hit-rate :D
        
       | karaterobot wrote:
       | In late 2019, I applied for a job I read about on a Who's Hiring
       | thread, and worked at that company for about 2 years.
        
       | peter_l_downs wrote:
       | Me! When I was in highschool I started emailing companies from
       | the whoishiring thread, managed to find an apprenticeship in SF.
       | My thinking was that before I went to college to study computer
       | science I should check to see if I liked writing code.
       | 
       | Turns out I love writing code and don't care much for computer
       | science. I've been a software engineer (NOT a computer scientist)
       | ever since.
       | 
       | Thank you to Mek, Stephen, and Matt for taking a chance on me.
        
         | gwbas1c wrote:
         | > Turns out I love writing code and don't care much for
         | computer science. I've been a software engineer (NOT a computer
         | scientist) ever since.
         | 
         | That was a piece of advice I wish I had when I was in high
         | school. It wasn't until halfway though college that I
         | understood the difference. It was abundantly obvious that the
         | vast majority of CS students should have been in a "Software
         | Engineering" program, too.
        
           | peter_l_downs wrote:
           | I ended up working for 2 years before I went to school, and
           | it made a lot of things easier. When I graduated I was very
           | certain that I wanted to go back to industry rather than go
           | to academia. Definitely different jobs and skillsets.
        
             | gwbas1c wrote:
             | The irony is that, I think if I had studied software
             | engineering in college, I probably would have continued to
             | get a PhD!
        
           | hirvi74 wrote:
           | Why do you think such students should have been in SE
           | instead? Because it aligns more with their goals?
           | 
           | Perhaps you are right, but I am thankful for my CS background
           | despite being a SWE myself.
           | 
           | Understand that I am also close to the intelligence level of
           | crayon-eating compared to most on this site. I felt like my
           | unspectacular public state university level CS degree
           | wouldn't even hold a candle to some of the people's education
           | in this very thread like the one commenter who studied at
           | MIT.
           | 
           | However, I still believe what I learned was extremely
           | valuable. In fact, I am sadden by my level of understanding
           | and I wish I knew more CS. Just because I do not apply pure
           | CS every single day does not mean that my decisions are not
           | influenced by what I learned. At worst, my knowledge has
           | never been a hindrance.I refuse to believe that knowledge can
           | ever be useless. Not applicable != useless.
           | 
           | Genuine question though, what would a software engineering
           | program provide that a computer science student would
           | struggle to understand?
        
             | pavel_lishin wrote:
             | I think you can have an SE track with the appropriate
             | amount of CS background. You'd have to, to be a functional
             | engineer. (Then again, some I've worked with...)
             | 
             | One reason I also wish I'd gone along an SE track is that
             | it would likely have given me a lot more experience
             | actually doing what I do for work. Using version control,
             | working with others in a group setting, actually _making
             | software_.
        
               | laurencerowe wrote:
               | Having done a software engineering degree (albeit 25
               | years ago now) you should probably not expect it to be
               | any more practical in that way. We had only a handful of
               | extra mandatory modules over the CS requirements (I think
               | on working on larger systems) but no extra practical
               | programming.
        
           | devwastaken wrote:
           | SE programs are scams in the U.S. unfortunately. Comp sci is
           | the only universally recognized and mostly standard degree.
           | SE isn't even an option for many hiring/job app platforms
           | like IBM.
        
           | cchance wrote:
           | I didn't go to college, I got out of high school, took care
           | of my mom and almost immediately worked for an ISP as
           | customer service, worked my way up over 3 buyouts, and 20
           | years to be a sysadmin for the company that everyone depended
           | on.
           | 
           | Sadly something I only recently allowed myself to understand
           | is that I really don't have passion for networking, I
           | absolutely love coding and creating new integrations,
           | interfaces and backend, I did a lot of it to patch holes in
           | the company i worked for and streamline my own and others
           | work.
           | 
           | I'm a remote contractor for that same company now still doing
           | the networking and some dev work for them but really want to
           | get out and find a company that I can focus more on the
           | DevOps side.
        
         | rvrs wrote:
         | Your website says you went to MIT to study computer science
         | anyways...?
        
           | peter_l_downs wrote:
           | Yes, and I learned a lot there, including that I much prefer
           | software engineering to computer science.
        
       | atum47 wrote:
       | I was working for a big bank, facing moral harassment almost
       | every day from a shitty manager. The thing with moral harassment
       | is it don't happen out of nothing, it is gradual. The manager was
       | testing the waters, every day making the insult a bit harder than
       | the day before. One day he actually cursed me in a meeting with
       | 14 other people and I decided I had enough. Reported him to HR
       | and quit. After that I was working on a game, that I was going to
       | try to make a living out of. I was decided not to go back to work
       | for a while. Then, on HN I saw those to topics - who wants to be
       | hired and who is hiring. I selected 6 openings that seems
       | interesting to me and send an email. 4 wrote me back. 3 gave me a
       | coding challenge. 1 Hired me. Been working with them for almost 3
       | years now. Great company. Really nice people.
        
         | silisili wrote:
         | Nice story, good for you.
         | 
         | I like that you curated your search, hiring would be in such a
         | better place if everyone did that. Anymore, every single
         | opening gets spammed thousands of resumes with absolutely no
         | skill or history relevant to the company. Makes it harder for
         | the hiring side and people like yourself.
        
           | atum47 wrote:
           | To be honest it took me about 6 hours to go through all the
           | openings, selecting the ones I was interested in, writing a
           | custom email and adapting my resumee to fit that particular
           | opening. It was actually work.
        
         | mylastattempt wrote:
         | This is my first time hearing of 'moral harassment'. Is that an
         | actual phrase or is English not your native language? Reading
         | the rest of your comment it seems the manager was just a bully,
         | but please elaborate if that understanding is incorrect!
        
           | atum47 wrote:
           | Yeah, I tend to use Portuguese terms translated to English,
           | sorry about that. English is not my native language.
        
             | mylastattempt wrote:
             | No need for apologies, it was merely my curiousity getting
             | the better of me!
        
         | piloto_ciego wrote:
         | There was another post in this thread that basically said,
         | "toughen up buttercup" that I can no longer find. While I agree
         | that this is a dickish thing to say, I can't help but somewhat
         | agree with the sentiment that tech workers are perhaps a little
         | bit better off than the average person and don't have a lot of
         | perspective here about how bad it can get. Not saying that it's
         | ok, rather that when you can easily find another job it's
         | pretty easy to take a principled stand.
         | 
         | I flew for a living for a long time and was verbally harassed
         | at many jobs by a superior. I remember talking on the radio
         | once during a checkride - "do you have shit in your mouth?
         | Because you sound like it."
         | 
         | He was just being an asshole to rile me up, but it remains an
         | asshole thing to say, and you have to deal with it because he
         | literally holds your career in his hands. Personally, in that
         | moment I vowed I'd never do that to anyone - but it doesn't
         | mean it isn't widespread and it doesn't mean quitting was an
         | option.
         | 
         | Other times in my career I was expressedly told violate
         | regulations or do legal but wildly unsafe things; because I had
         | massive student loan debt at the time (I paid all that shit off
         | eventually greatest feeling in the world), rent to pay, I had
         | to make a lot of compromises I'm not proud of retrospectively
         | because I did not want to be homeless or laid off looking for a
         | flying job in 2009.
         | 
         | To act as though everyone can quit if their ego gets bruised by
         | some jackass is the height of privilege. Many many other
         | careers do not have that option. Not saying it is right in the
         | least, but I feel a lot of people would really benefit from an
         | understanding that how principled a person can be often
         | practically changed by exterior circumstances.
         | 
         | That's the thing I want people to take away from all this - a
         | sort of "dialectical materialism" sort of view - that being
         | able to quit without worse consequences than a bruised ego is
         | unto itself a sort of prosperity many many people do not have.
        
           | twosdai wrote:
           | I hear you, being able to leave a job and quickly find a new
           | one is a great thing to have in this field, and it helps in
           | having a great sense of job security.
           | 
           | The issue isn't that these jobs pay well and are great to
           | work in so we should deal with any bs that flys. It's that
           | people don't deserve to be harrassed, regardless of how
           | "good" their work is.
           | 
           | If you make 2 million a year as an investment banker, you
           | don't deserve to be unfairly humiliated at your job more than
           | any part time fast food worker.
        
         | cchance wrote:
         | Thats so great to hear, glad that you got out of that toxic
         | environment.
        
       | jszymborski wrote:
       | I got hired via HN through the Who's Hiring post and gotten two
       | solicitations through comments.
       | 
       | The Who's Hiring post was actually posted by an employee seeking
       | a referral bonus. Overall a good experience.
        
         | drcoopster wrote:
         | I posted a "Who's Hiring" post as an employee seeking a
         | referral bonus. I got a few leads from that and ultimately
         | referred two of them, one of whom we hired and is still working
         | with us (and me) nearly three years later.
        
       | dewey wrote:
       | I reached out to a company here and got hired as a working
       | student, still there 9 years later :)
        
       | fuzzieozzie wrote:
       | Related: I hired over 25 people through HN (across the world)
       | before CompilerWorks was bought by Google in Oct 2022!
        
         | 7thaccount wrote:
         | I think I remember reading about your company. Very cool stuff,
         | but outside my real skill set.
        
       | gwbas1c wrote:
       | I applied for a job from a December 2020 Who's Hiring post,
       | started in early February 2021.
       | 
       | I'm still with the posted position: I really like the company and
       | the people I work with. It's certainly one of the better jobs
       | I've had in my career.
       | 
       | In my 2020 job search, I gravitated towards "Who's Hiring" for a
       | few reasons: I interacted directly with hiring managers, and I
       | prefer early-stage companies. The concise nature of posts makes
       | it easy to flag the ones I want to pursue. The fact that it's
       | once a month means I know that someone is actively hiring.
       | 
       | In contrast, I don't like working with non-technical "middlemen"
       | recruiters, I don't like FAANG-style hiring, long job postings
       | make it hard to narrow down which ones I want to pursue, and I'm
       | always afraid that I'm applying to a job posting that's "for
       | show" and I'm just wasting my time. (IE, some managers always try
       | to keep a few open positions as a way of working large company
       | politics without seriously intending on filling those positions.)
        
       | bilsbie wrote:
       | I'm thinking the who's hiring works reasonably well but the other
       | two: freelancers, and wants to be hired are pretty worthless (for
       | job seekers)
       | 
       | Please correct me if I'm wrong.
        
         | Arubis wrote:
         | I've found a few clients through the Freelancer/Seeking
         | Freelancer posts over the years. It's not a huge contributor to
         | my pipeline, but it's not zero.
        
       | Sparkenstein wrote:
       | Me
        
       | Arubis wrote:
       | I found my first full-time remote W2 through HN back in
       | 2013/2014. It wasn't a Who's Hiring post (were we running those
       | back then?), but rather an HN discussion that linked out to a
       | blog post at an organization that felt like an excellent cultural
       | and technical match, despite being a couple timezones away. That
       | kicked off an email thread with their tech leadership, and I had
       | a job within about a month. Stayed there for four pretty good
       | years!
        
       | kevdev wrote:
       | I got hired at my current company back in 2022 through their post
       | on a Who's Hiring post here. Likely never would have heard of
       | them otherwise, but glad I did!
        
       | buggy6257 wrote:
       | Not specifically the HN who's hiring etc threads, but through
       | YCombinator's job board I was approached, interviewed, and hired.
       | Loved the company, work was fun (even if not my favorite
       | language), but I upset the CTO by questioning his Golden Boy, the
       | CTO stole an idea wholesale from me after telling me it was a bad
       | idea, and then fired me with no specific reasons.
       | 
       | If it weren't for that CTO I'd likely still be working there.
        
       | taternuts wrote:
       | I think it was almost 7 years ago but I was flown from VA->SF and
       | interviewed for a company that I ultimately didn't end up getting
       | an offer for, but it was a good experience
        
       | ekvintroj wrote:
       | Anyone else from latam?
        
       | private-hr-meta wrote:
       | I have the best job in my career and I was hired from responding
       | to a who's hiring thread. wish I could give more details, but any
       | single data point about the firm yields who it is.
       | 
       | generally, the company was looking for a very unique form of
       | talent driven by a certain attitude and experience. they
       | developed tools for verifying and filtering for it. if you've
       | read any william gibson novels the firm would fit right into
       | something he would describe.
       | 
       | if I were to characterize it, I'd say someone who has been any
       | one of a FOSS contributor, bootstrapped founder, hacker,
       | competitor especially elite level or minor fame in anything,
       | autodidact, amateurist, performing artist, among other high
       | competence bars that demonstrate tacit knowledge, focus, clarity,
       | humility, reflexive curiosity, and related qualities, then
       | imagine a firm that had somehow managed to quietly collect scores
       | of them.
       | 
       | HN seems to attract a cluster of those people.
        
         | azmodeus wrote:
         | Would love to hear more about these attributes and whether they
         | are only used for software engineers or client facing roles as
         | well
        
       | headcanon wrote:
       | I didn't get hired through HN personally, however I did publish a
       | Whos Hiring? post for an opening on my team a few years ago and
       | we found a great frontend engineer.
       | 
       | I'm super happy about the practice overall and I hope it
       | continues!
        
       | tracker1 wrote:
       | I'd applied to maybe 20 positions that were applicable in the
       | past year. I got either no response or a boilerplate rejection
       | from most of them. 2-3 I did get a reply from. Got to final round
       | on one of them.
       | 
       | I've gotten about 3 responses when posting to the who is looking
       | post.
       | 
       | It can really vary, and depends on what you are looking for, what
       | tools/tech you have experience in and experience.
        
       | as1mov wrote:
       | I've had 3 jobs in last 7 years, 2 were through HN. The first one
       | through here was alright, the pay was shit but the work itself
       | was very interesting. Stayed there for 3 years and learned a lot,
       | though the working conditions were terrible. I was constantly
       | working 12-13 hour days and barely making anything.
       | 
       | I posted here again in late 2019 and a recruiter asked me if I
       | wanted to move to Europe for work. Not seeing any future back
       | home, I gambled and said yes. Interviewed with the company for a
       | few months and eventually moved to EU in late 2020 and been here
       | since then. I never got to thank the recruiter in person as he
       | had already left by the time I started at the new job. His one
       | email in Oct 2019 was something that dramatically changed the
       | trajectory of my life. Hi J, if you're reading this! :)
       | 
       | I've been posting on Who is Hiring threads again in the last few
       | months but the situation has changed drastically now. I need a
       | work permit to stay here and not many companies (at least on HN)
       | are offering that. I guess it's time to pack my bags and move
       | again to places unknown.
        
       | Fizzadar wrote:
       | Twice! First through who's hiring fresh out of university in 2013
       | and more recently via a submission (Kanmail).
        
       | qwelias wrote:
       | Got a job from here last year, goes alright, tho it was a lucky
       | one as noone else has invited me for an actual interview.
        
       | ownagefool wrote:
       | I hired a couple who posted they're seeking employment, and
       | interviewed a few more than that.
        
       | BrandiATMuhkuh wrote:
       | I found my last 2 jobs via "Who wants to be hired" and hired 2
       | people via "Who is hiring".
       | 
       | I found the experience was great, in both cases
        
       | v3ss0n wrote:
       | Me and 10 out of 15 devs of my team got hired and we are very
       | happy with current client for almost a year now.
        
       | elamje wrote:
       | Massively changed my life trajectory.
       | 
       | I was working on my first "startup" (if you want to call it that)
       | and wasn't getting traction. The owner of a software consulting
       | firm found me on Hacker News and brought me in as his first
       | employee on a massive contract. We grew the team substantially,
       | made great money and that lead to doing a real startup after. And
       | then another. All from a post I made on a hiring thread.
        
         | VirusNewbie wrote:
         | Man, that's amazing. Glad it worked out. Sometimes I miss the
         | old days of the internet where everyone was helping each other,
         | so it's great to hear stories of it still happening on HN.
        
       | drewcoo wrote:
       | I've been on both ends of successful hiring via "Who's Hiring?"
       | more than once. It seemed like CraigsList was really useful back
       | in the mid-aughts, then HN lists started to dominate the
       | "interesting jobs without BS job board" category.
       | 
       | You're going to get an overwhelming number of "yup, worked for me
       | in 2XXX" responses. I'm not sure what the point of the question
       | is, though.
       | 
       | The job market for us is very different now than even a handful
       | of years ago, so any results won't be representative of now. And
       | asking only for survivors won't tell you how successful the
       | postings really were to either side, just that eventually the job
       | was filled from here and not another source.
        
       ___________________________________________________________________
       (page generated 2024-07-11 23:02 UTC)