[HN Gopher] Coffee helped the Union in the Civil War
       ___________________________________________________________________
        
       Coffee helped the Union in the Civil War
        
       Author : bookofjoe
       Score  : 131 points
       Date   : 2024-06-30 00:41 UTC (22 hours ago)
        
 (HTM) web link (www.smithsonianmag.com)
 (TXT) w3m dump (www.smithsonianmag.com)
        
       | mrblampo wrote:
       | Fun article! Particularly enjoyed the anecdotal evidence from
       | individual soldier's writing.
        
         | brightball wrote:
         | Studying the civil war is really interesting and I wish schools
         | did a better job of it. There is so much material from letters
         | people wrote at the time that is just fascinating to read.
        
       | kristianp wrote:
       | Reminds me of a recent story of how speed kept the germans
       | advancing for days on end in WWII, in the blitzkrieg.
       | 
       | "How Methamphetamine Became a Key Part of Nazi Military Strategy"
       | https://time.com/5752114/nazi-military-drugs/
        
         | cj wrote:
         | Still in use by the US Air Force. Although it's amphetamine /
         | modafinil instead of meth. I'm always curious if they train
         | while medicated, which seems kind of necessary considering how
         | it modifies decision making behavior.
         | 
         | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Go_and_no-go_pills
         | 
         | Edit: Actually looks like amphetamine isn't approved anymore.
        
           | rafaelmn wrote:
           | Modafinil doesn't really affect decision making ? Being
           | exhausted is probably way bigger impact, even under
           | Modafinil.
        
             | BossingAround wrote:
             | Well, per [1], it increases dopamine, norepinephrine,
             | serotonin, and other chemicals in the brain. It is highly
             | unlikely that it has no effect on one's decision making
             | (esp. when you take it when you are _not_ very tired). It's
             | more likely that you don't notice the effects, but the
             | effects would likely be measurable.
             | 
             | It's the same with caffeine. I'd wager a guess that most
             | people don't think it influences their decision making...
             | And yet it seems it does (e.g. [2]).
             | 
             | [1] https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/medicine-and-
             | dentistry/...
             | 
             | [2] https://www.freethink.com/health/does-caffeine-harm-
             | your-dec...
        
             | bryanrasmussen wrote:
             | I remember reading a study on modafinil that found people
             | on modafinil for a couple days when giving directions where
             | apt to be irritable and not throwing in identifying
             | details.
             | 
             | so a modafinil user "Go three blocks that way, turn left,
             | go two blocks turn left again, turn right immediately"
             | 
             | non-modafinil user "Go that way until you see the Circle-K,
             | turn left, then it's two blocks where you have to turn left
             | again, the street name is something like Majors way, and
             | then the first time you can turn after that you turn right
             | - there's a large drawing of a man drinking coffee on the
             | side of the building"
             | 
             | on edit: unfortunately no idea where I read this but that
             | was a big let-down for me as it implied there was perhaps
             | no such thing as a free ride. Bummer.
        
             | reaperman wrote:
             | Modafinil increases my risk-taking behavior much more than
             | amphetamine does, though otherwise has much lower physical
             | side effects than amphetamine. Took me awhile to realize I
             | was being incredibly flirty due to modafinil. It was
             | typically well-received and it took me a long time to
             | realize that it was modifying my behavior. But once I knew
             | what to look for I saw the modifications across wide parts
             | of my life including work and personal goals. Generally
             | made me take on more ambitious goals.
             | 
             | Eventually I suffered some traumatic events and modafinil
             | started causing anxiety, especially when mixed with
             | caffeine, and I found vyvanse was better after that for
             | managing my ADHD without quite as much paralyzing anxiety.
             | 
             | Everyone's brain reacts very differently to each stimulant.
             | On the very rare occasion that I take cocaine I usually
             | just fall asleep and enjoy a hard nap! I don't experience
             | about 90% of the effects my friends report from it.
             | 
             | Caffeine keeps me awake all night long even if I have just
             | half of a cup of coffee any time after 11AM, and increases
             | my anxiety to the point where it's very difficult to be
             | productive.
             | 
             | Dextroamphetamine and Vyvanse both affect work productivity
             | similarly for me but dextroamphetamine shuts down my social
             | interaction, whereas Vyvanse increases it. This is
             | particularly strange because they "should" be the exact
             | same active drug once the Vyvanse is metabolized. Biology
             | is still very much being discovered and there is a lot that
             | we just don't know yet.
        
             | s1artibartfast wrote:
             | Very much underestimate the impact of exhaustion. If I
             | recall correctly, I read a study that driving after a long
             | day of work was many times more dangerous than driving over
             | the legal limit for alcohol. Kind of puts both into
             | perspective
        
           | freedomben wrote:
           | Modafinil has been the go to pill for the Air Force for quite
           | some time. I don't know about nowadays, but in the mid 00s
           | they handed it out like candy in the war zones. Same with
           | Ambien. (source: I was there)
        
           | the__alchemist wrote:
           | Here are the current details:
           | 
           | - "Go pills" are either dextroamphetamine (Similar to
           | adderall), or modafinil. They are not used for normal day-to-
           | day training. They are used reasonably heavily on deployments
           | and international flights, to keep you sharp in these
           | situations (Sudden combat after a long uneventful air patrol,
           | or just fighting drowsiness while crossing the ocean and
           | needing to mid-air refuel for the 5th time etc.)
           | 
           | No-go pills (eg ambien) are also common on deployments,
           | mainly to deal with shift changes, or dealing with sunlight
           | affecting the circadian rythm.
           | 
           | Use is up to the individual. I found that Dex has a severe
           | impact on my sleep, even when taking 14+ hour prior. It is a
           | very effective mental performance enhancer and obliterates
           | exhaustion IMO, if you don't develop a tolerance. Ie, if you
           | have available when flying, and take only when needed.
           | 
           | Rule of thumb: Always fly with dex available, but only take
           | when needed. Never have ambien anywhere in the cockpit, or
           | you risk mixing them up.
        
             | toast0 wrote:
             | > They are not used for normal day-to-day training.
             | 
             | That makes sense, but you probably should do some training
             | with them, so first use is not in a dangerous situation.
        
               | the__alchemist wrote:
               | Correct - called "ground testing"
        
         | PopAlongKid wrote:
         | The animated show "Archer" (action/comedy TV series) season 9
         | episode 7 had this as a plot point. From the IMDB trivia
         | section:
         | 
         | https://www.imdb.com/title/tt7576240/trivia/
         | 
         | "Pervitin was one of the first commercially available
         | formulations of methamphetamine hydrochloride (salts); it also
         | contained large doses of caffeine. It was used by Nazi
         | soldiers, sometimes along with cocaine, to help them remain
         | alert on night patrols, long marches and also to help increase
         | aggression and stamina during battle. Pervitin was heavily used
         | by Stuka (a German fighter plane) pilots to help keep them
         | alert on long patrol flights, hence the nickname "Stuka
         | tablets". By 1940 the German Army had started greatly reducing
         | the number of tablets each solider was allowed to have due to
         | the severe side effects. While the drug was in their system, it
         | had the benefit of causing decreased fear and increased
         | strength, stamina, aggression and gave them a high resistance
         | to pain. However, after the drug wore off, soldiers often took
         | several days to recover. They suffered from a form of
         | amphetamine "hangover" and were pretty much useless for the
         | next few days because they acted more like zombies than
         | soldiers; this was mainly because of the long duration of
         | methamphetamine's effects which would cause soldiers to be
         | awake for a few days straight, so it would take several days
         | for the body to recover. Pervitin use also was responsible for
         | Nazi soldiers becoming too aggressive and attacking fellow
         | soldiers and superior officers. It also caused some to commit
         | war crimes by killing civilians and raping women and young
         | girls as amphetamines often greatly increase libido and
         | decrease inhibitions."
        
         | jordanb wrote:
         | This podcast talks about Nazi drug use:
         | 
         | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A3_3aUKfLoI
         | 
         | One of the takeaways is that meth works ok during fast blitz
         | campaigns like Poland or France where you want to get the whole
         | thing over in a few weeks at most. But it works horribly in a
         | long attritional fight like the eastern front where soldiers
         | start suffering from the cognitive and physical consequences
         | while still in the field fighting.
        
         | xhkkffbf wrote:
         | Another good book is _Blitzed_.
         | 
         | A bit about it:
         | 
         | https://www.nytimes.com/2016/12/09/books/high-on-hitler-and-...
        
       | bevan wrote:
       | There's a short and fun book called Blitzed about "PED" use in
       | WWII. Covering German pharmaceutical industry's monopoly over
       | certain stimulants, Hitler's unlikely doctor who shot him up with
       | everything under the sun, and the ultimate consequences for
       | everyone involved (addiction, exhaustion, insanity).
        
         | BossingAround wrote:
         | Meth specifically is believed to be one of the contributing
         | factor in the early success of the German army. Interestingly,
         | I believe the same was used by the Japanese to encourage
         | suicidal attacks, since, it turns out, it's easier to carry one
         | when you're high as a kite.
        
       | mikemitchelldev wrote:
       | Sounds like anything to eat or drink would have helped.
        
         | morkalork wrote:
         | The know how and ability to manufacture condensed milk is
         | another famous example from the civil war.
        
       | BossingAround wrote:
       | Caffeine is a very interesting drug that makes capitalism and
       | just daily work bearable. It's interesting that this went all the
       | way to 1800s for the US.
       | 
       | After reading Your Mind on Plants [1], I decided to do an
       | experiment, and stop any caffeine intake for ~3 months. After ~1
       | month, I felt "normal". Only when you cannot rely on a drug, a
       | clutch, you realize how many pressures you face every day. One
       | might have a deadline, something doesn't work, some part of work
       | is boring... Maybe you just slept badly. Coffee fixes all of
       | those.
       | 
       | Nothing is free though, and soon, you'll discover your sleep is
       | not the best pretty much every day of the week. That, in turn,
       | forces you to consume more caffeine, and thus the addiction cycle
       | begins.
       | 
       | Interestingly, after being 3 months caffeine free, I succumbed to
       | the pressure and started drinking some amount of caffeine again
       | (work needs to be done, caffeine makes it easier to concentrate
       | -> it's really difficult to say no).
       | 
       | I would encourage everyone to examine their relationship with
       | this particular drug. It's insane to me that the population in
       | 1800s was already so addicted to the drug that the lack "plugs"
       | threaten to lose the civil war.
       | 
       | [1] https://www.amazon.com/This-Your-Plants-Michael-
       | Pollan/dp/05...
        
         | zeta0134 wrote:
         | I went on a similar caffeine experimentation journey, and
         | eventually settled on one (1) cup of coffee in the morning,
         | followed by usually plain water for the rest of the day. I
         | appreciate the boost to "get a task started" willpower that the
         | caffeine provides, and by limiting my intake, it's mostly
         | flushed out of my system by the time I'm ready to sleep. For my
         | body, this balance seems to work well: I sleep deeply, dream
         | vividly, and am occasionally woken by nightmares. (always
         | wasps.) Usual stuff.
         | 
         | Ideally I'd avoid caffeine entirely, but when I tried to
         | sustain this (for over a year) I felt lethargic and fatigued
         | more often than not. From a willpower perspective, it was far
         | too easy to go, "I'm too tired to start this task right now,
         | I'll put it off." Some of that is mental, I realize, but the
         | quick fix won. I have stuff to do and I don't want to spend
         | months in misery trying to force a major lifestyle change when
         | the coffee is right there.
         | 
         | What I *cannot* do anymore is drink caffeine (in any form) all
         | day long, like I used to when I was younger. I have no idea how
         | I slept at all. I'm partly convinced I mostly did not, and in
         | hindsight it explains a lot of weird sleep consistency issues I
         | was constantly struggling with.
        
           | Nathanba wrote:
           | Same journey for me, sadly I don't think drinking coffee
           | consistently is the perfect answer. No matter what amount I
           | drink it either becomes too little (because I adapt) or too
           | much (Far worse sleep, somewhat depressive, can't work out or
           | jog anymore because of heart fluttering, only truly feel good
           | for ~4-5h per day, then worse all day). I think the only
           | theoretical way to consistently get value out of coffee is to
           | drink it during the work week and then force myself to
           | withdraw on the weekend so my body always has a fresh
           | response to it. The reason why I don't like this either is
           | because I obviously lose two entire days of my life to
           | feeling pretty bad per week and you still eventually start
           | drinking more because it's inevitable. Now what I remember
           | seeing over the years is that whenever somebody would mention
           | that they don't drink coffee and that person is still a high
           | performer then they always seemed to be really into fitness
           | and sports. Maybe this is the only way, using physical
           | exercise as a stimulant instead of coffee.
        
             | mirsadm wrote:
             | Caffeine is great for working out. I have a coffee before
             | running or lifting weights. It's also usually included into
             | lots fitness oriented supplements.
        
           | mirsadm wrote:
           | If you feel tired and lethargic without coffee than to me
           | that is a bigger problem to solve. I find the view on coffee
           | here so strange. If I don't drink coffee I still get up and
           | go for a run, I can still do everything just the same. My
           | performance at work is the same. I drink it because I enjoy
           | the taste and that's where it ends.
        
             | BossingAround wrote:
             | > I drink it because I enjoy the taste and that's where it
             | ends.
             | 
             | Coffee is a very bitter drink. I don't know you of course,
             | but my guess is that what you like more is the dopamine
             | caffeine releases in your brain, which you've now
             | associated with the taste. You can try and experiment with
             | good decaf coffee to see if it is actually the taste that
             | you like.
        
               | jameshart wrote:
               | A strange sentiment. Do you think in general people can't
               | like 'bitter' flavors?
               | 
               | Bitterness is very loosely defined in general - we know
               | what 'sweet' and 'salt' are; bitterness is sometimes
               | associated with some sort of acidity, but a lot of people
               | seem to just describe things that have strong flavor but
               | lack sweetness as 'bitter'. Lemon, chocolate, kale, and
               | red wine are all sometimes described as 'bitter' and they
               | have virtually no common flavor compounds.
               | 
               | It's definitely possible to like the taste of coffee. My
               | evidence for this is that when I drink coffee that tastes
               | bad, I don't like it as much.
        
               | denton-scratch wrote:
               | Acidity causes things to taste sour, not bitter.
               | Bitterness is associated with alkaloids (many alkaloids
               | are poisonous, so the fact we have taste-buds for
               | bitterness is an advantage).
               | 
               | I experience lemons as both sweet and sour, but certainly
               | not bitter.
               | 
               | [Edit] Perhaps the peel is bitter; the white pulp is
               | certainly bitter.
        
               | klyrs wrote:
               | If you like coffee, dark chocolate, grapefruit, kale,
               | arugula, etc., you might just love bitter flavors.
               | 
               | Many people cut their coffee with milk and sugar to
               | complement the bitterness. But then they typically enjoy
               | the resulting flavor, too.
               | 
               | I've known plenty of people who loved caffeine but not
               | coffee. They drink soft drinks or take caffeine pills.
               | 
               | Believe people when they say they like the flavor of
               | coffee.
        
               | mirsadm wrote:
               | I drink decaf in the afternoon. Otherwise I'll have an
               | Americano with a little bit of milk at least twice a day.
               | I'll happily drink espresso and filter coffee though.
               | 
               | Personally I don't find well made coffee bitter at all.
        
               | BirdieNZ wrote:
               | Coffee isn't inherently bitter, but overextracted coffee
               | is bitter. If you ever have the chance to try a well-
               | extracted specialty drip coffee I encourage you to try
               | it, it's quite an eye-opening experience as to what black
               | coffee can taste like!
        
               | themadturk wrote:
               | Twenty or thirty years ago (the time flies!) the
               | Starbucks closest to me in downtown Seattle sold a very
               | limited amount of Jamaican Blue Mountain coffee. They
               | sold beans and brewed it for day or before running out.
               | It was the smoothest, most flavorful coffee I've ever
               | had.
        
               | pipe2devnull wrote:
               | Coffee isn't all that bitter if it's a decent cup of
               | coffee. I love coffee but mostly drink decaf and also
               | like 90+% dark chocolate. What makes you think people
               | don't like bitter things?
        
         | nradov wrote:
         | A lot of people such as Mormons manage to bear capitalism just
         | fine without caffeine. I like to have a little coffee most days
         | but let's not exaggerate it's necessity.
        
           | haltingproblem wrote:
           | Underrated comment.
           | 
           | Perhaps Mormons have in their belief system a strong
           | motivating stimulant? I am trying to avoid use of the word
           | drug here as it is pejorative. Perhaps, Coffee is just what
           | we need to overcome the ennui and pointless of modern
           | existence and a set of religious (or cultural) beliefs helps
           | us do the same.
           | 
           | This would also imply that Caffeine consumption is lower in
           | societies that are religious and have strong belief systems -
           | religious or cultural, which can be tested!
        
             | rayiner wrote:
             | I agree with Razib Khan, who calls organized religion a
             | form of "social technology."
        
             | Arn_Thor wrote:
             | I'd venture that Mormons (and SDAs, with which I'm more
             | familiar) have more close knit (Caucasian) communities for
             | generations that support each other and have elevated their
             | collective socioeconomic status. So perhaps they're less
             | likely to be bottom-level corporate drones, code moneys or
             | Amazon warehouse workers.
        
             | nradov wrote:
             | Existence is no more pointless in the modern (or
             | postmodern) era than at any previous time. Some people need
             | to get over themselves with this "ennui" nonsense.
        
           | stevenwoo wrote:
           | Marx wrote this just prior to the Civil War. Religion is the
           | sigh of the oppressed creature, the heart of a heartless
           | world, and the soul of soulless conditions. It is the opium
           | of the people.
        
             | rayiner wrote:
             | Really ironic thing to say about the Civil War, which was
             | to a great degree a holy war:
             | https://www.politico.com/news/magazine/2023/05/21/how-
             | abraha...
             | 
             | The Republican coalition of religious conservatives and
             | business has its origins in the Civil War, where northern
             | industry joined forces with fundamentalist Christians who
             | opposed slavery. A quarter of all union soldiers were
             | immigrants, mostly poor German immigrants. Iowa sent more
             | volunteers (per capita) to fight for the union than any
             | other state. What motivated all those people to fight and
             | die in a war between British people? They had no personal
             | stake in the war--they didn't have industry powered by
             | southern resources like cotton, nor were any battles fought
             | anywhere near their homes. For them, fighting for the union
             | was about vindicating a religious opposition to slavery.
             | 
             | It was the confederates that portrayed themselves as being
             | on the side of "science" against religious "zealots."
             | https://www.battlefields.org/learn/primary-
             | sources/cornersto.... To make sense of that, put yourself
             | in 1861. That was more than a century before we had the
             | technology to determine that humans are genetically all the
             | same. If you were someone who looked at the world--what
             | people had built in Africa and what they had built in
             | Europe--and said "these people are all the same," that was
             | a statement of faith.
        
               | samatman wrote:
               | > _That was more than a century before we had the
               | technology to determine that humans are genetically all
               | the same._
               | 
               | What a comically false thing to say.
        
             | shrimp_emoji wrote:
             | Really ironic thing to say about religion given how deeply
             | Christian Marxism is (or how Marxist Christianity,
             | specifically, is). We're all equal ~~under God~~, sharing
             | is caring, a camel can go through the eye of a needle more
             | easily than a rich man can ~~get into Heaven~~ stay out of
             | a gulag... :D
        
           | systems_glitch wrote:
           | It is a common misconception that Mormons are not allowed to
           | consume caffeine, the limitation is actually on "hot drinks,"
           | which is interpreted as having meant tea and coffee
           | specifically in the time it was written down. They still
           | drink soda and other heated drinks such as wassel, hot
           | chocolate, and postum (a morning coffee substitute most folks
           | find absolutely disgusting).
           | 
           | (we live near a de facto Mormon college and pester our
           | neighbors, who are largely Mormon professors, about such
           | things)
        
             | DontchaKnowit wrote:
             | all the mormons I know are tee-totalers and drink only
             | water or uncaffeinated drinks.
        
               | systems_glitch wrote:
               | Most of them seem to drink soda here; in fact, we have a
               | Mormon-owned soda shop in town that a lot of the school-
               | age Mormon kids seem to hang out at! I've been told it's
               | often a regional thing, that they're less "Mormon-y"
               | (their term, not mine) if there's a community of them in
               | the area. I suppose it's probably like any other group,
               | and they feel less like outsiders.
               | 
               | Kinda interesting being somewhat immersed in what's
               | effectively a conservative subculture that's supposed to
               | not shun folks who aren't part of it. We have some weird
               | conversations.
        
               | vlachen wrote:
               | Swig, right? We had one of those open here and the line
               | was ridiculous for months. Not my jam, but always
               | blocking access to my coffee shop.
        
               | systems_glitch wrote:
               | This one's called Straws.
        
             | nunez wrote:
             | Didn't know wassel was big with the Mormons. Wassel is
             | delicious! Denton, TX has a wassel fest every year; that's
             | how I got introduced to it.
        
               | systems_glitch wrote:
               | Seems to be, at least with some of the families around
               | here! A bunch of them also get together and do caroling
               | around the holidays, so maybe it's related to that?
        
             | CommieBobDole wrote:
             | My understanding is that it changed in 2012 - the church
             | released a statement then saying that the prohibition only
             | applied to coffee and tea. Before that, it was ambiguous
             | but customarily interpreted to apply to all caffeinated
             | drinks.
             | 
             | As a (anec?)data point, I had a Mormon friend growing up
             | and they drank caffeine-free Coke for this reason.
        
               | systems_glitch wrote:
               | It seems many things have officially changed-but-always-
               | been-that-way :P Everyone's got old-timey atlas prints of
               | central America instead of upstate NY now.
        
           | varnaud wrote:
           | My Mormon friend in college was an avid consumer of Monster
           | Zero.
        
         | bdjsiqoocwk wrote:
         | I was 100% caffeine free for a year and a half while keeping a
         | demanding full time job. That eventually ended when COVID
         | lockdowns started (it's unclear even to me what the
         | relationship between the two was; maybe my subconscious used it
         | as an inspector excuse to go back)
         | 
         | Caffeine doesn't seem to affect my sleep until I get to absurd
         | amounts like 10 cups in a day, which some times it does happen.
         | 
         | Currently I love the drug and intend to keep using it.
        
         | systems_glitch wrote:
         | I think this is really understated. After developing a facial
         | twitch and realizing I was consuming more than 1000 mg of
         | caffeine a day, I switched to decaf once the particular project
         | was over. No one told me it's physically addictive and has
         | withdrawal symptoms! It's the only thing that would keep me
         | functional and able to drive on with a project though.
        
           | brightball wrote:
           | My wife and I switched to decaf about 6 months ago and we are
           | pretty happy with it. Generally sleeping better and I can
           | have 2-3 cups throughout my morning without going off the
           | rails.
        
             | systems_glitch wrote:
             | Oh I can drink a quart or two of regular coffee and still
             | sleep like a rock, not get the jitters, etc. Pretty much my
             | mom's entire side of the family is like that. Switching to
             | decaf got rid of the facial twitch, but even after two
             | months (in between projects) I was basically completely
             | ineffective at even personal projects. I told the doctor
             | about it and it's apparently likely I have adult ADHD.
        
           | wombat-man wrote:
           | Yeah I used to just drink coffee or energy drinks all day.
           | Now I'm sticking to one in the morning and a less caffeinated
           | drink in the afternoon and my days are going a lot better.
        
           | chronogram wrote:
           | Why do you go from extremely high intake to decaf, or do you
           | mean to not go back to using caffeine for your next project?
           | For me a 200mg tablet in the morning works well, more doesn't
           | give me more benefits and by bedtime a lot or most has gone.
        
             | systems_glitch wrote:
             | I had no idea there was withdrawal, and I have no
             | psychological addiction to it, so I just switched to decaf
             | not thinking anything of it, other than that I'd probably
             | be more tired for a while.
        
           | swaginator wrote:
           | > It's the only thing that would keep me functional and able
           | to drive on with a project though.
           | 
           | Don't you think that part of this could be stress? Also
           | potentially dehydration. I have had eye twitches a couple
           | times during long road trips where I drank Red Bull or
           | Monster to keep focused, and was not drinking enough water.
           | But I have never had twitching from caffeine under normal
           | circumstances, since I usually drink 2 parts water for every
           | part caffeinated drink (lots of bathroom breaks).
        
             | systems_glitch wrote:
             | Probably not, I drink a lot of water, especially during hot
             | weather -- I walk to work and back twice a day no matter
             | the weather.
        
           | samatman wrote:
           | For what it's worth, I've found that muscular twitches are
           | always a symptom of magnesium deficiency, which caffeine does
           | exacerbate.
           | 
           | Since I adore coffee and don't intend to stop drinking it, I
           | supplement with magnesium drops in the water I drink large
           | amounts of all day. This has completely prevented tics and
           | twitches, and greatly reduces jaw tension as well.
        
         | ProjectArcturis wrote:
         | I did this too. After I got through the withdrawal, I basically
         | found myself sitting at my desk and waiting to die.
        
         | moomoo11 wrote:
         | I stopped caffeine. It sucked for a week, and I'd taken a week
         | off because I knew it would be hell. And it was.
         | 
         | But after a week I felt free.
         | 
         | I barely consume caffeine anymore, like if I'm with friends at
         | a cafe or something. Otherwise I don't make tea or coffee at
         | home unless I have guests who want some.
         | 
         | Some results I've noticed is that I literally don't give a shit
         | anymore about any pressures. I'll just #dealwithit and it's
         | fine.
         | 
         | I also sleep way better and I am able to utilize the full
         | waking day (I wake up at 6am and I sleep at 10pm).
         | 
         | One thing that's strange is that it seems caffeine no longer
         | has much effect like it used to in the rare occasion I'll have
         | a coffee. I'm able to sleep just fine and I feel no burst of
         | energy or anything. Just a warm drink so maybe it warms me up a
         | bit when it's cool.
         | 
         | Idk. 10/10 would recommend quitting caffeine. My mind is way
         | clearer (no brain fog from being groggy) and it runs like a
         | diesel engine just pulls like a mfer all day.
        
           | dieselgate wrote:
           | Great analogy being like a diesel engine, keep it up
        
         | nunez wrote:
         | I did the same back in December...while I was undergoing sleep
         | compression during my CBT for insomnia treatment. Withdrawal on
         | hard mode!
         | 
         | What motivated me to do so was trying a single origin decaf
         | that my local roaster had available and realizing that, yes,
         | decaf coffee can taste like regular coffee! I literally decided
         | to stop drinking caffeinated coffee after that first cup.
         | 
         | Things were rough for about a month but all good after that.
         | 
         | The nice thing about drinking decaf every day is that caffeine
         | _really_ works when I do choose to use it. Super helpful while
         | driving long distances.
        
           | anonymouskimmer wrote:
           | > The nice thing about drinking decaf every day is that
           | caffeine _really_ works when I do choose to use it.
           | 
           | And how.
        
           | jorvi wrote:
           | Decaffeinated coffee's main problem isn't that it tastes bad,
           | it's that it goes stale incredibly quickly.
           | 
           | You'll have to consume a steady amount of coffee each day if
           | you want to finish your supply on time. Or purchase only
           | small amounts.
        
             | _DeadFred_ wrote:
             | I thought the main problem was that it's made with the same
             | chemicals used to do dry cleaning.
        
               | gruez wrote:
               | That's one way of making it, but it's by no means the
               | only way. Also, the reason why it tastes bad isn't
               | because it's "same chemicals used to do dry cleaning",
               | it's that the decaffination process changes the physical
               | structure of the beans, making it easier to stale.
               | 
               | source for both claims:
               | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yYTSdlOdkn0&,
               | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IszQ2JR3Olc
        
         | Arn_Thor wrote:
         | For me it's not that clear cut. Caffeine is a motivating
         | booster each day but if I stick to my rhythm, one in the
         | morning and one at lunch, then it doesn't affect my sleep at
         | all. It's only when I'm pressured to go beyond that I suffer
        
           | srid wrote:
           | > For me it's not that clear cut. Caffeine is a motivating
           | booster each day but if I stick to my rhythm, one in the
           | morning and one at lunch, then it doesn't affect my sleep at
           | all.
           | 
           | Same with me.
           | 
           | > It's only when I'm pressured to go beyond that I suffer
           | 
           | What I discovered was that If I _gradually_ increase my
           | consumption, then it doesn 't cause any issues. There was a
           | point where I'd drink my 4 or 5th cup of coffee very close to
           | bed time and still get a good night of sleep. But the key was
           | to gradually build up to that point.
           | 
           | I drink 2 or 3 cups now (mainly because I can no longer
           | consume coffee after large meals, and OMAD at night is no
           | longer sustainable).
        
           | hesdeadjim wrote:
           | Exactly my experience. I have a big cup of cold brew in the
           | morning and nothing the rest of the day. When my head hits
           | the pillow at night I'm out and sleep without any
           | interruption.
           | 
           | There was a point a long time ago where I wasn't under
           | control, and in an effort to rein it in I quit for two
           | months. It was awful. I struggled to concentrate and felt no
           | real benefit from being "clean".
           | 
           | I decided to set limits and started up again. That blast of
           | caffeine in the morning is all it takes to set my brain on
           | the right path the rest of the day. My theory is that people
           | who end up struggling with caffeine, do so because they
           | equate more caffeine with being even more productive. If you
           | treat it like you would a (enjoyable) medicine, you can have
           | the best of all worlds.
        
             | woleium wrote:
             | I did the same, but then transitioned to 10 mins of
             | vigorous exercise instead in the morning. I found that
             | getting my heart rate up was a better stimulus
        
               | op00to wrote:
               | 10 minutes of rowing is an excellent replacement for
               | coffee for me, having quit coffee due to hypertension.
        
               | FooBarBizBazz wrote:
               | Yeah, I do love me some coffee, but it's amazing what
               | just a couple push-ups will do. All of a sudden you have
               | blood flow in the upper part of your body and you just
               | feel "ready to go".
        
               | bookofjoe wrote:
               | James Bond spent 5 minutes under a needle-sharp cold
               | water shower before breakfast.
        
               | karlzt wrote:
               | Pavel Durov (Telegram's CEO) does something similar but
               | in a bathtub filled with 0 degrees water with ice added
               | in it too.
        
         | srid wrote:
         | Since it has now become fashionable to give up on coffee, it
         | would be refreshing to hear anecdotes from "the other side" as
         | well -- people who drink plenty of coffee, throughout the day,
         | but do not suffer from significant negative side-effects (i.e.,
         | they continue to get good sleep, have low stress, etc.)
        
           | bodhi_mind wrote:
           | People want to find the secret to living with joy in their
           | lives. Someone who "quits caffeine" has enough mindfulness to
           | have noticed something wasn't quite right in their life and
           | they had the courage to try and change it. That mindset right
           | there is the key to reducing stress. It's not caffeine
           | (unless you're consuming a lot), it's a perspective and
           | framing thing. Daily coffee ritual can absolutely be a part
           | of a routine that has been having negative affects on your
           | state of mind, but it's much more complex than "caffeine is a
           | drug and it's bad for you".
        
           | luzojeda wrote:
           | I don't consider I drink _"plenty"_ of coffee throughout the
           | day but I can't remember the last day I went without some
           | form of caffeine. On average I take 1 cup in the morning with
           | some milk and sometimes mate or black tea, both of which have
           | caffeine as well, in the afternoon... plus Coke or other
           | caffeinated drinks as well here and there.
           | 
           | Ok maybe it could be plenty for some people, but for me 4
           | cups a day would be plenty lol.
           | 
           | Maybe caffeine doesn't affect me much to this point and
           | that's why I don't have any problem sleeping. I doze off 10'
           | after putting my head on the pillow.
           | 
           | Now regarding stress... comparing myself to the people around
           | me I'd say I have normal levels of it. But most of those
           | people consume caffeine daily so it's hard to have an
           | objective measure.
           | 
           | I'd like to carry out the experiment of going 15 days without
           | caffeine to see if stress decreases though but it would be
           | very hard considering how ingrained the substance is in our
           | lives, even the social aspect. Mate for example is a drink
           | which we usually share here in Argentina. You could maybe
           | call it a ritual and a way of social bonding. And I like how
           | it tastes too, of course. Add that to all the times you meet
           | with people "for a coffee and chat", for example.
        
           | booleandilemma wrote:
           | I drink around 3 or 4 cups (around 50 oz total) per day 7
           | days a week and I sleep well enough. I try to avoid drinking
           | it after 7pm though. I don't drink alcohol more than a couple
           | times per month, if that much.
           | 
           | If I skip a couple cups I _will_ get a headache, it 's very
           | predictable.
        
           | pirates wrote:
           | this is me, I drink about a pot per day and sometimes drink
           | caffeinated soda with food. only a small amount of half and
           | half in the coffee. my sleep schedule is pretty routine,
           | hardly ever stay up past 11:30 and wake up naturally with no
           | alarm between 6:30 and 8 every morning.
           | 
           | it is noticeable if i don't have a cup at least at some point
           | during the day but there are plenty of days i don't have as
           | much or hardly at all. but i just like the warmth and how it
           | tastes, the caffeine is a non factor if i decide to have a
           | cup or not.
           | 
           | other things that are probably significant factors: low
           | stress job at a small private company where i don't really
           | have hard deadlines or deliverables and WFH as much as i
           | want; wife and pets but no kids; low stress otherwise is
           | areas of my life
        
           | gambiting wrote:
           | I don't know if it's a lot, but I drink 3 cups a day, with
           | the last one usually around 6pm, and I don't have any trouble
           | going to sleep around 10-11pm, usually fall asleep the second
           | I put my head down(but then I never had any issues going to
           | sleep).
        
             | BossingAround wrote:
             | Going to sleep is the easy part. The quality of your sleep
             | is the thing :) The biggest problem is that you don't know
             | how good/bad your sleep is, unless you make some changes to
             | your lifestyle (e.g. starting or stopping with coffee).
        
           | lc9er wrote:
           | I've quit caffeine for 3-4 months. Aside from a rough few
           | days from quitting cold-turkey, there was zero discernible
           | difference in my day to day life. I enjoy black coffee, and
           | the drawbacks, compared to say, soda or alcohol consumption
           | are minimal, so I started drinking it again because I missed
           | it. And most decaf is too gross to drink black so
           | -\\_(tsu)_/-
        
           | denton-scratch wrote:
           | I don't drink a lot of the stuff, but I haven't quit.
           | 
           | I used to drink about a litre of brewed coffee a day,
           | starting at 7AM and going on until 5PM. Eventually that fell
           | away, without any decision on my part, and I now drink one
           | mug a day (1/2 imperial pint), after getting up.
           | 
           | It doesn't seem to power me up or make me more alert; I think
           | it actually makes me dozy, 2-3 hours after my morning joe.
           | That is, I think I only notice the crash.
        
           | swaginator wrote:
           | The parent comment's experience does not reflect my
           | relationship with coffee at all.
           | 
           | I was diagnosed with ADHD as a kid, never medicated for it.
           | Just regulated with diet and exercise, also probably self-
           | medicated with caffeine and nicotine in college. Quit
           | nicotine because of the very obvious health problems that
           | come with it, I found it very easy to quit interestingly
           | enough (thank God I quit before the Zyndemic).
           | 
           | But I have never felt that coffee comes with any negative
           | side effects for me other than anxiety. It doesn't affect my
           | sleep unless I drink it past 5 PM, and I've never felt like
           | it "wakes me up", it just lets me enter a hyperfocus state a
           | lot more easily. Other people describe their relationship
           | with coffee that they wake up and feel groggy, so they take
           | coffee to have a baseline. For me it has never been about
           | waking up, it's just something that helps with focus.
           | 
           | I do get the jitters when drinking coffee especially since I
           | eat my first meal very late in the day (12pm), so I switched
           | to mate cocido, which is just mate in tea bags. The effect of
           | even very strongly-brewed mate is far less pronounced than
           | the effect of coffee, and I would even go so far as to say
           | that whatever benefits I think I am getting from mate is
           | probably just placebo.
           | 
           | For reference during college I probably consumed 3-4 cups of
           | coffee a day, then as I started working I would consume 5-6
           | cups a day, black. Now I stop drinking coffee after I eat at
           | noon, so I am down to 2-3 cups a day.
           | 
           | Also I think that brewing methods matter. Hot-brewed coffee
           | causes less jitters and more focus. Cold-brewed coffee tastes
           | better but it is easy to overshoot what feels like a
           | "therapeutic dose" and actually end up making it harder to
           | focus, as well as more jitters. It might be that I usually
           | have hot coffee black, and I have cold brew with a bit of
           | milk and simple syrup. The sugar or coldness might also make
           | me colder or do something with my blood sugar, not sure.
        
           | deergomoo wrote:
           | I have idly wondered if I just don't absorb caffeine very
           | well. Coffee and energy drinks neither pep me up nor keep me
           | awake; I continue to drink them solely because I enjoy them.
           | 
           | The only consistent effect I've observed is that the first
           | cup of the day jump starts things in the digestive department
           | and brings on a trip to the bathroom with some haste, but
           | I've suffered on and off with IBS-like symptoms over the
           | years anyway--even before I started drinking coffee.
           | 
           | In my early and mid-twenties I'd drink 5-6 cups of black
           | coffee a day at work. I noticed no ill effects or really any
           | effects at all--no crashes, no jitters, but also no increased
           | alertness or focus.
           | 
           | I now usually make myself one latte in the morning then an
           | additional one or two black coffees through the day, but I
           | can still drink a coffee right before bed with no noticeable
           | effect on getting to sleep. I don't usually have any coffee
           | at the weekend, because Saturday I take my machine apart for
           | cleaning, and Sunday I'm typically out of the house at the
           | times I would normally make one. If I go away on holiday
           | somewhere I might go a full week without any coffee at all,
           | again with no noticeable effect.
           | 
           | Unfortunately I can't honestly say I have _good_ sleep,
           | because even now (I 'm 31) my natural sleep schedule still
           | wants to be something like 3am-11am, but society doesn't
           | tolerate that. I really hoped that would be something I'd
           | grow out of, but I haven't. So I'm pretty much tired all the
           | time whether I drink coffee or I don't.
        
           | Arrath wrote:
           | I drink 4-5 cups a day, although I always stop by noon.
           | 
           | No problems sleeping, and stress seems average for the job
           | lol
        
           | dyauspitr wrote:
           | I drink a lot of black tea (about 60mg of caffeine per cup)
           | throughout the day. Between 6-8 bags. My last cup is usually
           | around 8pm. I'm soundly asleep by midnight and get a lot of
           | deep and REM sleep (as validated by my Apple Watch). I do
           | have to mention that I don't get very noticeable effects from
           | caffeine, probably because according to a 23andme test,
           | genetically caffeine doesn't affect me as intensely as most
           | people. I mostly drink the black tea because I love the taste
           | of fruit flavored, unsweetened black tea.
        
           | kjkjadksj wrote:
           | I can drink a cup at 8 and fall asleep at 10. Sleep a full 8
           | hours with dreams and wake up refreshed. I can binge it for
           | weeks and stop and not feel anything. The coffee eschewers on
           | the internet seem to posit that people like me can't exist
           | but here I am, chiming in.
        
         | crazygringo wrote:
         | > _Coffee fixes all of those._
         | 
         | The thing is, it only does for a few days. At least for me.
         | Then the coffee isn't helping at all -- it's just keeping you
         | at the same baseline you previously were at with coffee.
         | 
         | I used to drink coffee all the time at just a constant level.
         | Then I just got tired of feeling "dependent" on something and
         | weaned off over a couple of weeks. Which was fine when you
         | don't do it cold turkey -- just a little less energy each day
         | but easily manageable.
         | 
         | Now I still drink coffee sometimes but I use it _as a temporary
         | performance tool_. I 'll "start up again" on any particular day
         | where I have a ton of meetings, where I didn't get enough
         | sleep, where I have to do a lot of physical stuff, etc. Often
         | this might be several days in a row, where I increase my coffee
         | each day a little more relative to the previous day for the
         | same effect.
         | 
         | But then as soon as the demands stop, _I immediately taper off
         | to zero again_ , usually taking 2-5 days to do so. Not really
         | because I "don't want to be dependent", but because I want to
         | _make sure I can get the full effect of coffee again the next
         | time I need it_ , whether that's in a week or a month or three
         | months.
         | 
         | It's kind of weird that I'm always fully aware of _exactly_ how
         | much I 'm "dosing" myself with coffee. I'm almost always either
         | "tapering up", "tapering down", or just off of it completely.
         | 
         | But it's very effective as a tool that way. Way more effective
         | than when I just drank the same amount every day, which I
         | discovered was no different from not drinking any at all (after
         | tapering off).
        
           | fhub wrote:
           | I stop consuming caffeine 2 days before a holiday and
           | preemptively take acetaminophen for a day to prevent any
           | headaches. Then no caffeine on the holiday. I sleep more,
           | relax more and just generally more chilled. I sometimes try
           | to stay off it a bit after the holiday but that rarely lasts
           | long.
        
             | crazygringo wrote:
             | Just a question -- are you entirely sure your acetaminophen
             | pill doesn't also contain caffeine?
             | 
             | Just since that's an extremely common combination, and I
             | wasn't aware of acetaminophen on its own being able to
             | counter the effects of a caffeine-withdrawal headache.
             | 
             | I'm fascinated if this actually works.
        
               | gruez wrote:
               | From wikipedia:
               | 
               | >Paracetamol relieves pain in both acute mild migraine
               | and episodic tension headache.[21][22]
               | 
               | Is there a reason to believe that it doesn't work for
               | caffeine withdraw induced headaches?
        
               | crazygringo wrote:
               | Because a caffeine headache is neither a migraine nor a
               | tension headache.
               | 
               | And according to Wikipedia, paracetamol is mainly only
               | useful for migraines. For tension headaches, you need the
               | combination with caffeine and aspirin as well.
               | 
               | Caffeine constricts blood vessels, which is why it's
               | useful against headaches. And why withdrawal _causes_
               | headaches, because now you have more blood flowing than
               | you 've been used to.
        
           | Log_out_ wrote:
           | like running a ship aground on the rocks of a riff,coffein
           | provides a few waves that get you further inland before the
           | wreck comes to an halt
        
         | arbuge wrote:
         | > Maybe you just slept badly. Coffee fixes all of those.
         | 
         | It doesn't fix sleeping badly for me anymore, at all. Perhaps
         | it used to when I was younger _, but after turning around 45, I
         | increasingly found that the only fix for a poor night 's sleep
         | is a good night's sleep.
         | 
         | _ or perhaps poor nights of sleep just didn't affect me much
         | back then.
        
         | slibhb wrote:
         | > Caffeine is a very interesting drug that makes capitalism and
         | just daily work bearable. It's interesting that this went all
         | the way to 1800s for the US.
         | 
         | Michael Pollan's thesis is absurdly exaggerated. I've been on
         | and off coffee for the past few years and it's not necessary to
         | "make daily work bearable". His link between caffeine and
         | capitalism is just silly.
        
         | WalterBright wrote:
         | > Caffeine is a very interesting drug that makes capitalism and
         | just daily work bearable.
         | 
         | What is it about socialist work that makes it bearable?
        
           | cryptonector wrote:
           | Not OP but I think it must be the fear of the gulag.
        
         | taeric wrote:
         | The more I read anecdotes like this, the more im convinced
         | there is not a homogenous response.
         | 
         | For me, too much caffeine can be a thing. But I can stop coffee
         | fairly consequence free. I stick with it as I do like the
         | taste, but the world moving heavily to arabica coffee may get
         | me to stop. Not at all a fan of it.
         | 
         | To my point, I'm growing convinced we will someday find
         | something like blood types for how it impacts you. Probably
         | closer to the cilantro effect. But, same general ideas. Maybe
         | even closer to catnip for cats?
        
       | softwaredoug wrote:
       | Conversely wouldn't the south have a near monopoly on nicotine
       | (also a stimulant). I wonder what impact nicotine consumption -
       | if any - had on the war.
        
         | crawfishphase wrote:
         | the outcome was that tobacco kills, and the surgeon general lee
         | agrees
        
           | TimTheTinker wrote:
           | That was only a national conclusion after the advent of
           | modern cigarettes.
           | 
           | Cigars and pipes are more nuanced and far less harmful
           | (especially because of the chemicals that aren't added, and
           | the fact that you don't inhale)
        
             | TeaBrain wrote:
             | Both Ulysses S Grant and Grover Cleveland were heavy
             | consumers of cigars. Both ended up with oral cancer.
        
               | TimTheTinker wrote:
               | Hot smoke in general causes cancer. Wood smoke (from
               | fireplace, bonfire, etc.) is more carcinogenic per unit
               | than pure (non-cigarette) tobacco smoke. There's a
               | stronger link between regular wood fireplace use and
               | cancer than there is between moderate pipe/cigar use and
               | cancer.
               | 
               | So _moderate_ (not heavy like Grant) cigar and pipe
               | smoking ought to be regarded as within the realm of
               | acceptable risk, especially given the enjoyment and
               | mental benefits that result.
               | 
               | But if we're going to discuss carcinogens, a lot of other
               | things ought to be considered too. For example, why isn't
               | alcohol, a known carcinogen, considered socially taboo
               | compared to pipe smoking? Why are burning wood fireplaces
               | considered "a nice touch" when the second-hand smoke from
               | them is far more dangerous than that from an outdoor
               | cigar user nearby?
        
               | lukan wrote:
               | "So moderate cigar and pipe smoking ought to be regarded
               | as within the realm of acceptable risk"
               | 
               | I believe that you have the right to come to this
               | personal conclusion, but I do not think it is true, as a
               | general statement.
               | 
               | (also please be consciousness about where you smoke,
               | other people might not share your enjoyment)
        
               | TimTheTinker wrote:
               | I'm curious - you believe wood fireplace use is an
               | acceptable risk?
               | 
               | > (also please be consciousness about where you smoke,
               | other people might not share your enjoyment)
               | 
               | Totally understood. I don't smoke much (less than once a
               | week)... but when I do, it's almost always at home.
        
               | lukan wrote:
               | "I'm curious - you believe wood fireplace use is an
               | acceptable risk?"
               | 
               | Personally I believe that the benefits of a wood
               | fireplace and the benefits of moderately smoking tobacco
               | mixed with cannabis outweigh the downsides - for me. But
               | I do not believe my personal choices are the right ones
               | in general.
               | 
               | (also woodfire .. there are quite different types)
        
               | TeaBrain wrote:
               | I agree with your line on personal conclusions. I think
               | it is fair to come to a personal conclusion on acceptable
               | risk, given the balance between risk and personal
               | enjoyment, but I do not necessarily think that it is
               | equally fair to come to this same conclusion for others.
        
               | op00to wrote:
               | No, there is no safe amount of cigar consumption.
               | 
               | "Consistent data from all identified cohort and case-
               | control studies indicate a significantly elevated risk
               | for oral and pharyngeal cancer associated with cigar use,
               | with evidence of a dose-dependent relation. Coupled with
               | biologic mechanisms that likely are very similar to those
               | involved in cigarette-related carcinogenesis, the
               | available evidence strongly supports the conclusion that
               | cigar use is a cause of cancer of the oral cavity and
               | pharynx."
               | 
               | This is one of many negative health effects from cigar
               | consumption, including overall mortality, cardiovascular
               | disease, lung, bladder, and head/neck cancer, chronic
               | obstructive pulmonary disease, and periodontal disease
               | risk. You can evaluate your own risk, but tobacco
               | consumption seems like there is no "safe" amount of
               | consumption according to broad literature reviews.
               | 
               | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK586217/
        
               | TimTheTinker wrote:
               | "Medically safe" and "acceptable risk" are very different
               | terms with different meanings.
               | 
               | The medical establishment also says there's no safe
               | amount of alcohol use, but that doesn't stop people from
               | (rightly, I believe) enjoying a beer or glass of wine
               | every now and then.
               | 
               | The medical establishment's obsession with harm/risk
               | reduction to the extreme is hazardous to human
               | flourishing, in my opinion. We all have to come to terms
               | with our eventual death to make the most of the life we
               | have. I think the medical establishment is more motivated
               | by insurance policy profits than by a desire to promote
               | human flourishing.
               | 
               | Joy and friendship and enjoyment and gratitude (etc.) are
               | far better for our well-being than minimization of harm.
        
               | TeaBrain wrote:
               | I'm not trying to convince you or anyone else to never
               | smoke cigars. I just think that it is fair to make the
               | point that cigars are not necessarily entirely safe, even
               | if the relative risk for lung cancer is less than for
               | cigarettes. I didn't even necessarily even make this
               | point, as with my previous comment, I simply made two
               | separate statements, and you came to a possibly implied
               | conclusion yourself.
               | 
               | Regardless of the safety of cigars, I fail to see the
               | logic behind how the idea that the relative risk of wood
               | smoke compared to cigar smoke is supposed to convince
               | anyone that cigar smoke should seem safe, considering
               | that wood fires are no longer commonly used to heat homes
               | in the developed world. Indoor smoke from heating and
               | cooking has been well-established as a carcinogenic risk,
               | but people not using wood to heat nor using smoke-point
               | inducing temperatures when cooking, do not regularly
               | expose themselves to these risks.
               | 
               | Also, I never claimed that alcohol did not increase
               | carcinogenic risk. I make no position on that. However,
               | given the proposition that alcohol is a carcinogen, then
               | as cigars use is not mutually exclusive to alcohol use,
               | and as smoking cigars incurs some carcinogenic risk, then
               | for users of cigars and alcohol, cigar use would be an
               | additive risk along with the risk incurred by alcohol
               | use.
        
               | TimTheTinker wrote:
               | > I fail to see the logic behind how the idea that the
               | relative risk of wood smoke compared to cigar smoke is
               | supposed to convince anyone that cigar smoke should seem
               | safe
               | 
               | It's not so much a logical argument as an emotional one
               | (though it is a true statement). So much of the public
               | opposition to tobacco is emotional, not logical. So
               | that's where at least some of the discussion needs to
               | happen. Sometimes the best way to put something in the
               | proper perspective is to make a comparison to a more
               | familiar thing.
               | 
               | I grew up believing tobacco use was one of the worst
               | possible sins against God, and that lighting wood in the
               | fireplace was a relaxing, enjoyable thing to do. So at
               | least for me, the argument was helpful to put things into
               | perspective.
        
         | eggoa wrote:
         | Ulysses Grant was pretty much a machine that consumed cigars
         | and emitted union victories.
        
           | ProjectArcturis wrote:
           | Whiskey was also one of the inputs.
        
             | seizethecheese wrote:
             | He didn't drink much while in charge of troops engaged in
             | battle, then he'd go on massive binges where he got silly
             | drunk. So, sort of?
        
       | kaycebasques wrote:
       | They touch on the political affinities between the Union and
       | Liberia but no so much the Confederacy and Brazil. I wonder if
       | something similar was going on? Brazil still had slavery at that
       | time. After the Confederates lost I recall learning that some
       | slave-owning farmers moved down to Brazil to continue their
       | slavery-driven farming practices. They only had 20 years though
       | because slavery was banned in Brazil in the 1880s.
        
         | jhbadger wrote:
         | No doubt Brazil and the Confederacy would have liked to trade,
         | as there was a strong tie between them as you guessed from the
         | slavery issue. After the war, a number of Confederates (some
         | illegally with their enslaved people) moved to Brazil, where
         | their descendants are known as "Confederados" [1]. However,
         | during the war the Union blockaded Southern ports and few trade
         | items (including coffee) got through.
         | 
         | [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Confederados
        
       | nunez wrote:
       | Well, yeah, when you're hella sleep deprived, of course not
       | having a stimulant readily available is a problem.
        
       | vonnik wrote:
       | I never thought of Caffeine as the Pervitin of the civil war...
       | or pervitin as the caffeine of WWII
        
       | agtech_andy wrote:
       | It is a very compelling article and nice to read about the
       | Liberian farmer entreprenuer, but the South also had tea,
       | tobacco, and yaupon (black drink) which are all stimulants.
        
         | jb1991 wrote:
         | As the article states, it wasn't just stimulant qualities, it
         | was also for morale. Imagine having no choice but to drink tea
         | after decades of very rapid cultural absorption of coffee by
         | every person.
        
           | leereeves wrote:
           | Wouldn't the lack of tobacco have similar effects on Union
           | soldiers' morale?
        
             | saalweachter wrote:
             | I'm curious now.
             | 
             | The Union had _some_ tobacco production -- 50 million
             | pounds compared to 225 for the Confederacy. Was that enough
             | for morale?
             | 
             | Also, it looks like _cigarettes_ weren 't popular until
             | after the Civil War. What would the morale hit be like for
             | Civil War era pipe/cigar smokers running short, versus the
             | meltdowns experienced by cigarette smokers?
        
             | richardw wrote:
             | For a short while but surely reduced access to smoking
             | would improve performance in the medium term? Both are
             | obviously possibilities and it would be good to know if
             | anyone had an answer.
        
               | kjkjadksj wrote:
               | You can smoke all day and be stimulated around the clock.
               | Try drinking coffee all day every 30 minutes and you'd be
               | bent over on the latreen after your tenth cup by noon.
        
       | gullywhumper wrote:
       | John Billings Hardtack and Coffee is a detailed account of camp
       | life during the war. Here's the section discussing rations and
       | (obviously) coffee:
       | 
       | https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/72532/pg72532-images.ht...
        
       | programmer3050 wrote:
       | I love coffee myself
        
       ___________________________________________________________________
       (page generated 2024-06-30 23:02 UTC)