[HN Gopher] Western Pennsylvania dirt is used in the infields of...
       ___________________________________________________________________
        
       Western Pennsylvania dirt is used in the infields of most MLB
       stadiums (2017)
        
       Author : goles
       Score  : 79 points
       Date   : 2024-06-08 18:12 UTC (2 days ago)
        
 (HTM) web link (www.post-gazette.com)
 (TXT) w3m dump (www.post-gazette.com)
        
       | neonate wrote:
       | https://archive.ph/vUQm4
       | 
       | https://web.archive.org/web/20180730152634/https://www.post-...
        
       | CSMastermind wrote:
       | It's weird that they don't talk about what they're doing that
       | supposedly makes the soil so special. They mention that once they
       | installed the soil at the Pirates stadium (about 2 hours away
       | from where it's manufactured) the number of rain delays dropped.
       | If it were a property of the local soil you'd assume the existing
       | soil in the pirates stadium would already have it. I can't
       | believe the clay composition differs that much on a two hour
       | drive.
       | 
       | Instead I'm guessing it has something to do with how they process
       | it?
        
         | kevin_thibedeau wrote:
         | Pennsylvania is a geologically diverse state. The soil can
         | definitely vary across short distances.
        
           | tadfisher wrote:
           | Yes, and Western PA has the Poconos mountain chain, so
           | various geologic strata are exposed in close proximity.
        
             | anyonecancode wrote:
             | Poconos are actually eastern PA. There are also mountains
             | in western PA, but I don't know their names without looking
             | it up.
        
               | 5555624 wrote:
               | The Allegheny Mountains are in western Pennsylvania.
        
             | 5555624 wrote:
             | The Poconos are in northeastern Pennsylvania.
        
           | giantg2 wrote:
           | Soil map https://free-printablemap.com/wp-
           | content/uploads/2018/10/gen...
        
         | nubinetwork wrote:
         | > It's weird that they don't talk about what they're doing that
         | supposedly makes the soil so special.
         | 
         | That would be like a bakery asking McDonald's how much sugar
         | they put in their buns. If everyone could do it, they'd be out
         | of business.
        
           | affinepplan wrote:
           | the sugar content of a McDonald's bun is public knowledge
           | 
           | Their competitive advantage has nothing to do (or at least
           | extremely little) with recipe trade secrets. Any professional
           | test kitchen could reproduce any McDonald's item within weeks
        
             | seanw444 wrote:
             | Exactly. McDonald's not-so-secret secret recipe is immense
             | scale.
        
         | SkyPuncher wrote:
         | This video may be of interest to you:
         | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H6AUq3BSoLY
        
         | DiggyJohnson wrote:
         | Soil conditions can definitely vary wildly within 100 miles,
         | and Pennsylvania goes from coast to river valley to mountains
         | in much less distance.
        
         | teruakohatu wrote:
         | New Zealand is a major milk exporter, some countries pay a
         | premium for our milk.
         | 
         | And yet the milk we locals buy in the supermarket (which I am
         | sure is the same as our exports) is milk that has been divided
         | into its core elements (fat sugar protein) and the recombined
         | in a certain ratio.
         | 
         | New Zealand milk does not come from a cow, and I would think PA
         | dirt baseball fields do not come from the ground, but rather PA
         | has the right raw ingredients at hand.
         | 
         | On a side now people here pay a premium for "raw milk"
         | (unpasteurised straight from a cow).
        
       | limitedfrom wrote:
       | Related, all the dirt used to add texture to new MLB baseballs
       | are from a riverbank somewhere in New Jersey, near Palmyra
       | 
       | https://www.nytimes.com/2022/07/26/sports/baseball/baseball-...
       | 
       | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Baseball_Rubbing_Mud
        
         | jihadjihad wrote:
         | That's crazy, I've never heard of that before, and I've watched
         | plenty of baseball. They just straight up rub the balls in mud,
         | before every game? And just rinse them and they're good to go?
        
           | ciabattabread wrote:
           | And that section of the Delaware River is not known for its
           | water quality.
        
             | hanniabu wrote:
             | Well, technically it is, it's just not good water quality!
        
           | limitedfrom wrote:
           | Pretty much! Here's a video of it in action (and the mud
           | collection): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=flrWvnhPmng
           | 
           | Considering over 1,140,000 (2019 figures[0]) balls get used
           | through the season (not even including practice and playoff
           | balls), it's an astounding amount of mud rubbing action.
           | 
           | [0] https://www.nytimes.com/athletic/1171328/2019/08/29/what-
           | you...
        
           | legitster wrote:
           | Breaking in balls for professional sports is a whole thing.
           | 
           | Brand new equipment out of the box sucks, but if you let
           | equipment managers bring out old balls than there is going to
           | be wild variations between every different ball used. So
           | having a consistent break-in process is pretty important.
           | 
           | You should see the kind of shenanigans they do in the
           | football world:
           | https://www.nytimes.com/athletic/4136154/2023/01/31/nfl-
           | kick...
        
         | mmmlinux wrote:
         | Why does he have to make up a story about why hes getting the
         | mud. Is he not allowed to be taking mud from a public place and
         | reselling it, since that's what it sounds like hes doing.
        
           | tyree731 wrote:
           | Since the location of where the mud is gathered is considered
           | a secret, I imagine it's more about giving people a different
           | reason as to why he's there.
        
             | LeifCarrotson wrote:
             | Probably a bit of both.
             | 
             | Assuming the oft-cited Delaware River and Palmyra
             | references are genuine, no, Blackburne Rubbing Mud does not
             | own any public property in Palmyra. Blackburne's registered
             | address is 60 miles away. There's about a mile of
             | riverfront on a public park, an industrial warehouse, and
             | some condos.
             | 
             | He's stealing the mud from public property. I'm sure that
             | he'd be arrested if he showed up with an excavator and
             | tried to start a gravel pit on a nature trail, but, it
             | turns out, you can boast on national media about taking
             | dirt from a public park if you only take a couple hundred
             | pounds of it a year and do it sneakily, two bucketfuls at a
             | time.
        
               | DiggyJohnson wrote:
               | There are so many plausible arrangement for this to be
               | legal without his main company owning the riverfront
               | property that and it's absurd for you to think you've
               | uncovered a scam in plain sight of a beloved and well
               | known process .
        
       | FL410 wrote:
       | This is neat. First I heard of it was this last weekend, when
       | they mentioned during the Phillies/Mets game in London that the
       | dirt had been shipped in from here as well.
        
       | Turing_Machine wrote:
       | TFA is behind a paywall, so I don't know if this was mentioned.
       | 
       | I've read that the Romans used to import arena sand from a
       | certain area in North Africa because it was somehow better than
       | the local sand. I think it was also used in upscale athletic
       | facilities as well.
        
         | tfryman wrote:
         | https://archive.is/20220515135638/https://www.post-gazette.c...
        
       | FredPret wrote:
       | Worth a look at the article just to get an eyeful of the man's
       | "older computer". It's absolutely prehistoric and still in use.
       | 
       | I love that.
        
       ___________________________________________________________________
       (page generated 2024-06-10 23:01 UTC)