[HN Gopher] Learning to Touch Type Again
       ___________________________________________________________________
        
       Learning to Touch Type Again
        
       Author : Decabytes
       Score  : 62 points
       Date   : 2023-07-13 12:15 UTC (10 hours ago)
        
 (HTM) web link (www.deusinmachina.net)
 (TXT) w3m dump (www.deusinmachina.net)
        
       | YellowSuB wrote:
       | I spent a long time trying to learn touch typing on a regular
       | keyboard but I could never get it to stick, it always felt like
       | the keys were off, due to the stagger, and I would frequently hit
       | two keys at the same time. Getting an ortholinear keyboard
       | (planck) really helped me and finally I can touch type at about
       | 70-90wpm without the awkwardness of staggered keys. It feels like
       | the keys are exactly where they are supposed to be, instead of
       | always being slightly off angle. I guess my brain is just wired
       | differently or something. I don't think there is any way to go
       | back to a regular keyboard for me, which was a minor issue when I
       | started working, but I started bringing my ortho to work and it
       | has worked nicely for me.
        
         | stronglikedan wrote:
         | > I would frequently hit two keys at the same time
         | 
         | For me, it was as simple as switching out my mechanical
         | keyboard for a mecha-membrane keyboard, thankfully. Although,
         | now I struggle with anything else! :shrug:
        
         | medeshago wrote:
         | I had the same experience, but with a preonic. It's not that
         | hard for me to use a regular keyboard but it definitely feels
         | akward and when I do I type slower and more prone to errors.
        
           | YellowSuB wrote:
           | Yeah I've been thinking about getting a preonic, or at least
           | something slightly larger than the planck, at times I find it
           | a bit too minimal, also I would like to have two orthos so I
           | don't have to lug one to work every day.
        
       | rgoulter wrote:
       | For emacs, I've found that putting the modifier keys on home row
       | works well. i.e. tapping the key works as normal, and holding the
       | key acts as Alt/Win/Ctrl/Shift.
       | 
       | An advantage to doing things this way is reducing hand
       | movement/stretching.
       | 
       | Another advantage to that technique is it'd work with pretty much
       | any keyboard. (Even keyboards which have large spacebars).
        
       | PAPPPmAc wrote:
       | I've been toutchtyping from late elementary school, and do it
       | "too much" especially with a genetic predisposition for fine
       | joint problems, so I'm always trying different input devices.
       | 
       | I do OK on splits, except for tending to reach for "b" with my
       | right hand. I've mostly corrected that as I've used them more.
       | They certainly help with wrists and shoulders, especially being
       | able to tent, and take the least retraining per ergonomic
       | benefit.
       | 
       | I haven't tried an ortholinear/columnar, it's somewhere on the
       | list.
       | 
       | I _can not_ get myself fully acclimated to a non-qwerty layout,
       | whether mechanically conventional or not, its just too deep in my
       | hands. I 've been making an occasional pass at dvorak since the
       | mid 2000s, and somewhat more frequent and dedicated attempts to
       | get a BAT/Spiffchorder style chorder (specifically a left handed
       | one) into my fingers for the last decade or so, and I always end
       | up sore and slow because I start to twitch toward the qwerty
       | motion before making the right one for the other design. It
       | doesn't help that they're unusual enough that there aren't (AFIK)
       | any good tutor programs suited to the progression on that style
       | of chorder. Better every time I try, but never quite good enough
       | for real work.
       | 
       | I suspect a certain degree of limited benefit using something
       | unusual, in the same way using a non-bash shell increases
       | friction with the rest of the universe.
        
       | PopAlongKid wrote:
       | I wonder how words per minute (WPM) is actually measured. For
       | example, an illustration in the article seems to indicate that
       | the speed of 1 minute of typing with 12 errors is a valid data
       | point.
       | 
       | I learned touch typing on a manual typewriter using Gregg book[0]
       | (summer school prior to freshman year of high school), and seem
       | to recall that the official WPM test involved something like 5
       | minutes of transcribing a provided text, and nothing you typed
       | after the fifth error counted at all. So obviously a much
       | stricter standard. My best at the end of the class was something
       | like 42 WPM, and I haven't tested it since then, but I do think
       | I'm pretty fast and with good accuracy.
       | 
       | The errors mattered a lot more on a manual typewriter due to time
       | needed to correct (or start over). And of course most typing
       | nowadays is probably to generate original content rather than to
       | transcribe an existing text.
       | 
       | [0]https://archive.org/details/greggtyping191se00rowe/page/n9/m..
       | .
        
         | PopAlongKid wrote:
         | I found this at archive.org from a Gregg book circa 1960s.
         | Items 1-16 not shown are about mistakes relating to pagination,
         | margins, characters too light to be easily read, etc.
         | 
         | There was a time when this test was a primary factor in certain
         | job interviews.
         | 
         | ------------------
         | 
         | Calculation of test results
         | 
         | 17. Gross Strokes. Strokes are counted correctly by considering
         | the entire copy as having been typed in one continuous line.
         | Each character or space in such a line counts as one stroke.
         | 
         | 18. Gross Words. The total gross words are the total gross
         | strokes typed, divided by 5. Do not add strokes in repeated
         | matter or subtract strokes in omitted matter. NOTE: The count
         | given with most test copy is the cumulative gross word count
         | (strokes/5).
         | 
         | 19. Penalty. For each error charged under these rules, 10 words
         | must be deducted from the gross words.
         | 
         | 20. Net Words. After deducting the penalty from the gross
         | words, the remainder represents the total net words. The
         | typist's net rate (words a minute-- wam ) is computed by
         | dividing his total net words by the number of minutes he typed.
         | Fractions of .500 or less are discarded; fractions over .500
         | are credited to the next whole number.                 EXAMPLE:
         | A typist writes 5,808 gross strokes with 8 errors in 15 minutes
         | --       5,808/5=1,161.6 or 1,162 gross words
         | 8(errors)X10=80 (penalty)       1,162 - 80=1,082 net words
         | 1,082/15 (minutes) =72.1 net words a minute
        
       | trane_project wrote:
       | GNU Typist was good enough when I had to learn to type on a
       | similar keyboard.
       | 
       | Ironically, I am now very slow to work with normal keyboards.
        
       | melling wrote:
       | "As someone who easily spends more than 60 hours a week at the
       | keyboard gaming, coding, working, and writing, I am no stranger
       | to wrist pain. Particularly the part where my thumb and wrist
       | meet on my right hand."
       | 
       | Patient: "Doctor, doctor, it hurts when I do this."
       | 
       | Doctor: "Then don't do that!"
       | 
       | Perhaps it would be a good idea to reduce typing in general?
       | 
       | We've got voice input that's getting much better.
       | 
       | We had this a decade ago:
       | 
       | https://youtu.be/8SkdfdXWYaI
       | 
       | Some sort of gesture based input? AR/VR has helped improve this?
       | 
       | Hopefully a combination of keyboard, voice, and gestures could
       | reduce RSI issues.
        
         | iib wrote:
         | I've been trying to find the modern equivalent of that video,
         | and nothing seemed to be good enough. Do you know of a good
         | setup, preferably local and emacs-based?
        
           | aliceryhl wrote:
           | The best tool for voice-to-text for programmers is Talon.
           | 
           | https://talonvoice.com/
        
         | dietrichepp wrote:
         | > We've got voice input that's getting much better.
         | 
         | Voice input for tasks like writing has been "solved" for at
         | least twenty years now, you just need to get your software set
         | up to use it. As I understand it, the improvements to speech
         | recognition these days are making it easier to handle noisy
         | environments, different accents, more languages, that sort of
         | thing, but if you just care about accuracy and productivity in
         | a controlled environment, then we've had good solutions
         | available for a long time now. If you travel back in time to
         | 2003 and decide to write a novel using speech recognition, it
         | will still be a pleasant experience--you shell out some cash
         | for a system like Dragon NaturallySpeaking, train it to
         | recognize your voice, and get working. Your accuracy and
         | productivity will improve over time as you get in the habit,
         | and as the system adapts to your voice.
         | 
         | If you can do a portion of your 60 hours using voice, I
         | recommend it. Take some load off your hands.
        
           | bsder wrote:
           | > Voice input for tasks like writing has been "solved" for at
           | least twenty years now, you just need to get your software
           | set up to use it.
           | 
           | So, where is the Linux writeup on how to do this?
           | 
           | The last time I tried to put my control keys on a footpad, it
           | was a pain in the ass. The issue was you couldn't send a
           | modifier from one HID device and a key event from a different
           | one and have the OS pick them up and combine them. So, you
           | had to get a special keyboard with a special footpad that you
           | plugged into the special input on the keyboard.
           | 
           | I'd love to do a hybrid of voice/keyboard but I haven't seen
           | any good writeups. I don't need everything on voice, but it
           | would be nice to get some of the things that cause me to move
           | my hands in the most contorted ways to be better. Hell, just
           | putting _scrolling_ on voice would be a big win given all the
           | web  "progressive scrolling" shittiness seems to require you
           | to scrub the hell out of the scroll wheel nowadays.
        
             | [deleted]
        
           | kortex wrote:
           | >> keyboard gaming
           | 
           | > We've got voice input that's getting much better
           | 
           | I have this hilarious mental image of someone playing Diablo
           | by yelling "Double-you Double-you Double-you aye aye dee dee
           | dee dee"
           | 
           | Jokes aside,
           | 
           | > If you can do a portion of your 60 hours using voice, I
           | recommend it. Take some load off your hands.
           | 
           | is great advice. Much of preventing repetitive stress
           | injuries is reducing repetitive motion. I definitely ought to
           | use more voice input, but there's an inertia aspect to it I
           | need to overcome.
        
       | hospitalJail wrote:
       | The keyboard injury makes me wonder why this is a problem for
       | some people but not for others.
       | 
       | Like shouldn't this be an epidemic?
        
         | jstanley wrote:
         | I think it comes down to how you're sitting, and whether you do
         | something about it when you get the first hint of pain.
         | 
         | I don't get any wrist pain at all when sitting at my desk and
         | typing on my keyboard, but if I try to type on a laptop while
         | lying down for more than about half an hour, my wrists start
         | hurting. Part of me wants to carry on, but I know it's just
         | going to make the wrists hurt more, so I just stop if they
         | start hurting, and the problem doesn't seem to be getting any
         | worse.
        
         | ff_within wrote:
         | bad wrist genetics/poor posture/weak wrists/grip
         | strength/uneven floor/uneven desk. i have noticed many of my
         | ergo issues are reduced/eliminated if i have been exercising
         | regularly, particularly using my forearms.
        
       | ff_within wrote:
       | I really like full maks minimo. Once I got over moving the
       | modifiers the increase in comfort over qwerty or even colemak is
       | really good. Its basically a different typing experience
       | entirely. Just rolling your fingers over the home row randomly
       | will shit out half the words or more in most sentences. people
       | who have not tried a better layout don't realize how much more
       | work qwerty is to type for no reason. Thats most of the reason
       | for all of these split keyboards and other ergo shit. Qwerty is
       | just that bad to type on.
        
       | junwen wrote:
       | [dead]
        
       | mattrighetti wrote:
       | I started touch typing with keybr too, took almost two months to
       | get to my usual 90 wpm.
       | 
       | I remember practicing for an hour a day, it is fun after you nail
       | the first 4 letters so don't give up too early.
       | 
       | Now I am using a Corne v3 which I built myself and I am
       | considering investing more time switching to another keyboard
       | layout like dvorak or colemark, can anyone recommend it? Was it
       | worth it?
        
         | JTyQZSnP3cQGa8B wrote:
         | Both Dvorak and Colemak seem better than QWERTY but it's
         | difficult to choose between those alternatives. I started using
         | Colemak a few days ago because it's more modern than Dvorak
         | (whatever that means) but I'm still not sure if it's the best
         | choice.
         | 
         | One bonus of Colemak is that it has the same location for the
         | keys XCV used for cut, copy, and paste.
        
           | TheRoque wrote:
           | To be fair, I think that DVORAK is overkill. If you want a
           | good compromise between ergonomics and ease of use,
           | definitely go for Colemak. Also a way better choice if you
           | are European, and occasionally need some accents or
           | characters that are not on the Dvorak keyboard. If you are
           | crazy about min-maxing every aspect of your typing, IMO it
           | becomes a rabbit hole: programmer's dvorak, colemak DH and
           | other mods etc. etc. Don't forget that the more your setup is
           | away from the standards, the more it can be a pain to go back
           | to the standard, or have other people use your setup
        
             | IndrekR wrote:
             | Used Dvorak (with some modifications for Estonian language)
             | for few years around 2005. Then switched back to QWERTY as
             | this is available on almost every computer. Was hard to
             | switch back, but got used to it again in a week. Based on
             | this experience I think alternative layouts are a bit
             | overrated.
        
           | masters3d wrote:
           | I am learning a new layout that does not have xcv in the same
           | place but I fix this by using a layer that keeps the same
           | positions for xcv when holding down cmd/ctrl
        
         | rgoulter wrote:
         | Dvorak is much more comfortable to use than qwerty.
         | 
         | The main cost is the fingers needing to re-learn motor memory.
         | Likely with QWERTY your fingers 'knew' where the letters where.
         | When I learned to touch-type Dvorak, my fingers took some time
         | to adjust, and I had a hard time typing on QWERTY.
         | 
         | With a separate column-staggered keyboard like the Corne, I
         | imagine it's easier to retain the row-staggered QWERTY on
         | standard keyboards, & touch-typing whatever on the Corne.
        
         | nico_h wrote:
         | There are other layouts, like BEAKL, MTGAP, Hands Down (Neu,
         | Gold,Vibranium...). The current recommendation for Colemak on
         | split kb is Colemak Mod DH, but i think the optimal layout
         | depends on the ratio of code to prose that you use.
         | 
         | There is a subreddit dedicated to this very discussion, and the
         | more general subbredit ( r/ergoMechanicalKeyboard) migrated to
         | Lemmy https://lemmy.world/c/ergomechkeyboards
         | 
         | https://www.reddit.com/r/KeyboardLayouts/comments/14m5hpy/no...
        
         | bbojan wrote:
         | I've tried many (too many) layouts and my recommendation would
         | be Colemak-DH.
         | 
         | If you have a programmable keyboard, feel free to experiment
         | with symbols, letters, etc. Home-row mods are also something
         | that I warmly recommend.
        
         | dannyz wrote:
         | I was starting to get wrist pain in my right hand at the end of
         | the day. I believed it was from never learning to type
         | properly, I only used two fingers on my right hand even though
         | I could type relatively fast.
         | 
         | I tried many times to re-train myself to type properly, but
         | with proper technique I was only typing at half of my normal
         | speed and would give up quickly.
         | 
         | In the end I switched to colemak to force myself to re-learn
         | how to type with proper hand technique. It took a year but now
         | I can type faster than I used to be able to with QWERTY and
         | without any pain. It was definitely worth it for me, but there
         | are enough annoyances with everything being QWERTY by default
         | that I wouldn't recommend anyone make the switch without a
         | reason to do so.
        
           | dietrichepp wrote:
           | I had the same experience switching to Dvorak. It forced me
           | to relearn how to type, and when I was relearning, I made
           | sure to learn properly. The switch, and relearning to type,
           | 95% solved my RSI problems.
        
       | catboybotnet wrote:
       | keybr.com is a neat site. Used it a lot when I was working hard
       | on fixing my typing posture (don't knock it, it'll save you from
       | a lifetime of RSI ;v;).
        
       | Decabytes wrote:
       | Lots of Dvorak users in the comments, but does anyone use colemak
       | or workman? How does it feel? Is it awkward from programming?
       | Also for those using Dvorak, How is programming and gaming?
        
         | rgoulter wrote:
         | For gaming, I use the same solution as the OP: have a 'profile'
         | where I switch to QWERTY for gaming.
         | 
         | For programming.. for vim and emacs (or helix, whatever) you
         | end up memorising the mnemonics by the letters rather than by
         | position.
         | 
         | Specifically for vim's hjkl (where the positioning of the
         | letters is significant), Dvorak is not so bad because the jk
         | keys are together. (And h is to the left of l).
        
         | ff_within wrote:
         | colemak is fine for both. the odd game or two may have
         | something hard coded, but its usually zxcv.
        
       | dgrabla wrote:
       | To learn in a non-tedious way I recommend the games "The typing
       | of the dead overkill" (Linux Port) and also the more modern
       | "Epistory"
        
       | rcarmo wrote:
       | I'm doing something a little more extreme: I decided to get
       | myself an https://artsey.io 8-key Bluetooth keyboard, not because
       | I was aiming to type faster (I do just fine with QWERTY, and
       | would find it really odd to depend on a different layout), but
       | because I wanted something I could use for short sentences
       | alongside a mouse.
        
       | bobobob420 wrote:
       | As someone who is teaching themself to type properly (home row
       | keys and multiple fingers) but can touch type somewhat fast (130
       | wpm) this website https://www.keybr.com/ is truly amazing. I
       | struggled teaching myself how to type properly and this website
       | is really good at abosrbing the good patterns. Funny enough
       | practicing correct typing (home rows + all fingers) lets me type
       | faster and more accurately with my own system Ive designed. I
       | practice typing speed tests daily so I can confirm this is true.
        
         | IndrekR wrote:
         | I started practicing with Keybr few years ago, but switched to
         | superb https://monkeytype.com/ at some point when Keybr
         | capabilities started limiting the progress. Usually using
         | English 10k database.
        
           | bobobob420 wrote:
           | I use monkey type for sprints, see the max I can output in
           | 15sec, 30sec, 1 minute. I improved my speed from 105 --> 130
           | primarily using 10fastfingers.com I find typeracer to be the
           | most superb site as it includes punctuation and is actual
           | real life passages. You can also compete with other people
           | which is very useful. I find sites like monkeytype better for
           | benchmarking speed than learning to type.
        
       | Zambyte wrote:
       | A few years ago I also got a split + columnar keyboard (ZSA
       | moonlander). When I made the switch, I also switched to Dvorak
       | from QWERTY. It was a brutal first month grinding typing
       | practice, but I'm really glad I did it. My posture has felt much
       | better with the split keyboard, and my hands have felt much less
       | strained with the columnar + Dvorak.
       | 
       | I don't think I type much faster than I did before switching
       | (maybe from like 80 WPM to 90 WPM), but I feel much more
       | comfortable typing as fast as I can for much longer.
        
         | 1MachineElf wrote:
         | I'm also a happy Dvorak convert. Yes, it's tough at first.
         | Switches back to Qwerty also take some getting used to.*
         | 
         | I believe there is a universal benefit of learning a non-QWERTY
         | layout. Many people learn QWERTY first when they are young, and
         | as a side-effect, they carry with themselves the baggage of bad
         | typing habits. While making an intentional effort to touch type
         | with QWERTY can help significantly, I believe it can't compare
         | to the benefits of starting from fresh with something new.
         | 
         | *I think I was lucky to have a job where I needed to make those
         | switches often, so I gained proficiency quickly.
        
           | Zambyte wrote:
           | > Many people learn QWERTY first when they are young, and as
           | a side-effect, they carry with themselves the baggage of bad
           | typing habits.
           | 
           | Absolutely! This was a huge factor in my decision to switch.
           | I learned to type quickly on QWERTY mostly from FPS shooters
           | - which meant that I would start typing while moving my hand
           | from my mouse to my keyboard, which meant that I would type
           | much more with my left hand than my right. I probably used my
           | left hand for 60 to 70% of the keyboard, rather than 50/50
           | for each hand. I really wanted to learn to type properly, but
           | breaking old habits on such a familiar layout was hard.
        
       | absoluteunit1 wrote:
       | In the last couple years I tried a couple resources to practice
       | touch typing and even decided to build my own, I practiced mostly
       | on it now: typefaster.app
        
       | mellosouls wrote:
       | Another upvote for keybr here, a couple of weeks last year half
       | an hour a day got me touch typing.
       | 
       | Also recommended: typelit.io, where you type books out.
       | 
       | For a small subscription you can upload your own books,
       | convenient for bookclub/typing practice killing-two-birds
       | efforts.
       | 
       | https://www.typelit.io/
        
         | throw1234651234 wrote:
         | Typing books is half the battle for programmers (if you are
         | one). I bet your wpm drops in half once you start needing
         | common-code characters:
         | 
         | http://wpm-test.com/programming-typing-test/
         | 
         | The one thing I struggle with is arrow keys and/or ctrl+arrow
         | to go the end of the word or needing home/end to go to the end
         | of the line. I don't want a non-standard programmed
         | keyboard/layout, but it really slows things down when writing
         | code.
        
           | brenainn wrote:
           | https://typing.io/ is a good one for practice
        
             | throw1234651234 wrote:
             | Definitely, I was even going to pay for it, but I feel like
             | I need to dedicate at least 30m to an hour a day for a
             | month, and I just can't be bothered.
        
       | smokel wrote:
       | Some people are asking for advice on switching to Dvorak. Here is
       | my life story:
       | 
       | I grew up typing Qwerty using only four fingers for typing
       | letters, and my right-hand thumb for pressing the space bar. I
       | could type pretty fast, which was especially useful for having
       | heated discussions on irc. My typing speed also got me a job
       | offer during the first dot com bubble.
       | 
       | At around 20, I switched to Dvorak, because I learned about the
       | silly history of the Qwerty layout, and how Dvorak would result
       | in more typing in less time. Over a period of two weeks, I worked
       | my way up from the Beavis and Butthead lessons (uuuu hhhh ...) up
       | to using all ten fingers (apart from the thumb on my left-hand,
       | which isn't doing much apart from the occasional Alt or Super
       | here and there.)
       | 
       | In this training period I suffered from terrible headaches. In
       | retrospect, I think the main pathways in my brain connected my
       | thoughts directly to the Qwerty layout, and this needed a
       | complete rewiring. Also, during this period I could not respond
       | quickly to people on irc who were obviously wrong about
       | something. The frustration was enormous.
       | 
       | Eventually, my typing speed on TypeRacer plateaued somewhere at
       | around 100 wpm. That's a lot less than Sean Wrona, but still
       | requires you to perform a test to check if you didn't cheat.
       | 
       | Switching from Qwerty to Dvorak was really hard, especially in
       | the beginning. It took about five years before I could work on
       | somebody else's machine. I'm also hardwired to Emacs key
       | bindings, so that's a limiting factor as well. Also, I can't seem
       | to type Dvorak with only one finger, when I'm eating a snack for
       | instance. This is still possible with Qwerty! And I can recite
       | the entire Qwerty layout in a pub at night, but I require a
       | keyboard to say aoeui.
       | 
       | In my early days of Dvorak, I wrote some utilities that
       | calculated the travel distance that my fingers would make if I
       | were to retype the entire bible. Depending on how you looked at
       | it, Dvorak required about 5 to 30% less finger movement.
       | Unfortunately, when you put in the Linux source tree, with
       | numbers, curly braces, and other symbols, the advantage isn't so
       | big.
       | 
       | What I do notice though, after ~20 years of Dvorak, is that it
       | feels much more fluent than what I observe at my Qwerty typing
       | coworkers. I guess what _really_ helped for lowering the risk of
       | wrist problems, though, is to remap Caps Lock to an additional
       | Control, and using C-p, C-n, C-b, C-f for keyboard navigation and
       | C-h for backspace. Switching from keyboard to mouse and back
       | really annoys me.
        
       | Tomte wrote:
       | Tipp10 is great: https://www.tipp10.com/en/index/
        
       | opan wrote:
       | When I last relearned to type with a new layout (Workman), I
       | think I started with keybr until I had all the keys in my
       | head/hands (One night was enough to turn off the visual of a
       | keyboard), then after a bit moved to monkeytype where I turned on
       | all the capitalization and symbols and set it to 60 second tests.
       | I did daily tests, often many, and would note down when I hit a
       | new 5 or 10wpm incremental milestone. I think it was 10wpm jumps
       | until progress slowed down, then I went to 5. Within a month or
       | two I was pretty close to my old speeds. Once I seemed to stop
       | going up significantly in speed anymore, I changed to untimed 50
       | word tests, this way I can let loose and it's done when it's
       | done. I don't have to worry that I'll get discomfort from going
       | all out for too long in a row. I get higher speeds this way, so
       | it's not a 1:1 comparison to the settings I learned on, but
       | perhaps closer to results I got on other sites in the past like
       | 10fastfingers when I used other layouts.
       | 
       | I used to use qwerty, typed over half the letters with my left
       | hand, very non-proper technique, but I was quite fast (160wpm is
       | the best I recall getting). I had occasional left hand pain, so
       | at one point I changed to Dvorak. Fast forward a year or two and
       | I've been getting right hand pain which seemed worse than the old
       | pain. I built a Pinky4 split ergonomic keyboard (columnar
       | stagger). I loved the keyboard, but a month or two in, my pain
       | wasn't really solved. I decided to learn Workman because of that.
       | I'd considered some others like QGMLWB or Halmak, but Workman was
       | pretty unique in that it has 50/50 hand usage, while qwerty is
       | left-biased and dvorak is right-biased (the others have a bias as
       | well). My hand pain is gone now and I'm extremely happy with both
       | Workman and the Pinky4. I configured my layout in the QMK
       | firmware, so I can plug my keyboard into whatever and not have to
       | tweak OS settings (assuming the computer is set to qwerty).
       | 
       | I would recommend both an ergonomic keyboard and the Workman
       | layout, but if you only went with one, changing to Workman may
       | have the bigger impact. I would recommend full immersion and not
       | running away back to your preferred layout. This ensures fast
       | progression and constant progress, though it's frustrating at the
       | start for sure.
       | 
       | I use Workman on my phone as well with AnySoftKeyboard. Many
       | people say this is ridiculous, but I just don't want to look at
       | or use qwerty anywhere if possible. Also, I didn't make the
       | layout available, it was already there or I wouldn't have
       | bothered probably. I did the same with dvorak previously.
        
       | jedberg wrote:
       | It always amuses me when someone sits down at my computer and
       | tries to use it. I use the Microsoft split ergo keyboard. It's
       | not much different than a regular keyboard, other than the big
       | gap down the middle.
       | 
       | But you'd be surprised how many people use the wrong hand for the
       | keys near the middle. You can tell every time someone messes up
       | when they stab the big empty space and it makes a loud "thunk".
       | :)
        
       | thepaulmcbride wrote:
       | I went through a very similar exercise recently and wrote about
       | it (https://paulmcbride.com/posts/i-learned-how-to-type). I've
       | yet to pick up an ergo keyboard, but I can absolutely type faster
       | than I once could.
       | 
       | I found both monkey type and keybr to be super helpful.
        
       | Waterluvian wrote:
       | Tangentially related: I began learning the piano last year at 35
       | and, for obvious reasons I suppose, it feels 100% like I'm
       | learning how to type all over again. But I'm now old enough to
       | really notice and appreciate the progress. Yesterday my left hand
       | was jumping around to different chords without even noticing and
       | I had that moment of, "oh wow it's happening!"
       | 
       | I'm entering this phase of what I'll call "general purpose use"
       | where instead of building the muscle memory for specific "words"
       | and phrases, I'm able to just conjure "words" and phrases in
       | whatever order I want. Reminds me of the jump from Mavis Beacon
       | to actually typing up school reports and whatnot.
        
         | rimunroe wrote:
         | > Yesterday my left hand was jumping around to different chords
         | without even noticing and I had that moment of, "oh wow it's
         | happening!"
         | 
         | I had this experience when picking up the VR rhythm game Beat
         | Saber. It felt a lot like learning an instrument. If you're not
         | familiar, Beat Saber is a game where you hold two lightsaber-
         | type swords and slice blocks in specific directions as they fly
         | toward you to the rhythm of a song.
         | 
         | At some point my hands just started moving into the right
         | positions without me even consciously registering every block
         | coming toward me. I have a distinct memory of seeing a block
         | right as it was about to pass me by and thinking that I
         | wouldn't have time to cut it before I realized that I was
         | already doing so. Nowadays the limiting factor is overcoming
         | the physical inertia of my arms in order to move them quickly
         | enough.
        
       | jasonlotito wrote:
       | The Kinesis Freestyle keyboards are also split, but have a more
       | traditional layout. They come both wired and wireless, with the
       | bluetooth Freestyle 2 version allowing you to connect to multiple
       | devices with the press of a button. It's also much cheaper.
       | 
       | The benefit to these keyboards is they have a more traditional
       | layout. This makes it easier to move to different keyboards.
       | While the 360 is really nice, it also means you have to learn a
       | new way of typing that doesn't map well enough to more
       | traditional keyboards.
       | 
       | My wrists don't hurt since using the split keyboard, and find
       | that using the split during the day is enough where when I do use
       | a non-split keyboard, I'm fine.
        
       | samsquire wrote:
       | I bought a split keyboard but when I realised I had to relearn
       | everything after trying to use it, I abandoned it. I once used
       | DVORAK but I abandoned that too (not overlapping the split key
       | keyboard).
       | 
       | I also really liked vimperator, the firefox plugin that let you
       | manipulate firefox and click links through the keyboard and
       | scroll with vim bindings.
       | 
       | My tastes have completely changed. I no longer want to optimise
       | how I do the work that I do do, but innovate or learn brand new
       | things.
       | 
       | Switching machines is painful and jarring when you swap from a
       | custom configured machine to a default configuration machine. So
       | things like keybindings, tmux bindings, zsh customisations, ssh
       | shortcuts. I just decided to remember how to use -W so I wasn't
       | dependent on ssh shortcuts.
       | 
       | I am just keenly aware that the profit I get from tweaking
       | everything has diminishing returns. I would rather spend that
       | time learning a new algorithm or playing with some code on
       | repl.it.
       | 
       | There is a case for avoiding syntax highlighting too, learn how
       | to setup a codebase from scratch, not use autocomplete so you
       | really learn how to read and write code. Those I agree with.
       | 
       | I use a trackball out of inertia.
       | 
       | Please note this comment is NOT against tweaking or optimising,
       | it's just I think it's fine to not want to do certain things. I
       | don't think it's obviously superior or worse, it's just not for
       | me.
        
         | woleium wrote:
         | Vimperator lives on as pentadactyl and tridactyl
         | 
         | I believe there was also a vim based chromium fork too, but I
         | never tried it
        
         | [deleted]
        
       | TheRoque wrote:
       | I learned Colemak a year ago so I could touch-type properly,
       | because the regular layouts are so sub-optimal that the balance
       | between fingers feel so weird, and being on the home row is
       | actually not optimal. I definitely am happy with the change. I
       | use Colemak mostly for coding, and writing short texts. I would
       | switch to my native layout whenever I need to type fast and long
       | texts (AZERTY, french layout). I definitely think Colemak is the
       | sweet spot for someone wanting to get a better layout, without
       | much hastle: it's already on MacOS and Linux, it keeps a lot of
       | keys the same as QWERTY (for shortcuts), and it has a ton of
       | built-in dead keys for European accents ! I didn't even need to
       | remap the vim bindings using it. I may not actually type faster
       | (actually I max at 80 WPM now, before it was 100 WPM), but the
       | ergonomics just feels so much better.
        
         | nabogh wrote:
         | How does colemak work with the cardinal directions, hjkl?
        
       ___________________________________________________________________
       (page generated 2023-07-13 23:02 UTC)