[HN Gopher] Show HN: PuzzleMoji, a daily emoji pictionary challe...
___________________________________________________________________
Show HN: PuzzleMoji, a daily emoji pictionary challenge against
ChatGPT
Author : sunnyba
Score : 58 points
Date : 2023-05-20 10:49 UTC (1 days ago)
(HTM) web link (puzzlemoji.com)
(TXT) w3m dump (puzzlemoji.com)
| [deleted]
| isawczuk wrote:
| Zzz zzz zzz - perfect hit for inception
| [deleted]
| shlant wrote:
| got an error that Chat GPT was overloaded and now the game is
| totally bricked. Can't make new guess, can't make same guess
| sunnyba wrote:
| Should be back up, sorry about that! For anyone else hitting
| this you may need to refresh and try again in a few minutes --
| the OpenAI API sometimes complains but I don't handle this so
| gracefully yet.
| MrScruff wrote:
| Fun game! I prompted it to guess Inception with a thought cloud,
| an hourglass and a gun.
| jeroenhd wrote:
| Why is this page requesting web canvas access?
|
| Edit: looks like some kind of emoji detection feature? I don't
| understand why when you can just serve an open source emoji font,
| but I suppose at least it's not tracking this time.
| xp84 wrote:
| This is incredibly fun. Very fun and addictive, and brings the
| fun part of a 2-player game to a single-player experience. This
| is a brilliant way to use the LLM.
|
| Wish list: It would be super cool if we could use the emoji skin
| colors.
| sunnyba wrote:
| Thanks a lot!
|
| I disabled skin tones since they're encoded in an odd way, but
| it's on my future feature list to re-add them if people are
| enjoying it enough.
| xp84 wrote:
| I wanted to put this bug report in its own thread so it wouldn't
| distract from my main comment: oddly it told me on my first round
| today that "Black Panther" wasn't the right guess for "Black
| Panther." I had used the prompt and it said: "Black Panther "
|
| I tried a slightly different variation and it guessed BP again
| and was accepted.
| sunnyba wrote:
| That's really strange! I should probably add some logic to
| strip whitespaces for that validation, thank you!
| hailmac wrote:
| Rename it to StretchGPT - below was for Superbad
|
| La La Land: The rainbow emoji and cocktail emoji represent the
| colorful and musical theme of the movie, and the police officer
| emoji represents the main character's job as a jazz pianist who
| falls in love with an aspiring actress in Los Angeles.
| gs17 wrote:
| For my Superbad attempt it (hallucinated?) a movie "ID" where
| adults were partying.
| FranklinMaillot wrote:
| This is genius!
|
| But I couldn't find the thumb up and thumb down emojis. How am i
| supposed to make it guess Gladiator?
| forgotusername6 wrote:
| History, Italy, swords
| sunnyba wrote:
| Thank you! Sadly I removed the thumbs up/down emojis and okay
| hand emoji -- when these were used in clues, GPT 3.5 tended to
| complain that the emojis were too generic and refuse to guess.
| peeja wrote:
| Maybe it would help to show them disabled and give an
| explanation like this when you try to use it?
| the_snooze wrote:
| It guessed properly when I gave it swords-stadium-king.
| bil7 wrote:
| is it just me or are thumbs up/down (:+1: and :-1:) not
| available?
| sunnyba wrote:
| That's right, they're not available.
|
| From testing as I developed this, I noticed that certain emojis
| often lead to complaints from GPT 3.5 about how the
| combinations were too generic. After some really basic testing
| I ended up removing the 3 worst offenders from the emoji
| picker: ['+1','-1','okay_hand'].
| bil7 wrote:
| seems reasonable. Maybe this explanation could be present in
| the game when the user searches one of these blacklisted
| emojis?
| yreg wrote:
| What about country flags? For Gladiator I considered the
| Italian flag (and then also the thumbs up/down).
| wartijn_ wrote:
| It's not just you, I couldn't find them either.
| drones wrote:
| Is chatgpt given a list of films to guess from beforehand, or
| does it just guess the film outright, no extra info? I wouldn't
| have guessed inception for [Puzzle-piece, scientist, city]
| sunnyba wrote:
| I asked ChatGPT for lists of movies and TV shows that it knows
| about and used those, to avoid getting into situations with
| movies published after the training window
| Name_Chawps wrote:
| I think you misunderstood the question. When it is guessing,
| is it guessing "which of these 50 movies is represented by
| these 3 emojis" or something, or is it free to guess any
| movie?
| sunnyba wrote:
| It's free to guess any movie -- the prompt is like "guess
| the movie represented by these 3 emojis", no filtering at
| all.
|
| It'll guess some crazy obscure stuff once in a while!
| Waterluvian wrote:
| This was fun!
|
| I'd like to suggest the name: "Moviemoji"
| sunnyba wrote:
| thanks!
|
| When I soft launched it 3 weeks ago I was doing TV shows, but
| 3x shows per day quickly exhausted my initial list, so I
| switched to movies over the past few days
| ioseph wrote:
| I failed on the dark knight because chatgpt guessed Batman: the
| dark knight. Really cool game though!
| rpastuszak wrote:
| "Pulp Fiction: The gun, the clock, andx the bed are all iconic
| scenes from the movie."
|
| The movie was Inception, but the response is better than the
| original suggestion imho!
| hammock wrote:
| For Inception I got it on the first try with Zzz, Russian
| Nesting Doll and Business Suit
| oli-g wrote:
| Haha that's cool!
|
| For me, it correctly guessed Inception from [hourglass clock],
| [a pair of wide open eyes], [zzzz]
|
| Did anyone manage to make it guess Superbad?
| Name_Chawps wrote:
| I got all three.
|
| Inception was slightly smiling face, the zZZ emoji, and
| upside down face.
|
| Gladiator was Italian flag, classical building, swords
|
| Superbad was clinking beer mugs, no one under 18 symbol, and
| ID button
| grilledchickenw wrote:
| Yeah, nerd face + cop + beer.
| siraben wrote:
| Managed to get it to guess Inception:
|
| 128164 1F4A4 SLEEPING SYMBOL
|
| 129670 1FA86 NESTING DOLLS
|
| 128188 1F4BC BRIEFCASE
| forgotusername6 wrote:
| I got inception with sleep, dream, crazy
| [deleted]
| lelandfe wrote:
| Quite happy with mine:
|
| 1F300 CYCLONE
|
| 1F51D TOP WITH UPWARDS ARROW ABOVE
|
| 2753 BLACK QUESTION MARK ORNAMENT
| k2xl wrote:
| Anyone get superbad? It got Hangover for my suggestions
| wartijn_ wrote:
| beer mug + police officer + "no one under eighteen" sign
| kaoD wrote:
| Yeah I did teen+clinking beers+police officer.
| peeja wrote:
| For Superbad I hit Deadpool, Hangover, and 21 Jump Street. Ah,
| well.
| nom wrote:
| Got superbad with (police officer, clinking beer mugs, girl)
|
| Haven't seen the movie, I skimmed the plot for a second and
| picked what stood out. Didn't expect it to work, i wanted to
| input a lot more.
|
| No idea how there aren't any other movies that match better.
| Feels like the search space doesn't contain all movies.
| sunnyba wrote:
| nice! I don't limit the search space in the system prompt to
| GPT, though each daily puzzle is using popular movies. I
| think for the top ~100 movies it'll probably do a fine job.
|
| If this game goes on for a full year though, I imagine it's
| going to really struggle unless the movie is about something
| really unique.
| Name_Chawps wrote:
| I got it with clinking beer mugs, no one under 18 symbol, and
| ID button
| yreg wrote:
| ID button, beer, eggplant
| Somatochlora wrote:
| Cop car, graduate with cap and gown, beer mugs got it for me
| nathias wrote:
| its weirdly good at this...
| ajnin wrote:
| Pretty entertaining concept, but I guess the site was developed
| with mobile in mind ? It's frustrating to use on a laptop, it
| looks like about 80% of the page is unused black space, with a
| big bar at the bottom, and the actual emoji area is smaller
| still, I can see about 3 rows worth of icons.
| admtal wrote:
| Fun project, looks great, well done!
|
| I had a similar project, but I like yours better - more
| interactive
|
| https://www.emojipuzzlebook.com/
| sunnyba wrote:
| thanks a lot! I came across yours as well, great idea to
| publish.
| tobr wrote:
| Fun that the idea is not to guess the movie, but to get the robot
| to guess it. I wish I could to use the regular emoji keyboard to
| pick the emoji, though.
| sunnyba wrote:
| Thank you!
|
| I ended up trying to funnel people towards the emoji picker so
| that I could: 1) prevent unknown emojis outside the training
| window of GPT 3.5. As an example, ChatGPT said that this one
| was a box of falafel.
|
| 2) exclude certain emojis that had a high likelihood of leading
| to GPT refusing to guess (it would claim were too generic).
| buddhistdude wrote:
| Maybe you got Display an error message upon entering an
| illegal emoji
___________________________________________________________________
(page generated 2023-05-21 23:00 UTC)