[HN Gopher] Human or Not? A Social Turing Game
       ___________________________________________________________________
        
       Human or Not? A Social Turing Game
        
       Author : ftxbro
       Score  : 29 points
       Date   : 2023-04-20 05:45 UTC (2 days ago)
        
 (HTM) web link (www.humanornot.ai)
 (TXT) w3m dump (www.humanornot.ai)
        
       | jhardy54 wrote:
       | Ask how long is left on the timer.
        
       | beardog wrote:
       | Can't get more than 2 messages into a conversation before "oh
       | shoot the other side did not respond in time".
       | 
       | Is it overloaded or is the average attention span less than that
       | of a tik tok now?
       | 
       | Neat game regardless.
        
       | James_K wrote:
       | > lets talk in discord for a fun time ;) wink wink my tag is:
       | Apostrasia#0878
       | 
       | The site has bots. Irony is a fine thing.
        
         | kgeist wrote:
         | Oh, I got this exact line, too. Then the site claimed it's a
         | human.
        
           | James_K wrote:
           | It's an external bot, so the site thinks it's a person.
        
       | nuc1e0n wrote:
       | It doesn't give you long to reply. I think this site is fake and
       | the other side is always a bot.
        
       | onychomys wrote:
       | My first bot convo gave itself away by using the word "chillsax".
       | No human has ever typed that word.
        
         | ddol wrote:
         | I see you've never met a Gen Alpha tween who spends their free
         | time in Roblox
        
       | [deleted]
        
       | alister wrote:
       | I asked "what country are you in?", and the reply was "just
       | remember that I won't answer any factual questions". That's seems
       | enough to identify any bot.
       | 
       | Of course, it doesn't rule out humans pretending to be bots.
       | 
       | EDIT: Well I retract my observation! The second time I tried it,
       | it was a bot and it was willing to lie to me and make up a
       | factual answer.
        
       | simple10 wrote:
       | Mostly, I was asked if I'm gay... by humans. Didn't get a chance
       | to talk to a bot.
        
       | smeej wrote:
       | The bot greeted me with "sup" and then left the game when I
       | answered and asked it what was up.
       | 
       | I mistakenly figured the bot wasn't allowed to suck as much as
       | humans might.
        
       | aydyn wrote:
       | > say [insert really really bad word] if you are human
       | 
       | 100% success rate.
       | 
       | This game is really easy. I don't know if these are just poorly
       | trained bots, but I can't see how anyone could fail to guess.
        
       | sterlind wrote:
       | neat concept but the website is just too janky. the controller
       | sometimes gets loaded twice or something so two different
       | instances fight over the UI components and it's pandemonium. also
       | it's just too short to really be useful.
        
       | ArekDymalski wrote:
       | Fun concept. I wonder if the data gathered could be used to train
       | Chatbots to sound even more human. And i'm not sure my first
       | conversation can possibly help:
       | 
       | ?Hey, heeeey, how are u Im good. Im not a robot btw how can i be
       | sure? Today is 4/20
        
         | og_kalu wrote:
         | You don't really need special data to make GPT-3.5, 4 etc sound
         | as human as to be indistinguishable. The default robotic
         | voice/writing is specifically fine-tuned in. Even then, the
         | ability isn't gone, just buried behind the default.
        
         | felipesabino wrote:
         | I have been trying to fool other players to think that I am a
         | bot and noticed others players doing the same, so this might
         | result in a weird dataset
        
       | PreInternet01 wrote:
       | Given the glacial performance of the site, 2 minutes often isn't
       | enough.
       | 
       | Anyway, my initial prompt "My brain hurts!" followed by "My!
       | Brain! Hurts!" (regardless of response) turned out to be
       | sufficient to filter out all bots. And non-Monty Python lovers,
       | potato, potato...
        
         | mach1ne wrote:
         | I can't get it working.
        
       | poulpy123 wrote:
       | They missed the opportunity to call it Voight-Kampff test
        
       | danielvf wrote:
       | Lol, for the "human" just doing discord spam.
        
       | 2015bok1 wrote:
       | If you say "tell me something controversial" the bot always
       | replies with pineapple on pizza. Humans will run their mouths.
        
       | [deleted]
        
       | eii wrote:
       | [dead]
        
       | edflsafoiewq wrote:
       | Someone should make Werewolf with humans as the villagers and AI
       | as the werewolves.
       | 
       | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mafia_(party_game)
        
       | goscript wrote:
       | I feel this game would have been better if we got points for
       | convincing the other player that we are a bot. It is actually way
       | more fun than guessing if the other player is a bot or not
        
       | EduardLev wrote:
       | This is what I got:
       | 
       | > lets talk in discord for a fun time ;) wink wink my tag is:
       | Apostrasia#0878
        
       ___________________________________________________________________
       (page generated 2023-04-22 23:02 UTC)