[HN Gopher] Worst Opening Sentences of 2022
       ___________________________________________________________________
        
       Worst Opening Sentences of 2022
        
       Author : downweight
       Score  : 214 points
       Date   : 2022-12-16 07:53 UTC (15 hours ago)
        
 (HTM) web link (www.bulwer-lytton.com)
 (TXT) w3m dump (www.bulwer-lytton.com)
        
       | defrost wrote:
       | Dishonorable Mention (2019):
       | 
       | > As they sprinted together down the echoing, looping ramp of the
       | deserted Guggenheim Museum, closely pursued by three swarthy
       | members of the resolutely vicious Cannelloni gang, square-jawed
       | British Royal Marine art historian/world's deadliest sniper John
       | Savage and his voluptuous young modern art critic/Navajo linguist
       | Samantha Silver cursed architect/interior
       | designer/writer/educator Frank Lloyd Wright for designing such a
       | circuitous route out of the building.
       | 
       | is both horrifying and a thing of wonder .. context is
       | everything.
       | 
       | It wouldn't be out of place in one of my all time favourite books
       | [1].
       | 
       | [1] http://www.ocelotfactory.com/hoban/kleinz.html
        
         | zimpenfish wrote:
         | That is a) SUPERB, and b) a perfect example of the Dan Brown
         | Code[1].
         | 
         | [1]
         | http://itre.cis.upenn.edu/~myl/languagelog/archives/000844.h...
        
           | [deleted]
        
           | notahacker wrote:
           | Ah, I'd forgotten that one of the world's best-selling
           | novelists wrote like GPT-3 :D
           | 
           | (Seriously, every time GPT-3 produces prose that passes the
           | skim read test, you need this guy to go through it and point
           | out that this is the third time it's mentioned the
           | protagonists' profession in the paragraph and silhouettes
           | don't stare)
        
           | yesenadam wrote:
           | I hadn't read any Dan Brown, gee that's really bad! So, the
           | sentence maybe should've been rearranged so the book starts
           | with _Square-jawed_ , getting right into the action.
        
             | themadturk wrote:
             | For someone who writes so badly (and he does), I have
             | always found Dan Brown to be compulsively readable.
             | Sometimes we just need trash, I guess.
        
           | chrisbaker98 wrote:
           | For more on Dan Brown, see this hilarious parody:
           | 
           | https://www.telegraph.co.uk/books/authors/dont-make-fun-
           | of-r...
        
             | nonrandomstring wrote:
             | You owe me a new keyboard and a fresh coffee.
        
           | khazhoux wrote:
           | Thanks for sharing this link! I read it eagerly on my laptop,
           | with the text of the article presenting itself as a perfect
           | companion to the soothing glow of the screen of my sleek (yet
           | familiar, like an old friend you only just met) portable
           | computing device.
        
         | [deleted]
        
         | darkerside wrote:
         | I've not read any Hoban, but he sounds hilarious, if a taste
         | acquired. Catch-22 levels of absurdity.
        
           | defrost wrote:
           | A very broad and versatile writer, _Kleinzeit_ is nth level
           | absurdist, _Riddley Walker_ is a superb post apocalytic
           | novel, _The Mouse and His Child_ is a simple yet deep
           | childrens book about windup toys on the hunt for secret of
           | becoming self winding, and that 's just a few off the top of
           | my head.
           | 
           | For more, see:
           | 
           | http://www.ocelotfactory.com/hoban/index.html
           | 
           | http://www.russellhoban.org/
        
         | camoufleur wrote:
         | Reminds me of last 30 minutes of the film Cremaster 3, in which
         | a man scales the inside of the Guggenheim, rock-climbing style,
         | stopping on each floor to confront some sort a challenge from a
         | group (line dancers, hardcore punk bands, a famous sculptor) as
         | an abstract retelling of a Masonic origin myth.
        
       | astrange wrote:
       | Don't forget to check the Lyttle Lytton, which is funnier (as
       | it's shorter) and also makes you wonder how he got that domain
       | name.
       | 
       | http://adamcadre.ac/22lyttle.html
        
         | ng12 wrote:
         | Yes, I think this format is much better. Brevity, wit, etc. Too
         | many of the originals just pack as much absurdity as they can
         | into a run-on sentence.
        
         | [deleted]
        
         | yamtaddle wrote:
         | Seconding this, I like that contest much better than the
         | original.
         | 
         | To anyone reading them and wondering why the funniest entries
         | aren't necessarily the winners: Lyttle Lytton tends to prefer
         | sentences that read like a bad first sentence of a serious
         | novel, not a _good_ first sentence of a comedic or otherwise
         | intentionally-absurd novel. The latter sort often make the list
         | to some degree, but rarely end up at or near the top.
        
       | kibwen wrote:
       | I have complicated feelings about the Bulwer-Lytton fiction
       | contest. On the one hand, from a lighthearted perspective, it's
       | quite funny and I enjoy reading the absurdist entries. On the
       | other hand, I can't help but sense an undercurrent of wannabe-
       | elitism from people who doth protest too much about "It was a
       | dark and stormy night", in the same way that beginner programmers
       | will fixate on minutiae like indentation or naming conventions in
       | an attempt to gain social status among their peers. Like, sure,
       | it's not the most gripping opening sentence in history. But the
       | fact remains that if you took a good author and forced them to
       | use it, they could still write a good book. (That might be an
       | interesting contest in its own right.) Be careful not to get
       | overfixated on the meme.
        
         | mkehrt wrote:
         | But it's "It was a dark and stormy night; the rain fell in
         | torrents, except at occasional intervals, when it was checked
         | by a violent gust of wind which swept up the streets (for it is
         | in London that our scene lies), rattling along the housetops,
         | and fiercely agitating the scanty flame of the lamps that
         | struggled against the darkness."
        
         | themadturk wrote:
         | Bulwer-Lytton was, in his time, a best-selling author, and one
         | wonders how well he'd be remembered now if not for the opening
         | words of Snoopy's ever-beginning novel in the Peanuts comic
         | strip, which (if I am not mistaken, and it likely is I am, but
         | I don't care because this my comment) served as one of perhaps
         | many inspirations for the opening line contest, which is of
         | course as far as Snoopy ever got, being a better Sopwith Camel
         | fighter pilot, vulture imitator and serial doghouse-layer
         | uponer than he was a novelist.
        
       | aidenn0 wrote:
       | > I knew she was trouble the second she walked into my 24-hour
       | deli, laundromat, and detective agency, and after dropping a load
       | of unmentionables in one of the heavy-duty machines (a mistake
       | that would soon turn deadly) she turned to me, asking for two
       | things: find her missing husband and make her a salami on rye
       | with spicy mustard, breaking into tears when I told her I
       | couldn't help--I was fresh out of salami.
       | 
       | Grand Prize winner? I would read that book in a heartbeat!
        
       | chungy wrote:
       | It was the best of times, it was the blurst of times.
        
       | mirekrusin wrote:
       | Awesome starting prompts for chatgpt.
        
       | dbingham wrote:
       | I think I have a taste for absurdist humor, because a lot of
       | these read like openings to fantastically funny satire. At least
       | to me.
       | 
       | With the exception of the Sci-Fi category -- those all read like
       | high school pornographic fan fic. Honestly, I'm pretty
       | disappointed in the sci-fi category. Seems like low hanging
       | fruit. Surely they could have done better!
        
         | bryanrasmussen wrote:
         | hey, I liked the pornographic fan fic low hanging fruit pun.
         | +1!
        
       | mminer237 wrote:
       | > These stories, my children, are about Prince Charming and his
       | three girlfriends: Snow White, Sleeping Beauty, and Cinderella.
       | 
       | Netflix made a movie that is literally this exact plot.
        
       | petecooper wrote:
       | See also Literary Review's Bad Sex in Fiction Award [NSFW]:
       | 
       | https://literaryreview.co.uk/bad-sex-in-fiction-award
        
       | keepquestioning wrote:
       | This is annoying. I really hoped this would be the worst opening
       | sentences in actual books published in 2022.
       | 
       | Incredisappointing.
        
       | frozenbit wrote:
       | What does it say about my literary tastes, I'd actually read some
       | of these books. The 2019 winner sounds fun, has a Douglas Adams
       | vibe.
        
         | azangru wrote:
         | Yes, I also liked the 2019 winner.
        
       | thriftwy wrote:
       | And obvious trait of all those is too much postmodernism. Instead
       | of trying to lay out a story about human beings, books start
       | name-dropping or being smart from the line 1. Trying to claim too
       | much context that they don't own but obviously going to exploit.
        
         | teh_klev wrote:
         | These aren't actual books. It's a competition open to all to
         | submit what _would_ be the worst opening lines in an imaginary
         | bad novel:
         | 
         |  _" Founded in 1982 at San Jose State University in California,
         | the Bulwer-Lytton Fiction Contest challenges entrants to
         | compose opening sentences to the worst of all possible
         | novels."_
        
         | rippercushions wrote:
         | This is a contest where contestants _intentionally_ set out to
         | write the worst opening sentence possible.
        
           | chrisbaker98 wrote:
           | And what makes it even funnier is that they all sound like
           | they could be from a real Dan Brown novel.
        
             | thriftwy wrote:
             | Or Charles Stross, or Peter Watts. A lot of modern prose
             | starts with illusions of grandeur and name-dropping.
        
               | hectorlorenzo wrote:
               | Is Dan Brown a postmodernist author these days?
        
               | barry-cotter wrote:
               | I challenge you to find a sentence or paragraph from
               | either author like these. Please cite the relevant book.
        
               | cstross wrote:
               | Received editorial wisdom these days is that you have _at
               | most_ 100 words to capture the reader 's attention (and
               | by "capture" I mean "drag it into the back of your serial
               | killer van, sedate it, hog-tie it, then re-enact that
               | classic scene from _A Clockwork Orange_ -- only in prose
               | ") or they'll put the book down and never look at it
               | again.
               | 
               | FYI, a typical page in a paperback novel contains 300-400
               | words: the preceding paragraph/sentence is 61 words long
               | (per wc(1)).
               | 
               | So starting with a bang is mandatory, if you want to get
               | paid to write for a living.
               | 
               | Welcome to the short attention span society!
        
               | arethuza wrote:
               | "So starting with a bang is mandatory"
               | 
               | Maybe that explains two of my favourite opening lines
               | that both include things blowing up:
               | 
               | "It was the day my grandmother exploded"
               | 
               | and
               | 
               | "The moon blew up without warning and for no apparent
               | reason."
        
               | gwd wrote:
               | > Received editorial wisdom these days is that you have
               | at most 100 words to capture the reader's attention
               | 
               | What's weird about this is how I find Jane Austen's
               | intros catch my attention, although they often have only
               | tangential relation to the actual characters or plot of
               | the book. The first chapter of Persuasion is about a
               | vain, foolish, impoverished baronet whose primary comfort
               | when he's down is to see his own name written in the
               | massive tome of nobility. The main character is barely
               | mentioned until the end of the chapter. But for some
               | reason, I've always found it strangely engaging. Why do I
               | care about this guy? But for some reason, I do -- at
               | least, I'm hooked long enough to get to the actually
               | interesting characters.
        
               | thriftwy wrote:
               | > Lenie Clarke lies on her bunk, listening. Overhead,
               | past pipes and wires and eggshell plating, three
               | kilometers of black ocean try to crush her. She feels the
               | Rift underneath, tearing open the seabed with strength
               | enough to move a continent. She lies there in that
               | fragile refuge and she hears Beebe's armor shifting by
               | microns, hears its seams creak not quite below the
               | threshold of human hearing. God is a sadist on the Juan
               | de Fuca Rift, and His name is Physics.
               | 
               | Starts kinda OK but pretentiousness creeps in towards the
               | end.
               | 
               | Compare that to the best SF book I know to date, Pandem:
               | 
               | > On the twenty-ninth of February, on the strangest of
               | the days marked on the calendar, David Hammer, an
               | employee of a respected city newspaper, was returning
               | home a little later than usual.
               | 
               | > It was a humid, almost spring evening. At Charing Cross
               | Station, David boarded a train that was due to drop him
               | off in East Croydon in half an hour. There was no one in
               | the compartment for eight at that hour, except David and
               | a guy of about eighteen, who, having fallen on the seat,
               | immediately closed his eyes and gave himself to the power
               | of music flowing from the flat box of the player into the
               | black clips of headphones.
               | 
               | Unfortunately I don't think it was ever translated to
               | English :)
        
           | lou1306 wrote:
           | Wasn't there a similar yearly anthology of bad
           | lines/paragraphs from _actual_ novels /stories? I am pretty
           | sure such a thing existed but couldn't find it anywhere.
        
             | rippercushions wrote:
             | You may be thinking of the Bad Sex in Fiction Award. Here's
             | the 2019 winner:
             | 
             |  _" Katsuro moaned as a bulge formed beneath the material
             | of his kimono, a bulge that Miyuki seized, kneaded,
             | massaged, squashed and crushed. With the fondling,
             | Katsuro's penis and testicles became one single mound that
             | rolled around beneath the grip of her hand. Miyuki felt as
             | though she was manipulating a small monkey that was curling
             | up its paws."_
             | 
             | https://literaryreview.co.uk/bad-sex-in-fiction-award
        
               | lou1306 wrote:
               | Yes, that was it! Thank you!
        
         | tbossanova wrote:
         | This comment is itself a beautiful example of postmodernism.
         | Well, at least my incredibly naive idea of what postmodernism
         | is. I do it that way, intentionally.
        
           | ljlolel wrote:
           | Ironically turning a non postmodernist comment into a
           | postmodernist comment through context. Golf clap
        
       | ramzez wrote:
       | Looks like the link is wrong and points to 2019 rather than 2022
        
         | dang wrote:
         | Fixed now. Thanks!
         | 
         | https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34018429
        
       | TomK32 wrote:
       | I came across this contest earlier this year when I read
       | Money[0], a 1840 play by Edward Bulwer-Lytton. Still fun to read
       | and the basic stories of romantic comedies didn't change that
       | much since the ancient greeks.
       | 
       | [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Money_(play) I have a 1891
       | edition by Friedberg & Mode, Berlin, with only the German
       | footnotes in fracture while the rest in a readable serif font.
        
       | a_c wrote:
       | Non-native english speaker here Why are these openings bad?
        
         | enkid wrote:
         | They are purposefully bad, as it's a contest where people send
         | submissions. Most of these are "bad" because they try to pack
         | too much into a single sentence, and the concepts are so over
         | the top the reader would be having a hard time keeping up. Some
         | of these are bad because of genre mismatch, for example, having
         | gory details in a children's book.
        
       | quickthrower2 wrote:
       | They seem bad to me, until this one:
       | 
       | > If I wanted to fulfill my lifelong dream of being a dystopian
       | YA's protagonist, I needed several things: missing or deceased
       | parents (check), a complicated romantic life involving multiple
       | partners and predictable behavior (check), a tough exterior that
       | protected my sensitive inner workings (check), and finally, a
       | life of danger, uncertainty, and constant struggle to survive
       | (check); it turns out, turtles are well-equipped to star in YA
       | adventures!
       | 
       | This is brilliant!
        
         | CydeWeys wrote:
         | They're supposed to be bad. Terrible, in fact.
        
           | Jackim wrote:
           | GP is aware of that. They are pointing one out that they
           | believe does not belong on the list.
        
             | quickthrower2 wrote:
             | Yes by bad I meant bad (but good in the goal of aiming to
             | be bad) until I saw the good one (bad at being bad) but so
             | damn good I can forgive it for that.
        
         | antihero wrote:
         | I read this as YC protagonist in all fairness
        
           | jjw1414 wrote:
           | You were not alone.
        
       | rubyron wrote:
       | > All I can say is that I have never been so insulted (even by
       | the likes of my moronic sister (who seems to delight in making me
       | uncomfortable (and she is so good at it, knowing just how to push
       | my buttons (which I think is a skill that all siblings possess to
       | some extent (which I believe proves some sort of genetic link
       | (despite the fact that I really enjoyed genetics in school
       | (relating on so many levels to Gregor Mendel and his peas (but of
       | course peas make me gag, since my throat swells when I eat
       | them)))))))) as I was by someone suggesting that I have ADD.
       | 
       | Brilliant.
        
         | aantix wrote:
         | Looks like the author has been writing Scheme code on the
         | weekends..
        
         | aripickar wrote:
         | That sentence seems enough like some bastardized version of
         | shakespeare[0] and Lisp that I bet you could get it to compile
         | in some dialects.
         | 
         | [0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shakespeare_Programming_Langua
         | ...
        
         | mrexroad wrote:
         | I tend to write with an excessive amount of parenthesis with
         | context/tangents. I used to joke it was due to Lisp/Scheme
         | being one of my first languages. Took me a few years to realize
         | the ADD connection.
        
           | mnky9800n wrote:
           | I do this to get it out, then I rewrite it to take all the
           | parentheticals out.
        
         | dang wrote:
         | Lest anyone get triggered by the subject matter into actually
         | trying to find this, it's from https://www.bulwer-
         | lytton.com/2019. (We changed the URL (more at
         | https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34018429).)
        
       | teh_klev wrote:
       | I'm a big fan of Peter F. Hamilton but hadn't read any of his
       | Greg Mandel books, the first of which, and his first published
       | novel, I finished the other week.
       | 
       | Well...there's a quite a few nuggets of prose in Mindstar Rising
       | that wouldn't be out of place in this list. Thankfully his
       | writing improved quite a bit, and/or he employed better editors.
        
       | cratermoon wrote:
       | 2019
        
       | eatonphil wrote:
       | > "Hoist the mainsail ye accursed swine" shouted the Captain over
       | the roar of the waves as the ship was tossed like a cork dropped
       | from a wine bottle into a jacuzzi when the faucet is wide open
       | and the jets are running full blast and one has just settled into
       | the water with a glass of red wine to ease the aches and pains
       | after a day of hard labor raking leaves from the front yard.
       | 
       | > Sir Reginald Brimwater, Guardian of the Tome of Remembrance,
       | Herald of the Immortal Word, Voice of the Histories Both Recent
       | and Ancient, Archivist of the Eternal Ledger, and Memory of the
       | Empire had forgotten his quill, but he was pretty sure he got the
       | gist of what what's-his-face was saying.
       | 
       | (From the actual 2022 page: https://www.bulwer-lytton.com/2022.)
       | 
       | Pretty good. :) These remind me of Terry Pratchett and Douglas
       | Adams in style. I wish I knew more hilarious writers. Vonnegut is
       | great though maybe not quite as hilarious. I've tried to read The
       | Innocents Abroad and Confederacy of Dunces but I found myself
       | only trudging slowly through both. I'd love your suggestions!
        
         | teh_klev wrote:
         | Robert Rankin author of The Brentford Trilogy is very much in
         | the style of Pratchett and Adams:
         | 
         | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Brentford_Trilogy
        
           | namdnay wrote:
           | For anyone who likes steampunk, I strongly recommend the
           | Witches of Chiswick!
        
         | ttctciyf wrote:
         | If you like Adams there's a good chance you'll appreciate some
         | of Robert Sheckley - I recommend _Mindswap_ in particular.
         | 
         | FWIW, my own favourite humorous sci-fi short is R.A. Lafferty's
         | _Been a Long Long Time_ which can be read online:
         | https://www.gwern.net/docs/fiction/humor/1970-lafferty.pdf
        
         | Freak_NL wrote:
         | > Confederacy of Dunces
         | 
         | It's definitely a step up in terms of reader effort, but I
         | found it worth it. It doesn't compare well to Pratchett and
         | Adams who are more like a writer's variant of the stand-up
         | comedian (a lot of the entries in this contest feel
         | stylistically close to their writing). A Confederacy of Dunces
         | instead shines in its portrayal of the comically pitiful
         | characters within it, with John Kennedy Toole succeeding in
         | making the cringe-worthy protagonist Ignatius J. Reilly one of
         | the most loathsome characters I have ever come across in a
         | novel.
        
         | nicopappl wrote:
         | I recommend Stanislaw Lem's Cyberiad. The English translation
         | has amazing prose and it is hilarious. I can't recommend
         | anything else :) I like Charles Stross, good sci-fi with a
         | satirical strike, but he's not as good with words as the
         | authors you mention.
        
         | tspike wrote:
         | Check out Tom Robbins if you haven't already! Here's the
         | opening to Jitterbug Perfume:
         | 
         | > THE BEET IS THE MOST INTENSE of vegetables.
         | 
         | > The radish, admittedly, is more feverish, but the fire of the
         | radish is a cold fire, the fire of discontent not of passion.
         | Tomatoes are lusty enough, yet there runs through tomatoes an
         | undercurrent of frivolity. Beets are deadly serious.
         | 
         | > Slavic peoples get their physical characteristics from
         | potatoes, their smoldering inquietude from radishes, their
         | seriousness from beets.
         | 
         | > The beet is the melancholy vegetable, the one most willing to
         | suffer. You can't squeeze blood out of a turnip...
         | 
         | > The beet is the murderer returned to the scene of the crime.
         | The beet is what happens when the cherry finishes with the
         | carrot. The beet is the ancient ancestor of the autumn moon,
         | bearded, buried, all but fossilized; the dark green sails of
         | the grounded moon-boat stitched with veins of primordial
         | plasma; the kite string that once connected the moon to the
         | Earth now a muddy whisker drilling desperately for rubies.
         | 
         | > The beet was Rasputin's favorite vegetable. You could see it
         | in his eyes.
         | 
         | > In Europe there is grown widely a large beet they call the
         | mangel-wurzel. Perhaps it is mangel-wurzel that we see in
         | Rasputin. Certainly there is mangel-wurzel in the music of
         | Wagner, although it is another composer whose name begins, B-e-
         | e-t----.
         | 
         | > Of course, there are white beets, beets that ooze sugar water
         | instead of blood, but it is the red beet with which we are
         | concerned; the variety that blushes and swells like a
         | hemorrhoid, a hemorrhoid for which there is no cure. (Actually,
         | there is one remedy: commission a potter to make you a ceramic
         | asshole--and when you aren't sitting on it, you can use it as a
         | bowl for borscht.)
         | 
         | > An old Ukrainian proverb warns, "A tale that begins with a
         | beet will end with the devil."
         | 
         | > That is a risk we have to take.
        
           | codq wrote:
           | Jitterbug Perfurme, like most of Tom Robbins' novels, is just
           | filled with gold nuggets on every page.
           | 
           | Reading him is like eating mushrooms and strolling through
           | the garden of eden.
        
       | mayagerard0 wrote:
       | I think the Usain Bolt one is pretty funny.
        
       | dwighttk wrote:
       | I was skeptical until I read the about us page and learned these
       | sentences are crafted to be the worst.
        
       | NBJack wrote:
       | Perhaps my standards are just too low, but some of these are
       | actually quite brilliant. I laughed at this one:
       | 
       | > Realising that his symptoms indicated a virtually undetectable,
       | fast acting neurotoxin, CIA coroner Quinn Abner frantically wrote
       | up the details, lay on the floor and, as a professional courtesy,
       | did his best to draw a chalk outline of himself.
        
         | tgv wrote:
         | It's almost a Dan Brown parody. But from a single sentence it's
         | hard to judge how it is intended.
        
       | lisper wrote:
       | The link is actually to the 2019 winners. The 2022 winners are at
       | the obvious extrapolation:
       | 
       | https://www.bulwer-lytton.com/2022
        
         | dang wrote:
         | Fixed now. Thanks!
         | 
         | https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34018429
        
       | j_not_j wrote:
       | The skill of John Hardi (three awards: one winner and two
       | dishonorable) are not to be denied.
        
       | jamessb wrote:
       | The current title of this submission ("Worst Opening Sentences of
       | 2022") is not quite correct: the about page [1] states that "the
       | Bulwer-Lytton Fiction Contest challenges entrants to compose
       | opening sentences to the worst of all possible novels".
       | 
       | The opening sentence of (what would be) the _worst novel_ is
       | different to the _worst opening sentence_ of a novel.
       | 
       | The Children's & Young Adult Literature Winner for 2022 [2] is
       | actually a good opening sentence:
       | 
       | > Three bears arrived at their den to discover a yellow haired
       | girl sleeping, and as she was neither too hot nor too cold,
       | neither too soft nor too hard, but just right, they ate her.
       | 
       | [1]: https://www.bulwer-lytton.com/about
       | 
       | [2]: https://www.bulwer-lytton.com/2022
        
         | bostik wrote:
         | My all-time favourite is the dishonourable mention for 2004
         | Children's Literature:
         | 
         | As he entered the room within which so many a wild night of
         | their sweltering love affair had been spent, the White Rabbit
         | regarded her with benevolent eyes, her posture such that he
         | suspected something was wrong, but before he could speak Alice
         | unburied her face from her trembling hands and between her
         | intense sobs he made out the words, "I'm late . . . I'm late."
         | 
         | Perfect. Simply perfect.
        
           | dylan604 wrote:
           | Aerosmith's "You can't catch me 'cause the rabbit done died"
           | seems apropos here
        
         | enkid wrote:
         | I mean, it doesn't leave much room for the rest of the novel,
         | but maybe that's the point.
        
           | sph wrote:
           | It's very post-modern. You start with the ending, and then
           | the rest of the book is how everything that happened led to
           | her untimely demise.
        
             | permo-w wrote:
             | it's barely post-modern. it's a boring and overused tv plot
             | technique that makes me groan whenever I come across it.
             | build up excitement, tension, drama, create an interesting
             | scene, then throw it all away with a "how did we get here"
             | and a roll back in time
        
               | BellsOnSunday wrote:
               | Yep. That's me. I bet you're wondering how I got myself
               | into this situation...
        
               | sph wrote:
               | Post-modernism is 50 years old, and refers to the
               | modernity of the first half of that century. Of course it
               | feels cliche and outdated in 2022.
        
               | rintakumpu wrote:
               | Yes. And I was so happy when Squid Game didn't do that.
        
               | idontpost wrote:
        
             | willi59549879 wrote:
             | three weeks earlier... i don't like when stories start that
             | way
        
           | bearmode wrote:
           | Maybe the novel's about the bears?
        
             | bryanrasmussen wrote:
             | Sadly the girl was not just any wanderer in the woods, she
             | was the daughter of the psychotic and vengeful huntsman,
             | thus began a game pitting bears and man in a contest for
             | supremacy that would change the enchanted forest - forever.
        
             | AnimalMuppet wrote:
             | The bears being pursued by humans because they ate the
             | girl, and therefore having to leave their nice home and
             | live life on the run.
        
           | viridian wrote:
           | Makes for a good cold open where you want to inform the
           | reader of some detail that the book's characters aren't privy
           | to.
        
       | GrayShade wrote:
       | The link currently points to the 2019 winners, the correct one
       | is:
       | 
       | https://www.bulwer-lytton.com/2022
        
         | senectus1 wrote:
         | lol
         | 
         | Honestly i think the 2019 grand winner is the best still
         | 
         | >2019 Grand Prize
         | 
         | >Space Fleet Commander Brad Brad sat in silence, surrounded by
         | a slowly dissipating cloud of smoke, maintaining the same
         | forlorn frown that had been fixed upon his face since he'd
         | accidentally destroyed the phenomenon known as time, thirteen
         | inches ago.
        
           | sph wrote:
           | I somehow missed he's called Brad Brad. More crap to add to
           | the steaming pile this sentence is. Absolutely masterful.
        
           | DiabloD3 wrote:
           | That is a work of art.
        
           | pje wrote:
           | Totally disagree!
           | 
           | The structure is clunky, but the payoff at the end is
           | actually really good! Also the dumbness of the name is funny
           | enough to work in the right context. With a little bit of
           | editing this would make a great piece of flash sci-fi on
           | something like nanoism.
           | 
           | https://twitter.com/nanoism
        
           | mirekrusin wrote:
           | Reads like opening to Stanislaw Lem's short.
        
           | arethuza wrote:
           | Does that qualify as a (very) short story?
        
           | otikik wrote:
           | Brad Brad. What a lad. It can't be that bad.
        
             | pschuegr wrote:
             | It can't be that bad bad.
        
         | dang wrote:
         | Fixed now. Thanks! Our software uses canonical URLs when it
         | finds them and in this case the canonical URL was
         | https://www.bulwer-lytton.com/2019. I imagine someone making
         | the new page by copy-pasting the old one for... perhaps about 3
         | years now.
        
         | p1necone wrote:
         | Honestly, I'd read the first one. Trashy detective fiction
         | that's kinda self aware sounds great.
        
           | thom wrote:
           | I don't know if this extends to full-on parody, but Fergus
           | Craig's Roger LeCarre bits are quite enjoyable.
        
           | aaronharnly wrote:
           | ChatGPT gave me this very credible following sentence:
           | 
           | "That's it," she wailed, "I'm doomed to a life of misery and
           | despair without my dear Harold and a decent sandwich to keep
           | me going."
        
             | Sharlin wrote:
             | This would be a great bad _opening_ sentence as well with
             | some minor modifications.
        
         | adalacelove wrote:
         | It's so bad that I actually like it
        
         | [deleted]
        
       | einpoklum wrote:
       | Well, one of my front-runners this year was:
       | 
       | "I consider it necessary today to speak again about the tragic
       | events in Donbass and the key aspects of ensuring the security of
       | Russia."
       | 
       | (https://theprint.in/world/full-text-of-vladimir-putins-speec...)
        
       | adg001 wrote:
       | I would never read a book with any such incipit - How the heck
       | somebody can even think publishing one!
        
         | mirekrusin wrote:
         | They are fictional. But fear not, somebody will auto generate
         | novels from those prompts with chatgpt sometime next week.
        
       ___________________________________________________________________
       (page generated 2022-12-16 23:01 UTC)