[HN Gopher] Trombone Champ turns all songs into tooting works of...
       ___________________________________________________________________
        
       Trombone Champ turns all songs into tooting works of genius
        
       Author : helsinkiandrew
       Score  : 77 points
       Date   : 2022-09-23 05:28 UTC (2 days ago)
        
 (HTM) web link (www.polygon.com)
 (TXT) w3m dump (www.polygon.com)
        
       | xnx wrote:
       | The game is fun for sure. I fully expect someone to hack-up a
       | hardware DIY trombone interface. You might be able to get pretty
       | close doing something has improvised as taping a mouse to a
       | cardboard tube with a small hole in the side that allows the
       | mouse sensor to read movement from another cardboard tube inside
       | the first.
        
         | jffry wrote:
         | There is somebody who rigged up a mic, and some code to listen
         | for loud sounds and use the pitch to set mouse position :)
         | https://twitter.com/kupobucks/status/1573060085177262082
         | 
         | But a DIY controller with a mouse taped to a physical thing
         | would also be fun and I eagerly await the video
        
       | LegitShady wrote:
       | seems like a missed opportunity for Tromboner
        
       | epaulson wrote:
       | The Onion is ahead of the times - from 2007:
       | https://www.theonion.com/activision-reports-sluggish-sales-f...
        
       | jquery wrote:
       | You can tell the devs are trombone players because the trombonist
       | gets to play the melody.
        
         | krallja wrote:
         | The first tweeted video, by Jacob DeRose, "William Tell
         | Overture", is the counter-melody at best.
        
       | Applejinx wrote:
       | QWOP, but music :)
        
       | beefman wrote:
       | Does it use real slide positions? I'm guessing not. (The slide is
       | only long enough to change pitch by a small amount. Lip tension
       | is used to select a resonant mode at each slide position.)
       | 
       | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rc1EPud2VAQ&t=8s
        
         | skywhopper wrote:
         | No, it's just a single continuous "slide".
        
           | beefman wrote:
           | Would be cool to have an expert mode where the keyboard is
           | used to select lip tension and the slide works as on a real
           | instrument. With a simple physical model, would make hitting
           | the right notes easier since there's a natural 'pull' to the
           | resonances.
        
       | ec109685 wrote:
       | Does Nasty actually mean you messed up or did something dope?
       | 
       | From the article: mess up and game will proclaim it "nasty."
       | 
       | However, nasty can be good: "4. an expression of approval or
       | impressment with regard to a person's actions or ability"
       | https://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=nasty
        
         | wolfram74 wrote:
         | Welcome to auto antonyms.
        
           | clucas wrote:
           | Cleave to the traditional uses of words! Don't cleave their
           | meanings!
        
             | jfk13 wrote:
             | Should we sanction such usages, or should they be
             | sanctioned?
        
       | smrq wrote:
       | I learned to type on my first non-traditional keyboard using a
       | previous game from these devs, "Icarus Proudbottom Teaches
       | Typing". Similar offbeat sense of humor (though, if playing Sousa
       | marches taught me anything, shouldn't the horns be off-beat
       | instead?) It was a Flash game but there surely must still be a
       | way to play it.
        
       | fuball63 wrote:
       | My senior project in college was "Trombone Hero", which was a
       | game based on guitar hero. I had an old trombone, and I took
       | apart a cheap gamepad and put the sensors along a custom PVC pipe
       | slide at positions 1 - 7. There was then a button attached to it
       | that you would press for "blowing".
       | 
       | I then made a little tool that would play music and record inputs
       | to generate the "levels". I used some Beatles songs I had on a
       | CD, and then recorded each note individually on a real trombone
       | to superimpose on the song.
       | 
       | I made the game engine with some Java graphics library that I
       | don't remember. I was really proud of this when I made it, and is
       | always a fun story to tell.
       | 
       | I found an old video from ~2012 when I demoed it to the class:
       | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3rawTtdv50s
        
       | krallja wrote:
       | > Trombone Champ has been released for PC via Steam! ... > > A
       | Mac release is currently being researched. Further ports are
       | possible but not currently planned.
       | 
       | Uh, why not? This would be perfect for touch screens. And
       | accelerometers. Just imagine the Joy-Con chaos.
        
         | grimgrin wrote:
         | for starters, it's using an _inverted mouse_ by default, which
         | has to be intentional to add to the ridiculousness of the
         | entire experience
         | 
         | playing with a touch screen would be ez mode
        
         | schmorptron wrote:
         | https://twitter.com/lawrenceyang/status/1572438040173490182
         | Seems like the accelerometer part can be done with the PC
         | version already :D
        
           | Bytewave81 wrote:
           | Probably just by mapping the accelerometer to a virtual
           | joystick. Steam Input is a fairly powerful framework for
           | mapping new controls onto existing control schemes.
        
       | AlbertCory wrote:
       | I can see a whole family of games built on difficult instruments.
       | 
       | Just for yucks, I took a couple French Horn lessons, because I
       | knew the teacher Scott. I bought a new one from Walmart for
       | ~$200, which Scott bought back from me because he can always sell
       | them. I told him I had no commitment to learning it, and he was
       | fine with that.
       | 
       | Man, that is one _hard_ instrument. Compared to the  'bone? I
       | couldn't say.
        
         | a_cardboard_box wrote:
         | The French horn is a popular answer to "what's the hardest
         | orchestral instrument?".
         | 
         | It has longer tubing and therefore a lower fundamental
         | frequency than a trombone, but typically plays in a higher
         | range.
         | 
         | The higher above the fundamental frequency of a brass
         | instrument you play, the more notes can be played with a single
         | fingering. So the French horn requires very precise lip control
         | to get the right note.
        
           | libraryatnight wrote:
           | I was a trumpet player in band and had a "Lemme try..."
           | moment after one of the French horn players told us this. It
           | was indeed much harder. It was sort of fun to have her do the
           | fingerings while I tried to make sensible sounds come out of
           | the thing.
           | 
           | French horn has a buttery warmth I love when played well.
           | Sounds the first cry of some newborn hellspawn in the arms of
           | an neophyte.
        
             | AlbertCory wrote:
             | My persistence level was very low, as I said. So bear with
             | me if I tell you that the song "Beautiful Dreamer" was the
             | killer. I just could NOT hit that C on "dream-ER."
             | 
             | Scott's played with every big orchestra in the Bay Area, as
             | a sub. When their regular horn player can't make it, he's
             | the one they call.
        
               | jfk13 wrote:
               | I hope all you horn players (or would-be players) are
               | familiar with Flanders & Swann's take:
               | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VjA6bA1qtfQ
        
               | AlbertCory wrote:
               | Thanks, never heard of them.
               | 
               | It could use a transcript, though.
        
       | 2-718-281-828 wrote:
       | Anybody remembering Microsoft's Songsmith?
       | 
       | https://youtu.be/Ci1K9Zcwvy4?t=17
       | 
       | https://youtu.be/mg0l7f25bhU?t=27
       | 
       | :D
       | 
       | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microsoft_Songsmith
        
       ___________________________________________________________________
       (page generated 2022-09-25 23:02 UTC)