[HN Gopher] Monetizing hobbies
       ___________________________________________________________________
        
       Monetizing hobbies
        
       Author : victorstanciu
       Score  : 146 points
       Date   : 2022-04-21 08:26 UTC (2 days ago)
        
 (HTM) web link (tegowerk.eu)
 (TXT) w3m dump (tegowerk.eu)
        
       | u2077 wrote:
       | As someone with a somewhat successful side project, I highly
       | recommend monetizing it. However, you should choose a small
       | enough price that you don't feel like you owe customers fast
       | support or every feature they ask for. (In some cases a donation
       | button may be better)
       | 
       | Also, when you start expecting your project to meet income
       | requirements, it can take the fun out extremely fast. Part of the
       | fun is being able to work on it as much or as little as I want.
       | 
       | Benefits of monetizing (from my experience):
       | 
       | Extremely validating, what you enjoy doing has value to others.
       | 
       | Offsets costs, even if your only cost is time, a few bucks really
       | helps.
        
         | DoreenMichele wrote:
         | _(In some cases a donation button may be better)_
         | 
         | If you are not a charity, do not call it a donation. Call it a
         | _tip_.
        
           | WJW wrote:
           | Is there some legal distinction? Getting money with the
           | expectation that it will be used to further some vaguely
           | defined public good you are doing (writing freely available
           | software in this case) sounds exactly like a charity,
           | especially since you will be doing most of the public good
           | regardless of whether you get the donation or not. A tip on
           | the other hand is an additional payment for some good or
           | service that you were already paying for, but that is not the
           | case for most software projects.
        
             | DoreenMichele wrote:
             | I'm a blogger, not a programmer. I don't make near enough
             | money from it but calling it a tip instead of a donation
             | has performed better.
             | 
             | Tip signals "payment for my work." Donation signals "gift."
             | 
             | People seem to be more inclined to actually fork over a few
             | bucks if you signal "This is my work. I deserve to be paid
             | for it." than if you signal "I would like gifts (or
             | charity) from random internet strangers."
        
               | WJW wrote:
               | Interesting, thanks for the explanation!
        
           | jlokier wrote:
           | Fun fact: Tips are subject to income tax, donations are not.
           | 
           | That may be relevant to people seriously monetizing their
           | hobbies.
           | 
           | (Whether something is, for tax purposes, a tip or a donation
           | is determined by the reason the money is given, not what you
           | call it, but if it's truly a donation then I'd be inclined to
           | call it one just in case that influences some judgement
           | further down the line.)
        
             | DoreenMichele wrote:
             | Years ago, PayPal had _donate_ buttons and my recollection
             | is there was text somewhere on the site indicating that if
             | you hit $10k in donations, they would want a copy of your
             | 501c3 or some such. It 's one of the reasons I stopped
             | using _donate_ buttons.
             | 
             | These days, there are other monetization products but I'm
             | not sure the IRS would approve of you calling it whatever
             | you want for reasons of avoiding taxes.
        
       | 13415 wrote:
       | I monetized my German science fiction novels by publishing them
       | on Amazon, but so far have regretted it. They generally get great
       | reviews and sure have their readers, but mostly just one of them
       | (by far not the best) sells well continuously. The rest would
       | require marketing that is a completely different activity than
       | writing books, and really not fun to me at all. Moreover, you
       | invariably get the occasional bad or intentionally misleading, if
       | not downright evil review, and if you happen to get one of those
       | in the beginning by accident, then your book will never sell -
       | nobody is going to buy a self-published book with a score below 4
       | stars and future reviews will be lower than deserved due to the
       | anchoring effect. I'm no longer sure the benefits of getting a
       | few hundred readers and the corresponding royalties outweigh the
       | substantial efforts of getting a book ready for publication,
       | which have nothing to do with the joy of writing.
       | 
       | Seeking for channels to give away your work for free like open
       | source or creative commons can make more sense. Software is
       | another issue, by the way. I used to sell shareware for Macs for
       | 20 years, and the problem is it can cause a lot of work if you
       | want to support your customers _after initial sales_ have cooled
       | down. It can easily turn into a chore.
        
         | victorstanciu wrote:
         | First of all, congrats on finishing the novels. That's a huge
         | accomplishment in itself!
         | 
         | Writing sits comfortably in the territory of hobbies which
         | require neither money nor storage space to perform, so I can
         | totally understand how someone would choose to forgo money
         | completely in order to not have to deal with the unpleasant
         | aspects of self-publishing. Speaking of which, I assume you've
         | already decided against traditional publishing?
        
         | ffhhj wrote:
         | You should convert them into ebook apps, something I have
         | noticed is that nobody reads the reviews. Maybe give the first
         | chapters for free and the rest paid. Just make sure the user
         | knows that's the deal so they don't get frustrated.
        
           | [deleted]
        
         | ghaff wrote:
         | I've published a few non-fiction books in the tech space--one
         | through a major publisher and couple independently.
         | 
         | Certainly some people do well but, in the main, the finances
         | don't really work. I've never done a serious marketing push
         | beyond book signings at some industry events (with someone else
         | paying for the book copies) but I'm not at all confident that
         | incremental sales would cover significant PR/marketing
         | activities.
         | 
         | What it _has_ done in my case is a likely pretty significant
         | enhancement to my visibility /stature professionally. Which has
         | been very beneficial.
         | 
         | I did shareware for a while too back in the 90s (MS-DOS
         | mostly). I enjoyed doing it for a time, liked interacting with
         | my testers and other users, was part of the shareware
         | community, etc. And made reasonable side hobby business money.
         | But certainly not at my day job level.
        
       | political12345 wrote:
       | If you are so obsessesed with optimizing your life (most of us on
       | HN are) and want to monetize your hobby, pick a job so
       | interesting and open ended that your job becomes your hobby.
       | 
       | You are killing two birds with one stone in that case
        
         | jotm wrote:
         | That's a very limited pool with high competition though :D
        
         | koheripbal wrote:
         | Running a small business is like this.
        
         | n4bz0r wrote:
         | > You are killing two birds with one stone in that case
         | 
         | Achievement unlocked: Dennis the Menace
        
         | cehrlich wrote:
         | The downside is you might end up resenting your hobby
        
           | Damogran6 wrote:
           | Then pivot. So many of these decisions are "If you do X,
           | you'll end up with Y" as if that's the end. There's nothing
           | wrong with 'trying something on and changing your mind once
           | you see how it looks.'
        
       | turtledove wrote:
       | Why do we feel the need to be 'productive' (in the economics
       | sense) even in our leisure time?
       | 
       | I'm not sure such an attitude is healthy or sustainable. We
       | fought hard to get a 40 hour work week, why do we feel pressure
       | to go back on that and work in our leisure time?
        
         | Helitioo wrote:
         | My personal development should not be driven by my work.
         | 
         | Personal development means more than sitting in front of a tv.
         | 
         | I want to need to work less so I can be productive for myself.
        
           | abhaynayar wrote:
           | You can have personal development without being productive.
           | 
           | There are many hobbies where you don't produce or monetize
           | anything, but they are still better watching TV. For example,
           | playing a sport, learning an instrument, reading books,
           | learning a new language, etc.
           | 
           | The distinction being whether you are producing something or
           | learning something just for its own sake.
        
       | black_13 wrote:
        
       | drmpeg wrote:
       | There's an old saying in ham radio. "If you want to make a small
       | fortune in ham radio, start with a large fortune".
        
         | Damogran6 wrote:
         | Also racing cars. Boats have a lot of similar aphorisms, too.
        
           | krallja wrote:
           | "Boat, (noun): a hole in the water you throw money into"
        
             | PyWoody wrote:
             | Break Out Another Thousand
        
       | abakker wrote:
       | I think there's an important distinction here. Monetizing
       | metalwork or woodwork (which I do, and have done) doesn't seem to
       | ruin the fun for me. The hobby is about output, and more time
       | spent equals more practice equals more skill. So, with some
       | hobbies, it really benefits to get commercial.
       | 
       | I've found that commercial work as a craftsman has pushed me to
       | learn much more than my own designs are. I think this is akin to
       | learning other people's songs when you learn an instrument; if
       | you don't, its much too easy to get stuck in a rut of your own
       | ideas.
        
       | ThinkBeat wrote:
       | A hobby should be something you can do for yourself. Something
       | you get pleasure / relaxation / a welcomed distraction. out of
       | doing.
       | 
       | If you take up painting (art, not houses) you should know you
       | will never be Rembrandt and it should not keep you from painting
       | (Unless painting houses is your hobby)
       | 
       | With things like (marathon) running, hiking, it is easy to
       | meassure Objective progress and qutie hard to moneteize.
       | 
       | If you are a programmer all day, and your hobby is programming I
       | dont think that is ideal.
       | 
       | I have been there myself a bit earier in life and regret that
       | now.
       | 
       | Thers is soo much to see, experience, learn outside of computers.
       | 
       | Plus doing something else will help your brain relax, or at least
       | not running the exact same parts as when you are at work, that is
       | in itself a valuabe thing. Giving your brain something different
       | to chew on, connect new paths, all good.
        
         | FourthProtocol wrote:
         | _With things like (marathon) running, hiking, it is easy to
         | meassure Objective progress and qutie hard to moneteize._
         | 
         | Well, no. You can do sooo much here. Log your hike, provide
         | coordinates of off-the-beaten-track routes and sites, provide
         | info on trail conditions, run team events, gear reviews, first
         | aid courses...
         | 
         | Also, who said I can't be the next Rembrandt? Kandinsky is only
         | one of many proofs that that second sentence of yours is off
         | the mark.
         | 
         | I've actually just started work on making piste maps better for
         | snowboarders. Making bank off that would be ace, if not well OK
         | then. Being defeatist because the probability of failure is
         | bigger than success is defeatist, no?
        
           | verve_rat wrote:
           | But that is not running, hiking, or snowboarding. What you
           | are talking about is making maps and writing reviews. They
           | are related, but are not the thing the enthusiast enjoys.
        
       | Arrivest wrote:
       | As a software developer, when I monetized my hobby code that
       | solved a niche problem, I needed to spend 10x more time to make
       | it from "usable for me" to "usable for users".
        
       | soheil wrote:
       | I wish there was a straightforward way to monetize software
       | written as a hobby just like selling pottery on Etsy.
        
       | quags wrote:
       | I turned my love of computer hobby into a business and have been
       | running it for many years. I don't regret it, I still like
       | computers but no longer have that young love for it where I would
       | learn all about another cool programming language. Part of that
       | may be I am older, part is certainly dealing with customers. It
       | is now a job so I sometimes say I lost my hobby by doing what I
       | loved. I at least like my job but need a new hobby.
        
       | OrangeMonkey wrote:
       | My wife and I were feeling cooped up from Covid so we started a
       | new hobby - storage auctions. We buy abandoned storage units at
       | auction, sell the things, keep (very very rarely) any upgrades or
       | things we want, and move to the next.
       | 
       | Its still a hobby, but we are now optimizing for cash / time
       | spent / ease of flip so I think its at the cusp of moving away
       | from hobby.
        
       | photochemsyn wrote:
       | The author mentions bike repair as a hobby, and the issue with
       | trying to turn that into a monetized hobby will quickly become
       | apparent once you talk to some experienced full-time bike
       | mechanics. As a hobbyist your scope is almost always rather
       | narrow, i.e. you may know all about how to repair your particular
       | model of bicycle, and perhaps a few others. In contrast a
       | professional will deal with dozens of models and will also know
       | who to contact for specialty jobs (some of the early suspension
       | bicycles, for example, require highly specialized tools that only
       | a few mechanics own and which are no longer produced).
       | 
       | It is sometimes possible that a hobbyist can find an entry point
       | to the professional world. Building wheels is something I've
       | recently been learning, but there are a lot of people who've been
       | doing that for over a decade and they can probably build a wheel
       | in 1/10th the time it would take me. Given the supply chain
       | backups and the scarcity of bike parts today, however, there
       | might be a little niche there.
       | 
       | Point being, the leap from hobbyist to professional in any area
       | can be a lot larger than it appears at first glance.
        
         | SnaggyJoker wrote:
         | Something you will find is that sometimes you can become
         | friends with the owners of the speciality shops and borrow
         | their tools. I have run into this in the automotive repair
         | field. Specifically when I was repairing foreign vehicles. Of
         | course some times the shop will charge you for the favor and
         | usually it is better to just recommend them for the service if
         | they have the availability. This can also help bolster your
         | friendship with them.
         | 
         | As far as monetizing something like wheel building, of course
         | the more experience you have the faster you will be at it. In
         | the end it is all about what the customers want, and they might
         | value having you do it over the more experienced person for
         | different (and possibly illogical) reasons than you might
         | think. It might even boil down to simple availability or your
         | location being more convenient.
         | 
         | Make sure you have proper insurance!
        
       | pmlnr wrote:
       | Never monetize your hobby. You'll end up hating it, whereas it's
       | supposed to charge you up.
        
       | ChrisMarshallNY wrote:
       | I like the "don't get caught up in metrics" approach.
       | 
       | I love what I do. Folks here, would call it a "hobby," because I
       | don't get paid for it, but I _guarantee_ that the folks I 'm
       | working with, don't see it that way. They are quite aware that I
       | have done hundreds of thousands of dollars' worth of top-shelf,
       | beyond-production-Quality work for them, for free.
       | 
       | I do work, for free, that would have a lot of startup founders
       | crying in their beer. I take it ultra-seriously, and do a highly
       | professional job. In fact, the professionalism of my approach is
       | one of the challenges that I set for myself.
       | 
       | I don't bother measuring myself. I may measure my code, but not
       | myself.
        
         | deebosong wrote:
         | I don't mean to pry, but it sounds like you have "retired" and
         | found your calling instead, if you are working for free, but
         | are 100% invested in the quality and professionalism? And that
         | you have your basic needs (and then some) pretty much covered?
         | 
         | If so that sounds amazing!
         | 
         | If I may prod a bit, why not take a salary in your situation?
         | Why work for free, especially when it's highly valued not only
         | by others, but to you as well, since you know what you're
         | giving, and work hard to maintain a high level of quality?
        
           | ChrisMarshallNY wrote:
           | It is amazing. I was forced into it, though. I found out (the
           | hard way) that no one wants to play with older folks. I'm
           | very fortunate that I had built up enough of a base to retire
           | early. It wasn't planned, but it was there. I just heard from
           | an ex-employee of mine, that he just got let go, and is
           | running smack-dab into this ageism issue. He's very, very
           | good, but he'll struggle like hell, and he doesn't have my
           | resources.
           | 
           | I do work for nonprofits. These are folks that can't afford
           | even crappy devs.
           | 
           | TBH, I get kind of a "screw you" kick from doing this. I was
           | willing to work for quite a bit lower wages than even kids
           | right out of school (if the work interested me), as I had my
           | retirement set, and I would have settled for having the bills
           | paid. I would have been absolutely ideal for startups.
           | 
           | But every company that I applied to, was more interested in
           | insulting me, and ignoring my portfolio, than in taking me
           | seriously.
        
             | deebosong wrote:
             | Wow that's kind of amazing.
             | 
             | Much respect. It's def inspiring and a very different way
             | to just view the world, and to do work that matters to you.
             | 
             | Warms my heart! haha. Old people rock!
        
               | ChrisMarshallNY wrote:
               | _> Old people rock!_
               | 
               | Not all of us. I do understand some of the animosity, but
               | it is _very_ self-destructive; especially when I see some
               | of these Jurassic-scale crash-and-burn disasters that
               | were entirely avoidable, if only one single person in
               | authority had been out of school for more than ten years.
               | 
               | I also have participated in a Service organization
               | (nonprofit) for most of my life, and a lot of the work
               | that I do is based around the community it Serves.
               | 
               | But I was just talking to a friend of mine, whose father
               | suffered a stroke, and we'll probably work on an iOS app
               | that will be designed to help with some of his rehab.
               | 
               | I like to help people that help people.
        
               | deebosong wrote:
               | Oops, for some reason I thought you were volunteering to
               | help older folks, hence my comment (expressing I am a fan
               | of the older cohort, as they carry much wisdom & grace).
               | Didn't mean to express the opposite!
               | 
               | Just to level the playing field, I've participated in
               | orgs with "younger" leadership and have been burned, and
               | also made my errors from my own arrogance/ lack of
               | experience. The "good" that came out of that was perhaps
               | a deeper appreciation for older folks (again I mistook
               | one of your previous comments as that you were
               | volunteering to help older folks - my mistake).
               | 
               | My own dad also still works, despite being way over
               | retirement age, and he helps those older than him as
               | well. I got nothing but respect for those who wanna serve
               | those that society often overlooks out of callousness and
               | overall lack of heart, so to speak.
               | 
               | Either way, really appreciate you sharing your insights/
               | experiences.
        
               | ChrisMarshallNY wrote:
               | What amused me, the most (except it wasn't really
               | amusing, at the time. Looking back, I'm ROTFLMAO), was
               | the recruiters.
               | 
               | I have a pretty heavy-duty resume. I've been _shipping_
               | (not just  "writing") software for over thirty-five
               | years, and have a fairly big portfolio (that really only
               | covers the last ten years of my work, and just the open-
               | source portion of it). I've written APIs that have lasted
               | 25 years. I do good work, and can prove it.
               | 
               | They would contact me, breathless and excited by my CV,
               | then ghost me, as soon as they figured out that I was
               | over 40.
               | 
               | I guess that math isn't a big requirement to be a
               | recruiter. The industry must be awash in 30-year-olds
               | with 35 years of experience.
               | 
               | These days, I just make it clear that I'm older, and they
               | stopped bothering me.
        
               | deebosong wrote:
               | Dang. Ageism sucks. Would be cool to have a culture
               | change where those with more years & experience are
               | honored, and seen as deep players on the team rather than
               | as outdated.
        
               | ChrisMarshallNY wrote:
               | Well, I think what's happened, is twenty-something-year-
               | old CEOs.
               | 
               | They may be brilliant, driven, creative, hardworking
               | people, but they Just. Don't. Have. Scars.
               | 
               | They never really had the chance to run face-first into
               | reality, while still in a position where the stakes are
               | low, and there's more experienced folks around, to help
               | them get back on their feet.
               | 
               | Their first mistakes are disasters, because they have it
               | all on the line.
               | 
               | In the past, the older folks had the money and power, but
               | were often locked up by caution, and lack of creativity.
               | 
               | The younger folks had the energy and creativity, but not
               | the sense of mortality. They needed the money and power
               | from the older folks, and the older folks needed that
               | creativity, and, for lack of a better word, recklessness,
               | that could drive their investments forward, so they had
               | to work together.
               | 
               | These days, it's pure recklessness. The first forays into
               | shipping are "bet the company," so failure is an E.L.E.
        
             | Damogran6 wrote:
             | This is why I stay at a job where I'm not working at my
             | optimum, isn't the best, isn't the worst, but also isn't me
             | looking for another job in my 50's.
        
       | qiskit wrote:
       | What'll you do for enjoyment then?
        
       | vonunov wrote:
       | Turning your hobby into your business is a very different move
       | from getting a _job_ in the field that your hobby suggests
        
         | draw_down wrote:
        
       | ed-209 wrote:
       | It sure is a fine line - putting your thing out to the world &
       | trying to make more of the world appreciate the thing more. My
       | hobby being an art, I get to experience this internal tug-of-war
       | with each new work. If I do nothing, I may be the only person on
       | earth to appreciate it, which feels really bad. If I promote with
       | the handful of inadequate tools at my disposal, I may become lost
       | in metrics and disappointed with cost/benefit.
        
       | daveaiello wrote:
       | The author has some good points.
       | 
       | What can look like a hobby to some people can be seen by the
       | creator as part of their mission in life, or a calling card that
       | is part of what makes the creator unique.
       | 
       | If you feel that way about something that doesn't monetarily pay
       | off, does that make it a hobby or something else?
       | 
       | A company in a tangential space approached me the other day for a
       | second time to discuss whether I could collaborate with them on
       | something that would make their service offering more complete.
       | 
       | For years I have been building an on-line resource that provides
       | information about an avocation of mine that I thought the on-line
       | world needed. Currently, that resource is very poorly monetized,
       | and its existence is financially supported by other consulting
       | and advisory work that I do for which I am fairly compensated.
       | 
       | At one level, this is totally a hobby. But at another, I always
       | believed that if I built this on-line resource that a group of
       | people and/or companies would find my work important, and I would
       | find a way for the work to pay off.
       | 
       | If a collaboration produces revenue in any amount, it's a
       | confirmation that my work has utility and value to others who
       | certainly are making money from a larger service offering.
        
         | hammock wrote:
         | Magic the gathering?
        
       | bradlys wrote:
       | I think something missing here is return on investment and
       | opportunity cost.
       | 
       | People here are using survivor bias to indicate what has went
       | from a hobby to a full time career. While nice - not relevant for
       | most young people these days. Truth is - very few can turn a
       | hobby into a real profitable profession. This isn't because they
       | lack talent, dedication, or smarts. It's because they lack timing
       | (being born when a house in SV wasn't $2.5m), lack the right
       | hobby to monetize (e.g. dancing - a notoriously poorly paying job
       | unless you're in the top 0.01%), or lack the social capital
       | necessary (again - many reasons for why this might not be
       | possible for you. Your race, gender, orientation, class, and
       | looks really could be holding you back here. In the case of
       | dancing - you often need to be good looking too).
       | 
       | If you're working in SF as a software eng making $400k/yr - just
       | enjoy your hobbies and stop trying to monetize them. If you're
       | struggling for money - leetcode, system design, and being a rule
       | following brown noser will do you 200x on your time investment.
       | 
       | Personally - I have no interest in trying to monetize my hobbies.
       | There's no chance they will ever have _any_ return on investment
       | that will make it worthwhile compared to what I get paid at my
       | job. They are for pleasure and for enrichment of the mind.
        
       | draw_down wrote:
        
       | makz wrote:
       | I don't understand how people monetize hobbies. For me a hobby
       | could be a very niche thing that only interests me and maybe a
       | dozen people in the world. Hard to monetize that.
        
         | lupire wrote:
         | Why so obscure?
        
         | Finnucane wrote:
         | In that case, you go into academia.
        
       | thowaway_420_69 wrote:
       | Turning your hobby into a business can get complicated, to the
       | extent that it could kill your passion for it. It is, in the end,
       | a commitment that requires hard work.
        
       | ahmed_ds wrote:
       | One key point here is how comfortable you are with pressure and
       | deadlines. Hobbies don't have deadlines but
       | clients/users/stakeholders do. No matter what value you provide
       | the hobby-centric approach of doing it on your own time, own pace
       | might not work out.
        
         | kQq9oHeAz6wLLS wrote:
         | That depends on the hobby you're monetizing, I think. For
         | instance, one of my hobbies is watchmaking (cleaning,
         | servicing, restoring). I don't do it for money, but those who
         | do don't really adhere to deadlines. It's all very open ended,
         | even for the large companies like Seiko and Rolex. They don't
         | guarantee a timeframe, and you won't know how long they'll have
         | it until they tell you they're sending it back.
         | 
         | I think this is partly because these are generally considered
         | luxury items rather than necessities, but also partly because
         | many regard the inner workings of a mechanical watch to be
         | magic.
        
       | floren wrote:
       | I've spent the last 5 months or so working on a custom-built
       | mouse, for the fun of it. Designed the PCB around a high-end
       | laser sensor, designed the case in FreeCAD, wrote the firmware.
       | I've made two so far and given one of them away. I'm planning to
       | make at least a few more. By the time I get 5 or 6 built, I'll
       | have probably spent $1000 on the project, although a majority of
       | that is a 3d printer.
       | 
       | I'm still not sure if I want to try and monetize that or not.
       | People have expressed interest in buying them, but I've actually
       | done the electronics production line thing in a long-ago
       | internship and I know that it really is a job. Also, it's not
       | like I'm going to be retiring off the proceeds of selling
       | weirdly-shaped 3-button wired mice with no scrollwheels, it's a
       | hell of a niche.
        
         | batperson wrote:
         | Sounds interesting. Got a picture or something ?
        
           | floren wrote:
           | http://jfloren.net/b/2022/3/2/0 has pictures and a video
        
       | karaterobot wrote:
       | > In a professional environment, it makes total sense to measure
       | time. Cheesy as it might sound, time is money for the
       | professional, and when your paycheck depends on how much work you
       | can do in a limited time span, time itself becomes a factor for
       | optimization. But when the main reason you're doing it is because
       | you love doing it, time becomes the gun you shoot yourself in the
       | foot with.
       | 
       | Except that if you do that, you're a dilettante, not a craftsman.
       | If you take on a project to fix somebody's bike, and you take
       | your time so as not to stress yourself out, your customer is
       | going to be pissed off at you: they want their bike fixed, that's
       | why they're paying you money that they earned doing things that
       | stressed them out. You should feel a sense of obligation when you
       | take someone's money: not an obligation to chase your own sense
       | of joy, but to do the thing they paid you to do.
       | 
       | That's why I think turning your hobby into a job (which is what
       | you do when you take money for it, no matter what you want to
       | call it) is a bad idea. The author dismisses it as a cliche, or
       | as bullshit, but it's the most valid argument against what
       | they're saying: making your hobby your job means it's not your
       | hobby anymore.
       | 
       | If you have a lot of money -- enough to lose it on a failing
       | business -- it's okay to be a dilettante, take your time, and
       | appeal only to a small number of customers. If you have a lot of
       | hobbies, and can afford to sacrifice one of them to make it a
       | real profession that pays your bills, while getting your pleasure
       | in other areas, then that's fine too. But if you have one big
       | thing you love doing, you will _probably_ stop getting the same
       | kind of pleasure from it if it becomes your full time job. This
       | isn 't true in every case, but in the majority of cases it is.
        
       | xwdv wrote:
       | Monetizing a hobby is like monetizing your wife. Things will
       | never really be the same afterwards, even if you decide to
       | demonetize.
        
       | blantonl wrote:
       | Ah, the old phrase "my avocation is my vocation"
       | 
       | I'm very blessed to be able to tell people this. When I was
       | growing up, my grandmother had a radio scanner in her small town
       | Virginia home, and I was fascinated that you could listen in on
       | what the police and fire departments were doing on a daily basis.
       | My parents bought me a radio scanner a few years later and as a
       | young boy I followed the rabbit hole of radio communications,
       | scanners, and listening in to police, fire, aircraft, amateur
       | radio etc.
       | 
       | Fast forward many years: I'm well established in a career as an
       | IBM System Engineer, and during my downtime in the 90's, I
       | thought it would be really neat if, instead of purchasing books
       | with radio frequencies, it would be pretty cool if you could
       | search on the WWW for this data. This was back in the day when
       | this data was just starting to be made available on dial-up BBSs,
       | but this new WWW thing was becoming more and more popular.
       | 
       | Mind you, I still pursued my hobby of radios and scanners, and
       | had lots of expensive equipment to listen to everything around
       | me. All the while taking multiple conference calls with IBM
       | customers and generally doing my "day" job from home.
       | 
       | So, one week I sat down and taught myself Perl and MySQL. Created
       | an online database, solicited people over Usenet to submit data
       | to the new site, and RadioReference.com was born.
       | 
       | Fast forward to today. RadioReference.com is my avocation and
       | vocation, I get to stay home and develop and manage my business
       | which is also my hobby. And we did some amazing innovation which
       | resulted in Broadcastify.com, which allows you to listen to
       | police scanners all over the world without ever having to buy a
       | complex radio.
       | 
       | So, yes, you can monetize your hobby, and this article really
       | resonates. I never made it about the money, but my business is
       | wildly successful and I can definitely tell you that I am living
       | the dream :)
        
         | AviationAtom wrote:
         | But now many jurisdictions are choosing to go full-encrypted,
         | because of people showing up to the scene and getting in the
         | way. :-/
        
         | victorstanciu wrote:
         | I feel like you might like one of my previous posts too
         | (https://tegowerk.eu/posts/serendipity/). The trajectory of my
         | life has also been shaped and defined by a series of decisions
         | and events which didn't seem at all momentous at the time :)
        
         | bitxbitxbitcoin wrote:
         | Just wanted to thank you for your work! I got my Technician
         | license last year and your site was one of the resources that I
         | found as a result.
        
         | mooreds wrote:
         | That is awesome, congrats!
         | 
         | I wonder what percentage of people of working age have this
         | privilege (or more precisely, have earned it!).
        
         | mod wrote:
         | I've used your site several times, thanks!
        
       | AussieWog93 wrote:
       | I've monetised my hobbies three times so far.
       | 
       | All three times it has become lucrative, but none of them are
       | hobbies any more.
       | 
       | One of the important things along the way I've learned is that
       | what makes hobbies relaxing and fun isn't about the specific task
       | you're doing but the fact that it's about enjoying the process of
       | making/doing rather than feeling pressure to deliver the end
       | result.
       | 
       | That's not to say I have any regrets about what I did - it's
       | turned into a pair of businesses that are interesting and
       | challenging in their own way while bringing in some serious coin
       | - but the whole adage about "do what you love and you'll never
       | work another day in your life" doesn't apply to running a small
       | business.
        
         | rockbruno wrote:
         | I agree with this sentiment. I started taking sponsorships for
         | my blog and it very quickly sucked the fun away from it. I now
         | felt like I couldn't do whatever I wanted because I needed to
         | optimize the sponsor's time and post content to make them feel
         | like it was worth it. In other words, it became a boring job.
        
         | is_true wrote:
         | A hobbie with dates isn't a hobbie.
         | 
         | I also successfuly monetized my hobbies.
        
           | scrapcode wrote:
           | Interesting tidbit that obviously has plenty of objections.
           | However, I do feel that this is the biggest barrier to my
           | progress in one of my hobbies, jiu-jitsu. I have plenty of
           | time to dedicate 10+ hours a week to fitness, but it is the
           | aspect of having a set time that seems to limit when I can,
           | or want to go.
        
         | nicolas_t wrote:
         | Which hobbies did you monetize? I'm curious. I'm guessing
         | EspoTek Labrador is one of them (which I'll be sure to remember
         | when I get back into electronics)
        
         | agumonkey wrote:
         | > All three times it has become lucrative, but none of them are
         | hobbies any more.
         | 
         | I regularly wonder how to balance the intrinsic pleasure with
         | extrinsic value. I keep thinking that people could meet on the
         | point where both find great pleasure in this venture. Something
         | rare in the current economy it seems.
        
           | bombcar wrote:
           | One way to do it have the hobby be something that's entirely
           | yours (you carve intricate models of Vietnamese railway cays
           | say) and someone else sells them, almost without any
           | communication as to "what is selling etc".
           | 
           | Never take orders.
        
             | agumonkey wrote:
             | kinda like agents and artists ?
        
               | bombcar wrote:
               | The hard part is finding an agent who will not try to
               | convince you to do things to increase profits.
               | 
               | But yes, some artists have famously gone through
               | intermediaries such that there isn't a feedback loop
               | possible.
        
           | kqr wrote:
           | It's hard because extrinsic motivation kills intrinsic
           | motivation (see _Drive_ for some of the behavioural science
           | here). Once you start putting a monetary reward on things,
           | people in general lose the interest in doing them for their
           | own sake.
           | 
           | So I think for this to work, you have to go full
           | collectivist: gather up a bunch of people interested in
           | different things, produce stuff for each other and divide
           | equally with no money being involved in the transaction.
        
         | mooreds wrote:
         | > the whole adage about "do what you love and you'll never work
         | another day in your life" doesn't apply to running a small
         | business.
         | 
         | Is that because when you turn a hobby into a business there are
         | lots of non-hobby tasks and requirements? Like sales,
         | marketing, etc, etc?
         | 
         | Or because of the pressure of delivering the result?
         | 
         | Or for some other reason?
        
           | egypturnash wrote:
           | My experience as someone who loves drawing and does often
           | delightedly remind herself that her day job is _sitting
           | around a park drawing shit_ :
           | 
           | basically, yes, all of these reasons apply.
           | 
           | I'm good at _drawing_ , not at selling myself; my work sells
           | itself to a certain degree but that only gets you so far. Not
           | everything I'm paid to draw is a thing I love to draw,
           | either. And sometimes even a thing I love to draw becomes
           | less fun when it has to meet someone else's approval; going
           | back and forth with a client is a very different feeling than
           | "I start drawing and I fix things I don't like until I'm
           | happy with the piece".
           | 
           | Deadlines suck and I mostly arrange my work so as not to have
           | any. Yes, this is a luxury. It probably means less money but
           | I make enough to get by.
        
           | earth_walker wrote:
           | Most hobbies doesn't have sales, marketing, taxes, regulatory
           | mandated recordkeeping, deadlines, people yelling at you, or
           | "regular business hours". Businesses have most if not all of
           | these.
        
           | WJW wrote:
           | Hobbies are almost by definition not mandatory activities.
           | Earning money to eat and pay the mortgage is not really
           | optional. Making the hobby activity mandatory will make it
           | feel a lot more like work and a lot less like a "fun"
           | activity. It might not be as bad as working in an Amazon
           | warehouse, but it'll be a job all the same.
           | 
           | Worst case, if you get burned out on the new job you will not
           | only no longer have a job but also won't enjoy your hobby
           | anymore.
        
       ___________________________________________________________________
       (page generated 2022-04-23 23:01 UTC)