[HN Gopher] Raising a Stink
       ___________________________________________________________________
        
       Raising a Stink
        
       Author : horseradish
       Score  : 65 points
       Date   : 2021-11-24 17:21 UTC (5 hours ago)
        
 (HTM) web link (www.guernicamag.com)
 (TXT) w3m dump (www.guernicamag.com)
        
       | dsizzle wrote:
       | > Going to the bathroom at a friend's house was an act of
       | generosity. It was like leaving a gift.
       | 
       | An idea just in time for Christmas season!
        
         | mattbee wrote:
         | Startup idea: toilets that issue receipts.
         | 
         | I don't know what for, the market will find a way.
        
           | pokoleo wrote:
           | NFTs
        
           | dharmab wrote:
           | It already exists as a curiosity: A toilet that uses waste as
           | fuel for a bioreactor and pays "users" in a cryptocurrency:
           | https://www.reuters.com/world/asia-pacific/south-korean-
           | toil...
        
         | ciconia wrote:
         | Come visit us - we have composting toilets in our home.
         | Seriously, when people visit and leave such gifts it makes me
         | very happy - more organic matter that will return to our
         | garden.
         | 
         | Using composting toilets in the last 5,5 years has changed our
         | relationship with our waste, and with other waste like cow or
         | horse manure. The disgust subsides and you learn to handle it
         | just like any other raw material. Humanure is really valuable
         | for gardening and fertilizing your soil.
        
           | dsizzle wrote:
           | What does the end result look and smell like after it's done
           | composting? How long does that take? I always thought
           | composting toilets were mostly practical in trailers and
           | other non-full-time locations so it's interesting you've
           | adopted this in your home! One other advantage must be not
           | worrying about clogs?
        
           | bargle0 wrote:
           | How do you maintain food safety? Using human waste seems
           | dangerous. Harmful bacteria would be part of it, but I'd
           | worry about accumulating pharmaceuticals, etc., in it, which
           | feudal Japanese people probably didn't have to worry about.
        
         | praptak wrote:
         | It's better to give than to receive.
        
       | d883kd8 wrote:
       | I wonder if it will be like this when people live in space
        
         | pugworthy wrote:
         | Worked for Mark Whatley.
        
         | anthonygd wrote:
         | Feels like a clear cut answer: Yes.
        
         | bckr wrote:
         | Yes. That we don't do this on the ISS is a shame, and an
         | opportunity.
        
       | InfiniteRand wrote:
       | I don't think cities providing manure for farming communities is
       | unique to Japan, my understanding is it was standard for cities
       | until modern era
       | 
       | Bret Devereaux mentions it in his description of pre-modern
       | cities https://acoup.blog/2019/07/12/collections-the-lonely-city-
       | pa...
        
       | LennyHenrysNuts wrote:
       | I understand there are some health concerns about using human
       | fertiliser for food with particular regard to the spread of
       | disease.
       | 
       | It worked well for the Japanese - I wonder if these health
       | concerns are really just our squeamishness?
        
         | rmason wrote:
         | In Michigan it's against the law to fertilize crops with human
         | waste. Actually knew a farmer in the seventies who got caught
         | and was fined for doing it. The reason is because it can spread
         | disease causing pathogens to the crop.
         | 
         | I'm not certain how the Japanese got around that. Or perhaps
         | people got sick from it and they hadn't yet figured out the
         | cause.
        
       | blamazon wrote:
       | In the Boston metro area, a portion of the 'sludge' from the MWRA
       | Deer Island water treatment plant gets piped underneath the
       | Boston Harbor to Quincy, MA where it is turned into fertilizer
       | pellets and sold to the public. Very popular for golf courses.
       | 
       | https://www.mwra.com/03sewer/html/sewssc.htm
        
       ___________________________________________________________________
       (page generated 2021-11-24 23:01 UTC)