[HN Gopher] Amazon's Older Kindles Will Start to Lose Their Inte...
       ___________________________________________________________________
        
       Amazon's Older Kindles Will Start to Lose Their Internet Access in
       December
        
       Author : theduder99
       Score  : 190 points
       Date   : 2021-07-29 16:05 UTC (6 hours ago)
        
 (HTM) web link (www.theverge.com)
 (TXT) w3m dump (www.theverge.com)
        
       | pgrote wrote:
       | This is for cellular connections.
       | 
       | "Amazon's Kindle e-readers with built-in 3G will begin to lose
       | the ability to connect to the internet on their own in the US in
       | December, according to an email sent to customers on Wednesday.
       | The change is due to mobile carriers transitioning from older 2G
       | and 3G networking technology to newer 4G and 5G networks. For
       | older Kindles without Wi-Fi, this change could mean not
       | connecting to the internet at all."
        
         | floatboth wrote:
         | Huh, they made _cellular-only_ models? That 's such a bizzare
         | idea.
        
           | hellotomyrars wrote:
           | It _kind of_ made sense at the time. I have a Kindle DX, and
           | that came out in 2009. Wifi was less ubiquitous and more
           | terrible, and the idea with the Kindle anyways is you could
           | be anywhere and buy a book, and it would just work.
           | 
           | It did open up some very interesting homebrew applications
           | too!
           | 
           | Also the early models with WiFi had the absolute worst radios
           | and constantly tripped over themselves. When I worked for
           | Centurylink in/around 2011 one of the most common issues with
           | wifi was Kindle devices. Thankfully most customers could
           | figure that if their 3-5 other devices were connected and
           | working, the issue was their Kindle, and not the CPE.
        
             | ghaff wrote:
             | WiFi was pretty terrible for quite a while after it came
             | out in general. I remember, in the early to mid 2000s, the
             | Intel Developers Forums had desks set up to try to help
             | press and analysts get, often plug-in PCMCIA card, WiFi
             | working. And it was almost certain to fall over during
             | general sessions anyway--well some things mostly don't
             | change.
             | 
             | But if you actually needed a working network connection in
             | the press room, you plugged an Ethernet cable into your
             | laptop.
        
           | ssully wrote:
           | It was actually wonderful. My girlfriend at the time, now
           | wife, had a grandmother who was an avid reader but didn't own
           | a computer or have internet. They were able to get her to
           | switch to a Kindle because of the cellular delivery feature.
           | She was able to figure out how to buy stuff directly from the
           | device, but I always thought it was neat how they could buy
           | Grandma books and have the auto delivered to her a device.
        
           | Cd00d wrote:
           | I pre-ordered the first Kindle and knowing that I could order
           | a book from my airplane seat for a flight before they closed
           | the cabin door was a huge gratifier for me!
        
           | filmgirlcw wrote:
           | In 2007, putting WiFi and cellular in the same radio stack
           | was a real challenge. The iPhone was one of the first phones
           | to have both radios in it -- a handful of other devices did
           | too, but it was really rare. Heck, I remember it took years
           | for BlackBerry to successfully ship a phone with both 3G and
           | WiFi (as opposed to having to choose between WiFi and 2G or
           | only a 3G connection).
           | 
           | The big selling point of the first Kindle was the idea that
           | you could access the store to download stuff anywhere. WiFi
           | wasn't ubiquitous like it is now (and even now, it isn't as
           | ubiquitous as I think we all would have hoped), which made
           | having a free 2G connection really nice, especially when
           | outdoors in areas that the E Ink display really shined.
        
           | michaelbuckbee wrote:
           | At the time it was pretty clever as WiFi wasn't as ubiquitous
           | and the bandwidth used by them was so low.
        
           | ghaff wrote:
           | The cellular was included with the device. I'd have to
           | stretch my mind back but WiFi wasn't as ubiquitous, as easy
           | to use, or as cheap to implement as today.
        
             | sumtechguy wrote:
             | Don't know why but this reminds me of one support ticket on
             | those things. 'i can not download any books' 'uh sir
             | according to our data you are 10 miles off the coast of
             | florida?' 'oh yeah I am on my boat' 'do you see any cell
             | towers?' 'no' 'they need those to work' 'ohhhhh'
             | 
             | We were surprised that it even had enough signal to figure
             | out the GPS cords.
             | 
             | Even back then cell coverage was not as good as it is now.
             | So many times it was 'go stand at the end of your driveway
             | and try'.
        
               | ghaff wrote:
               | >So many times it was 'go stand at the end of your
               | driveway and try'.
               | 
               | Like my dad's house in Maine today :-)
               | 
               | In the early years of the iPhone in the US, there was--
               | including on this site I imagine--much wailing and
               | gnashing of teeth over AT&T's coverage.
        
               | sumtechguy wrote:
               | Think with early kindle it was altel and sprint. Verizon
               | buying altel fixed a lot of that issue. But there were
               | still gaps.
        
           | jhbadger wrote:
           | Amazon was targeting book readers who may not have been
           | computer users, so they wouldn't necessarily have Wifi (or
           | any Internet) at home. The cellular connection (which was
           | free and not dependent on any data plan of the user) allowed
           | the user to purchase and download books, and so paid Amazon
           | for the very small amount of data used given that a typical
           | book is only a couple of megabytes.
        
             | Nition wrote:
             | You could also plug it in via USB if you needed to transfer
             | data another way.
        
             | ghaff wrote:
             | Home broadband connectivity was only about 2/3 of where it
             | was today. The iPhone was _just_ rolling out.
             | 
             | As much to the point, Amazon was also very much aiming for
             | the use case of the business traveler who wanted to buy a
             | book before hopping on the plane in an airport that
             | probably didn't have WiFi and almost certainly didn't have
             | free WiFi.
             | 
             | I won't say 2007 was the stone ages. But a lot of things we
             | mostly just take for granted today didn't exist or were
             | relatively nascent.
        
               | Dylan16807 wrote:
               | I don't think a Kindle would need broadband, though there
               | probably weren't all that many dial-up connections
               | plugged into wifi routers.
        
               | ghaff wrote:
               | Right. You don't need the bandwidth. But while it's
               | presumably possible, also presumably almost no home users
               | had WiFi before they got broadband.
        
               | tomjen3 wrote:
               | We didn't but we did have a LAN. That was probably a
               | special case though.
        
         | vessel wrote:
         | TheVerge purposefully left that out of the headline for
         | clickbait. It's really not hard to write "Amazon's Older 2G/3G
         | Kindles" or "Lose Their Cellular Connections"
        
           | jjeaff wrote:
           | I know that with many publications, the journalists don't get
           | to pick their own headlines. There has been a lot of talk
           | about how journalism is dead, but I have found that often,
           | the article is well done, but the headline paints an
           | inaccurate or divisive picture. I think the editors and maybe
           | the MBAs are more of a problem than the journalists.
        
           | eli wrote:
           | Also really buried the fact that you are eligible for a free
           | upgrade to a new Kindle
        
             | echelon wrote:
             | It's not free? You get a $50 coupon.
        
               | eli wrote:
               | Depends which model I guess
        
               | prophesi wrote:
               | From the article:
               | 
               | For customers with Kindle (1st Generation), Amazon is
               | offering a free Kindle Oasis (10th Generation) device and
               | cover.
               | 
               | Customers with Kindle (1st and 2nd Generation), Kindle DX
               | (2nd Generation), and Kindle Keyboard (3rd Generation)
               | can receive $70 off a new Kindle Paperwhite or Kindle
               | Oasis, plus $25 in ebook credits.
               | 
               | Customers with Kindle Touch (4th Generation), Kindle
               | Paperwhite (5th Generation, 6th Generation, and 7th
               | Generation), Kindle Voyage (7th Generation), and Kindle
               | Oasis (8th Generation) can receive $50 off a new Kindle
               | Paperwhite or Kindle Oasis, plus $15 in ebook credits.
        
               | renewiltord wrote:
               | This is a _tremendous_ deal. Makes me so confident in
               | buying first gen Amazon products. The Oasis is their high
               | end reader. I have one and it's better than the normal
               | kindles by far.
        
               | filmgirlcw wrote:
               | Getting a $250 device and cover for a device first sold
               | in 2007 is pretty great, honestly. Even getting $50 off a
               | Kindle and $15 credit is a pretty good option, all things
               | considered.
        
               | vbsteven wrote:
               | I'm not familiar with their product line but from reading
               | just this comment I would guess that old devices that
               | lose connectivity get a full new device and devices with
               | WiFi losing partial connectivity get coupons and credit
               | for their inconvenience (caused out of Amazons hands
               | through the carriers)
               | 
               | That sounds like a fair deal to me. Although it's pure
               | speculation. I haven't checked if that is actually the
               | case.
        
               | cmiles74 wrote:
               | I have a DX, as far as I can tell it does not have any
               | WiFi capability. It's only network connectivity is
               | cellular.
        
               | Cd00d wrote:
               | That's very generous.
               | 
               | And, now I'm kicking myself for dropping my 1st gen
               | Kindle off at the e-waste recycler!
        
               | kreddor wrote:
               | Doesn't "Kindle (1st and 2nd Generation)" include "Kindle
               | (1st Generation)"? Getting a new device is a pretty nice
               | gesture though I guess very few still have a working 1st
               | generation Kindle.
        
           | rchaud wrote:
           | It never occurred to me that the headline meant anything
           | other than Whispersync, which uses 2G/3G bands.
        
             | deadmutex wrote:
             | Kudos to you?
             | 
             | Clearly, a lot of people felt like the headline was
             | misleading.
        
               | dhosek wrote:
               | I think a lot depends on whether you actually had one of
               | those early generation kindles or not. I saw the headline
               | and figured it was about WhisperSync and guessed it was
               | probably due to sunsetting of the cellular networks and
               | not Amazon turning off a feature to get people to
               | upgrade.
        
           | [deleted]
        
           | Rd6n6 wrote:
           | Seems like a good opportunity to ask: what are some news
           | agencies that do not use deliberately misleading headlines?
           | For the blizzard thread, Bloomberg was the only article I saw
           | linked with an accurate title
        
           | echelon wrote:
           | The default Kindle models did not have WiFi for several
           | years. That cost an extra $30-50 or so.
           | 
           | I remember thinking at the time that hacking these would make
           | nice sensors to deploy in the field and that they could stay
           | online for free, essentially. Kindle had a built-in web
           | browser, so HTTP calls wouldn't be too hard to make.
           | 
           | Controversial HN opinion: ten years ago everyone would be up
           | in arms about this change. Something happened. We no longer
           | care about device obsolescence. It's like our concept of
           | ownership and longevity has been stripped from us.
           | 
           | You stream music instead of owning it, you download games
           | instead of owning physical copies, devices are locked down,
           | you can't run software you want, and we tolerate devices no
           | longer working after a certain date.
           | 
           | It's _okay_ if things stop working, because they weren 't
           | meant to work forever. It's sad.
        
             | laGrenouille wrote:
             | Well, that's not exactly what is happening here. Devices
             | will still work after the internet connection stops, books
             | will still be readable, and it will still be possible to
             | load books through USB (or in some cases WiFi). The free
             | cellular connection was an extra service that was clearly
             | part of the sale pitch but I doubt most people who bought
             | these expected that component to last forever.
             | 
             | Also, there is a clear reason they are turning these off
             | (dropping on 2G and 3G coverage) as opposed to companies
             | that needlessly brick devices just because they turned off
             | a easy-to-maintain DRM server somewhere without an
             | alternative recourse.
        
               | johannes1234321 wrote:
               | I'm fascinated how long they support that feature (while
               | I haven't seen a software update on my old kindle for a
               | while)
               | 
               | That feature was quite nice while travelling as it got me
               | free Wikipedia everywhere, which is nice to read up on
               | sights etc.
        
             | filmgirlcw wrote:
             | > Controversial HN opinion: ten years ago everyone would be
             | up in arms about this change. Something happened. We no
             | longer care about device obsolescence. It's like our
             | concept of ownership and longevity has been stripped from
             | us.
             | 
             | I don't think this is true at all. Ten years ago, we had
             | already gone through the analog to digital transition in a
             | number of countries [1], obsoleting a lot of older
             | television sets without the aid of a converter box.
             | 
             | In the US, TDMA and AMPS cellular networks were shut down
             | by 2008 (TDMA shutdown started even earlier), obsoleting
             | tons of early cellular phones, but also many phones from
             | the early 2000s (again, TDMA). People were often given
             | vouchers by carriers IIRC, since phones were largely
             | subsidized by rate plans.
             | 
             | DIVX, a terrible DVD rental scheme that helped put Circuit
             | City out of business, went under by 1999, leaving the
             | devices essentially worthless (fortunately, most did
             | receive a firmware update allowing them to be used as
             | regular DVD players).
             | 
             | I'm sure there were some grumbles about some of this stuff
             | (people were very mad about TV, even though converters were
             | given away for free), but it is largely accepted that
             | progress obsoletes certain technologies. This isn't new.
        
               | tomjen3 wrote:
               | TV updates coincided with the changeover to HD tv so I
               | don't think people really cared - it ruined my portable
               | since it had a builtin antenna, but that was that.
               | 
               | However there has been many more fights about turning of
               | the FM signals, at least here in Denmark, mostly because
               | people can't upgrade the radio in their cars easily but
               | probably also because the new type of radio is a lot
               | worse than FM. So now we have both.
               | 
               | I suspect that when/if they turn it of people won't get a
               | new radio and will just play music from their phones.
        
               | jhoechtl wrote:
               | Thank you for the comment. As a ham radio operator and
               | radio junky in general I was wondering how the transition
               | to all dab+ went for Denmark. Here in Austria we have
               | both (more important and larger stations not receivable
               | via dab though) and my car head unit has both. I find the
               | sound of dab awful (to much compression and artefacts)
               | and on fringe areas it pales compared to FM which will
               | deteriorate in quality but still be continuously
               | receivable. DAB just stutters. A real set back at least
               | when used mobile.
        
               | filmgirlcw wrote:
               | Yeah, the timing of HD Radio coincided with the rise of
               | smartphones/iPods/nascent streaming, so it didn't really
               | take off in the US (and there was never a huge reason to
               | b/c the FCC didn't shut off analog radio waves), but I do
               | agree that if they cut off analog radio signal (or more
               | accurately, if more stations moved to a pure digital
               | format), some subset of users would complain (tho less as
               | you said, thanks to phones), but that's sort of my point:
               | this obsolescence acceptance thing isn't new, it's how
               | we've treated the changing nature of tech for decades.
               | Yes, there might be fewer loud neckbeards who are irate
               | online about it, but the fantasy that we used to all care
               | a lot more about the longevity of devices and tech just
               | isn't true.
        
             | dhosek wrote:
             | I'm pretty sure my first cell phones from the 90s and 00s
             | won't work anymore because the networks no longer exist. I
             | should get out the pitchforks and torches. I think there
             | might not even be cellular network access for my first
             | iPhone anymore.
        
             | Wowfunhappy wrote:
             | > Ten years ago everyone would be up in arms about this
             | change. Something happened. We no longer care about device
             | obsolescence. It's like our concept of ownership and
             | longevity has been stripped from us.
             | 
             | Broadly speaking, I absolutely agree. People are impressed
             | that Apple supports 6-year-old iPhones, whereas I think
             | that's an unconscionably short length of time. (
             | _Particularly_ given how Apple makes customers reliant on
             | them for everything.)
             | 
             |  _However_ , in the case of these Kindles, I'm a bit more
             | sympathetic to Amazon here. They're not the ones who are
             | turning off 3G networks, so I'm not really sure what they
             | could do.
        
               | ghaff wrote:
               | And they're actually giving pretty reasonable promo
               | codes.
               | 
               | For some reason, I didn't get one--probably because my
               | device is no longer registered on Amazon.com. Not that I
               | have any real reason to run out and buy a new Kindle
               | anyway.
        
               | LorenPechtel wrote:
               | A lot better than than what happened with my TracDot
               | luggage trackers with lifetime service. They were 2G
               | based and simply died when the 2G went away.
        
           | spike021 wrote:
           | The Verge really fell off a cliff after the first year they
           | launched.
           | 
           | I guess that's too tangential for this post, though.
        
             | knolan wrote:
             | In fairness their attempt at building a PC was at least
             | entertaining.
        
               | httpsterio wrote:
               | Rarely have I ever seen a serious tutorial or guide be so
               | wrong on so many levels. I was flabbergasted, entertained
               | and felt pity at the same time. Truly a train wreck of a
               | video, would strongly recommend watching.
        
               | arthurcolle wrote:
               | Link? This sounds funny. Like a "The Verge" branded pc?
        
               | detaro wrote:
               | No, just one of their people making a video showing "how
               | to build a custom gaming PC" and ... not doing a
               | particularly good job of it. After a few days of mocking
               | they took the video down, and then a while later made
               | sure everyone remembered again by copyright-striking some
               | Youtubers that had made reaction videos using material
               | from the original video. "the verge PC build" on youtube
               | should find stuff.
        
           | Wowfunhappy wrote:
           | Seeing as how many of these older Kindles lack wifi (or any
           | other way to get online), I actually find your headline more
           | misleading.
           | 
           | Headlines are hard.
        
             | [deleted]
        
             | [deleted]
        
       | NelsonMinar wrote:
       | Minor nit, but the article talks about "an old-fashioned micro-
       | USB cable". That'd be _mini_ -USB cable for many of the oldest
       | Kindles and Amazon stuck with that connector for far longer than
       | most manufacturers (it's apparently prone to mechanical failure).
       | I still have to keep one of these cables around for my old
       | Kindles and it's a nuisance.
        
         | franciscop wrote:
         | Rumors of a "new Kindle with USB-C" have been going around for
         | years. Hopefully this year is _the year_.
        
       | WalterBright wrote:
       | I just tried the "Experimental" browser on my Kindle Keyboard and
       | DX. It won't connect to many sites, with an error message about
       | being unable to establish a secure connection. I presume it's
       | because the migration to https left them behind.
       | 
       | Unfortunately, Amazon has provided no updates to address this.
       | The DX cannot connect to Amazon update because it can't establish
       | a secure connection.
        
       | reflexe wrote:
       | Alternative title: "3g is old and going away" What a crappy
       | clickbait.
        
       | WalterBright wrote:
       | > according to an email sent to customers on Wednesday ... check
       | your email for a promo code
       | 
       | I have 7 or 8 Kindles, and Amazon sends me email all the time.
       | But not this one.
        
         | impute wrote:
         | I'm the owner of a 3rd gen with 3G but haven't received an
         | email either. Wow, it was 10 years ago this month I bought it.
        
           | asciimov wrote:
           | I have the same 3rd gen. I got my $70 offer emailed to me
           | late last night.
           | 
           | Maybe they are slowly rolling out emails.
        
         | okamiueru wrote:
         | Out of curiosity, are any of them affected models?
        
           | WalterBright wrote:
           | Most of them are affected, like my precious DX.
        
             | Terretta wrote:
             | DX owner, active, no email.
        
         | mdavidn wrote:
         | I have an impacted Voyage and did not receive the message
         | either. Perhaps they only notified customers that use 3G? I
         | always have mine connected to WiFi to extend battery life.
        
       | maerF0x0 wrote:
       | > the only way to get new content onto your device will be
       | through an old-fashioned micro-USB cable.
       | 
       | This makes it a non story. The device is old, you can still
       | download things and get them on the device. Moving along.
        
         | gnicholas wrote:
         | If this were a smooth process, I would agree. But a relative of
         | mine, who is a retired computer science professor, was unable
         | to sideload books onto his Kindle. I worked with him to
         | troubleshoot it, and it took us nearly an hour to complete the
         | transfer.
        
           | mabub24 wrote:
           | Have they changed something? It shows up in your
           | finder/explorer as a drive like any other USB drive. You can
           | drag and drop books into the documents folder.
           | 
           | If it's azw3 stuff, push it through Calibre to mobi, then
           | drag and drop like anything else.
        
             | gnicholas wrote:
             | IIRC, it wouldn't even show up. We uninstalled/reinstalled
             | the software on his Windows computer, wiped the device, and
             | tried several different USB cables. It was some mix of
             | these steps that finally got it working.
        
           | maerF0x0 wrote:
           | I've noticed devices seem to be doing away with basic
           | computing primitives. File systems for example. Opening a
           | file in a program should be a simple feature, but lately it
           | seems that they deny you the opportunity to target what it is
           | you want to open....
           | 
           | (yes of course it's still a file system under the hood, but
           | it's abstracted away by a less powerful gui)
        
       | Foobar8568 wrote:
       | Well as an European who bought the kindle keyboard back in 2011,
       | I received nothing :(
        
         | AnssiH wrote:
         | Well, presumably in your country 2G and/or 3G still works.
         | 
         | At least here in Finland, while 3G shutdowns are planned by
         | most major carriers, 2G shutdown is probably at least a decade
         | away - the 2G network has slightly better coverage in some
         | rural regions, and there are a lot of M2M 2G data users (like
         | electricity meters - those installed over 10 years ago
         | generally use 2G, which is the majority of electricity meters
         | overall).
         | 
         | Large books will take some time to download over 2G, though...
        
       | patwolf wrote:
       | I always suspected this day would come for my 2nd gen Kindle. I
       | still remember getting it over a decade ago and feeling that
       | there was something magical about having content delivered to it
       | wirelessly. Now that smartphones and smart devices are ubiquitous
       | it seems mundane, but at the time it was amazing.
        
       | amerkhalid wrote:
       | I absolutely love Kindle Keyboard, in fact, even more than my
       | Kindle Oasis. Luckily, it has WiFi. But if needed, I rather use
       | cable to transfer content than give it up. Hoping one day we will
       | have another non-touch screen Kindle.
        
       | kweks wrote:
       | Now that it's closing, it seems safe to reveal - the SIM cards
       | from these kindles made for the best emergency data SIM that
       | money could (not) buy.
       | 
       | Everything passed via an http proxy, with a key that could be
       | easily extracted from the Kindle via SSH.
       | 
       | The SIM worked globally - I'd used it in China, Iran, Iraq, etc -
       | all sorts of places that normally are not covered by providers.
       | 
       | At some point others must have abused the system, because the
       | unlimited data got capped to 150MB a month, but in a pinch, it
       | was an incredible tool.
       | 
       | Ditto with first generation Lime scooters that had unlocked
       | global twillio SIMs ...
        
         | azca wrote:
         | this was one of the main reasons I acquired the kindle keyboard
         | :) worked excellent as an emergency device when you _needed_ to
         | rebook travel things with nothing else around.
        
         | mabbo wrote:
         | I was an Amazon intern in 2011 and there was another intern I
         | met at a party who told me about this fact. We all thought it
         | was hilarious.
         | 
         | His entire intern project was a small piece of the system being
         | built to detect abuse of these SIMs and stop it. Given it's a
         | decade later now, I doubt it still works or works for very
         | long.
        
           | kweks wrote:
           | I can't even begin to imagine the bills that were racked up
           | via this and others (like the Lime SIMs)..
           | 
           | For the Lime SIMs, there was a day when the pipe was turned
           | off - I can imagine it was the day someone looked into their
           | twillio billing in detail..
        
             | simonebrunozzi wrote:
             | I'm pretty sure Amazon agreed to a fixed fee from a number
             | of carriers, and moved on. The few outliars might have
             | costed a few $M over the years, which is a rounding error
             | for Amazon.
        
         | renewiltord wrote:
         | If you have a Google Fi connection, their extra data SIMs are
         | perfect. Zero extra cost and you get global roaming.
        
           | dharmab wrote:
           | Even the Fi roaming doesn't include US embargoed areas like
           | Iran.
        
             | renewiltord wrote:
             | Oooh I didn't know that. Good observation. Thank you.
        
         | encoderer wrote:
         | Yeah, must have been those "others" abusing the system while
         | all you were doing was accessing free data in China, Iran and
         | Iraq!
         | 
         | Seriously, though, great comment!
        
           | amelius wrote:
           | They said: " _emergency_ data SIM "
        
           | hdjjhhvvhga wrote:
           | > Yeah, must have been those "others" abusing the system
           | while all you were doing was accessing free data in China,
           | Iran and Iraq!
           | 
           | Seriously, what's the problem with that? That model had a
           | basic web browser, so it was basically designed to be used
           | this way. I used it in emergency situations (without taking
           | the card out) for checking email and the like. It was slow
           | and clumsy, but it worked. It would not occur to me that
           | since I'm abroad I'm doing something wrong because the device
           | was actually advertised as having global Internet
           | connectivity, and it was one of the reasons I bought it.
        
           | kweks wrote:
           | I postulate there are two categories of people: those who
           | assume that if the activity was minimum, the service would
           | continue, and others that assume the service will end, so
           | will pump as much as possible.
           | 
           | I'd found it to be invaluable solving the after-landing-
           | before-you-have-a-local-SIM conundrum.
        
             | peterburkimsher wrote:
             | I'm of the latter variety: use it until it ends.
             | 
             | It wasn't a Kindle, but another country's prepaid SIM that
             | I continued using while in Japan. Phone companies in Japan
             | don't do prepaid: only phone rentals by the day, or 2 year
             | subscriptions. Neither of those were suitable for the 2
             | months I lived there.
             | 
             | Some international SIM cards would run out of balance and
             | send an SMS as a warning. But others would redirect me to a
             | topup page. Let's just say that wasn't the only page that
             | was available, and the "send this page to a friend" email
             | function is very convenient when Japanese phones have
             | incoming email addresses for sending email-to-SMS.
             | 
             | Google calendar used to be a great way to get free email-
             | to-RSS-to-SMS notifications, but that shut down a couple of
             | years ago unfortunately.
        
         | [deleted]
        
         | random_savv wrote:
         | For what it's worth, it's possible to get 1GB/mo of global
         | roaming, for $130/mo - World offer here:
         | 
         | https://fiber.salt.ch/en/mobile/plans/standard
        
           | lbotos wrote:
           | When I travel I use airalo to get local e-sims for data and
           | pay probably something like $10 on average for 5GB for 30
           | days. (Another option for people who's phones support e-sims)
        
             | mortenjorck wrote:
             | I had no idea there was a company doing this already! I
             | just downloaded their app, and will have to give it a try
             | when my next travel destination opens its borders again.
        
               | lbotos wrote:
               | Tips:
               | 
               | - Set up the sim before you leave. It's the worst trying
               | to do it once you land. (Ask me how I know)
               | 
               | - You will get some interesting networks, but I've never
               | had problems with them.
               | 
               | - I think they just fixed it on iOS, but be prepared to
               | type in the details manually (not hard, just not
               | seamless) because they expect you to scan a QR code???
               | 
               | Even with those quirks, it's been great, simple, no
               | problems, and I've used in US/UK/Australia.
        
           | sjf wrote:
           | Fi has data roaming for 10$/GB, free after 6GB (speed reduced
           | after 15GB, unless you opt-in to pay extra). This is actually
           | the normal Fi plan- there are just no roaming charges. This
           | is single #1 reason why I am on Fi, no more messing around
           | with local SIMs.
           | 
           | https://fi.google.com/about/international-rates/
        
             | arthurcolle wrote:
             | yep, even for an infrequent traveler it is 100% worth it
        
             | vinay427 wrote:
             | FWIW, T-Mobile US had free throttled global data roaming in
             | most countries since a few years before Fi was launched. It
             | was typically more expensive than Fi for a single line,
             | although usually cheaper for family plans.
             | 
             | https://www.theverge.com/2013/10/9/4821692/t-mobile-
             | announce...
        
           | simonebrunozzi wrote:
           | What I need is something that could work on a boat, too.
           | Couldn't find anything below several $,000 per month.
        
             | GekkePrutser wrote:
             | Iridium Go is not 1000s per month but still 100s.
             | 
             | But hopefully starlink will help drive prices down once
             | they enable mesh communication.
        
           | rescbr wrote:
           | Before my provider offered worldwide roaming on my monthly
           | plan for an additional fee of the equivalent of USD 6 (that
           | you pay whether you use it or not), I've used Flexiroam for
           | data when traveling abroad. Good prices if staying for less
           | than a month.
        
         | jackson1442 wrote:
         | It seems Barnacle made the same mistake:
         | https://driving.ca/auto-news/news/students-defeat-new-barnac...
        
       | 43920 wrote:
       | For the old Kindles, this'll be close to 15 years of usability,
       | which is really good. However the list also includes a bunch of
       | newer models:
       | 
       | > Kindle Keyboard (3rd generation), Kindle Touch (4th
       | generation), Kindle Paperwhite (4th, 5th, 6th, and 7th
       | generation), Kindle Voyage (7th generation), and Kindle Oasis
       | (8th generation)
       | 
       | The 7th gen paperwhite, for example, was still being sold until
       | 2018 [1]. It seems kind of ridiculous to still be selling a
       | 3G-only device 3 years ago, and to only be offering a partial
       | credit for a device that's going to stop working so soon after
       | purchase.
       | 
       | [1] https://blog.the-ebook-reader.com/2018/11/09/kindle-
       | paperwhi...
        
         | NelsonMinar wrote:
         | You think 15 years is good you should see the lifetime of
         | books. Some work for hundreds of years!
        
           | 43920 wrote:
           | Well, yes, that is true :)
        
           | cromka wrote:
           | > Some work for hundreds of years!
           | 
           | Yeah, but you don't really have access to them!
        
         | schwartzworld wrote:
         | They'll still be usable as e-readers and still work on wifi.
        
       | gambiting wrote:
       | What's up with this clickbait title? Older kindles can absolutely
       | maintain their internet connection, just not through 3G as 3G is
       | being switched off entirely.
        
         | trutannus wrote:
         | This is The Verge, the same place that offered an infamously
         | bad build-a-pc tutorial. I'd hardly consider them credible
         | technology journalism.
        
         | salamandersauce wrote:
         | It's not THAT clickbaity. The oldest Kindles do not have WiFi
         | at all. Only cellular. So for Kindle 1s,2s and DXs they won't
         | have internet connections at all.
        
         | Apocryphon wrote:
         | It's significant enough that Amazon is offering trade-ins
         | despite these devices being wi-fi capable.
        
         | frosted-flakes wrote:
         | Older Kindle devices didn't have Wi-Fi by default, only
         | cellular 2G/3G. Wi-Fi was a paid upgrade.
        
       | deanCommie wrote:
       | Actual headline that would get less clicks from the Amazon-hate-
       | train:
       | 
       | "Amazon sending free kindle upgrades to customers affected by
       | carriers removing 3G network access"
        
         | Johnie wrote:
         | Why not both? Write two exact articles with the different
         | headlines to capture two separate customer demographic.
        
         | mjparrott wrote:
         | But how am I supposed to get mad at that headline?!
        
         | SoylentOrange wrote:
         | This isn't accurate, as Amazon is only giving full refunds to
         | those with the gen 1 kindle. The rest get a store credit
         | towards the purchase of their next kindle. I have a paperwhite
         | and the $50 credit is less than half of the cost of a new
         | kindle.
        
           | lupire wrote:
           | your paperwhite still has wifi, though, doesn't it?
        
       | guidoism wrote:
       | That original device was magical. Yes, it was ugly, but first-
       | time user experience was magic. 1. You bought it with your Amazon
       | account so it was automatically tied to your account. 2. You
       | bought some books or got some samples before you got the device.
       | 3. When you got the device in the mail you turned it on and Bam,
       | everything just worked. All your books were there. There was no
       | logging into anything. No wifi passwords. It just worked. I've
       | never experienced any product that worked that well from the
       | moment you got it.
        
       | WalterBright wrote:
       | I have a couple Kindle Keyboards and a DX. I wish Amazon would
       | re-release them with a high res screen and updated electronics.
       | No other changes.
       | 
       | I've tried the newer Kindles, and keep going back to the KK and
       | DX.
       | 
       | Well, I would make one change. Have the last page read be the
       | screen display when off instead of those boring and useless
       | pictures it shows.
        
         | flatiron wrote:
         | The dealbreaker for me is now that I've used a paper white I
         | can't not use a backlit kindle. Most of my reading is at
         | bedtime and it makes it so much more enjoyable.
        
         | nicoburns wrote:
         | Agreed, the buttons on the Kindle Keyboard are much better than
         | the touch screen on newer models. Seems like page turning
         | buttons are now only available on the premuim versions!
         | 
         | The screens are much better on the new ones though.
        
         | flakiness wrote:
         | I would also love to see larger screen Kindle like DX. I loved
         | it so much. Nowadays I'm using Boox and it's fine, but Kindle
         | DX 2021 would be nicer as a reading device.
        
         | wwweston wrote:
         | Glad it's not just me -- I felt like the larger eink screen +
         | physical keyboard hit a really nice sweet spot for an ereader
         | tablet and nothing else I've tried has quite dialed it in the
         | same.
        
       | thrower123 wrote:
       | I really miss my old, old Kindle keyboard. It was the perfect
       | form-factor for reading fiction, and the physical page turn
       | buttons on both sides were literally perfect - holding the Kindle
       | in either hand, the page forward button is in exactly the spot
       | where my thumb wants it to be.
       | 
       | When the last of my old Kindles with the physical buttons died, I
       | broke down and bought an Oasis, and... it's wildly better than a
       | modern Paperwhite or a Kindle Fire, but it's pretty shittily
       | designed from a usability perspective. The whole thing should be
       | as thick as the offset thick edge, in order to hold it
       | comfortably, and while it is nice to have physical turn buttons
       | back, they're really awkwardly placed to use if you're trying to
       | hold the thing in one hand and use your thumb, as one does with a
       | Kindle.
        
         | salamandersauce wrote:
         | Kindle keyboard is kinda bad form factor itself. You have a
         | keyboard that's rarely ever used for the main devices purpose
         | taking up a third of the device adding extra bulk and weight.
        
         | wccrawford wrote:
         | I actually quite like the buttons on the Oasis. I've had
         | regular kindles and then the Oasis, and far prefer it in every
         | way. I've thought about buying a new one, but they don't seem
         | to have really changed much, so I'm still on my original Oasis.
         | 
         | The buttons are well-placed for me. I hold it in one hand and
         | my thumbs naturally rest right there.
         | 
         | My one complaint is that the touch-screen is still active and
         | sometimes it changes pages when my thumb moves too far in, or
         | when I close the cover. (No idea why the latter happens. Does
         | the cover touch the screen and cause a page flip?)
         | 
         | There might be a better arrangement for the buttons, but I
         | can't imagine what it is.
        
           | slownews45 wrote:
           | Also on Oasis for same reason. I do wonder when there will be
           | significant improvements or if it's all going towards ipad
           | land etc.
        
             | fumar wrote:
             | Oasis is my favorite kindle next to the original. I have
             | had many. Oasis is a great travel size. It fits anywhere. I
             | wish they would release an updated version of the smaller
             | one.
        
           | dunnevens wrote:
           | Tap the menu button. Tap "Turn off touchscreen". That takes
           | care of what is a major annoyance.
           | 
           | This is on my 3rd gen Oasis. I don't know if this feature is
           | available on yours.
        
           | majormajor wrote:
           | Yeah, I wish I could turn OFF the screen page turning.
           | 
           | If I'm reading at night as I fall asleep I don't want to wake
           | up to a book in a different place because my finger brushed
           | the screen as I nodded off.
        
             | dunnevens wrote:
             | You can. At least on the Oasis. Tap the menu button. Tap
             | "Turn off touchscreen".
        
         | WalterBright wrote:
         | I have an Oasis. I kept dropping it, so I compared it with my
         | trusty Kindle Keyboard. The KK has a texture that sticks to
         | your fingers. The Oasis is slick. I kept dropping the Oasis
         | like I kept dropping my slick iPhone until I bought a sticky
         | shell for it.
         | 
         | I agree with the button placement. KK got it right, Oasis got
         | it wrong.
        
         | jamescontrol wrote:
         | I wish they would make a paperwhite with the long next page
         | buttons on each side of the screen.
        
           | Geezus_42 wrote:
           | I've only ever had a paperwhite but I've never had an issue
           | with just moving my thumb over the screen a bit and tapping
           | to go the next page. If it was a 50/50 split it would be and
           | issue but it's not.
        
             | salamandersauce wrote:
             | Yep. I've had buttoned eReaders like the Sony PSR-505,
             | original Kobo and used early Kindle models. Buttons just
             | aren't needed with the decent touch screens they have now.
        
               | [deleted]
        
       | gordon_freeman wrote:
       | Somewhat off-topic but still wanted to share. A while ago, I
       | realized that I am consuming so many books through Public Library
       | service Libby in the form of Audiobooks nowadays and for a few
       | books that I want to "read", I can just read in the Libby app
       | itself on my phone. This saves me time in transferring an ebook
       | to Kindle mainly but also the entire UX of Libby is just so great
       | that I don't even feel a need to read a book on Kindle. Because
       | of this, I have not been using either Kindle app or Kindle
       | eReader lately and may rarely do so in the future.
        
         | TedDoesntTalk wrote:
         | I've never been able to get public library apps to work. I've
         | tried two or three.
        
           | gordon_freeman wrote:
           | I'd suggest you to give Libby a try once. All you need is to
           | search your local library and add Card Number and PIN and
           | that's it. No logins required and a very polished UI.
        
             | jeromegv wrote:
             | Libby is indeed an amazing app. Surprising how it came from
             | the same company that created Overdrive, which is an awful
             | app.
        
         | salamandersauce wrote:
         | That's part of why I love my android eReader. I still get all
         | that eInky goodness but I can also just use the Libby, Kindle,
         | Kobo, Google Play Books etc. apps all on 1 device.
        
       | ben7799 wrote:
       | I have an Oasis and was confused about this cause I knew mine was
       | not current.
       | 
       | Turns out I'm fine, there are 3 generations of Oasis: The
       | original 6" with the weird battery in the cover, then the 7", and
       | now the 7" w/color temp adjustment
       | 
       | I've wanted a good excuse to get the latest one for a while but I
       | guess this isn't it.
       | 
       | The 3G has never been critical for me but it's always nice enough
       | to have that I've paid for it on various models over the last 11
       | years. It can save a lot of hassle when traveling, even if
       | there's a strange Wifi network you could use. A lot of the time
       | the security support on the Kindle has been a bit behind the
       | times and it'd be tricky to get on some networks.
        
       | hiidrew wrote:
       | paperwhite original kindle + library genesis + calibre = a happy
       | reader
        
       | mrfusion wrote:
       | When those came out we thought it was free forever :-(
       | 
       | https://xkcd.com/548/
        
         | [deleted]
        
         | solarkraft wrote:
         | "I'm happy with my Kindle 2 so far, but if they cut off the
         | free Wikipedia browsing, I plan to show up drunk on Jeff
         | Bezos's lawn and refuse to leave."
        
         | wccrawford wrote:
         | Yeah, that was before they started turning off networks like
         | analog TV and stuff, so we didn't think much about that
         | functionality just disappearing.
        
         | andrewguenther wrote:
         | I mean, free for as long as the cellular infrastructure exists
         | is still pretty damn good
        
         | lozenge wrote:
         | It didn't actually let you browse websites, did it? The one I
         | had would only load the Amazon store and download books.
        
           | ghaff wrote:
           | As I recall, browsing was an "experimental" feature (I had a
           | second gen I think?) and it was nearly unusable for most
           | purposes.
        
             | striking wrote:
             | It was good enough for Slashdot on the beach, so it was
             | enough for me.
        
           | mattficke wrote:
           | You had to click through a few menus to use it, but yes (I
           | think it was called "experimental web browser" or something).
           | Worked internationally too, I used it to look up some stuff
           | when I was on vacation in Turkey in 2010.
        
           | ok123456 wrote:
           | The 3rd generation at least had an 'experimental' web browser
           | that let you go wherever you wanted.
        
             | BostonEnginerd wrote:
             | The 2007 Kindle also had a basic web browser.
        
       | ismaildonmez wrote:
       | Amazon is sending brand-new Kindles to replace the affected
       | devices: https://i.imgur.com/NiRn1a9.jpg
        
         | zip1234 wrote:
         | As someone with 2x Kindle 2s, wondering how you got notified?
        
         | monatron wrote:
         | I have a second-gen and was offered $50 off a new one + $15
         | kindle store credit.
        
           | TrueGeek wrote:
           | I was also offered $50 but you have two weeks before the
           | coupon expires. This seems extremely short considering they
           | must have had a ton of time to prepare for the cellular
           | shutdown.
           | 
           | Plus, if you go to their site to buy a new Kindle it says you
           | get $50 + 20% off if you trade in your old Kindle. Customer
           | service told me I can't combine offers (plus trade in takes a
           | couple weeks anyway) so it seems the $50 offer is worse than
           | what normal customers get anyway.
        
           | gurchik wrote:
           | FTA:
           | 
           | > For customers with Kindle (1st Generation), Amazon is
           | offering a free Kindle Oasis (10th Generation) device and
           | cover.
           | 
           | > Customers with Kindle (1st and 2nd Generation), Kindle DX
           | (2nd Generation), and Kindle Keyboard (3rd Generation) can
           | receive $70 off a new Kindle Paperwhite or Kindle Oasis, plus
           | $25 in ebook credits.
           | 
           | > Customers with Kindle Touch (4th Generation), Kindle
           | Paperwhite (5th Generation, 6th Generation, and 7th
           | Generation), Kindle Voyage (7th Generation), and Kindle Oasis
           | (8th Generation) can receive $50 off a new Kindle Paperwhite
           | or Kindle Oasis, plus $15 in ebook credits.
           | 
           | Sounds like you should qualify for the $70 + $25 credits. If
           | you are actually considering it, I would contact Amazon if I
           | were you. Personally I have the Kindle Keyboard and I'm not
           | interested in the credit, I'm still happy with it and it
           | still works fine. But I think it's great that they are
           | offering it.
        
         | arduinomancer wrote:
         | Wow that's pretty generous considering you can still load
         | content on the devices with a USB
        
           | Johnie wrote:
           | Think of the kindle as a loss leader for them to sell books.
           | They probably make more money selling e-books than from the
           | device itself.
        
             | notatoad wrote:
             | while that's likely true for the cheaper models, an
             | oasis+cover bundle is $375cdn. that's a lot of ebooks.
        
             | sib wrote:
             | They don't just make _more_ money from the ebooks, that is
             | the only source of profit. In general, they lose money on
             | the Kindle readers.
        
         | wwweston wrote:
         | Hmmm. No email w/ promo-code for replacing my DX sent to me
         | yet.
        
         | [deleted]
        
         | xeromal wrote:
         | That looks like above and beyond customer service to me.
        
           | jackson1442 wrote:
           | Customer Obsession _is_ one of their Leadership Principles,
           | after all.
           | 
           | Their LPs are somewhat fascinating to me in that they're
           | publicly available and you can see how their actions fall
           | into them. Well, save for "Strive to be Earth's Best
           | Employer."
        
             | BeetleB wrote:
             | > Their LPs are somewhat fascinating to me in that they're
             | publicly available and you can see how their actions fall
             | into them.
             | 
             | They're very selective. Much of the Amazon web site is the
             | opposite of customer obsession. I've yet to find a single
             | person I know who agrees with their removing comments from
             | reviews, for example.
             | 
             | Their search filtering is very poor as well.
        
           | dnzkw wrote:
           | I wouldn't expect less of Amazon - that's why they are where
           | they are.
        
             | xeromal wrote:
             | 100%. They definitely take customer service seriously.
        
               | [deleted]
        
               | lotsofpulp wrote:
               | Except when it comes to providing a filter on their
               | website to only show products sold by Amazon. Or not
               | commingling inventory.
        
               | queuebert wrote:
               | Or filtering out scummy sellers at least. What happened
               | to Cliff Stoll was awful.
        
               | jacquesm wrote:
               | Him and many thousands of others, who don't have much
               | visibility here.
        
               | kevin_thibedeau wrote:
               | They learned from Sam Walton's rules about treating the
               | customer well. Something Wal-Mart has forgotten since his
               | death.
        
               | Finnucane wrote:
               | Just treat your employees and suppliers like shit.
        
       | Causality1 wrote:
       | My kindle 3 is still a workhorse. It predates the idea that
       | physical buttons and text to speech should be premium features.
       | With cheap replacement parts still available it may last me for
       | decades.
        
       | blhack wrote:
       | Ah man this kindof sucks. I've been buying these on ebay for
       | ultra cheap when they inevitably break (I bring them everywhere
       | with me).
       | 
       | The ability to just sync without having to think about anything,
       | is amazing.
       | 
       | There used to be a dream that was ubiquitous free wifi (like
       | water fountains), but it unfortunately never materialized.
       | Everything requires a password, some terrible captive portal, and
       | often a registration of some kind to use now. It's really sad.
       | 
       | These things just _work_. I 'll miss that.
        
       | wly_cdgr wrote:
       | You get a $50 coupon towards a new model that can download your
       | new purchases, and you'll continue to be able to access
       | everything you've already downloaded on your old device. And you
       | get a heads up so you have lots of time to download stuff before
       | service ends
       | 
       | For anyone who doesn't have an anti-Amazon agenda, this is either
       | a non-story or a model example of how to gracefully and
       | professionally handle a transition away from obsolete hardware
        
         | teruakohatu wrote:
         | The a cover for the new model costs $30. I don't think it is
         | particularly generous offer.
        
       | tyingq wrote:
       | The free cellular was really nice back when roaming charges
       | outside of the US were crazy high. Checked my gmail occasionally
       | with the experimental browser from Mexico for free. Though the
       | screen lag was pretty bad.
        
       | blantonl wrote:
       | Another major set of products facing this same predicament are
       | home security systems with cellular backup modems. Quite a few of
       | them were deployed with 3G modules that will be useless after
       | this year, requiring mass module replacements.
        
       | fortran77 wrote:
       | Well, this is because 3G is going away.
        
       | knaik94 wrote:
       | Back when I was younger with a limited texting plan, I got a
       | google voice number and managed to get a used kindle keyboard
       | with free 3g for life. Had some wonderful conversations on the
       | kind of solution a broke teenager puts up with. I had to refresh
       | the mobile google voice page in order to see any new messages.
       | 
       | It's not really Amazon's fault, I know a relative is receiving a
       | free flip phone through AT&T because the old phone they were
       | using doesn't have 4g LTE support. In that case I think it has to
       | do with being able to call 911.
       | 
       | What actually surprises me is that they have kept backwards
       | support through wifi for these devices, to be able to browse the
       | kindle store. Whispersync, at least the part of it used for cloud
       | sync between kindle and your amazon account, seems to be working
       | too.
        
       | OnionBlender wrote:
       | I have a Kindle DX with cellular only but Amazon's trade in page
       | is only offering me $5. How do I get the $70 off a Kindle Oasis
       | plus $25 ebook credit that the verge article mentions? I never
       | received an email from Amazon.
        
         | wwweston wrote:
         | Fellow cel-only DX owner, also haven't received an email.
        
         | Anther wrote:
         | I'd give them a call. Their customer service is amazing with
         | things like this.
        
       | tomduncalf wrote:
       | Off topic but I'm hoping there'll be a new Kindle announced soon.
       | Great device but I would love an adjustable colour temperature
       | backlight, but not sure I want to fork out for an Oasis.
        
         | mttjj wrote:
         | So the thing you want already exists but you're not willing to
         | pay for it but you hope Amazon releases a new version because
         | then you'll buy it? Do I have that right?
        
           | heurisko wrote:
           | Originally the front light was a Paperwhite-only feature,
           | until it was also introduced to the basic Kindle range.
           | 
           | It's reasonable to have the wish that color temperature might
           | be similarly introduced to a basic model, when the other
           | features of the basic model otherwise suffice.
        
             | tomduncalf wrote:
             | Yeah sorry, this is exactly what I meant - I was hoping
             | that feature would filter down to the base Paperwhite
             | model. However I do now see that they offer 20% trade in
             | off the Oasis, which makes it a bit more tempting... seems
             | like some sites think they might release a new model this
             | year is the only thing, but who knows really!
        
       | chx wrote:
       | How hard is it create a microcell which translates from 2G/3G to
       | 4G?
        
       | ok123456 wrote:
       | People are going to go back and very closely parse what was
       | promised. It was billed as being "Free Lifetime 3G". Are owners
       | of these devices entitled to a buy out?
        
         | edoceo wrote:
         | *for the life of 3G, not the life of the customer.
        
           | ashtonkem wrote:
           | It's kind of hard to blame Amazon for cell carriers shutting
           | down 2G/3G service.
        
         | [deleted]
        
         | gambiting wrote:
         | But Amazon isn't changing anything - and in fact since Kindles
         | 3G have global roaming, I imagine they will continue to work in
         | countries that still have 3G.
        
         | rchaud wrote:
         | They get a $50 coupon for a new Kindle, according to the story.
        
         | asciimov wrote:
         | Depends on how old of a unit you have. I have a 3rd Gen, and
         | was offered $70 off a new Kindle (paperwhite or oasis) and $25
         | in Kindle credits. (I'm not sure the last time that I used
         | whispernet, but I did see use when visiting relatives. Not sure
         | I am going to pay for that privileged again.)
         | 
         | Some that had a 1st gen have been offered a free Oasis and
         | cover.
        
       | BooneJS wrote:
       | I have a 1st gen kindle but haven't used it in ages after I got a
       | paperwhite. It can be traded in for a free Oasis? Woa.
        
         | LorenPechtel wrote:
         | I've got a couple of Kindles that aren't old enough for that
         | deal. I've ended up with them in a drawer, only using the
         | Kindle app on my phone. The number of times I've wanted to read
         | while out in the sun just hasn't been enough to bother with.
        
       | mikestew wrote:
       | At least Amazon had the foresight to use 3G. Our Nissan Leaf,
       | which was built well after the earliest Kindles, came with GPRS
       | in 2011 and it's been several years since AT&T turned those
       | frequencies off. No free upgrades, or coupons, either: $250 for a
       | new cell radio, please. We just had them remove the radio that
       | was there, as Nissan's crap system never worked all that well
       | anyway.
       | 
       | Regardless, neither Amazon nor Nissan can help that another
       | company turned off those frequencies. Amazon has demonstrated
       | more foresight and better customer service, however.
        
         | pradn wrote:
         | It seems like practically anything car companies do that's not
         | the actual car itself is usually bad unless you pay for the
         | superpremium brands.
        
           | lupire wrote:
           | $250 one-time upgrade is better than the price premium and
           | all the upcharges for regular service on a luxury car.
        
         | don-code wrote:
         | This still seems better than BMW's model - cars were shipping
         | with 3G modems all the way through 2014, and up through 2015,
         | when the whole fleet went 4G. But, since most everything is
         | subscription-based, BMW just stopped renewing subscription
         | contracts for 3G-only cars in 2017. More confusingly, some
         | models are eligible for a new radio (which I assume is a lot of
         | money), and some aren't, even though it seems to vary more by
         | model than year of manufacture.
        
           | queuebert wrote:
           | To be fair, BMW's labor costs are _much_ higher than Amazon
           | 's.
        
           | mikestew wrote:
           | As I've told my wife when discussing BMWs: "we'd really,
           | really like to buy a BMW car, and BMW keeps telling us, 'we'd
           | rather you didn't.'"
           | 
           | And I say this as someone with two BMW motorcycles in the
           | garage that we're pretty happy with.
        
         | kwhitefoot wrote:
         | That's interesting and rather unfriendly of Nissan; after all
         | it has been well known that 2G or 3g or both would be scrapped
         | for quite some time. Here in Norway Tesla replaced the 3G radio
         | with an LTE module at no charge because 3G is being
         | discontinued in Norway. I think owners who had upgraded to LTE
         | at their own expense earlier were also offered some
         | compensation.
        
       | trey-jones wrote:
       | For those who bought these devices or used them regularly, what
       | do you use the internet connection for?
       | 
       | I've read on a kindle very close to every single day for at least
       | 10 years (Kindle Touch first, now Paperwhite), and I keep it in
       | airplane mode 99.999% of the time or more. If I buy a book from
       | Amazon, I'll put it on Wifi until it's downloaded, then back to
       | Airplane Mode.
       | 
       | I know that I can look something up on Wikipedia were I online,
       | and this is the only feature I know of that I might sometimes be
       | tempted to use. It's difficult for me to imagine a scenario that
       | I would want to buy a reading device that could connect to the
       | internet on cellular data.
        
         | wwweston wrote:
         | At this point I usually only use my DX for reading textbook-
         | like content where being able to have a large visual field
         | matters.
         | 
         | But for the first few years I owned it, I actually used it to
         | read nearly all of my ebooks _and_ do a significant amount of
         | web browsing and communication, including HN, Gmail, FB, and
         | anything else. The e-ink + physical keyboard made it my
         | favorite web mobile device.
         | 
         | Somewhere between 2012 and 2015 sites stopped working as well
         | and I realized it was because of https requirements which the
         | experimental browser wasn't supporting, and I stopped using it
         | as much, and then not too long after became a less frequent
         | user of it to read ebooks -- my iphone was always with me and
         | almost as good for most ebook content.
        
         | rhplus wrote:
         | Cellular can be used to buy and download books while travelling
         | without having to connect to random WiFi APs. It could also be
         | used for email, if you were patient enough.
        
         | mjparrott wrote:
         | I brought my kindle with me on international trips because back
         | then it wasn't so common to have a smartphone/wifi everywhere.
         | I used its browser feature all the time when traveling. I even
         | used it for texting people, gmail, etc.
        
         | cmiles74 wrote:
         | As the unit aged, more and more I would also leave the wireless
         | on my DX disabled. I would turn it on when I needed it which,
         | as you mention, has become more and more rare.
         | 
         | My real use-case for the DX was textbooks because the screen
         | was large and it was easier to read code snippets. Back in the
         | day I bought a lot of those from Manning or O'Reilly directly
         | and then loaded them onto the DX via USB. Reading PDFs was
         | nicer as well, but again, I loaded them over USB.
        
         | LegitShady wrote:
         | I used a Kindle keybkard for a long time to read all sorts of
         | text based websites on the experimental browser as well as
         | sending emails. The screen Refresh times weren't good but for
         | text stuff it was alright. At the time I had an extremely
         | limited data plan that still cost $40/month and provided
         | minimal data so offshoring anything to the Kindle was a
         | benefit. I took it travelling to the us and the middle East a
         | handful of times as well.
        
         | SoylentOrange wrote:
         | In 2013 there was a massive snow/ice storm and power outage
         | here in Ontario, Canada lasting multiple days [1]. Having the
         | paperwhite was amazing, because it had near-unlimited battery,
         | and I used the 3G to buy a few books. Nearly every other
         | portable electronic device was useless, since most phones at
         | that time had maybe 12 hours of battery life. That event made
         | me truly fall in love with the kindle.
         | 
         | 8 years later, it still works wonderfully.
         | 
         | [1]: https://nationalpost.com/news/canada/toronto-ice-
         | storm-2013-...
        
         | frakkingcylons wrote:
         | I keep mine connected to the internet so that it automatically
         | updates my reading place because I frequently switch between
         | reading on my phone and my kindle.
        
       | matsemann wrote:
       | I know multiple people that bought it here in the EU, just to use
       | the experimental browser while on vacation. Worked basically
       | world wide (albeit slow), and at the time roaming charges even
       | within EU was insanely high.
        
       ___________________________________________________________________
       (page generated 2021-07-29 23:00 UTC)