[HN Gopher] Ferrofluid display cell Bluetooth speaker
       ___________________________________________________________________
        
       Ferrofluid display cell Bluetooth speaker
        
       Author : thunderbong
       Score  : 300 points
       Date   : 2021-05-13 13:25 UTC (1 days ago)
        
 (HTM) web link (hackaday.io)
 (TXT) w3m dump (hackaday.io)
        
       | Animats wrote:
       | Oh, I thought the ferrofluid was going to be the speaker. Like
       | plasma speakers [1].
       | 
       | The helium plasma speaker was only good for high frequencies, and
       | needed something else for the bass. Using a heavy liquid for bass
       | might work.
       | 
       | [1] http://hillplasmatronics.com/
        
       | lwhi wrote:
       | Phenomenal. The concept, the design and the execution.
        
       | bitdivision wrote:
       | I experimented with making a clock using ferrofluid previously. I
       | was inspired by this clock [0] but put off by the price tag.
       | 
       | Generally the main issues I found were that it degraded over time
       | and I had real trouble with ferrofluid smearing on the container.
       | 
       | Will have to try again now!
       | 
       | [0]: https://www.thisiswhyimbroke.com/ferrofluid-clock/
        
         | gfaure wrote:
         | This kind of reminds me of the Heptapod writing system from
         | "Arrival". I wonder what contributes to the cost -- is it
         | simply because it's unique, or are some of the materials
         | expensive?
        
         | nerfhammer wrote:
         | The article mentions "Because ferrofluid adheres well to glass,
         | special treatments were required on the glass" but doesn't go
         | into details
        
         | bawolff wrote:
         | That is so cool
         | 
         | But 12 grand!? Wow.
        
           | stronglikedan wrote:
           | They must read HN, because they've reduced it to the low, low
           | price of only $8k now.
        
             | pierrec wrote:
             | 12 Canadian.
        
       | [deleted]
        
       | fouronnes3 wrote:
       | Great entry to xkcd 2326!
        
       | jacquesm wrote:
       | Very neat. I wonder if there is some kind of soundpattern that
       | can be used to 'sweep up' the smaller globules back into a single
       | larger one.
        
       | oilostthelast wrote:
       | I've always wanted to make something like this. I'm curious about
       | parsing the fields into something both pleasing and physically
       | representative of the actual waveform of the music. I'd also like
       | to play around with using the fluid as a driver as well, though
       | I'm sure getting sound out of it would be immensely difficult if
       | not impossible without a horn the size of a barn. As far as I'm
       | aware it has yet to be attempted.
        
       | ur-whale wrote:
       | This is really cool. I hope someone makes a commercial version of
       | it.
        
         | anshumankmr wrote:
         | He can potentially do it, if he puts it on Indiegogo.
        
           | permo-w wrote:
           | or he could go the traditional way and look for investors.
           | 
           | There are ups and downs to both
        
       | tsimionescu wrote:
       | For anyone as fascinated with this substance as I am, here [0] is
       | a YouTube video of someone making it 'from scratch'. It's a very
       | detailed explanation, and includes some comparisons of the
       | outcome VS commercial ferro fluids.
       | 
       | [0] https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=6L8yUY-doNc
        
         | adonovan wrote:
         | There's an interactive exhibit in the lobby of the New York
         | Hall of Science that lets you deform a blob of this shiny goo.
         | It's a lot of fun.
        
           | 3r3rni9 wrote:
           | Thought of exactly the same exhibit -- love that thing! Worth
           | a stop into NYHS to play with it. I immediately wanted to
           | make one and I'm psyched to see on HN. Evidently it
           | originally had buttons to control the charge, then curators
           | upgraded it with the more tactile wheel controllers.
           | 
           | https://www.sciartmagazine.com/spotlight-michael-flynn-
           | and-f...
        
         | sitharus wrote:
         | NileRed is one of my favourite chemistry YouTubers, along with
         | NurdRage. There's so much great content on his channels.
        
           | simlevesque wrote:
           | When I first saw many of his videos, I was like: "damn, this
           | dude has access to all sorts of chemicals, radioactive stuff,
           | I bet he lives in Texas or Mexico".
           | 
           | Then I learned that he lives in the same city as me.
        
           | SV_BubbleTime wrote:
           | When I originally found his channel I thought he might be too
           | young to take any sort of seriously, but he handles being
           | that young pretty well. There isn't a lot of YouTube
           | nonsense, or begging for subscribers, or jokes that for
           | extremely flat. A model for others I think. Really well done.
           | 
           | Although... Explosions and Fire is peak YouTube Chemistry to
           | me!
        
             | Huiokko wrote:
             | I would assume that certain amount of basic chemistry is
             | still quite advanced for a non chemist.
             | 
             | If you would create a YouTube channel talking about basis
             | programming language you would also attract plenty of
             | people.
             | 
             | Nonetheless I don't want to lower the value or skill of
             | him.
             | 
             | I'm entertained by it and can't judge his skills.
             | 
             | It still takes a lot to stand in front of a camera and
             | doing what he does but still it could be that a chemist
             | find it boring what he shows.
        
             | earthscienceman wrote:
             | Young? He's 29? Were you mistaken or are you implying that
             | 29 is pretty young to be creating self-aware youtube
             | content.
        
               | syoc wrote:
               | He has videos dating 7 years back. I thought he looked
               | young for what he was doing. Did not see him until quite
               | a bit into the video and it was not what I expected.
               | Really knowledgeable, a lot of equipment and a really
               | good setup for someone so young. There is also the fact
               | that there is no big source of income that I could easily
               | spot.
        
               | Zancarius wrote:
               | I read it to infer that NileRed looks pretty young for
               | his age, which I think is true.
        
         | intrasight wrote:
         | Great video!
        
         | [deleted]
        
       | webmobdev wrote:
       | Reminds me a lot of Winamp that popularised such kind of music
       | visualisations.
        
         | joshspankit wrote:
         | I really wish we were still there culturally.
         | 
         | Imagine the kind of music visualizers we could have with AI,
         | CUDA cores, and RTX...
        
         | Cthulhu_ wrote:
         | In the 90's and 2000's, car radios and the like had some really
         | interesting visualizations going on. The market for radios and
         | music installations that aren't high-end seems to have pretty
         | much collapsed thanks to mp3 players and bluetooth speakers
         | though. That said, there's still things like portable karaoke
         | speakers that still come with the bells and whistles.
        
           | jahnu wrote:
           | Funnily enough given your user name, Cthulu was a popular
           | visualiser back in the DOS days of the 90s.
           | 
           | https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cthugha_(software)
           | 
           | Edit: it was cthugha... my old brain is failing me :)
        
       | yreg wrote:
       | Very cool project. There is a video of it in action[0] at the
       | bottom. This is something that screams Kickstarter to me.
       | 
       | [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7a3JiGTE9sc
        
         | bsanr2 wrote:
         | 21st century lava lamp. In that, it 100% has the chance to
         | become an iconic consumer product.
        
         | achow wrote:
         | Thank you. Video should have been embedded at the top of the
         | website. Only a video can explain the value of the idea.
        
         | GuB-42 wrote:
         | If it becomes a Kickstarter, I really hope the makers know what
         | they are getting into. There is a lot between a prototype and
         | mass production, and a lot of projects fail between the two.
         | 
         | Keeping it small scale, hand made on demand and high priced may
         | be a safer option.
        
       | senectus1 wrote:
       | shutup and take my money. i want one yesterday!
        
       | matthewmfrost wrote:
       | Amusingly I made a prototype of something similar 4 years ago
       | during university:
       | https://www.facebook.com/1764751847/videos/10202928199083698...
       | 
       | It was done to promote the use of Ferrofluid for DataVis rather
       | than a consumer product.
        
         | jan_Inkepa wrote:
         | That's pretty awesome - it picks up on way more signal detail
         | than the top project (which is also nonetheless cool).
        
           | IshKebab wrote:
           | Yeah, it does feel weirdly out of sync though.
        
         | bitdivision wrote:
         | I can't see the video, but if it's the same idea could you give
         | some details on what you used as a suspension fluid and how you
         | dealt with the smearing on the container?
        
           | matthewmfrost wrote:
           | Give this link a go:
           | 
           | https://drive.google.com/file/d/1iqUnmD79tMlswlQQhhId1cuW6DX.
           | ..
        
             | earthscienceman wrote:
             | Really cool. With something like this I can't help but
             | imagine combining it with real time signal
             | processing/filtering. Where the visualization can be
             | attached clearly to different components of the music. A
             | vocal filter, melody filter, etc etc. I'm always
             | dissatisfied with how visualizers don't really cue off
             | auditor-ily obvious parts of songs.
        
             | bitdivision wrote:
             | Nice! I assume that was just ferrofluid and water?
        
         | matthewmfrost wrote:
         | Happy to collab, if anyone is interested feel free to reach
         | out... matthewmf.com
        
         | jessedhillon wrote:
         | Do you know how well it works if the speaker is on top of the
         | bottle, pointed downward at the fluid?
        
       | haarts wrote:
       | Ferrofluid is unstable iirc. I wonder how long this fluid lasts.
        
         | lowestprimate wrote:
         | Ferrofluid is was used in disk drive motors to seal bearing
         | grease from wandering out so it has reasonable life span of
         | greater than 5 years from my experience
        
       | totetsu wrote:
       | I want this, buy just as an eyeball that follows people around
       | with its gaze
        
       | radarsat1 wrote:
       | > This is called ferrofluid. It is a material developed by NASA
       | in the 1960s. It was used as both spacecraft fuel and sealing
       | material.
       | 
       | I'm a bit curious how ferrofluid was used as a fuel.
        
         | meibo wrote:
         | It's commonly suspended in Kerosene, so maybe that's what they
         | meant? Bit of a long stretch though.
        
           | swiley wrote:
           | I guess it would be easy to build a pump with it that has no
           | moving parts.
        
             | willcipriano wrote:
             | Self cleaning and self lubricating as well as kerosene is a
             | solvent and lubricant.
        
           | wlesieutre wrote:
           | This says it was an idea to pull rocket fuel to the right end
           | of the tank without gravity
           | 
           | https://www.nasa.gov/feature/glenn/2021/history/novel-
           | rocket...
        
       | rg2004 wrote:
       | I would be interested to see the ferrofluid dots resonating
        
       | amelius wrote:
       | I guess if you made little cells with this fluid, you could make
       | a matrix display.
        
       | nathias wrote:
       | this is the best DIY project I've seen, looks amazing
        
       | motohagiography wrote:
       | Naive question: could I use a speaker setup similar to this with
       | my analog synth rig to use combinations of sine, saw, and square
       | waves to find combinations of waves that suspended and
       | manipulated this ferrofluid - and would those sound shapes have
       | applications to laser pulses manipulating atoms? Intuitively, it
       | seems like a way to model concepts for macro quantum computer.
       | 
       | While atoms may not behave as liquids, laser pulses are waves. Is
       | there specific reason why not?
        
         | tmearnest wrote:
         | Yeah, you may find that due to the mass and length scale due to
         | the viscosity/surface tension etc. would require sub audible
         | frequencies. Totally worth trying. As far as atomic
         | manipulation, no since that needs to be in a hard vacuum and
         | low temperature. The same wave interference principle is used
         | in that technology though.
        
           | motohagiography wrote:
           | That interference principle seems like a function of the size
           | of the blobs and then how you manage the interference
           | patterns of multiple oscilators. Mind you, if you can
           | physically do it with audio synths, you can model it in
           | software, which means we should be able to use ML via a GAN
           | to grind through oscillator patterns to create the necessary
           | pulse effect results.
           | 
           | Maybe more fun for a toy or a game.
           | 
           | This is a great video of the effect of sound on ferrofluids:
           | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Axwm-5zng0s
        
       ___________________________________________________________________
       (page generated 2021-05-14 23:01 UTC)