https://www.pi-usa.us/en/tech-blog/nanopositioning-metrology-goedel-and-bootstraps Menu Close * Ask an Engineer * Quote list 0 Quote list + Products Overview Ask an Engineer Quote List / Send Request to PI Nanopositioning Metrology, Godel, and Bootstraps Content * Ask an Engineer * Quote list 0 Quote list + Products Overview Ask an Engineer Quote List / Send Request to PI Nanopositioning Metrology, Godel, and Bootstraps Why External Metrology Matters in Nanopositioning Nanopositioning Metrology, Godel, and Bootstraps More than 80 years ago, a discovery by Austrian Kurt Godel put an end to the dream mathematicians had pursued for centuries: a final unifying "Theory of Everything" or the idea that a system could be devised strong enough to verify itself. Godel's findings may seem rather obvious, but they had an enormous impact on all branches of science and today are widely considered as important as Einstein's Theory of Relativity. Kurt Godel (Image: Wikipedia.com) Kurt Godel (Image: Wikipedia.com) What has become known as the "Incompleteness Theorem" asserts that no statement can prove its own truth. One of the well-known analogies is that no one can lift themselves up in the air by their own bootstraps, no matter how hard they pull. What It Means for Test and Measurement Verification of the positional stability/drift, accuracy, and position resolution of a closed-loop positioning system requires an independent sensor (of higher accuracy). In the nanopositioning world, the most credible results come from a standards-traceable instrument, such as a laser interferometer because it measures distance directly using the wavelength of light. Good laser interferometers are expensive and the setup requires trained technicians and a stable, vibration and temperature controlled environment. Verifying Position Accuracy with External Metrology Cheap and Flattering Shortcuts The above may be the reason that cheap and flattering (but flawed) short-cuts are sometimes proposed. One such "solution" excites a vibration in the positioner and uses its internal sensor to infer its positional resolution (from the frequency spectrum), instead of measuring the actual stage position with an independent external sensor. This method violates the fundamentals of measuring technology (one sensor cannot verify its own capabilities). By switching from the time domain to the frequency domain, the results become less applicable to nanopositioning and could conceivably be used to prove anything.If conducted with a precise external sensor, frequency domain measurements would allow the accurate comparison of positioning systems based on their ability to reproduce certain frequencies. While essential for characterizing HIFI speakers, the method does not really apply to precision positioning equipment. Example: Point-to-point positioning, measured in the time domain at the motion platform using external traceable instrumentation (top), duplicates actual usage. Qualities such as overshoot, stability and noise are evident. Viewed in the frequency domain, none of these are evident. Example: Point-to-point positioning, measured in the time domain at the motion platform using external traceable instrumentation (top), duplicates actual usage. Qualities such as overshoot, stability and noise are evident. Viewed in the frequency domain, none of these are evident. How Nanopositioning Stages are Used Nanopositioning stages, especially if piezo-driven are typically operated in one of three ways: point to point motion, scanning, or tracking. In all three cases, the motion of the stage is expected to be in a certain place at a certain time. The correlation of position and time is very important. For example in imaging applications, the data gathered along the way is later easily reconstructed into an image by matching the data point with the position at a given time. This is why position vs. time (time domain) measurements can say more about the qualities of a nanopositioning system than other tests. In addition to graphically showing system behavior when it comes to reproducing nanometer-sized steps, they also indicate stability (ability to hold position over time), settling time, overshoot, and repeatability. The equivalent to having a sensor verify its own performance The equivalent to having a sensor verify its own performance Frequency domain measurements (FFT analysis) are useful to characterize system resonances. Frequency domain information, however, offers no time / position correlation. Again, for meaningful results, measurements need to rely on independent external metrology, such as laser vibrometry. Defining Resolution in Positioning Systems with Non-Incremental Actuators and Sensors Because of the analog nature of the amplifiers and sensors usually employed in closed-loop piezo positioners, resolution is not determined by discrete steps (as is typical with stepper motors or incremental encoders), making it theoretically infinite. In reality, there is always micro friction to be considered and sensor and control-electronics noise also have an impact on the practically usable resolution. For typical imaging, positioning, and alignment applications, the practically usable resolution is 1s the independently-measured positional noise, or ~1/6 of the peak-peak noise. As stated above, in addition to this statistical figure, the graphical data of nanometer sized discrete steps performed by the positioner reveals a great deal of information on system response, stability, and repeatability and is directly applicable to the way nanopositioning systems are used. Comparision of external and Internal Metrology, Time and Frequency Domain Measurements Author: Stefan Vorndran, VP Marketing, PI USA [AAE_green-bkgrnd_900x75] Learn more --------------------------------------------------------------------- More Reading [svg] Metrology and Test Equipment for Qualifying Nanopositioning and Motion Control Systems [svg] Metrology for Precision Motion / Positioning Systems - Methods and Principles [svg] Metrology for Precision Motion Systems at PI USA Products Overview About PI Subscribe to Tech Blog Sign up to receive an email of new blog posts. First Name*[ ] Last Name*[ ] Company / Organization [ ] Zip / Postal Code*[ ] City*[ ] State*[ ] Country*[United States ] Email*[ ] Please read the following and confirm your consent to the processing of your data. By submitting this form, you consent to the PI Group contacting you through the communication channels you specify. Additionally, you acknowledge that the PI Group may store, process, and analyze the necessary data. For further information, see our >> Privacy Policy. Each email includes an unsubscribe link that allows you to withdraw your consent. Privacy Policy* [ ] I have read the Privacy Policy and agree to its terms and conditions. Submit Your request is being processed Don't fill this field! [ ] spacer Back to Tech Blog homepage Blog Categories * Aero-Space * Air Bearing Stages, Components, Systems * Astronomy * Automation, Nano-Automation * Beamline Instrumentation * Bio-Medical * Hexapods * Imaging & Microscopy * Laser Machining, Processing * Linear Actuators * Linear Motor, Positioning System * Metrology * Microscopy * Motorized Precision Positioners * Multi-Axis Motion * Nanopositioning * Photonics * Piezo Actuators, Motors * Piezo Mechanics * Piezo Transducers / Sensors * Precision Machining * Semicon * Software Tools * UHV Positioning Stage * Voice Coil Linear Actuator * X-Ray Spectroscopy Subscribe to Tech Blog Recent Posts * Enabling Quantum Precision: Why Cryogenic 6-Axis Hexapods Matter * PRIME: Fiber-Optic Fabrication Breakthrough Enables Advanced Neuroscience Exploration at WUSTL * Hexapod Controllers and Simulation Software * Rethinking Microtome Motion Control: Why Precision Matters More Than Ever * Why a Virtual Pivot Point Matters in Optical and Photonics Alignment * Operating Linear Stages under Force Control * Can Hexapods Provide Advantages in Micro-LED Production? * 7 Engineering Challenges That Make Precision Gantry Systems Hard to Get Right * Case Study: Photonics Chip Level Test Strategies for Production Environments * Innovative High-Bandwidth Hexapod Concept for Nanopositioning Applications Load more contact@pi-usa.us EAST & MIDWEST (508) 832-3456 WEST (949) 679-9191 spacer Contact PI (Physik Instrumente) L.P. US Headquarters 440 Hartford Turnpike Shrewsbury, MA 01545 United States * 508-832-3456 * 508-832-0506 * contact@pi-usa.us * www.pi-usa.us Quick Links * Ask An Engineer * Careers * Contact / Service * Customers * News Login * * * (c) 1996-2026 PI Americas | Motion Control, Nanopositioning, Precision Positioning & Automation, Piezo Products Compliance with Applicable Laws; Export Control Laws User access to this website is governed by all applicable federal, state, and local laws. All information available on this website is subject to U.S. export control laws and may also be subject to the laws of the country where you reside. * Legal Information * Privacy Policy * Terms and Conditions of Sale Close [ ] [] 1. Home 2. Product Quick View 3. Product Categories 1. Back 2. Product Categories 3. Product Finder 1. Back 2. Product Finder 3. Product Finder 4. Customized Products 5. Product Demonstrators 4. Air Bearings / Stages 1. Back 2. Air Bearings / Stages 3. Precision Air Bearing Stages, Components, Systems Overview 4. Linear Air Bearing Stages, Linear Air Bearings 5. Air Bearing Rotary Tables - Precision Air Bearing Rotation Stages 6. XYZ Stage for Ultrafast Laser Material Processing 7. Multi-Axis Alignment Stage for Silicon Photonics Applications 5. Gantries / Cartesian Robots 6. Hexapod 6-Axis Stages 1. Back 2. Hexapod 6-Axis Stages 3. 6-Axis Hexapods / Parallel Positioners Overview 4. Control of Hexapod / Stewart Platforms: Hexapod Motion Controllers & Simulation Software 5. Vacuum Stages & Actuators 7. Motorized Actuators 1. Back 2. Motorized Actuators 3. Overview All Actuator Types 4. High Speed Actuators / Modules 5. Voice Coil Actuators 6. Piezo Motor Actuators 7. Piezo Flexure Actuators 8. Vacuum Stages & Actuators 8. Linear Stages: X ... XYZ 1. Back 2. Linear Stages: X ... XYZ 3. Linear Stages Overview 4. Miniature Stages 5. Voice Coil Stages 6. Fast Linear Stages (Direct Drive) 7. Industrial Linear Stages 8. Z-Stages 9. XY Stages 10. XYZ / XY-Theta Stages 11. Granite Systems, Automation 12. 6-Axis Stages 13. Vacuum Stages & Actuators 14. Motion Controllers 9. Rotary Stages, Goniom. 1. Back 2. Rotary Stages, Goniom. 3. Rotary Stages Overview 4. Stepper Motor Rotation Stages 5. Miniature Rotary Stages 6. Direct Drive Rotary Tables Precision Rotation Stages 7. Vacuum Stages & Actuators 10. Tip/Tilt Stages 11. Piezo Flexure Stages <1mm 1. Back 2. Piezo Flexure Stages <1mm 3. Overview - Piezo Flexure Stages 4. Linear Piezo Flexure Stages 5. Vertical & Z-Tip-Tilt Stages 6. Fast Steering Mirrors 7. Nano-Focus Motors & Stages 1. Back 2. Nano-Focus Motors & Stages 3. Overview - Nanofocusing Stages 4. Next Generation Fast Focus Stages 8. XY Piezo Flexure Stages 9. XYZ Piezo Flexure Stages 10. 6-Axis Piezo Flexure Stages 11. Vacuum Stages & Actuators 12. Nanopositioning Tutorial 13. Piezo Motion Control Wiki 12. Piezo Motors / Stages >1mm 1. Back 2. Piezo Motors / Stages >1mm 3. Piezo Motors Overview 4. Linear Actuators with Piezo Motors 5. Linear Stages with Piezo Motors 6. XY Stages with Piezo Motors 7. Rotary Stages with Piezo Motors 8. Vacuum Stages & Actuators 9. Piezo Motor Types: How to Choose 13. Piezo Actuators: Motion, Force 1. Back 2. Piezo Actuators: Motion, Force 3. Piezo Motion: Actuators, Stacks, Chips, Benders, Tubes, Shear... 4. Amplified Piezo Actuators 5. Value-Added Piezo Assemblies 6. Piezo Motion Control Wiki 7. Vacuum Stages & Actuators 14. Piezo Transducers: Sensing, Ultrasound 1. Back 2. Piezo Transducers: Sensing, Ultrasound 3. Overview: Piezo Ceramic Components & Transducers for OEMs 4. Value-Added Piezo Assemblies 5. Piezoceramic Composites 6. Ultrasonic Transducers 7. DuraAct Patch Transducers 8. Discs and Cylinders 9. Plates, Blocks, and Rods 10. Tubes 11. Bending Elements 12. Rings 13. Spheres and Hemispheres 14. PICMA(r) Piezo Linear Actuators 15. Nano-Measuring Sensors 16. Laser Beam Steering, Mirrors 17. Microscopy, Imaging, LSc 1. Back 2. Microscopy, Imaging, LSc 3. Stages for Microscopy & Bio-Imaging Overview 4. Application Stories: Medical & Life Sciences 5. Motorized Microscope Stages for Automation 18. Photonics Alignment Systems 19. Solutions for Semiconductor Manufacturing 20. Products for Astronomy 21. Vacuum Products 1. Back 2. Vacuum Products 3. Vacuum Technology / Products Overview 4. Vacuum 22. Software Suite 1. Back 2. Software Suite 3. Communication Concept & Platform-Independent Interfaces 4. Motion Control Software 5. Simulation & Emulation 6. Programming, Interfaces, and Integration 7. 3rd Party Integrations 8. Scan and Alignment Tasks 23. Controllers, Drivers, Software 1. Back 2. Controllers, Drivers, Software 3. Overview - Controllers, Drivers, Software 4. Piezo Controllers and Amplifiers 5. Motion Controllers for Motorized Stages 6. Hexapod Controllers 7. Software for Motion Controllers 24. Multi-Axis Positioners 25. Accessories: Adapters & Cables 26. More Products 1. Back 2. More Products 3. More Products Overview 4. Stages Made in the USA 5. Air Bearings & Stages 6. Linear Stage - Precision Positioners Overview 1. Back 2. Linear Stage - Precision Positioners Overview 3. Ultra-High Precision Linear Translation Stage 7. Motorized Stages and Actuators 8. Linear Stages 1. Back 2. Linear Stages 3. Stages with Magnetic Direct-Drive Linear Motor 4. Stages with Stepper, DC & Brushless DC (BLDC) Motors 5. Vertical Stages with Stepper, DC & Brushless DC (BLDC) Motors 6. Miniature Linear Stages 9. Motorized Linear Slides 10. Motorized Stages Overview 11. Micropositioning Stages 12. Miniature Rotation Stages 13. Multi Axis Motion Systems 1. Back 2. Multi Axis Motion Systems 3. Hexapod Motion Controllers 4. Miniature Hexapods 5. Simulation & Emulation 14. Fast Multi-Channel Photonics Alignment 15. Nanopositioning Piezo Flexure Stages 1. Back 2. Nanopositioning Piezo Flexure Stages 3. Multi-Axis Piezo Flexure Stages 4. PIFOC(r) Objective & PInano(r) Sample Scanners for Microscopy 5. Linear Piezo Flexure Stages 6. XY Piezo Flexure Stages 7. XYZ Piezo Flexure Scanners 8. Piezo Flexure Tilting Mirrors 16. Piezoelectric Transducers & Actuators 1. Back 2. Piezoelectric Transducers & Actuators 3. Discs and Cylinders 4. Plates, Blocks, and Rods 5. Rings 6. Tubes 7. Spheres and Hemispheres 8. Piezoceramic Composites 9. Bending Elements 10. PICMA(r) Piezo Linear Actuators 11. PICMA(r) Piezo Bender Actuators 12. PICA Piezoelectric Stack Actuators 13. DuraAct Patch Transducers 14. Ultrasonic Transducers 15. Picoactuator(r) Piezoelectric Crystal 17. PZT Components 1. Back 2. PZT Components 3. Piezoceramic Disks and Micro Disks 4. Piezoelectric Plates and Block Transducers 5. Piezoelectric Spheres & Hemisphere Transducers 6. Piezoelectric Ceramic Rings 7. Piezoelectric Tubes, Scanner Tubes 8. Piezoelectric Bending Elements 18. Nanopositioning Piezo Actuators 19. Linear Actuators 1. Back 2. Linear Actuators 3. PiezoMike for Long-Term Stability 4. Linear Actuators with Stepper & DC Servo Motors 5. Voice Coil Actuators with High Dynamics & Force Control Option 6. PiezoMove Lever Actuators 7. Nanopositioning Piezo Actuators 8. PiezoWalk(r) Actuators with High Force & Stability 9. PIRest Active Piezo Shims 20. PiezoWalk(r) Actuators with High Force & Stability 21. Rotation Stages 22. Voice Coil Actuators with High Dynamics & Force Control Option 23. XY Stages 24. XY Piezo Flexure Stages 25. Legacy Products 1. Back 2. Legacy Products 3. Legacy Products Overview 4. Piezo Controllers 5. Piezo Actuators 6. Piezo Stages 7. Fast Steering Mirrors 8. Micropositioning Stages 9. Rotary Stages 10. Photonics 11. Motorized Controllers 4. Nanopositioning Essentials 5. Applications 1. Back 2. Applications 3. Photonics Alignment Solutions 4. Semiconductor Manufacturing 5. Metrology 6. Laser Processing 7. Free-Space Optical Comm 8. Life Sciences, Imaging, Microscopy 9. Precision Automation 10. Aerospace 11. Astronomy 12. Product Demos 13. Markets 6. Tech Blog 7. Expertise 1. Back 2. Expertise 3. Competencies 1. Back 2. Competencies 3. Piezo Technology 4. Nano Positioning 5. Performance Automation 4. Markets 1. Back 2. Markets 3. Industrial Automation 1. Back 2. Industrial Automation 3. Laser Materials Processing 4. Electronics Manufacturing 5. Measurement, Test & Inspection 6. Flow Metering 7. Sensor Devices 8. Hydroacoustics 9. Industrial Dispensing 10. Industrial Printing 4. Microscopy & Life Sciences 1. Back 2. Microscopy & Life Sciences 3. Surgical Robots 4. Endoscopy & In Vivo Diagnostics 5. IVD In Vitro Diagnostics 6. Microscopy 7. Therapeutic & Surgical Instruments 8. Medical Sensors 9. Microfluidics 10. Diagnostic Imaging 11. Medical Implants 5. Semiconductor 6. Photonics 1. Back 2. Photonics 3. Silicon Photonics 4. Quantum Photonics 5. Free Space Optical Communication 6. Delay Line 7. Large-Scale Scientific Projects 1. Back 2. Large-Scale Scientific Projects 3. Astronomy 4. Beamline Instrumentation 5. Customer s 1. Back 2. Customer s 3. OEM 4. OEM Piezo Ceramics 6. Technologies 1. Back 2. Technologies 3. Piezo Technology 1. Back 2. Piezo Technology 3. Fundamentals of Piezo Technology 4. Properties of Piezo Actuators 5. Generating Ultrasound 6. Piezoceramic Materials 7. Manufacturing Technology 8. PICMA(r) Technology 9. Integrated Piezo Actuators 10. DuraAct Patch Transducer Technology 11. PIRest Actuators 4. Piezoelectric Drives 1. Back 2. Piezoelectric Drives 3. Piezo Actuators 4. PiezoWalk(r) Walking Drives 5. PILine(r) Ultrasonic Piezomotors 6. Piezo Inertia Drives 7. PiezoMike Linear Actuators 8. Comparison: Piezo Motors & Drive Technologies 5. Electromagnetic Drives 1. Back 2. Electromagnetic Drives 3. Rotating Electric Motors 4. Magnetic Direct Drives 5. PIMag(r) 6-D Magnetic Levitation 6. Hybrid Concept 6. Parallel Kinematics 1. Back 2. Parallel Kinematics 3. Hexapods Features at a Glance 4. Piezo Positioning Systems with Parallel Kinematics 5. Multi-Axis Positioners 6. Hexapods as Motion Simulator 7. Hexapods in Microproduction 7. Sensor Technologies 1. Back 2. Sensor Technologies 3. Capacitive Sensors 4. Incremental Sensors 5. PIOne Optical Nanometrology Encoder 6. Comparison: Position Sensor Technologies 8. Controllers & Software 1. Back 2. Controllers & Software 3. Digital & Analog Interfaces 4. EtherCAT Connectivity of PI Products 5. Control of Piezo Actuators 6. Digital Motion Controllers 7. Software 8. Active Alignment 9. Guiding Systems & Force Transmission 1. Back 2. Guiding Systems & Force Transmission 3. Classical Guiding Systems 4. Flexure Guiding Systems 5. Magnetic Bearings 6. PIglide Air Bearing Technology 10. Vacuum 7. Partners 1. Back 2. Partners 3. Turner Laser Systems provides Custom Turn-Key Laser Solutions Based on PI Stages and ACS Controllers 8. Future Technologies 9. Educational Videos 10. Future Zone 1. Back 2. Future Zone 3. Magnetic Levitation 4. Lever Hexapods 5. Surface Shaping 6. Miniature Tip/Tilt Mirror with Ultrasonic Drive 7. Electro-Optical Wafer Probing 8. Knowledge Center 1. Back 2. Knowledge Center 3. Tech Blog 4. Glossary 5. Demos/Videos 1. Back 2. Demos/Videos 3. Application Demos 4. Expert Interviews 5. Educational Videos 6. Product and System Demonstrators 6. Webinars 7. Knowledge Exchange 1. Back 2. Knowledge Exchange 3. It's Possible Sessions - Laser World of PI 4. It's Possible Sessions - Enabling the Technologies for Semicon 5. It's Possible Sessions - Unleashing the Power of Photonics 6. Register Now! Joint Webinar Averna & PI 8. Tutorials 1. Back 2. Tutorials 3. Piezo Motion Control Tutorial 4. Nanopositioning Basics 5. Product Demos 6. Expert Interviews 7. Educational Videos 9. Downloads 10. Additional Resources 1. Back 2. Additional Resources 3. Ask an Engineer (direct email request) 4. User Manuals, Software, Whitepapers 5. Catalogs, Brochures & Certificates 6. Catalog Preview & Download 7. ISO 90001 Certificates 8. Metric Tolerances & Thread Pitch 9. Motion Control Software 10. Technical Papers / Whitepapers 11. Videos & Animations 9. About PI 1. Back 2. About PI 3. About PI USA Overview 4. Capabilities 1. Back 2. Capabilities 3. Capabilities in Production Overview 4. Sustainable Investment 5. The PI Group 1. Back 2. The PI Group 3. About ACS Motion Control 4. About PI Ceramic 5. About PI miCos 6. News / Events / Tradeshows 7. Careers 8. Locations & Addresses 9. ITAR / Export Controlled Applications 10. + Contact / Service + Ask An Engineer + Customers + News + Careers + Technology Demos