https://www.thecanadianpressnews.ca/business/battle-of-the-rail-barons-how-a-merger-is-setting-the-industry-on-a-collision/article_4b82ef47-bb9b-533a-ac97-78a89d065ad1.html * Skip to main content You have permission to edit this article. Edit Close site-logo * Log In * + My Account o My Account o Dashboard o Profile o Saved Items o o Subscribe o o Manage Service o o Log Out * Subscribe * Manage Service [Logout] Home * About Us * About CP Fact Checks * Artificial Intelligence * Contact Us * Terms of Use * Privacy Policy * Local Weather * Subscribe Newsletters Sponsored Content National News Regional News * Atlantic * Quebec * Ontario * Prairies & BC * North World Politics Business * Business News * Stock Market * GlobeNewswire Press Releases * Business Wire Press Releases Health Environment Entertainment Sports Science Fact Checking Multimedia * Photo Galleries * Videos * Podcasts * Facebook * Twitter * YouTube * Instagram (c) Copyright 2022 The Canadian Press Terms of Use | Privacy Policy site-logo Site search [ ] [Search] Search Menu site-logo * + [ ] [Search] Search * Log In * + My Account o My Account o Dashboard o Profile o Saved Items o o Subscribe o o Manage Service o o Log Out * Subscribe * Manage Service [Logout] * Home * National * Regional + Atlantic + Quebec + Ontario + Prairies & BC + North * World * Politics * Business + Business News + GlobeNewswire Press Releases + Business Wire Press Releases + Stock Market * Health * Environment * Entertainment * Sports * Science * Fact Checking * Sponsored Content * Multimedia + Photo Galleries + Videos + Podcasts * Newsletters Close Battle of the rail barons: How a merger is setting the industry on a collision course [69bfcbcb75f26] A Union Pacific worker walks between two locomotives that are being serviced in a rail yard in Council Bluffs, Iowa, on Dec. 15, 2023. (AP Photo/Josh Funk) * Josh Funk * Facebook * Twitter * WhatsApp * SMS * Email * Print * Copy article link * Save [Save] Battle of the rail barons: How a merger is setting the industry on a collision course Rail merger sets industry on a collision course * Christopher Reynolds The Canadian Press * Mar 22, 2026 * 12 hrs ago * * Facebook * Twitter * WhatsApp * SMS * Email Battle of the rail barons: How a merger is setting the industry on a collision course [69bfcbcb75f26] A Union Pacific worker walks between two locomotives that are being serviced in a rail yard in Council Bluffs, Iowa, on Dec. 15, 2023. (AP Photo/Josh Funk) Josh Funk * Facebook * Twitter * WhatsApp * SMS * Email * Print * Copy article link * Save [Save] MONTREAL - A proposed merger between two big American railways will hurt competition and drive up consumer costs across the continent. Or it will drive them straight down. It depends who you ask. Union Pacific Corp., the second-largest railroad operator in the United States, announced in July it wants to buy Norfolk Southern Corp. -- the third-largest -- in a US$85-billion deal that would create that country's first transcontinental railway, and potentially trigger a wave of rail mergers across North America. The topic has been churning through boardrooms, ballrooms and train yards over the past eight months, as fears of market consolidation and lopsided power dynamics between rail carriers and shippers bubble up. The prospect has also drawn stiff resistance from some of the continent's railway giants, with Keith Creel, CEO of Calgary-based Canadian Pacific Kansas City Ltd., among its most vocal critics. He argues that without major conditions the acquisition would damage competition, cost customers and place unprecedented market power in the hands of a single railway, which would handle some 40 per cent of American freight traffic. "Forty per cent of everything is a lot," Creel said at conference in Washington, D.C., on Wednesday. "You create this Goliath of (Union Pacific-Norfolk Southern), which is going to be seven times the size of CPKC." Measured by revenue, CPKC is the smallest of the six remaining Class One freight railroads, though its tracks now stretch farther than those of Montreal-based Canadian National Railway Co. since Canadian Pacific acquired Kansas City Southern to form CPKC in 2021. Hauling everything from potash to petroleum, the company extended its sprawling network from Canada through the southern states to Mexico -- no competitor spans all three countries -- and marked the continent's first big rail merger in more than two decades. CN chief executive Tracy Robinson has taken a more moderate stance, saying the applicants have "a long way to go" to address questions around competition. "The impact on CN would be less than that of the other railroad," Robinson told analysts on a call in January, referring to Canadian Pacific, "but it won't be zero." The planned merger would marry Union Pacific's vast rail network in the Western U.S. with Norfolk's rails that snake across the country's eastern half. The combined railroad would include more than 80,000 kilometres of track in 43 states with connections to major ports on both coasts. The goal is efficiency. Among the four big U.S.-based railways, the Mississippi River acts as a rough dividing line separating Union Pacific and BNSF in the west from Norfolk Southern and CSX in the east. Rather than have thousands of containers transferred from one railway to another within the same riverside city -- St. Louis, Memphis, New Orleans -- the merger would allow for more fluid traffic flow and end-to-end operational control, proponents argue. They say it would shave off between 24 and 48 hours of transit time, nabbing business from diesel-guzzling semi trucks and slashing costs. It would allow for more streamlined corporate operations and could even prompt rivals to lower their rates to compete, backers say. A bigger railway would "force our competitors to do better," Union Pacific CEO Jim Vena said at a Chicago rail conference earlier this month. "If they can't meet our service ... then they have to do it only one way, and that is price." Opponents foresee different ramifications of the deal, including more acquisitions. CSX, one of the three smallest railways alongside CN and CPKC, looks particularly ripe for the picking by a larger player. "BNSF would be logical. But BNSF has gone out of its way to say, 'We're really not interested' -- for now," said TD Cowen analyst Jason Seidl. Clients of Union Pacific and Norfolk Southern aren't so enthusiastic about the merger either. Major trade bodies representing heavy hitters in the energy, chemicals, agriculture and construction industries -- Chevron, ExxonMobil, DuPont, Dow and Canada's Nutrien among them -- oppose the merger. Several large transport unions, including two representing more than half of the unionized workers at Union Pacific and Norfolk Southern, have also come out against it. "It's always bad for the customer," argued John Corey, president of the Freight Management Association of Canada. "No matter what they say as far as cost savings or benefits to competition or the shareholders ... they're going to raise the rates on their existing customers," he claimed, though it remains a matter of debate whether previous mergers sparked a price spike. As for rival railways, auto shipments mark one vulnerability, particularly for Canadian Pacific. The company competes with Union Pacific for car cargo running north-south between Ontario and Mexico. "They're worried about business being siphoned off," said Anthony Hatch, a transport analyst and founder of ABH Consulting. "UP would use their market power to say, 'I'll cut you a break here if you give me business there.'" On Jan. 16, the U.S. rail regulator rejected the UP-NS merger application as incomplete and asked the parties to flesh it out. Union Pacific has said it plans to resubmit by April 30, with a final decision by the Surface Transportation Board expected next year. Speculation has swirled that the merger might win approval under U.S. President Donald Trump's pro-business administration. But Hatch described the regulatory board as "honest" and "smart." A Trump-led government by no means guarantees a green light for the acquisition, he said. "This is going to be a fight between big Republican interests -- the chemical industry, the oil industry, the agribusiness industry, the auto industry, the steel industry, the housing industry," Hatch said. "If they were to oppose this merger, why would any president in their right mind try to ram this through?" Seven Republican state attorneys general have asked the antitrust division of the U.S. Department of Justice to review the deal, arguing it would hurt competition and the economy. While upbeat about their would-be nuptials, the two railways face a higher bar than previous mergers. Since 2001, following a wave of consolidation in the 1990s that led to weeks-long shipment delays, big railways looking to tie the knot have had to show the corporate marriage would enhance competition -- rather than merely preserving it -- and serve the public interest. As a result, CN failed to acquire Kansas City Southern in 2021, more than two decades after its ill-fated merger attempt with BNSF. "The benefit box is going to have to be fuller than the harm box, or you're never going to satisfy a definition that says you're serving the public interest," Creel said. This report by The Canadian Press was first published March 22, 2026. Companies in this story: (TSX:CP, TSX:CNR) The Canadian Press * Facebook * Twitter * WhatsApp * SMS * Email * Print * Copy article link * Save [Save] Tags * Business * Labour * Transport More Business Stories Microsoft lays off about 3% of its workforce in what one executive calls a 'day with a lot of tears' [68237a9ef149d] Microsoft lays off about 3% of its workforce in what one executive calls a 'day with a lot of tears' * Poll suggests Manitobans worried about costs, less confident in institutions [668a919ccb585] Poll suggests Manitobans worried about costs, less confident in institutions * France is investigating suspected smuggling to China and Russia of advanced chip technology [64c26ac1b8c02] France is investigating suspected smuggling to China and Russia of advanced chip technology * Respondents to Bank of Canada questionnaire largely oppose creating a digital loonie [65676e5d0869c] Respondents to Bank of Canada questionnaire largely oppose creating a digital loonie * +4 Zelenskyy vows not to retreat from Ukrainian city of Bakhmut [64062a2491fc7] Zelenskyy vows not to retreat from Ukrainian city of Bakhmut * +3 Federal judge to deny Trump administration's motion to dismiss lawsuit over block on wind projects [68530dbb30e1f] Federal judge to deny Trump administration's motion to dismiss lawsuit over block on wind projects * S&P/TSX composite posts loss Wednesday despite energy gains, U.S. markets also lower [64932e104be68] S&P/TSX composite posts loss Wednesday despite energy gains, U.S. markets also lower * Bell Media president Sean Cohan says layoffs were necessary to reach company's goals [660c71dd3d80c] Bell Media president Sean Cohan says layoffs were necessary to reach company's goals * 'Smoke screen': Canadian airlines use NDAs to keep a lid on passenger settlements [657eff4bebc63] 'Smoke screen': Canadian airlines use NDAs to keep a lid on passenger settlements * +2 Indonesia's Mount Lewotobi Laki Laki volcano erupts, prompting alert level to be raised [67dcf26e8ace4] Indonesia's Mount Lewotobi Laki Laki volcano erupts, prompting alert level to be raised * You might be interested in +3 Helicopter, snowmobiles help retrieve car abandoned on sea ice 3 km from N.S. shore [69b8617f33689] Helicopter, snowmobiles help retrieve car abandoned on sea ice 3 km from N.S. shore * P.E.I. minister Mark McLane dies at 56 [69bda7b3173b3] P.E.I. minister Mark McLane dies at 56 * +3 Scientists made a breakthrough in the study of whale sounds. Here's a look at the numbers [69b7fed601b15] Scientists made a breakthrough in the study of whale sounds. Here's a look at the numbers * +5 Behind the scenes at the Oscars: What you didn't see on camera [69b79c8659a70] Behind the scenes at the Oscars: What you didn't see on camera * Sponsored Content Events Coming Up in March [699ddd49af486] Events Coming Up in March Building Canada's Digital Future: Why High-Performing, Trusted, and Energy-Efficient Networks Matter More Than Ever [692da6599c6bb] Building Canada's Digital Future: Why High-Performing, Trusted, and Energy-Efficient Networks Matter More Than Ever Canada is entering a new era of nation-building. From clean-energy corridors and c... Similar Stories Iran threatens to 'completely' close Strait of Hormuz and hit power plants after Trump's ultimatum [69bfe7dff0fdc] Iran threatens to 'completely' close Strait of Hormuz and hit power plants after Trump's ultimatum The media may have unmasked Banksy - again. That's angered some art fans but not ruffled dealers [69bf859c39871] The media may have unmasked Banksy - again. That's angered some art fans but not ruffled dealers Enhanced role for immigration officers at US airports as shutdown frustrates travels and screeners [69bc1e29e12f5] Enhanced role for immigration officers at US airports as shutdown frustrates travels and screeners Sections * National News * Newsletters * Politics * Atlantic * Business * Quebec * Health * Ontario * Environment * Prairies & BC * Entertainment * North * Sports * World * Fact Checking * Science * * Multimedia [WZNAAAAEElEQVR42mM8U88ABowYDABAxQPltt5zqAAAAABJRU5ErkJggg] thecanadianpressnews.ca 33 Yonge St., 6th floor Toronto, ON M5E 1G4 Email: info@thecanadianpressnews.ca * Facebook * Twitter * LinkedIn * YouTube * TikTok * Instagram * Reddit * Apple Podcasts [WZNAAAAEElEQVR42mM8U88ABowYD] The Canadian Press is a member of the International Fact-Checking Network Acquire Licensing Rights x Browser Compatibility Your browser is out of date and potentially vulnerable to security risks. We recommend switching to one of the following browsers: Microsoft Edge Google Chrome Firefox (c) Copyright 2026 The Canadian Press 33 Yonge St., 6th floor, Toronto, ON | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy Powered by BLOX Content Management System from BLOX Digital. [pay][pay][pay][pay][pay][pay][pay][pay] Back x Sorry, an error occurred. Already Subscribed! Get StartedManage Service Cancel anytime Log In You are logged in Switch accounts Secure transaction. Cancel anytime. Back x Sign Up Account processing issue - the email address may already exist User information Username (Optional) [ ] This is the name that will be displayed next to your photo for comments, blog posts, and more. Choose wisely! * First name [ ] * Last name [ ] * Email Address [ ] Your email address will be used to confirm your account. We won't share it with anyone else. * Password [ ] Create a password that only you will remember. If you forget it, you'll be able to recover it using your email address. * Confirm Password [ ] Confirm your password. Mailing lists Join our mailing lists [*] Atlantic News Today The Atlantic News Today newsletter keeps you updated on the latest stories from Eastern Canada . It is sent from Monday to Friday. [*] Top News Today Top News Today newsletter delivers the day's essential stories from the Maritimes and top national headlines, directly to your inbox every day of the week. CAPTCHA Create Account Have an account? Log In x You're all set! Thank you . Your account has been registered, and you are now logged in. Check your email for details. OK Back x Log In Invalid password or account does not exist Email Address [ ] Password [ ] [*] Remember me Forgot your password? Log In Email me a log in link Admin login Subscribe Need an account? Sign Up Back x Reset Password Submitting this form below will send a message to your email with a link to change your password. Email or Screen Name [ ] CAPTCHA Reset Password x Forgot Password An email message containing instructions on how to reset your password has been sent to the email address listed on your account. Back x Email me a log in link Account Email [ ] CAPTCHA Send Email Back x Promotional Offers Enter Promo Code [ ] Redeem No promotional rates found. Back x Purchase Gift Purchase Access See More Offers details close x An error occurred x Secure & Encrypted [ ] [ ] What's your email address? Email [ ] Password [ ] Confirm password [ ] What's your name? First name [ ] Last name [ ] Who is this gift for? Recipient name [ ] Recipient email [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] Optional message for the recipient [ ] Who is this gift from? Purchaser name [ ] Purchaser email [ ] Purchaser zip code [ ] Delivery date Delivery date [2026-03-22 ] What's your billing location? State [Ontario, Canada ] Zip Code [ ] Country [Canada ] What's your delivery address? [ ] Copy billing location Address [ ] City [ ] State [Ontario, Canada ] Zip code [ ] Country [Canada ] Phone [ ] Subtotal: Total: How would you like to pay? Ending in Add New Card [pay] [pay] [pay] [pay] [pay] [pay] [pay] [pay] [ ] I Agree to the Subscription Terms of Use. This service will be automatically renewed and your credit card billed once it nears expiration. [Pay Now] Secure transaction. Secure transaction. Cancel anytime. x You're all set! Thank you. Your gift purchase was successful! Your purchase was successful, and you are now logged in. Rate: Begins: Transaction ID: A receipt was sent to your email. OK x An error occurred This offer is currently unavailable. Close