https://www.reuters.com/legal/legalindustry/anthropic-has-strong-case-against-pentagon-blacklisting-legal-experts-say-2026-03-11/ Skip to main content Exclusive news, data and analytics for financial market professionals Learn more aboutRefinitiv * World Browse World + Africa + Americas + Asia Pacific + China + Europe + India + Israel and Hamas at War + Japan + Middle East + Ukraine and Russia at War + United Kingdom + United States + Reuters NEXT New York * Business Browse Business + Aerospace & Defense + Autos & Transportation + Davos + Energy + Environment + Finance + Healthcare & Pharmaceuticals + Media & Telecom + Retail & Consumer + Future of Health + Future of Money + Take Five + World at Work * Markets Browse Markets + On the Money + Watchlist + Asian Markets + Carbon Markets + Commodities + Currencies + Deals + Emerging Markets + ETFs + European Markets + Funds + Econ World + Global Market Data + Rates & Bonds + Stocks + U.S. Markets + Wealth * Sustainability Browse Sustainability + Boards, Policy & Regulation + Climate & Energy + Land Use & Biodiversity + Society & Equity + Sustainable Finance & Reporting + The Switch + Reuters Impact + COP30 * More Legal + Government + Legal Industry + Litigation + Transactional + US Supreme Court Commentary + Breakingviews + ROI: Reuters Open Interest Technology + Artificial Intelligence + Cybersecurity + Space + Disrupted Investigations Sports + Winter Olympics + Athletics + Baseball + Basketball + Cricket + Cycling + Formula 1 + Golf + NFL + NHL + Soccer + Tennis Science Lifestyle + Culture Current City Memo Graphics + Chart of the Week Pictures Wider Image Podcasts + Reuters World News + Reuters Econ World + On Assignment + Viewsroom + The Big View Live Fact Check Video Media Center + Announcements + Awards + Inside the Newsroom + People News Sponsored Content + Reuters Plus + Press Releases Subscribe Anthropic has strong case against Pentagon blacklisting, legal experts say By Jack Queen March 11, 202610:04 AM UTCUpdated ago * * * * * * * * * Summary * Companies * Pentagon's use of obscure law against Anthropic is unprecedented * Anthropic claims blacklisting violates free speech and due process rights * Government could argue Anthropic policies create uncertainty NEW YORK, March 11 (Reuters) - Anthropic's lawsuit challenging its Pentagon blacklisting is likely to test the reach of an obscure law aimed at guarding military systems against sabotage, and legal experts say the artificial intelligence lab appears to have a strong case that President Donald Trump's administration overstepped. Anthropic said in its lawsuit filed on Monday that the Defense Department's decision to exclude the company from military contracts by designating it as a supply chain risk violated its free speech and due process rights and was aimed at punishing the company for its views on AI safety in warfare. Sign up here. The designation could cut Anthropic's 2026 revenue by multiple billions of dollars and cause reputational harm, company executives said Tuesday. In labeling Anthropic as a supply chain risk, the Pentagon invoked a rarely used law that allows it to bar companies from certain contracts if they risk exposing military information systems to enemy infiltration. The law has never been tested in court or used against a U.S. company, according to a Reuters review of legal databases. Courts often defer to the executive branch's judgment on national security, and that will likely be the centerpiece of the government's defense. But five national security law experts told Reuters the Pentagon may have overstepped. "It's not at all clear that the statute can even apply to an American company where there's no foreign entanglement," said University of Minnesota Law School professor Alan Rozenshtein. The Defense Department said it does not comment on pending litigation. 'EXQUISITE' TECHNOLOGY Anthropic, which is incorporated and headquartered in the U.S., said it is not an "adversary," which the Trump administration has defined in executive orders to mean China, Russia, Iran, North Korea, Cuba and Venezuela, according to Anthropic's lawsuit. The company also said Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth gave no explanation for how Anthropic's Claude AI tool constituted a supply chain risk despite its continued use by the U.S. military and Hegseth's own praise of Claude as "exquisite" technology that the Defense Department would "love" to work with during a February 24 meeting with Anthropic cited in the lawsuit. The military has used Claude as recently as last month during strikes on Iran, according to Reuters reports. Hegseth designated Anthropic a national security supply chain risk on March 3 after the company refused to lift restrictions on Claude that prohibit the military from using it for autonomous weapons or domestic surveillance. In a February 27 social media post announcing the designation, Hegseth accused Anthropic of cloaking itself in the "sanctimonious rhetoric of 'effective altruism'" to "strong-arm the United States military into submission." Anthropic has said AI is not reliable enough for autonomous weapons and that it opposes domestic surveillance as a matter of principle. The Pentagon has said that Anthropic's restrictions could endanger American lives. 'SURVEIL, DENY, DISRUPT' Under U.S. law, a supply chain risk is a threat that an adversary could sabotage, infiltrate or disrupt a federal information technology system or network. The law, known as Section 3252, invoked by the Pentagon, allows the defense secretary to exclude companies from certain contracts to guard against the risk that an "adversary" may "sabotage, maliciously introduce unwanted function" or otherwise "subvert" a military information system to "surveil, deny, disrupt, or otherwise degrade" its function. The Pentagon separately designated Anthropic a supply chain risk under a similar law that could eventually broaden contract exclusions to the civilian government. Anthropic filed a separate legal challenge to that designation on Monday. The Pentagon can only exclude companies under 3252 as a last resort, and other defense contractors are not required to stop working with them entirely. Illustration shows Anthropic logo Anthropic logo is seen in this illustration taken May 20, 2024. REUTERS/Dado Ruvic/Illustration/File Photo Purchase Licensing Rights, opens new tab Reuters could not identify any other companies that have been publicly designated supply chain risks under 3252, although the obscure government procurement statute does not require public disclosure of designations. 'BAD BLOOD' Amos Toh, a national security law expert at the left-leaning Brennan Center for Justice, said nothing about Claude's usage policies appeared to pose foreign sabotage or subversion risks. "These are basically safety protocols. You can debate whether these protocols are acceptable or not, but they run directly counter to the risk that the law is designed to regulate," Toh said. Anthropic's lawsuit said that the supply chain risk designation punishes the company for its views on AI safety in violation of the First Amendment of the U.S. Constitution, which protects free speech and expression. Legal experts said Trump and Hegseth's public attacks on Anthropic, including a social media post in which Trump called it a "RADICAL LEFT WOKE COMPANY," could bolster this argument. "A lot of things Hegseth has said and the Pentagon has done undermine their case and suggest there was personal animus and bad blood between the parties, and that the Pentagon had it out for Anthropic," said Joel Dodge, a law expert at Vanderbilt University. Anthropic also said Hegseth's supply chain risk order violated its Fifth Amendment right to due process by imposing "draconian punishments" without any "meaningful process," factual findings or opportunity for Anthropic to challenge them. SECOND-GUESSING THE PRESIDENT Courts are generally reluctant to question federal agency decisions but are especially deferential to the executive branch's judgment on national security matters. This would likely be the centerpiece of the government's defense, according to legal experts, who said Justice Department lawyers could cite a long line of cases where courts have found that it is generally not the place of judges to second-guess how the president and the military he commands defend the country. The government could similarly argue that the president and his cabinet secretaries have broad authority to choose suppliers and that the military cannot rely on a vendor whose usage policies constrain military action. The Justice Department could also cite legal precedent stating that contract decisions are not First Amendment violations if they are supported by legitimate policy or operational reasons. Eric Crusius, an attorney and government contract specialist who is not involved in the case, said the government is trying to impose the "death penalty" on Anthropic and will need to show "there was no alternative and that they meticulously considered other options prior to pulling the trigger." 'ARBITRARY AND CAPRICIOUS' Anthropic said in its lawsuit that Hegseth's decision violated the Administrative Procedure Act, a law that allows courts to overturn actions that are found to be "arbitrary, capricious, an abuse of discretion, or otherwise not in accordance with law." Legal experts said the apparent contradictions in the government's position are strong evidence that Hegseth's decision was arbitrary. "The government was simultaneously threatening to use the (Defense Production Act) to force Anthropic to sell its services, using its services in active military operations, and saying it's too dangerous to use them in government contracts," said University of Minnesota Law School professor Alan Rozenshtein. "Not all of these things can be true," he said. Reporting by Jack Queen in New York; Editing by Noeleen Walder and Christopher Cushing Our Standards: The Thomson Reuters Trust Principles., opens new tab * Suggested Topics: * Artificial Intelligence * Corporate Counsel * Civil Rights * Public Policy * Data Privacy * * * * * Purchase Licensing Rights Jack Queen Jack Queen Thomson Reuters Jack Queen covers major lawsuits against the Trump administration involving urgent questions of executive power and how their resolution could affect the law and the legal profession in the years to come. Previously, he covered criminal and civil cases against Trump during the interim of his presidential terms, including gavel-to-gavel coverage of his historic hush money trial in New York and his civil fraud trial, which ended in a half-billion-dollar judgment. Jack has also covered high-profile defamation cases including the Dominion Voting Systems' lawsuit against Fox News, which settled for $787 million after intense pretrial litigation. Based in New York, he specializes in breaking news as well as analysis, explainers and other explanatory reporting. * * * Read Next / Editor's Picks * agoBusinesscategory Pentagon opens door to exempt Anthropic use beyond 6-month ramp-down, memo says 'U.S. Department of War' and Anthropic logos * agoBusinesscategory Trading Day: Oil and yields up, up, and away Oil storage containers in Berlin * agoWorldcategory How the Anthropic-Pentagon dispute over AI safeguards escalated Pentagon Anthropic feud has sales and AI warfare at stake as Friday deadline looms * agoBusinesscategory Musk unveils joint Tesla-xAI project 'Macrohard', eyes software disruption Saudi-U.S. Investment Forum, in Riyadh * agoBusinesscategory Synopsys rolls out new software tools for designing AI chips Sassine Ghazi, CEO of Synopsys, a Silicon Valley firm that supplies software for designing computer chips, speaks at the company's annual developer conference in Santa Clara * ago Meta unveils plans for batch of in-house AI chips The logo of Meta is seen in Paris, France. * agoBusinesscategory Zoox and Uber tie up to deploy robotaxis on ride-hailing network A traveler walks into the Uber pickup zone at the Los Angeles International Airport's LAX-it pick up terminal in Los Angeles * ago AMD CEO to meet Samsung chief in South Korea amid race for AI memory chips, paper says CES 2026, an annual consumer electronics trade show, in Las Vegas * agoBusinesscategory Oracle rallies as strong revenue forecast eases concerns over massive AI bets Illustration shows Oracle logo * agoWorldcategory South Korea Presidential aide says AI cooperation with UAE could accelerate after conflict Illustration shows words * agoBusinesscategory Canal+ taps Google and OpenAI for AI-driven video production, content recommendation Logo of French TV channel 'Canal Plus' near Paris * agoBusinesscategory JPMorgan marks down value of loan portfolios of some private credit groups, source says JPMorgan Chase opens new global headquarters, in New York * agoBusinesscategory OpenAI plans to launch its Sora video tool in ChatGPT, The Information reports Illustration shows OpenAI and Sora logos * agoTechnologycategory ChatGPT, other AI chatbots approved for official use in US Senate, NYT reports Illustration shows ChatGPT app * March 10, 2026Technologycategory Applied Materials forges partnerships with Micron and SK Hynix for AI memory chips Illustration shows Applied Materials logo LSEG Workspace Site Index Latest * Home * Authors * Topic Sitemap * Archive * Article Sitemap Media * Videos * Pictures * Graphics * Podcasts Latest * Home * Authors * Topic Sitemap * Archive * Article Sitemap Browse * World * Business * Markets * Sustainability * Legal * Breakingviews * Technology * Investigations * Sports * Science * Lifestyle Media * Videos * Pictures * Graphics * Podcasts About Reuters * About Reuters, opens new tab * Media Center, opens new tab * Advertise with Us, opens new tab * Careers, opens new tab * Reuters News Agency, opens new tab * Brand Attribution Guidelines, opens new tab * Reuters and AI, opens new tab * Reuters Leadership, opens new tab * Reuters Fact Check * Reuters Diversity Report, opens new tab * Commercial Disclosure (Japan), opens new tab Stay Informed * Download the App (iOS), opens new tab * Download the App (Android), opens new tab * Newsletters * Subscribe Information you can trust Reuters, the news and media division of Thomson Reuters, is the world's largest multimedia news provider, reaching billions of people worldwide every day. Reuters provides business, financial, national and international news to professionals via desktop terminals, the world's media organizations, industry events and directly to consumers. Follow Us * * * * * * LSEG Products * Workspace, opens new tab Access unmatched financial data, news and content in a highly-customised workflow experience on desktop, web and mobile. * Data Catalogue, opens new tab Browse an unrivalled portfolio of real-time and historical market data and insights from worldwide sources and experts. * World-Check, opens new tab Screen for heightened risk individual and entities globally to help uncover hidden risks in business relationships and human networks. * Advertise With Us, opens new tab * Advertising Guidelines * Purchase Licensing Rights, opens new tab * Cookies, opens new tab * Terms & Conditions * Privacy, opens new tab * Copyright, opens new tab * Digital Accessibility, opens new tab * Corrections * Data Disclosure and Sources, opens new tab * Site Feedback, opens new tab All quotes delayed a minimum of 15 minutes. See here for a list of exchanges and delays. * Cookies, opens new tab * Terms & Conditions * Privacy, opens new tab * Copyright, opens new tab * Digital Accessibility, opens new tab * Corrections * Data Disclosure and Sources, opens new tab * Site Feedback, opens new tab (c) 2026 Reuters. All rights reserved