https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c178zzw780xo Skip to content Watch Live * Home * News * Sport * Business * Technology * Health * Culture * Arts * Travel * Earth * Audio * Video * Live * Documentaries * Home * News + US & Canada + UK o UK Politics o England o N. Ireland # N. Ireland Politics o Scotland # Scotland Politics o Wales # Wales Politics + Africa + Asia o China o India + Australia + Europe + Latin America + Middle East + In Pictures + BBC InDepth + BBC Verify * Sport * Business + World of Business + Technology of Business + NYSE Opening Bell * Technology + Watch Documentaries + Artificial Intelligence + AI v the Mind * Health + Watch Documentaries * Culture + Watch Documentaries + Film & TV + Music + Art & Design + Style + Books + Entertainment News * Arts + Watch Documentaries + Arts in Motion * Travel + Watch Documentaries + Destinations o Africa o Antarctica o Asia o Australia and Pacific o Caribbean & Bermuda o Central America o Europe o Middle East o North America o South America + World's Table + Culture & Experiences + Adventures + The SpeciaList * Earth + Watch Documentaries + Science + Natural Wonders + Climate Solutions + Sustainable Business + Green Living * Audio + Podcast Categories + Radio + Audio FAQs * Video + Watch Documentaries + BBC Maestro + Discover the World * Live + Live News + Live Sport * Documentaries [ ] Home News Sport Business Technology Health Culture Arts Travel Earth Audio Video Live Documentaries Weather Newsletters Watch Live India's top court angry after junior judge cites fake AI-generated orders 11 hours ago ShareSave Anahita Sachdev ShareSave [grey-place]Getty Images The Supreme Court building in Delhi Getty Images Senior judges at the Supreme Court in Delhi have threatened consequences over the use of AI India's Supreme Court has threatened legal consequences after a judge was found to have adjudicated on a property dispute using fake judgements generated by artificial intelligence. The top court, which was responding to an appeal by the defendants, will now examine the ruling given by the lower court in the southern state of Andhra Pradesh. The Supreme Court called the case a matter of "institutional concern" and said fake AI-generated judgements had "a direct bearing on integrity of adjudicatory process". The incident has made headlines, becoming the latest in a series of instances where AI has disrupted court proceedings in India and elsewhere in the world The problems in the case in Andhra Pradesh arose in August last year when a junior civil judge in the trial court in Vijaywada city passed an order in a case about a disputed property. The court had previously assigned an official to survey the property and file a report, which the defendants in the case objected to. The judge dismissed their objection, citing four past legal judgements - all of which were later found to be AI-generated. AI programmes have vastly simplified tasks in the workplace but generative AI systems are known for their ability to "hallucinate" and assert falsehoods as fact, even sometimes inventing sources for the inaccurate information. The defendants challenged the order in the state's high court, pointing out that the cited orders were fake. The high court acknowledged this, but accepted that the junior civil judge had made the error in "good faith" and went on to agree with the trial court's decision anyway. In its order, the high court said that "the citations may be non-existent, but if the learned trial court has considered the correct principles of law and its application to the facts of the case is also correct, mere mentioning of incorrect or non-existent rulings/citations in the order cannot be a ground to set aside the order". The high court had also sought a report from the junior judge who had used the AI-generated rulings. She told the court that this was her first time using an AI tool and she had believed the citations to be "genuine". She had no intention to misquote or misrepresent the rulings and that "the mistake occurred solely due to the reliance on an automatic source", the high court wrote. The high court also advocated for the "exercise of actual intelligence over artificial intelligence". Following this, the defendants appealed again, taking the matter to the Supreme Court, which was less forgiving about the impact of AI. Coming down sternly against the fake judgements, the top court last Friday stayed the lower court's order on the property dispute. It said the use of AI while making judgements was not simply "an error in decision making" but an act of "misconduct". "This case assumes considerable institutional concern, not because of the decision that was taken on the merits of the case, but about the process of adjudication and determination," the top court said. The court said it would examine the case in more detail and issued notices to the country's Attorney and Solicitor General, as well as the Bar Council of India. In another case last month, the Supreme Court raised concerns over the trend of lawyers using AI tools to draft petitions. "It is absolutely uncalled for," legal news website LiveLaw quoted the court as saying. India is not alone in reckoning with the effects of AI in courts. In October, two federal judges in the US were called out for the use of AI tools which led to errors in their rulings. In June 2025, the High Court of England and Wales warned lawyers not to use AI-generated case material after a series of cases cited fictitious or partially made up rulings. India's legal institutions are grappling alongside others around the world with how to regulate and monitor the use of AI in the courtroom. Last year, the Supreme Court published a white paper on AI in India's judiciary, in which it listed best practices as well as guidelines for AI use by judicial institutions, lawyers and clerks. The court stressed the need for human oversight and the importance of keeping institutional safeguards "firmly in place". Asia Artificial intelligence Delhi India Law and order --------------------------------------------------------------------- Related China removes three retired generals from national advisory body The little town making nearly all of China's lanterns Strait of Hormuz: What happens if Iran shuts global oil corridor? --------------------------------------------------------------------- More from the BBC 3 hrs ago [grey-place]The OpenAI CEO Sam Altman is wearing a dark blue suit with a white shirt and blue and white tie. He is holding and speaking into a microphone while sitting in front of the American flag OpenAI changes deal with US military after backlash Chief Executive Sam Altman said the group would prohibit the use of its systems to spy on Americans. 3 hrs ago 13 hrs ago [grey-place]England's Liam Dawson and Harry Brook celebrate a wicket England have better spinners than India - Vaughan Former England captain Michael Vaughan says England have a better spin attack than India and he has a "funny feeling" Harry Brook's side will win Thursday's T20 World Cup semi-final. 13 hrs ago 16 hrs ago [grey-place]A series of silver robots move around on rails. In the foreground, one picks up Warburton crumpets with an arm Did AI play a role in Ocado's 1,000 job cuts? Analysts say AI has boosted the grocer's competitors - but other factors are also at play. 16 hrs ago 17 hrs ago [grey-place]A man in a black tracksuit top holds up his young daughter who is wearing a yellow T shirt and is smiling broadly AI hope for doctor's 'most precious patient' Prof Rob Galloway hopes his charity will be help to people like his daughter, Frankie. 17 hrs ago 22 hrs ago [grey-place]Aquib Nabi Guns and curfews: How Jammu and Kashmir defied the odds to take India cricket crown The cricket team of the disputed region has won their first Ranji Trophy, India's premier domestic cricket championship. 22 hrs ago --------------------------------------------------------------------- * Home * News * Sport * Business * Technology * Health * Culture * Arts * Travel * Earth * Audio * Video * Live * Documentaries * Weather * BBC Shop * BritBox BBC in other languages The BBC is in multiple languages Read the BBC In your own language Oduu Afaan Oromootiin Amharic zeenaa ba'amaarenyaa Arabic `rby Azeri AZ@RBAYCAN Bangla baaNlaa Burmese m[?]n[?]maa Chinese Zhong Wen Wang Dari dry French AFRIQUE Hausa HAUSA Hindi hindii Gaelic NAIDHEACHDAN Gujarati gujraatiimaaN smaacaar Igbo AKUKO N'IGBO Indonesian INDONESIA Japanese Ri Ben Yu Kinyarwanda GAHUZA Kirundi KIRUNDI Korean hangugeo Kyrgyz Kyrgyz Marathi mraatthii Nepali nepaalii Noticias para hispanoparlantes Pashto pStw Persian frsy Pidgin Polish PO POLSKU Portuguese BRASIL Punjabi pNjaabii khhbraaN Russian NA RUSSKOM Serbian NA SRPSKOM Sinhala siNhl Somali SOMALI Swahili HABARI KWA KISWAHILI Tamil tmilllil ceytikll Telugu telugu vaartlu Thai khaawphaasaaaithy Tigrinya zeenaa betegerenyaa Turkish TURKCE Ukrainian UKRAYiNS'KA Urdu rdw Uzbek O'ZBEK Vietnamese TIENG VIET Welsh NEWYDDION Yoruba IROYIN NI YORUBA Follow BBC on: * Terms of Use * Subscription Terms * About the BBC * Privacy Policy * Cookies * Accessibility Help * Contact the BBC * Advertise with us * Do not share or sell my info * BBC.com Help & FAQs * Content Index * Set Preferred Source Copyright 2026 BBC. All rights reserved. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read about our approach to external linking.