https://www.theverge.com/tech/877235/nancy-guthrie-google-nest-cam-video-storage [collect] Skip to main content The homepageThe Verge logo. The Verge logo. * Tech * Reviews * Science * Entertainment * AI * Policy * The homepageThe Verge logo. Navigation Drawer The Verge logo. * Login / Sign Up close Search [ ] * Tech + Amazon + Apple + Facebook + Google + Microsoft + Samsung + Business + See all tech * Reviews + Smart Home Reviews + Phone Reviews + Tablet Reviews + Headphone Reviews + See all reviews * Science + Space + Energy + Environment + Health + See all science * Entertainment + TV Shows + Movies + Audio + See all entertainment * AI + OpenAI + Anthropic + See all AI * Policy + Antitrust + Politics + Law + Security + See all policy * Gadgets + Laptops + Phones + TVs + Headphones + Speakers + Wearables + See all gadgets * Verge Shopping + Buying Guides + Deals + Gift Guides + See all shopping * Gaming + Xbox + PlayStation + Nintendo + See all gaming * Streaming + Disney + HBO + Netflix + YouTube + Creators + See all streaming * Transportation + Electric Cars + Autonomous Cars + Ride-sharing + Scooters + See all transportation * Features * Verge Video + TikTok + YouTube + Instagram * Podcasts + Decoder + The Vergecast + Version History * Newsletters + The Verge Daily + Installer + Verge Deals + Notepad + Optimizer + Regulator + The Stepback * Archives * Store * Verge Product Updates Subscribe * * * * * The Verge logo. Why 'deleted' doesn't mean gone: How police recovered Nancy Guthrie's Nest Doorbell footage Comments Drawer Comments Loading comments Getting the conversation ready... * Tech Tech Posts from this topic will be added to your daily email digest and your homepage feed. Follow See All Tech * Report Report Posts from this topic will be added to your daily email digest and your homepage feed. Follow See All Report * Analysis Analysis Posts from this topic will be added to your daily email digest and your homepage feed. Follow See All Analysis Why 'deleted' doesn't mean gone: How police recovered Nancy Guthrie's Nest Doorbell footage Investigators pulled video from 'residual data' in Google's systems -- here's how that was possible and what it means for your privacy. Investigators pulled video from 'residual data' in Google's systems -- here's how that was possible and what it means for your privacy. by Jennifer Pattison Tuohy Jennifer Pattison Tuohy Jennifer Pattison Tuohy Senior Reviewer, Smart Home Posts from this author will be added to your daily email digest and your homepage feed. Follow See All by Jennifer Pattison Tuohy Feb 11, 2026, 6:00 PM UTC * * * If you buy something from a Verge link, Vox Media may earn a commission. See our ethics statement. 268342_How_police_recovered_Nancy_Guthrie's_doorbell_footage_CVirginia 268342_How_police_recovered_Nancy_Guthrie's_doorbell_footage_CVirginia Video footage from Nancy Guthrie's doorbell camera was recovered by Google and released by the FBI. Image: The Verge, FBI Part Of All the smart home news, reviews, and gadgets you need to know about see all updates Jennifer Pattison Tuohy Jennifer Pattison Tuohy Jennifer Pattison Tuohy Jennifer Pattison Tuohy Posts from this author will be added to your daily email digest and your homepage feed. Follow See All by Jennifer Pattison Tuohy is a senior reviewer with over twenty years of experience. She covers smart home, IoT, and connected tech, and has written previously for Wirecutter, Wired, Dwell, BBC, and US News. FBI Director Kash Patel said yesterday that investigators recovered footage from Savannah Guthrie's mother's doorbell camera using "residual data located in backend systems." This claim has many home security camera users asking an uncomfortable question: Is your data really gone when you hit delete? When Nancy Guthrie went missing, officials said she had a doorbell camera, but that it had been forcibly removed, and she did not have a subscription. This meant there were no videos stored in the cloud. Ten days later, the FBI released footage from the camera, which was revealed to be a Google Nest Doorbell, clearly showing the masked suspect. This is a huge break in the case and highlights the value of security cameras in solving crimes, even if their deterrent effect remains largely unproven. But it raises privacy concerns around how this supposedly "lost" footage was recovered. Related * How to keep your smart cam footage safe and private * FBI releases recovered footage from Nancy Guthrie's Nest cam How did Google retrieve footage that was deleted and that the user's account didn't have access to? Does this mean your deleted footage could be accessed by law enforcement? The answer to the second question, according to a forensic expert I spoke to, is technically yes. Deleted footage stored in the cloud can be recovered, but in this case, it was probably very difficult, and the resources to do so were likely made available only because of the case's high profile. I also reached out to Google, but it did not provide any additional information other than confirming that it is "assisting law enforcement with their investigations." To understand what likely happened, it helps to know how Google's Nest cameras work, because they operate differently from most cameras on the market. Most video doorbells only stream live footage, unless you either pay for a subscription to the company's cloud service to store recorded video, or use local storage, such as a microSD card or a home hub. "When you delete something from a server, it doesn't get overwritten immediately" -- Nick Barreiro Nest cameras, by contrast, can send clips to Google's servers even without a paid subscription. Google offers a small amount of free cloud storage -- older models store clips up to five minutes long for three hours; the latest models store 10-second clips for six hours. That means some footage is uploaded and stored, at least temporarily, whether you pay or not. Unlike most competitors, Google doesn't offer true local storage that you can access yourself. Newer Nest cameras do have limited on-device backup storage, but it's only accessible through Google's cloud. All of this means the footage of the suspect went to Google's servers, even though Nancy Guthrie did not pay for a subscription. If we assume Guthrie did not have the latest Nest Doorbell, which launched last October, then her doorbell would have been capable of recording five-minute clips, and she would have had access to them via the Nest or Google Home app for up to three hours after recording. The Pima County Sheriff's Department said the doorbell was disabled at 1:47AM on February 1st, and she was not reported missing until the next morning, more than three hours later. By that time, those recordings were no longer accessible to anyone with access to the account. (It's possible members of the Guthrie family had access to the app; I know I have access to my elderly parents' video doorbell app.) But because it had once been in the cloud, there was a chance it could be retrieved. According to Nick Barreiro, chief forensic analyst with Principle Forensics, deleting footage from the cloud doesn't necessarily mean it's immediately gone. "When you delete something from a server, it doesn't get overwritten immediately -- the file system is just told to ignore this data, and this space is now available to be used. But if no new data is written over it, it's still going to be there, even though you can't see it." While it would be fairly straightforward to retrieve this data from a local server or hard drive, Barreiro said the process to retrieve it from Google's servers was likely much more complicated. While Barreiro has no direct knowledge of Google's processes, he spent a decade in law enforcement focused on recorded evidence before moving to the private sector five years ago. "These video files aren't necessarily all stored on a single server; they are probably stored in fragments in servers all over the world. It probably gets very complicated with Google's architecture," he said. Footage of the suspect went to Google's servers, even though Nancy Guthrie did not pay for a subscription While the basic data recovery process remains the same, finding these files is like searching for a proverbial needle in a haystack. "Because they have been deleted, they aren't identified by the file system anymore," he says. "So you're manually looking for them." There may be other reasons it took over a week for the footage to be released. Barreiro says it could be that Google was able to access it immediately, but wouldn't release the footage without the proper legal process. "Google is notoriously uncooperative with law enforcement; they will comply with search warrants, but in the least helpful way possible and they will fight it," he says. "It's possible the delay was just getting through that legal process, properly worded court orders, and Google's lawyers fighting it." However, he says that this seems unlikely, given the high-profile nature of the case. Additionally, reports indicate it took Google's engineers "several days" to recover the footage. But it's an important point for those concerned about their data being accessible after it's been deleted. While it was technically possible in this case, it's highly unlikely to happen regularly. Barreiro believes this is "absolutely not something Google would do in a typical case." Ring, which also stores its video in the cloud, told me that the concept of "residual data" is not familiar to them. "We have run into this issue when folks have deleted footage and asked us if we can help get it back," Ring spokesperson Emma Daniels said. "But it's gone." While this case shows recovery is technically possible, it also shows it's rare, resource-intensive, and reserved for extraordinary circumstances. But if the idea makes you uneasy, you can reduce your risk by using local storage that you control and/or a cloud service that offers end-to-end encryption, which means not even the provider can access your footage. Follow topics and authors from this story to see more like this in your personalized homepage feed and to receive email updates. * Jennifer Pattison Tuohy Jennifer Pattison Tuohy Jennifer Pattison Tuohy Senior Reviewer, Smart Home Posts from this author will be added to your daily email digest and your homepage feed. Follow See All by Jennifer Pattison Tuohy * Analysis Analysis Posts from this topic will be added to your daily email digest and your homepage feed. Follow See All Analysis * Report Report Posts from this topic will be added to your daily email digest and your homepage feed. Follow See All Report * Smart Home Smart Home Posts from this topic will be added to your daily email digest and your homepage feed. Follow See All Smart Home * Tech Tech Posts from this topic will be added to your daily email digest and your homepage feed. Follow See All Tech More in: All the smart home news, reviews, and gadgets you need to know about Sen. Markey calls on Amazon to "discontinue" Ring monitoring features. Richard Lawler5:31 PM UTC Will Ring's pet finding cameras eventually track people? Jennifer Pattison Tuohy1:17 AM UTC Apple is killing the old HomeKit Tuesday Jennifer Pattison TuohyFeb 9 Most Popular Most Popular 1. Amazon Ring's Super Bowl ad sparks backlash amid fears of mass surveillance 2. Discord will require a face scan or ID for full access next month 3. The Toyota Highlander is now a three-row electric SUV with 320 miles of range 4. Discord says 'vast majority' of users won't see its new age verification setup 5. Nintendo keeps filling in the gaps The Verge Daily A free daily digest of the news that matters most. Email (required) [ ] Sign Up By submitting your email, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Notice. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply. Advertiser Content From Sponsor Logo This is the title for the native ad Sponsor thumbnail More in Tech Samsung's offering up to $900 of trade-in credit toward its new phones Samsung's offering up to $900 of trade-in credit toward its new phones Microsoft fixes Notepad flaw that could trick users into clicking malicious Markdown links Microsoft fixes Notepad flaw that could trick users into clicking malicious Markdown links Here are the 40 best Presidents Day deals you can already shop Here are the 40 best Presidents Day deals you can already shop Threads' new 'Dear Algo' feature lets you tell the algorithm what you want to see Threads' new 'Dear Algo' feature lets you tell the algorithm what you want to see Ableton Live is adding audio streaming for real-time musical collaboration Ableton Live is adding audio streaming for real-time musical collaboration Instagram and X have an impossible deepfake detection deadline Instagram and X have an impossible deepfake detection deadline Samsung's offering up to $900 of trade-in credit toward its new phonesSamsung's offering up to $900 of trade-in credit toward its new phones Samsung's offering up to $900 of trade-in credit toward its new phones Cameron Faulkner6:55 PM UTC Microsoft fixes Notepad flaw that could trick users into clicking malicious Markdown linksMicrosoft fixes Notepad flaw that could trick users into clicking malicious Markdown links Microsoft fixes Notepad flaw that could trick users into clicking malicious Markdown links Emma Roth6:06 PM UTC Here are the 40 best Presidents Day deals you can already shopHere are the 40 best Presidents Day deals you can already shop Here are the 40 best Presidents Day deals you can already shop Sheena Vasani6:00 PM UTC Threads' new 'Dear Algo' feature lets you tell the algorithm what you want to seeThreads' new 'Dear Algo' feature lets you tell the algorithm what you want to see Threads' new 'Dear Algo' feature lets you tell the algorithm what you want to see Jay Peters6:00 PM UTC Ableton Live is adding audio streaming for real-time musical collaborationAbleton Live is adding audio streaming for real-time musical collaboration Ableton Live is adding audio streaming for real-time musical collaboration Terrence O'Brien5:49 PM UTC Instagram and X have an impossible deepfake detection deadline Instagram and X have an impossible deepfake detection deadline Instagram and X have an impossible deepfake detection deadline Jess Weatherbed5:20 PM UTC Advertiser Content From Sponsor Logo This is the title for the native ad Top Stories 11:00 AM UTC 'Shut up and focus on the mission': Tech workers are frustrated by their companies' silence about ICE 2:00 PM UTC The Halide app's anti-algorithm camera mode looks better with a little processing 2:00 PM UTC Pokopia turns the Pokemon world into a relaxing, human-free paradise 4:00 PM UTC Reanimal wants to devour you 2:06 PM UTC How an 'icepocalypse' raises more questions about Meta's biggest data center project 21 seconds ago FTC says it's 'not the speech police' in letter warning Apple News about its alleged promotion of left-leaning outlets. The Verge logo. * * * * * * Contact * Tip Us * Community Guidelines * Archives * About * Ethics Statement * How We Rate and Review Products * Cookie Settings * Terms of Use * Privacy Notice * Cookie Policy * Licensing FAQ * Accessibility * Platform Status (c) 2026 Vox Media, LLC. All Rights Reserved