https://www.theverge.com/tech/876866/ring-search-party-super-bowl-ad-online-backlash [collect] Skip to main content The homepageThe Verge logo. The Verge logo. * Tech * Reviews * Science * Entertainment * AI * Policy * The homepageThe Verge logo. Navigation Drawer The Verge logo. * Login / Sign Up close Search [ ] * Tech + Amazon + Apple + Facebook + Google + Microsoft + Samsung + Business + See all tech * Reviews + Smart Home Reviews + Phone Reviews + Tablet Reviews + Headphone Reviews + See all reviews * Science + Space + Energy + Environment + Health + See all science * Entertainment + TV Shows + Movies + Audio + See all entertainment * AI + OpenAI + Anthropic + See all AI * Policy + Antitrust + Politics + Law + Security + See all policy * Gadgets + Laptops + Phones + TVs + Headphones + Speakers + Wearables + See all gadgets * Verge Shopping + Buying Guides + Deals + Gift Guides + See all shopping * Gaming + Xbox + PlayStation + Nintendo + See all gaming * Streaming + Disney + HBO + Netflix + YouTube + Creators + See all streaming * Transportation + Electric Cars + Autonomous Cars + Ride-sharing + Scooters + See all transportation * Features * Verge Video + TikTok + YouTube + Instagram * Podcasts + Decoder + The Vergecast + Version History * Newsletters + The Verge Daily + Installer + Verge Deals + Notepad + Optimizer + Regulator + The Stepback * Archives * Store * Verge Product Updates Subscribe * * * * * The Verge logo. Amazon Ring's lost dog ad sparks backlash amid fears of mass surveillance Comments Drawer Comments Loading comments Getting the conversation ready... * Tech Tech Posts from this topic will be added to your daily email digest and your homepage feed. Follow See All Tech * Report Report Posts from this topic will be added to your daily email digest and your homepage feed. Follow See All Report * Analysis Analysis Posts from this topic will be added to your daily email digest and your homepage feed. Follow See All Analysis Amazon Ring's lost dog ad sparks backlash amid fears of mass surveillance A new AI-powered Search Party feature can scan footage from neighborhood cameras to find lost dogs. Critics worry it could be used to search for people. A new AI-powered Search Party feature can scan footage from neighborhood cameras to find lost dogs. Critics worry it could be used to search for people. by Jennifer Pattison Tuohy Jennifer Pattison Tuohy Jennifer Pattison Tuohy Senior Reviewer, Smart Home Posts from this author will be added to your daily email digest and your homepage feed. Follow See All by Jennifer Pattison Tuohy Feb 11, 2026, 1:17 AM UTC * * * If you buy something from a Verge link, Vox Media may earn a commission. See our ethics statement. STK471_Government_Surveillance_CVirginia_E STK471_Government_Surveillance_CVirginia_E Image: Cath Virginia / The Verge, Getty Images Part Of All the smart home news, reviews, and gadgets you need to know about see all updates Jennifer Pattison Tuohy Jennifer Pattison Tuohy Jennifer Pattison Tuohy Jennifer Pattison Tuohy Posts from this author will be added to your daily email digest and your homepage feed. Follow See All by Jennifer Pattison Tuohy is a senior reviewer with over twenty years of experience. She covers smart home, IoT, and connected tech, and has written previously for Wirecutter, Wired, Dwell, BBC, and US News. Ring's new Search Party feature has once again drawn backlash for the company. A 30-second ad that aired during Sunday's Super Bowl showed Ring cameras "surveilling" neighborhoods to locate a lost dog. In the current political climate, a prime-time ad celebrating neighborhood surveillance struck a nerve. People voiced concerns across social media that the AI-powered technology Ring uses to identify dogs could soon be used to search for humans. Combined with Ring's recent rollout of its new facial recognition capability, it feels like a short leap for a pet-finding feature to be turned into a tool for state surveillance. Related * Ring's new Search Party feature is on by default; should you opt out? * Now anyone can tap Ring doorbells to search for lost dogs * Ring says it's not giving ICE access to its cameras Privacy expert Chris Gilliard told 404 Media that the ad was "a clumsy attempt by Ring to put a cuddly face on a rather dystopian reality: widespread networked surveillance by a company that has cozy relationships with law enforcement and other equally invasive surveillance companies." "This definitely isn't about dogs -- it's about mass surveillance" -- Sen. Ed Markey The fears center on the Amazon-owned Ring's partnership with Flock Safety, a surveillance technology company that has contracts with law enforcement to use its automated license plate readers, video surveillance systems, and other technologies. The partnership connects Ring's massive residential camera network with an organization that has reportedly allowed ICE to access data from its own nationwide camera network. "This definitely isn't about dogs -- it's about mass surveillance," Sen. Ed Markey (D-MA) posted on X. A vocal critic of Ring's ties to law enforcement, Markey has pressed for greater transparency into Ring's connections with law enforcement, along with stronger privacy protections for consumers. Comments on the YouTube video of the ad ranged from "This is a huge problem disguised as a solution," to "Smart way to gaslight people in mass surveillance." Video: Ring Ring spokesperson Emma Daniels told The Verge that Search Party is designed to match images of dogs and is "not capable of processing human biometrics." Additionally, she maintains that the Familiar Faces facial recognition feature is separate from Search Party. It operates on the individual account level, she said, and there's no communal sharing as there is with Search Party. While Familiar Faces is opt-in for each user, Search Party is enabled by default on any outdoor camera enrolled in Ring's subscription plan. It works by using AI to scan footage in the cloud for the missing dog once the owner uploads a picture to Ring's Neighbors app. If a match is found, Ring alerts the camera's owner, who can then choose to share the video or notify the owner through the app. "These are not tools for mass surveillance." -- Emma Daniels, Ring "These are not tools for mass surveillance," Daniels said. "We build the right guardrails, and we're super transparent about them." While that may be the case today, I asked whether Ring cameras could one day be used to specifically search for people. "The way these features are built, they are not capable of that today," she said. "We don't comment on feature road maps, but I have no knowledge or indication that we're building features like that at this point." Ring users can currently share footage from their cameras with local law enforcement during an active investigation through a feature called Community Requests. Unlike previous Ring police partnerships, Community Request goes through third-party companies -- the Taser company Axon and, soon, Flock. "The reason we did that is these third-party evidence management systems offer a much more secure chain of custody," says Daniels. If a user declines a request, no one will be notified. The company maintains that neither the government nor law enforcement can access its network, and that footage is shared only by users or in response to a legal request. Daniels reiterated what the company had previously told The Verge, that it has no partnerships with ICE or any other federal agency, and said you can see every request agencies have made on its Neighbors app profile. Additionally, the Flock integration is not currently live, although Daniels had no update on the company's plans for the partnership following the backlash. She referred me to an earlier response. "As we explore the integration, we will ensure the feature is built for the use of local public safety agencies only -- which is what the program is designed for." History has shown that tools capable of large-scale surveillance are rarely limited to their original purpose The problem is that there's nothing preventing local agencies from sharing footage with federal ones. And while the Super Bowl ad played up heartwarming images of a girl reunited with her puppy, the leap to this technology that can track people in your neighborhood is still very small. Combined with government overreach, it's not hard to imagine how a powerful network of AI-enabled cameras goes from finding lost dogs to hunting people. And Ring has a history of partnering with the police. While it has rolled back some of that in recent years, since founder Jamie Siminoff returned, the company has renewed its focus on using its products to prevent crime. Siminoff said he came back because of the possibilities AI brings. With this technology, he believes neighborhood cameras could be used to virtually "zero out crime" within a year. Given these stated goals and the new capabilities AI can bring, why wouldn't Ring be planning to add some form of Search Party for People to its cameras? Eliminating crime is an admirable goal, but history has shown that tools capable of large-scale surveillance are rarely limited to their original purpose. Ring has a responsibility here to protect its users, which it says it is doing. But ultimately, it comes down to how much you can trust a company - and the company it keeps - to never overstep. If Ring is cloaking its ambitions behind our instinct to protect our furry friends, that trust will be hard to find. Follow topics and authors from this story to see more like this in your personalized homepage feed and to receive email updates. * Jennifer Pattison Tuohy Jennifer Pattison Tuohy Jennifer Pattison Tuohy Senior Reviewer, Smart Home Posts from this author will be added to your daily email digest and your homepage feed. Follow See All by Jennifer Pattison Tuohy * Analysis Analysis Posts from this topic will be added to your daily email digest and your homepage feed. Follow See All Analysis * Report Report Posts from this topic will be added to your daily email digest and your homepage feed. Follow See All Report * Smart Home Smart Home Posts from this topic will be added to your daily email digest and your homepage feed. Follow See All Smart Home * Tech Tech Posts from this topic will be added to your daily email digest and your homepage feed. Follow See All Tech More in: All the smart home news, reviews, and gadgets you need to know about Why 'deleted' doesn't mean gone: How police recovered Nancy Guthrie's Nest Doorbell footage Jennifer Pattison Tuohy6:00 PM UTC Sen. Markey calls on Amazon to "discontinue" Ring monitoring features. Richard Lawler5:31 PM UTC Apple is killing the old HomeKit Tuesday Jennifer Pattison TuohyFeb 9 Most Popular Most Popular 1. Amazon Ring's Super Bowl ad sparks backlash amid fears of mass surveillance 2. Discord will require a face scan or ID for full access next month 3. The Toyota Highlander is now a three-row electric SUV with 320 miles of range 4. Discord says 'vast majority' of users won't see its new age verification setup 5. Nintendo keeps filling in the gaps The Verge Daily A free daily digest of the news that matters most. Email (required) [ ] Sign Up By submitting your email, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Notice. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply. Advertiser Content From Sponsor Logo This is the title for the native ad Sponsor thumbnail More in Tech Samsung's offering up to $900 of trade-in credit toward its new phones Samsung's offering up to $900 of trade-in credit toward its new phones Microsoft fixes Notepad flaw that could trick users into clicking malicious Markdown links Microsoft fixes Notepad flaw that could trick users into clicking malicious Markdown links Here are the 40 best Presidents Day deals you can already shop Here are the 40 best Presidents Day deals you can already shop Why 'deleted' doesn't mean gone: How police recovered Nancy Guthrie's Nest Doorbell footage Why 'deleted' doesn't mean gone: How police recovered Nancy Guthrie's Nest Doorbell footage Threads' new 'Dear Algo' feature lets you tell the algorithm what you want to see Threads' new 'Dear Algo' feature lets you tell the algorithm what you want to see Ableton Live is adding audio streaming for real-time musical collaboration Ableton Live is adding audio streaming for real-time musical collaboration Samsung's offering up to $900 of trade-in credit toward its new phonesSamsung's offering up to $900 of trade-in credit toward its new phones Samsung's offering up to $900 of trade-in credit toward its new phones Cameron Faulkner6:55 PM UTC Microsoft fixes Notepad flaw that could trick users into clicking malicious Markdown linksMicrosoft fixes Notepad flaw that could trick users into clicking malicious Markdown links Microsoft fixes Notepad flaw that could trick users into clicking malicious Markdown links Emma Roth6:06 PM UTC Here are the 40 best Presidents Day deals you can already shopHere are the 40 best Presidents Day deals you can already shop Here are the 40 best Presidents Day deals you can already shop Sheena Vasani6:00 PM UTC Why 'deleted' doesn't mean gone: How police recovered Nancy Guthrie's Nest Doorbell footageWhy 'deleted' doesn't mean gone: How police recovered Nancy Guthrie's Nest Doorbell footage Why 'deleted' doesn't mean gone: How police recovered Nancy Guthrie's Nest Doorbell footage Jennifer Pattison Tuohy6:00 PM UTC Threads' new 'Dear Algo' feature lets you tell the algorithm what you want to seeThreads' new 'Dear Algo' feature lets you tell the algorithm what you want to see Threads' new 'Dear Algo' feature lets you tell the algorithm what you want to see Jay Peters6:00 PM UTC Ableton Live is adding audio streaming for real-time musical collaborationAbleton Live is adding audio streaming for real-time musical collaboration Ableton Live is adding audio streaming for real-time musical collaboration Terrence O'Brien5:49 PM UTC Advertiser Content From Sponsor Logo This is the title for the native ad Top Stories 11:00 AM UTC 'Shut up and focus on the mission': Tech workers are frustrated by their companies' silence about ICE 6:00 PM UTC Why 'deleted' doesn't mean gone: How police recovered Nancy Guthrie's Nest Doorbell footage 2:00 PM UTC The Halide app's anti-algorithm camera mode looks better with a little processing 2:00 PM UTC Pokopia turns the Pokemon world into a relaxing, human-free paradise 4:00 PM UTC Reanimal wants to devour you 2:06 PM UTC How an 'icepocalypse' raises more questions about Meta's biggest data center project The Verge logo. * * * * * * Contact * Tip Us * Community Guidelines * Archives * About * Ethics Statement * How We Rate and Review Products * Cookie Settings * Terms of Use * Privacy Notice * Cookie Policy * Licensing FAQ * Accessibility * Platform Status (c) 2026 Vox Media, LLC. All Rights Reserved