https://nautil.us/childhood-friends-not-moms-shape-attachment-styles-most-1247316/ * * * home icon * search icon logo Close Search for: [ ] [Search] logo Log in Subscribe [ ] search icon * Channels * Topics * About * Contact us * Newsletter * Become a member * Shop Channels [qkQZ8WA9-art-science-4] Art+Science [Biology_Beyond-1] Biology + Beyond [Cosmos-logo] Cosmos [Culture-logo] Culture [Currents-homepage-logo] Currents [Earth-logo] Earth [Life-logo] Life [Mind-logo] Mind [Ocean-logo] Ocean [OneQuestion-logo] One Question [QuantaAb-logo] Quanta Abstractions [Rewilding-TEXT] Rewilding science at the ballot box Science at the Ballot Box [JAiEEmsV-science-phill] Science Philanthropy Alliance [spark_logo_short_color-] Spark of Science [TheAnimalIssue-homepage-logo] The Animal Issue [TheClimatesIssue-text-logo] The Climates Issue [uPhjJJqL-Kinship-homepage-logo] The Kinship Issue [Homepage-logo-ThePorthole-2] The Porthole [7vja40dB-Reality-issue-homepage-logo] The Reality Issue [TheRebelIssue-label] The Rebel Issue [Women-in-Science-Engineering] Women in Science & Engineering Topics * Anthropology * Arts * Astronomy * Communication * Economics * Environment * Evolution * General * Genetics * Geoscience * Health * History * Math * Microbiology * Neuroscience * Paleontology * Philosophy * Physics * Psychology * Sociology * Technology * Zoology Already a member? Log in * facebook-icon * twitter-icon * Subscribe Zoology Some Cockroaches Like to Cuddle, Too Paleontology These Neanderthals May Have Eaten Their Enemies Sociology Seeing a Superhero on the Subway Makes People More Likely to Surrender Their Seats Arts The Math Shows Jackson Pollock Painted Like a Child Would Technology Why Don't We Have More Solar Planes? Zoology Feeling Magnetism Helps These Little Sea Turtles Find Food Evolution "Living Fossil" Discovered by Accident Could Reshape Tree of Life Zoology Lions Have Been Keeping One of Their Roars Secret Zoology This Ancient Sea Monster Had a Killer Bite and No Teeth Environment Moss Might Survive Nearly Two Decades in Space Astronomy Earth's Nastiest Neighbor Was Closer Than We Thought Zoology A Leopard Seal Mother's Love Transcends Death ADVERTISEMENT Nautilus Members enjoy an ad-free experience. Log in or Join now . * Psychology Childhood Friends, Not Moms, Shape Attachment Styles Most A new study upends conventional wisdom about how we relate to those closest to us * By Kristen French * November 11, 2025 * [comment-pl] Add a comment * [share] Share img Facebook img Twitter img Pocket img Reddit imgEmail Illustration of the silhouettes of children playing in and under a green leafy tree. Unravel the biggest ideas in science today. Become a more curious you. Unravel the biggest ideas in science today. Become a more curious you. The full Nautilus archive * eBooks & Special Editions * Ad-free reading * The full Nautilus archive * eBooks & Special Editions * Ad-free reading Subscribe to Nautilus Join [currents-s] Explore Humans are social animals. We depend on our friends, partners, and family members to steer through troubled waters and cheer us on when we shine. One popular school of psychology known as attachment theory suggests that these close relationships tend to follow established patterns that differ from one person to the next: Some of us feel secure in our relationships, while others are more anxious about abandonment, less willing to trust even those we hold most dear. Nautilus Members enjoy an ad-free experience. Log in or Join now . Now a large, new, 30-year study has found that our earliest friendships may have the biggest impact on how well we "attach" to friends and romantic partners in adulthood. If true this finding would upend conventional wisdom that our relationships with our parents leave the biggest mark on our attachment styles later in life. The team of researchers found that, in fact, mothers come second, and fathers, at least in the cohort studied, had little influence. The study, published in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, followed 705 people and their families over three decades, starting in the 1990s. British psychiatrist and psychoanalyst John Bowlby developed attachment theory in the 1970s and early '80s, and it entered into the popular discourse in the intervening decades. The theory evolved, with subsequent research suggesting that our attachment styles are shaped across our lifetimes by multiple relationships, not just those with our parents, as Bowlby had initially proposed. But until now, few studies had experimentally tested, over a person's lifetime, the fundamental assumptions underlying attachment theory. To do this, Keely Dugan, an assistant professor of social personality psychology at the University of Missouri and her colleagues, analyzed data from one landmark longitudinal study of 1,364 children and their families that started in 1991 and stretched over 15 years. They then followed up with 705 of the original study participants, who were now 26 to 31 years of age. ADVERTISEMENT Nautilus Members enjoy an ad-free experience. Log in or Join now . Read more: "Love Is Biological Bribery" The data for the original study came from a variety of sources: The authors periodically videotaped mothers and fathers interacting with their young children and made notes about their sensitivity to their children's needs. They analyzed parent-child conflicts and closeness through reports from the parents and measured parents' warmth and hostility through reports from the children. They also examined how the children rated their friendship quality and collected teacher and parent reports about their social competence with peers. In the follow up, Dugan and her team evaluated the attachment styles and relationship quality of the now-adult participants, with their romantic partners, friends, and family members. They controlled for family income-to-needs ratio, maternal education, race and ethnicity, and sex assigned at birth. Dugan and her colleagues found that a person's relationship with their mother does shape their general attachment style and their specific individual relationships with friends, romantic partners, and fathers, accounting for 2 to 3 percent of differences in anxiety and avoidance. So, for example, people whose mothers were less warm and fuzzy during their younger years tended to feel more insecure in their adult relationships. The more recent the interaction with the mother, the more influence it potentially seemed to have. But early friendship bonds played an even bigger part than maternal relationships in the ways people navigated adult friendships and romantic partnerships, accounting for 4 percent of the variance in adults' romantic partner- and best friend-specific attachment anxiety, and 10 to 11 percent in their partner- and best friend-specific avoidance. ADVERTISEMENT Nautilus Members enjoy an ad-free experience. Log in or Join now . "In general, if you had high-quality friendships and felt connected to your friends in childhood, then you felt more secure in romantic relationships and friendships at age 30," Dugani told Scientific American. "When you have those first friendships at school, that's when you practice give-and-take dynamics," she added. "Relationships in adulthood then mirror those dynamics." Even more reason to choose your schoolyard friends wisely. [nautilus-f] Enjoying Nautilus? Subscribe to our free newsletter. Lead image: Ihnatovich Maryia / Shutterstock ADVERTISEMENT Nautilus Members enjoy an ad-free experience. Log in or Join now . * Kristen French Posted on November 11, 2025 Kristen French is an associate editor at Nautilus. She has worked in science journalism since 2013, reporting and writing features and news for publications such as Wired, Backchannel, The Verge, and New York Magazine. She has a masters degree in science journalism from Columbia University. Article Sidebar Image Zoology Some Cockroaches Like to Cuddle, Too Article Sidebar Image Paleontology These Neanderthals May Have Eaten Their Enemies Article Sidebar Image Sociology Seeing a Superhero on the Subway Makes People More Likely to Surrender Their Seats ADVERTISEMENT [comment-pl] View / Add Comments Fuel your wonder. Feed your curiosity. Expand your mind. Access the entire Nautilus archive, ad-free on any device. Explore Subscriptions [Print_2up_] * [currents-s] Explore Article Recirculation Lead Image Some Cockroaches Like to Cuddle, Too + By Jake Currie + November 21, 2025 + Zoology It's not the heat, it's the humidity * [currents-s] Explore Article Recirculation Lead Image These Neanderthals May Have Eaten Their Enemies + By Molly Glick + November 21, 2025 + Paleontology And it could be our fault * [currents-s] Explore Article Recirculation Lead Image Seeing a Superhero on the Subway Makes People More Likely to Surrender Their Seats + By Jake Currie + November 21, 2025 + Sociology You might be on your best behavior with the Dark Knight or Superman watching, too * [currents-s] Explore Article Recirculation Lead Image The Math Shows Jackson Pollock Painted Like a Child Would + By Kristen French + November 21, 2025 + Arts And that might be what made the artist so famous * [currents-s] Explore Article Recirculation Lead Image Why Don't We Have More Solar Planes? + By Molly Glick + November 21, 2025 + Technology These futuristic aircraft still haven't fully taken off after five decades logo NAUTILUS: SCIENCE CONNECTED Nautilus is a different kind of science magazine. Our stories take you into the depths of science and spotlight its ripples in our lives and cultures. Get the Nautilus newsletter Cutting-edge science, unraveled by the very brightest living thinkers. NL - Footer Email: * [ ] Captcha Sign up for free If you are human, leave this field blank. [ ] Quick links * Home * About Us * Contact * FAQ * Prime * Ebook * Shop * Donate * Awards and Press * Privacy Policy * Terms of Service * RSS * Jobs * Newsletter * Ethics Policy Social * Facebook * Twitter * Instagram --------------------------------------------------------------------- (c) 2025 NautilusNext Inc., All rights reserved. ! There is not an active subscription associated with that email address. Already a member? Log in Subscribe to continue reading, and get 25% off. You've read your 2 free articles this month. Access unlimited ad-free stories, including this one, by becoming a Nautilus member. Subscribe @ 25% off ! There is not an active subscription associated with that email address. Already a member? Log in This is your last free article. Get 25% off now. Don't limit your curiosity. Access unlimited ad-free stories like this one, and support independent journalism, by becoming a Nautilus member. Subscribe @ 25% off 1/2 FREE ARTICLES THIS MONTH Become a Nautilus member at our lowest price of the year. Subscribe @ 25% off x 2/2 FREE ARTICLES THIS MONTH This is your last free article. Get 25% off for a limited time. Subscribe @ 25% off x [szdBs2Dz-2] Literary and always interesting. To read this story, sign up for the free Nautilus newsletter: science and culture for people who love beautiful writing. NL - Emailgate * [ ] Captcha Sign up for free If you are human, leave this field blank. [ ]