https://www.billboard.com/pro/how-minecraft-score-became-big-business-for-composer/ an image, when javascript is unavailable x Skip to main content Billboard * Billboard Hot 100(tm) * Billboard 200(tm) * Global 200 LOGIN Login Click to Expand Search Input Account * Manage Account * Log Out Account Open menu Search Click to Expand Search Input Billboard Billboard Search Click to Expand Search Input LOGIN Login Account * Manage Account * Log Out Account Search Click to Expand Search Input * Billboard Hot 100(tm) * Billboard 200(tm) * Global 200 Open menu Search Click to Expand Search Input Billboard Billboard Search Click to Expand Search Input LOGIN Login Account * Manage Account * Log Out Account Search Click to Expand Search Input * Billboard Hot 100(tm) * Billboard 200(tm) * Global 200 Trending Topics > * Diddy Verdict * KPop Demon Hunters * Indie Power Players * Chinese Streaming Stocks Still Surging, Sphere Entertainment ... * In Canada: TikTok CEO Requests 'Urgent' Meeting With Ministe ... * Billboard's Music Industry Events Calendar * Streaming 04/16/2025 * Share on Facebook * Share on X * Share to Flipboard * Share on Pinterest * + additional share options added * Share on Reddit * Share on LinkedIn * Share on Whats App * Send an Email * Print this article * Post a Comment * Share on Tumblr How the 'Minecraft' Game Score Unexpectedly Became Big Business For Its Composer Daniel 'C418' Rosenfeld wrote the score to the highest-selling game in history, then turned down a tech giant's offer to buy it. Billions of streams later, he reflects on the decision. By Kristin Robinson Kristin Robinson Senior Writer More Stories by Kristin * Five Years Post-Rehab, $uicideboy$ Are 'Grateful to be Alive' -- And Maybe Even Happy * How Indie Thinking Helped Faye Webster Create Her Own Musical Universe -- And Prepare For Her Move to a Major * ASCAP Pledges $1 Million to Songwriter Members Suffering from Wildfire Losses View All * Share on Facebook * Share on X * Share to Flipboard * Share on Pinterest * + additional share options added * Share on Reddit * Share on LinkedIn * Share on Whats App * Send an Email * Print this article * Post a Comment * Share on Tumblr Daniel Rosenfeld and Patrick McDermott Daniel Rosenfeld and Patrick McDermott Phoebe Wilson In 2009, in between full-time shifts at a local factory, then-19-year-old musician Daniel Rosenfeld composed a score for an independent video game. "It was just a side hustle, maybe not even that. It was a hobby, really," explains Rosenfeld, who records under the name C418. Related Jack Black and David Grohl Jack Black Teams With Dave Grohl For Rocking 'Minecraft' Soundtrack Song 'I Feel Alive... 03/24/2025 The game, Minecraft, turned out to be successful beyond Rosenfeld's wildest dreams. In 2014, Microsoft purchased Minecraft's Swedish developer, Mojang Studios, for $2.5 billion, and through 2023, it had sold 300 million copies of the game, making it the best-selling video game of all time. Now, it's the latest one to receive a movie adaption, and even that has been wildly successful: A Minecraft Movie, starring Jack Black, is the biggest box office hit of 2025 to date, having already grossed $550.6 million since it opened on April 4. Because no one anticipated the game's whirlwind success, or had the budget to properly pay him back in 2009, Rosenfeld was compensated for his work with a small fee and 100% ownership over Minecraft's now-iconic score. Then, when Microsoft came calling, Rosenfeld made a fateful decision: he refused to sell the score to the tech behemoth, opting instead to bring on game composer manager Patrick McDermott to help him navigate building a business as an independent composer of Minecraft. Trending on Billboard McDermott counts himself as one of the rare folks who understands how to navigate both games and music. He started his career at Captured Tracks, and from 2015 to 2020 he built Ghost Ramp, a label which specialized in releasing game soundtracks on vinyl. At the time he was brought in to help Rosenfeld, he was also managing a number of other games composers, too. Though McDermott says deals like Rosenfeld's, where composers retain ownership of their IP, are increasingly rare, his Minecraft soundtracks have proven to be big business. The score, Minecraft Volume Alpha, which is distributed via TuneCore, was certified gold by the RIAA in 2023, and this month, it was inducted into the Library of Congress by the National Recording Registry, which cited it as an "audio treasure worthy of preservation." Related C418 C418 Hits No. 1 on Emerging Artists Chart Thanks to 'Minecraft: Volume... 08/03/2023 Since its release on digital service providers, streams of Minecraft Volume Alpha and its companion Volume Beta have averaged 38% year over year growth, and they have been streamed 2.8 billion times worldwide, according to McDermott. McDermott and Rosenfeld have built a surprisingly formidable vinyl business, too. The album, distributed by Ghostly, has sold over 200,000 units to date globally. Rosenfeld even has fans of his own who often congregate in a Discord server devoted to talking about his work, which includes the scores for other games such as Catacomb Snatch and Wanderstop. But it's not all fun and games for Rosenfeld. He thinks that by not selling the score to Microsoft, he might have sacrificed his chance to make future soundtracks for the Minecraft franchise -- and it's true that since he declined Microsoft's offer once and for all, Rosenfeld has not written anything for the game, with Microsoft instead turning to other composers. But because many Minecraft players are nostalgic for his original soundtrack, the score for A Minecraft Movie, composed by Devo's Mark Mothersbaugh, interpolates it -- giving Rosenfeld some upside from the blockbuster's success. In the end, Rosenfeld feels he made the right choice. "I don't want to be stuck with the same thing for the next 50 years," he says of Minecraft, and now, he can turn his attention to the new scoring gigs that excite him. Here, Rosenfeld and McDermott speak to Billboard about the strange business of scoring for games and building a living off of Minecraft. "I know it's hard to believe, but there's a real argument that Daniel's music is up there for the most heard audio by humans in history," says McDermott. Related Lil Nas X roblox The Crossover Potential Between Music & Gaming Is Clear - But It Requires a Thoughtful Approach... 06/08/2023 How were you compensated for the original Minecraft game? Daniel Rosenfeld: I asked for a share of the game, and I didn't get a share. I got a tiny, tiny amount of salary for the music itself. The good thing, though, is that I owned the rights to the music, and that's still persistent to this day. At the time, like 2010, people liked doing [revenue] shares for indie games as payment -- like the musician gets 10 percent [of the game's IP], the visual artist gets 20, and then the main developer gets 40 or whatever. That's usually what happened back then. Mine was a little different. Back in the day, when you made this score, is this also how larger game scores worked? Would Nintendo, for example, offer a deal like this? Rosenfeld: Absolutely not. Nintendo is a Japanese company and in that culture, it's typical that you would likely not get ownership but you'd just be employed there for, sometimes, the rest of your life. It's the expectation of a company like Nintendo that it's like a family -- we work together and stay together. The mindset of American video game companies is different. The usual deal is the composer writes a song, and they get a single fee. That's it. No residuals are typical in a AAA [a term used to describe video games produced by large publishers] big game. Patrick McDermott: The typical structure is to get paid a price per minute of audio. Has the way composers are paid in the independent game industry shifted since Minecraft launched? McDermott: The way I see it is that there was a big boom of independent games. The comparison I use to explain this is what happened to the music business when [digital audio workstations] and home recording got easier. We got a lot more independent musicians, right? Independent gamemaking was the same. It got a lot easier because you had new tools like Unity and Gamemaker that make it possible to start building your own games. I'd say the heyday of indie games was something like 2008 to 2012 or so. The upstart, scrappy indie game business that allowed for a lot of this shared equity model was really successful for a period of time, but it's just one of the sad, prototypical things that as people see more success in a market, the more bureaucratic and standardized things become. Minecraft was a surprise hit. Then, Microsoft came along and bought it. You've said before that they wanted to buy the music rights from you. Why did you decline that offer? McDermott: We did have conversations about it. Honestly, beyond sheer dollar figures, there was a gap in our understanding of each other. This was the genesis of Daniel and my relationship -- when these conversations with Microsoft started to happen. And Daniel was smart enough to say, "Maybe it would be good to have an intermediary to help with it." We involved a really wonderful lawyer on our side, and we had a strong belief that this music really matters. We just never quite came to the same terms and understanding on it [with Microsoft]. Daniel's music is doing incredibly well. Who knows? Maybe they'll knock on the door again someday, but for now, we're thrilled that Daniel maintained ownership through all this. Rosenfeld: I'm still going to therapy for this whole process. [Laughs ] Do any of your peers have the rights to their music from popular games today? Rosenfeld: I am in a unique position, but it's a bit of a monkey paw. I think it's still frowned upon by the Microsofts, Sonys and Nintendos of the world for an artist to have ownership like I do. I'm a proponent of keeping rights, but it comes with the problem of some people not liking you so much for it. McDermott: A lot of these composers don't have anyone to advocate for them in these deals. I've had a couple situations with clients that I've worked for that are less known than Daniel, and we've been able to secure some rights for them, just because video games lawyers typically don't know the nuances of the music business language enough to iron some things out. In a number of cases, I've been able to get the full IP ownership [of the music for the composer] and give gaming companies the unfettered usages that they want, but we can still sub-license back the monetization of digital and physical royalties that the musician wants. Related Netflix TV and Film Composers Say Netflix, Other Streaming Services Insist on Buying Out Their... 12/11/2019 Patrick, when you go into a negotiation for one of your clients, what is the first thing you ask for? McDermott: I always want artists to be able to maintain their digital royalties, their physical royalties and their autonomy to make those decisions where they can sign with a record label for the vinyl side of things -- stuff like that. I honestly wouldn't expect someone to want a game soundtrack on vinyl, but it seems like you all have built a booming vinyl business. McDermott: When we grew up, we would buy games, and we loved the physical boxes and manuals and keepsakes that came with it. Now, most things you buy you just fire up on Steam or on the PlayStation store. I think people are drawn to the idea of having something physical from the Minecraft game they've always loved. If I had to guess, probably like 75% of the people who buy it never put it on a turntable. Even beyond just Daniel's music, there's just a lack of physical collectibles in these digital spaces, so it just fills that need. Patrick, you've mentioned before that there's a lack of understanding, on both the music and gaming sides, of the other. What are some of the mistakes you saw musicians making in the gaming world? McDermott: When I got into game audio, I would talk to these game composers and realize their sales numbers were so massive compared to the independent tier that I had worked on. It was akin to the top artists at a label like Captured Tracks [where I previously worked]. You'd find someone who casually had Mac DeMarco-level sales numbers. The biggest mistake I saw some game composers making is they would be selling 30,000 units on Bandcamp in six months, but they never registered their music with a PRO. They didn't know about SoundExchange. They probably had not been receiving publishing royalties in a meaningful way. I realized I could at least bridge these gaps for these composers and help them capture the royalties that are out there for them. Rosenfeld: Yeah, I wasn't signed with a PRO [when I met Patrick]. There were a lot of back royalties that were owed to me that I didn't know existed. McDermott: BMI, to their credit, reached out to Daniel because there was uncollected money. Thankfully these PROs have a period of about three years for retroactive royalties. So some of his money was technically lost, but we were still able to garner three years of back royalties. Related VR Gaming From Music Star To Avatar: Tech-Savvy Lawyers Share Tips For Negotiating Artist Appearances In... 07/24/2020 I imagine the streaming habits for fans of the Minecraft score are pretty different from traditional mainstream pop listeners. Patrick, can you explain what listening behavior you're seeing? McDermott: There are two main things that I find pretty wild about Daniel's digital performance. One is just the sheer amount of organic listens that avoid any of the algorithmic and editorial playlisting. The other thing is Spotify started sharing streams per listeners, which obviously shows if listeners hear a single once and move on or if they are bingeing the track, and Daniel's is quite high. It's 15 streams per listener. That's at least seven or eight listens higher than anyone else I have access to. It's also very evenly listened to throughout the soundtrack. How is Daniel's score represented in the new Minecraft film? McDermott: There's a song that the film licensed from us for interpolation across the score. It's in there a number of times. There's one song called "Dragonfish" that's from a separate composition Daniel did during his negotiation with Microsoft, and Microsoft actually owns the rights to that one -- well, Daniel owns the royalty and monetization rights, but Microsoft owns the IP. They actually play that song in full in the movie. We have no idea if that was gamesmanship on their part, using one of the songs of Daniel's that they have better access to, or if they creatively just chose that one. Rosenfeld: To their credit, I find the way they interpolated my song to be quite respectful. I haven't seen the movie. I don't know if I want to see the movie. I still need to go to more therapy. [Laughs] The movie is still very new, but has hype around it translated into more streams for Daniel's original score? McDermott: Since the release of the film, his three highest streaming days ever were consecutive. Like within a range of 10 percent to 20 percent higher than usual. Patrick, have you seen a noticeable impact in the consumption for this soundtrack since you came on as manager? McDermott: Since Daniel and I started working together, the catalog is probably about eight to 10 times [more] in terms of monthly [listeners]. Still, every year has been bigger than the last since we started working together. I think it's just worth saying that Minecraft is obviously continuing to add players -- I think that's what separates this. It's such a unique IP to be associated with -- so different from traditional music or even film. It's just getting bigger over time. Related How the 'Minecraft' Score Became Big Business For Its Composer Nashville's Big Score? Luring Game Composers To Town 07/24/2020 Do you attribute the growth in listenership to Minecraft's continually growing popularity, or do you also think that the trend is due to your various marketing efforts? Rosenfeld: This is actually my little source of pride: as long as I have worked on Minecraft, there has been next to no marketing help. McDermott: We don't have a marketing budget for ads or anything. This is just organic. We just let it ride and see where it goes. But I think the reason it's growing is twofold. It's new Minecraft fans, and I think there was a transition of game audio listeners leaving Bandcamp and becoming Spotify users. We saw a big drop in Bandcamp and a big jump in Spotify in the last few years. What about YouTube? There are so many gamers who are streaming their game play on there and other sites like Twitch. How do you handle monetizing your IP versus letting users enjoy the soundtrack? Rosenfeld: We don't collect any Content ID stuff on YouTube. We just rejected the idea of claiming those videos. Why? Rosenfeld: Legally I wasn't allowed to. It was part of the original first contract. McDermott: It's a pretty unique thing to gaming. You would never want to short-change the marketing of the game to monetize the music. It just wouldn't make any sense to pull monetization from these streamers because then they will just start muting the music. The spirit of the arrangement is to let content creators play the game and even do things beyond the game and let the score be part of it. It's definitely different. If my music was being used on a random stream, I would claim it, but that's not how it works here. How much does Spotify account for Daniel's soundtrack income now? McDermott: Nearly 70 percent. Back when you had the opportunity, you decided to not sell to Microsoft. Since then, there have been more compositions made to build on the Minecraft universe that came from other composers. Do you feel that if you had done it differently then maybe you'd be part of the newer scores? Rosenfeld: Yeah, I bet I would, but here's the thing: If I would have said yes, I would probably be able to write so much more music for them, but I probably would not feel great about it. I chose not to sell it, and now, I get the different sadness of, like, a messy divorce [with Minecraft] -- but in return, I get my mental health and my freedom. This story is part of Billboard's music technology newsletter Machine Learnings. Sign up for Machine Learnings, and other Billboard newsletters for free here. Daily newsletters straight to your inbox Sign Up Read More About * Billboard Family * Catalog * minecraft * Publishing * video games More From Pro [tencent-mu] Business News Chinese Streaming Stocks Still Surging, Sphere Entertainment Shares Gain * By Glenn Peoples * 2 days ago [shou-zi-ch] Business News In Canada: TikTok CEO Requests 'Urgent' Meeting With Minister of Industry Amid Shutdown Order * By Heather Taylor-Singh, Richard Trapunski * 2 days ago [Events-cal] Business News Billboard's Music Industry Events Calendar * By Chris Eggertsen * 2 days ago [Willie-Nel] Business News 'Austin City Limits' EP Terry Lickona on Federal Funding Cuts to Public Media: 'This Is a Kick in the Gut' * By Melinda Newman * 2 days ago [digital-mo] Business News 5 Things to Watch for in Music Companies' Upcoming Q2 Earnings Results * By Glenn Peoples * 2 days ago See All News Icon Link PMC Logo Most Popular Emmys 2025: List of Nominees Azealia Banks Leaks Unsolicited Nudes And DMs Allegedly From Conor McGregor Jamie Lee Curtis Thinks Colbert's Cancellation Isn't Just About Ratings -- & Her Words Are Chilling Donors to Reportedly Pull Funding from Florida University Museum After Controversial Transfer You May Also Like Loading... [Shark-Week] 'Shark Week' 2025 Is Here: Everything to Know About Discovery's 37th Annual Event 3 hrs ago [tracee] Tracee Ellis Ross On Why She Only Packs Two Pairs Of Undies In Her Carry-On For Vacation 2 days ago [scottie-sc] Scottie Scheffler's 4th Major Win Earns Him $3.1 Million in Prize Money 36 minutes ago [GettyImage] Rep. Jasmine Crockett: 'Wannabe Hitler' Trump Is Demanding GOP 'Loyalty' Over Epstein Files 3 hrs ago Cover, $uicideboy$ Customer Service Billboard * * About Us * Accessibility * Advertise * Shop * Events * Careers * Contact Us Legal * Privacy Policy * Terms of Use * California Privacy Rights * Ad Choices * Reprints & Permissions * Privacy Preferences * Your Privacy Choices Sitemap * Charts * Music * Culture * Media * Pro Follow Us * Follow Billboard on Facebook * Follow Billboard on Instagram * Follow Billboard on Pinterest * Follow Billboard on X * Follow Billboard on YouTube Have a Tip? Send us a tip using our anonymous form. Send us a tip Send us a tip The Daily A daily briefing on what matters in the music industry Your email [ ] Sign Up Sign Up By providing your information, you agree to our Terms of Use and our Privacy Policy. We use vendors that may also process your information to help provide our services. // This site is protected by reCAPTCHA Enterprise and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply. Have a Tip? Send us a tip using our anonymous form. Send us a tip Send us a tip Billboard * * About Us * Accessibility * Advertise * Shop * Events * Careers * Contact Us Legal * Privacy Policy * Terms of Use * California Privacy Rights * Ad Choices * Reprints & Permissions * Privacy Preferences * Your Privacy Choices Sitemap * Charts * Music * Culture * Media * Pro Subscriptions Customer Service Icon Link PMC Logo Billboard is a part of Penske Media Corporation. (c) 2025 Billboard Media, LLC. All Rights Reserved. Powered by WordPress.com VIP optional screen reader Our Sites * Art in America * Artforum * ARTnews * Billboard * BlogHer * Deadline * Flow Space * Gold Derby * IndieWire * Robb Report * Rolling Stone * SheKnows * Soaps * Sourcing Journal * Sportico * StyleCaster * The Hollywood Reporter * TVLine * Variety * Vibe * WWD Login Login * Account + Manage Account + Log Out Close the menu * Charts Expand charts menu + All Charts + Billboard Hot 100(tm) + Billboard 200(tm) + Global 200 + Hits Of The World(tm) + Chart Beat + Songs Of The Summer + Year-End Charts + Decade-End Charts * Music Expand music menu + Music News + Pop + R&B/Hip-Hop + Latin + Rock + Awards + Chart Beat + Concerts + Features + Reviews * Videos Expand videos menu * Culture Expand culture menu + Events + Lifestyle + Politics + TV/Film * Media Expand media menu + Lists + Photos + Podcasts + Videos * Business Expand business menu + Business News + Legal + Touring + Publishing + Radio + Record Labels + View All Pro * Pro Tools Expand pro-tools menu + Songwriters & Producers + Song Index + Artist Index + Royalty Calculator + Market Watch + Industry Events Calendar * Billboard Espanol Expand billboard-espanol menu + Noticias + Musica + Negocios + Cultura y Entretenimiento * Get Up Anthems by Tres Expand get-up-anthems-by-tres menu * Honda Music Expand honda-music menu GET ACCESS TODAY * Follow Billboard on Facebook * Follow Billboard on Instagram * Follow Billboard on Pinterest * Follow Billboard on X * Follow Billboard on YouTube [ ] By providing your information, you agree to our Terms of Use and our Privacy Policy. We use vendors that may also process your information to help provide our services. // This site is protected by reCAPTCHA Enterprise and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply. * About Us * Accessibility * Advertise * Shop * Events * Careers * Contact Us Billboard is a part of Penske Media Corporation. (c) 2025 Billboard Media, LLC. All Rights Reserved. ad Quantcast