https://nymag.com/intelligencer/article/google-ai-mode-search-results-bury-the-web.html * Intelligencer * The Cut * Vulture * The Strategist * * Curbed * Grub Street * Magazine Subscribe to the Magazine Give a Gift Subscription Buy Back Issues Current Issue Contents New York Shop Subscribe to New York Magazine * Subscribe * Sign In * Account Profile Saved for later Sign Out Menu Menu Close Close * Politics * Business * Technology * Ideas * About Intelligencer * Newsletters * New York App Like Us Follow Us * NYMag.com * New York Magazine * Intelligencer * Vulture * The Cut * The Strategist * Grub Street * Curbed Search [ ] Subscribe Give A Gift Menu Menu Close Close * Politics * Business * Technology * Ideas * About Intelligencer * Newsletters * New York App Like Us Follow Us * NYMag.com * New York Magazine * Intelligencer * Vulture * The Cut * The Strategist * Grub Street * Curbed Leave a Comment Search [ ] screen time Google Is Burying the Web Alive Portrait of John Herrman By John Herrman, a tech columnist at Intelligencer Formerly, he was a reporter and critic at the New York Times and co-editor of The Awl. 5:00 A.M. saved Save this article to read it later. Find this story in your account's 'Saved for Later' section. Comment [4cb731bcff029a47aa644ab8d45643cf9f-google-search-] Photo-Illustration: Intelligencer By now, there's a good chance you've encountered Google's AI Overviews, possibly thousands of times. Appearing as blurbs at the top of search results, they attempt to settle your queries before you scroll -- to offer answers, or relevant information, gleaned from websites that you no longer need to click on. The feature was officially rolled out at Google's developer conference last year and had been in testing for quite some time before that; on the occasion of this year's conference, the company characterized it as "one of the most successful launches in Search in the past decade," a strangely narrow claim that is almost certainly true: Google put AI summaries on top of everything else, for everyone, as if to say, "Before you use our main product, see if this works instead." This year's conference included another change to search, this one more profound but less aggressively deployed. "AI Mode," which has similarly been in beta testing for a while, will appear as an option for all users. It's not like AI Overviews; that is, it's not an extra module taking up space on a familiar search-results page but rather a complete replacement for conventional search. It's Google's "most powerful AI search, with more advanced reasoning and multimodality, and the ability to go deeper through follow-up questions and helpful links to the web," the company says, "breaking down your question into subtopics and issuing a multitude of queries simultaneously on your behalf." It's available to everyone. It's a lot like using AI-first chatbots that have search functions, like those from OpenAI, Anthropic, and Perplexity, and Google says it's destined for greater things than a small tab. "As we get feedback, we'll graduate many features and capabilities from AI Mode right into the core Search experience," the company says. I've been testing AI Mode for a few months now, and in some ways it's less radical than it sounds and (at first) feels. It resembles the initial demos of AI search tools, including those by Google, meaning it responds to many questions with clean, ad-free answers. Sometimes it answers in extended plain language, but it also makes a lot of lists and pulls in familiar little gridded modules -- especially when you ask about things you can buy -- resulting in a product that, despite its chatty interface, feels an awful lot like ... search. Again, now you can try it yourself, and your mileage may vary; it hasn't drawn me away from Google proper for a lot of thoughtless rote tasks, but it's competitive with ChatGPT for the expanding range of searchish tasks you might attempt with a chatbot. From the very first use, however, AI Mode crystallized something about Google's priorities and in particular its relationship to the web from which the company has drawn, and returned, many hundreds of billions of dollars of value. AI Overviews demoted links, quite literally pushing content from the web down on the page, and summarizing its contents for digestion without clicking: Photo-Illustration: Intelligencer; Screenshot: Google Meanwhile, AI Mode all but buries them, not just summarizing their content for reading within Google's product but inviting you to explore and expand on those summaries by asking more questions, rather than clicking out. In many cases, links are retained merely to provide backup and sourcing, included as footnotes and appendices rather than destinations: Photo-Illustration: Intelligencer; Screenshot: Google This is typical with AI search tools and all but inevitable now that such things are possible. In terms of automation, this means companies like OpenAI and Google are mechanizing some of the "work" that goes into using tools like Google search, removing, when possible, the step where users leave their platforms and reducing, in theory, the time and effort it takes to navigate to somewhere else when necessary. In even broader terms -- contra Google's effort to brand this as "going beyond information to intelligence" -- this is an example of how LLMs offer different ways to interact with much of the same information: summarization rather than retrieval, regeneration rather than fact-finding, and vibe-y reconstruction over deterministic reproduction. This is interesting to think about and often compelling to use but leaves unresolved one of the first questions posed by chatbots-as-search: Where will they get all the data they need to continue to work well? When Microsoft and Google showed off their first neo-search mockups in 2023, which are pretty close to today's AI mode, it revealed a dilemma: Search engines still provide the de facto gateway to the broader web, and have a deeply codependent relationship with the people and companies whose content they crawl, index, and rank; a Google that instantly but sometimes unreliably summarizes the websites to which it used to send people would destroy that relationship, and probably a lot of websites, including the ones on which its models were trained. And, well, yep! Now, both AI Overviews and AI Mode, when they aren't occasionally hallucinating, produce relatively clean answers that benefit in contrast to increasingly degraded regular search results on Google, which are full of hyperoptimized and duplicative spamlike content designed first and foremost with the demands of Google's ranking algorithms and advertising in mind. AI Mode feels one step further removed from that ecosystem and once again looks good in contrast, a placid textual escape from Google's own mountain of links that look like ads and ads that look like links (of course, Google is already working on ads for both Overviews and AI Mode). In its drive to embrace AI, Google is further concealing the raw material that fuels it, demoting links as it continues to ingest them for abstraction. Google may still retain plenty of attention to monetize and perhaps keep even more of it for itself, now that it doesn't need to send people elsewhere; in the process, however, it really is starving the web that supplies it with data on which to train and from which to draw up-to-date details. (Or, one might say, putting it out of its misery.) Two years later, Google has become more explicit about the extent to which it's moving on from the "you provide us results to rank, and we send you visitors to monetize" bargain, with the head of search telling The Verge, "I think the search results page was a construct." Which is true, as far as it goes, but also a remarkable thing to hear from a company that's communicated carefully and voluminously to website operators about small updates to its search algorithms for years. I don't doubt that Google has been thinking about this stuff for a while and that there are people at the company who deem it strategically irrelevant or at least of secondary importance to winning the AI race -- the fate of the web might not sound terribly important when your bosses are talking nonstop about cashing out its accumulated data and expertise for AGI. I also don't want to be precious about the web as it actually exists in 2025, nor do I suggest that websites working with or near companies like Meta and Google should have expected anything but temporary, incidental alignment with their businesses. If I had to guess, the future of Google search looks more like AI Overviews than AI mode -- a jumble of widgets and modules including and united by AI-generated content, rather than a clean break -- if only for purposes of sustaining Google's multi-hundred-billion-dollar advertising business. But I also don't want to assume Google knows exactly how this stuff will play out for Google, much less what it will actually mean for millions of websites, and their visitors, if Google stops sending as many people beyond its results pages. Google's push into productizing generative AI is substantially fear-driven, faith-based, and informed by the actions of competitors that are far less invested in and dependent on the vast collection of behaviors -- websites full of content authentic and inauthentic, volunteer and commercial, social and antisocial, archival and up-to-date -- that make up what's left of the web and have far less to lose. Maybe, in a few years, a fresh economy will grow around the new behaviors produced by searchlike AI tools; perhaps companies like OpenAI and Google will sign a bunch more licensing deals; conceivably, this style of search automation simply collapses the marketplace supported by search, leveraging training based on years of scraped data to do more with less. In any case, the signals from Google -- despite its unconvincing suggestions to the contrary -- are clear: It'll do anything to win the AI race. If that means burying the web, then so be it. Sign Up for the Intelligencer Newsletter Daily news about the politics, business, and technology shaping our world. Email [ ] [Sign up] This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply. Vox Media, LLC Terms and Privacy Notice By submitting your email, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Notice and to receive email correspondence from us. Tags: * screen time * google * artificial intelligence * search engines * the internet * big tech * ai chatbots * More Show Leave a Comment Google Is Burying the Web Alive Things you buy through our links may earn Vox Media a commission. Sign In to Comment THE FEED 12:00 p.m. american affairs american affairs This Report Shows the Path to Victory for Democrats in 2026 By Ross Barkan Don't assume Beyonce -- or any celebrity -- can turn out voters. But there are strategies that actually work. 5/25/2025 early and often early and often Elon Musk's Legacy Is Making Trump's Outrageous Agenda Seem Tame By Ed Kilgore The departing DOGE chief's wild opening assault on the federal government paved the way for more long-term demolition work. Most Popular 1. Google Is Burying the Web Alive By John Herrman 2. There's a Crazy New Wrinkle to College Admissions By Jeffrey Selingo 3. It's Time to Kill the Casual Workplace By Carrie Battan 4. Everyone Is Cheating Their Way Through College By James D. Walsh 5. Elon Musk's Legacy Is Making Trump's Outrageous Agenda Seem Tame By Ed Kilgore 1. Google Is Burying the Web Alive By John Herrman 2. There's a Crazy New Wrinkle to College Admissions By Jeffrey Selingo 3. Everyone Is Cheating Their Way Through College By James D. Walsh 4. It's Time to Kill the Casual Workplace By Carrie Battan 5. Barry Diller: The Truth About Me and Diane von Furstenberg By Barry Diller 5/24/2025 early and often early and often 2028 Voters Won't Care About the Biden 'Cover-Up' By Ed Kilgore If people are still focused on the ex-president's health, as some pundits think they will be, then Democrats will have bigger problems. 5/23/2025 early and often early and often Judge Calls Out Trump's Absurd Argument for Wrecking the Department of Education By Ed Kilgore In what could lead to a consequential Supreme Court decision, Myong J. Joun said it's absurd to claim demolishing an agency improves its efficiency. 5/23/2025 trump 2.0 trump 2.0 Trump's Hyped Meme-Coin Dinner Might Have Been a Bust By Matt Stieb The contest that promised "Dinner With President Trump" didn't even include a dinner with President Trump. 5/23/2025 early and often early and often J.D. Vance Believes It's Legal If It's Popular By Ed Kilgore Team Trump believes he uniquely embodies the Will of the People and judges should shut up and get onboard. 5/23/2025 what we know what we know How to Make Sense of Trump's Plan to Stop Making Cents By Chas Danner Here are answers to all your questions about how and when the U.S. will soon go penniless. 5/23/2025 pivot pivot Kara Swisher and Scott Galloway Say Good Riddance to Elon Musk By Intelligencer Staff The Pivot co-hosts discuss his bad reputation in Washington and what he might do next. 5/23/2025 early and often early and often 3 Ways Senate Republicans Could Blow Up Trump's Big Beautiful Bill By Ed Kilgore There are as many factions among Republicans in the upper chamber as in the House. Both chambers have to agree on the final product. It won't be easy. 5/23/2025 politics politics Trump Administration Tries to Expel Harvard's Foreign Students By Nia Prater As Homeland Security secretary Kristi Noem escalates the administration's war on the university, Harvard announced that it plans to sue. 5/23/2025 early and often early and often Republicans Kill California's Right to Clean Its Air By Ed Kilgore A six-decade tradition of federalism was snuffed out at the behest of oil and automotive interests. 5/23/2025 the law the law Letitia James Is Caught in a War of Her Own Making By Elie Honig She wrongly weaponized her office against Trump, but that doesn't make his retaliation with the Justice Department right. 5/23/2025 higher education higher education There's a Crazy New Wrinkle to College Admissions By Jeffrey Selingo A last-minute round of deal-making from schools eager to boost enrollment. 5/22/2025 liveblog liveblog Gunman Kills 2 Israeli Embassy Staffers Outside D.C. Jewish Museum: Live Updates By Intelligencer Staff The gunman allegedly opened fire outside a Wednesday-night event at the Capital Jewish Museum and afterward shouted "Free Palestine." 5/22/2025 announcements announcements Introducing How to Look at Art, by Jerry Saltz By The Editors A New York Night School course from our senior art critic. 5/22/2025 screen time screen time OpenAI's Huge Bet on the iPhone Guy By John Herrman Sam Altman is hoping you'll take a mysterious AI device with you everywhere. 5/22/2025 early and often early and often Trump Rams His Big, Dangerous Bill Through House By Ed Kilgore The bill redistributes wealth in an upward direction while adding debt, which Democrats will howl about as the bill slogs through the Senate. 5/22/2025 social studies social studies It's Time to Kill the Casual Workplace By Carrie Battan In the war of the office, etiquette is actually your friend. 5/22/2025 just asking questions just asking questions Jake Tapper Dissects Bidenworld's 'Big Lie' By Benjamin Hart The Original Sin co-author discusses the former president's decline and why it still matters amid Trump's chaos. 5/21/2025 the city politic the city politic What We Know About the DoJ's Investigation Into Andrew Cuomo By Nia Prater The inquiry follows a House GOP referral that alleges Cuomo lied when testifying before Congress about his handling of the COVID pandemic. 5/21/2025 tremendous content tremendous content Kristi Noem Needs a Mirror, Not DHS Staff Polygraphs By Margaret Hartmann The secretary is aggressively hunting for leakers within DHS, though the top source of embarrassing Kristi Noem stories is ... Kristi Noem. 5/21/2025 early and often early and often No Tax on Tips Act Shows Congress Can't Even Fix Easy Things By Ed Kilgore A bill so popular it passed the Senate unanimously is now snarled in Trump's "One, Big, Beautiful Bill" in the House. 5/21/2025 early and often early and often Trump's Military Parade: All About His Pricey Birthday Bash By Margaret Hartmann A long-planned celebration of the Army's 250th anniversary will now include the military parade of Trump's dreams. Here's everything we know. 5/21/2025 the city politic the city politic A Decade of Failure, Futility, and Violence on Rikers Island By Errol Louis It took a federal judge to do what at least three administrations would not: order an end to the mayhem. Email [ ] [Submit] You\'ll receive the next newsletter in your inbox. *Sorry, there was a problem signing you up. [ ] [] By submitting your email, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Notice and to receive email correspondence from us. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply. or Already a subscriber? Sign In What is your email? This email will be used to sign into all New York sites. By submitting your email, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy and to receive email correspondence from us. Enter your email: [ ] Please enter a valid email address. Submit Email or Connect with Google Connect with Facebook Sign in | Subscribe Today Sign In To Continue Reading Create Your Free Account edit email Sign in with Facebook Sign in with Google [pizza ] Choose a password to create an account: Enter your password orsign in with a different email [ ] [ ] Forgot Password? Password must be at least 8 characters and contain: * Lower case letters (a-z) * Upper case letters (A-Z) * Numbers (0-9) * Special Characters (!@#$%^&*) This password will be used to sign into all New York sites. By submitting your email, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy and to receive email correspondence from us. Sign In Create Account You're in! As part of your account, you'll receive occasional updates and offers from New York, which you can opt out of anytime. Continue Reading or Already a subscriber? Sign In What is your email? This email will be used to sign into all New York sites. By submitting your email, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy and to receive email correspondence from us. Enter your email: [ ] Please enter a valid email address. Submit Email or Connect with Google Connect with Facebook Sign in | Subscribe Today Sign In To Continue Reading Create Your Free Account edit email Sign in with Facebook Sign in with Google [pizza ] Choose a password to create an account: Enter your password orsign in with a different email [ ] [ ] Forgot Password? Password must be at least 8 characters and contain: * Lower case letters (a-z) * Upper case letters (A-Z) * Numbers (0-9) * Special Characters (!@#$%^&*) This password will be used to sign into all New York sites. By submitting your email, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy and to receive email correspondence from us. Sign In Create Account You're in! As part of your account, you'll receive occasional updates and offers from New York, which you can opt out of anytime. Continue Reading Already a subscriber? Sign In View Account Log Out Already a subscriber? Sign In View Account Log Out Gift Scout Promotional Image [ ] * please try a longer search Close Modal [modal-imag] Have an Account? Log In Like Us Follow Us Follow Us Follow Us * About Intelligencer * About New York Magazine * Newsletters * Help * Contact * Press * Media Kit * We're Hiring * Privacy * Terms * Ad Choices * Accessibility * Do not sell or share my personal data intelligencer is a Vox Media Network. (c) 2025 Vox Media, LLC. All rights reserved.