https://www.theverge.com/news/671711/google-ai-overviews-search-publisher-data-choice [collect] Skip to main content The homepageThe Verge logo. The Verge logo. * Tech * Reviews * Science * Entertainment * AI * More The homepageThe Verge logo. Menu Navigation Drawer The Verge logo. * Login / Sign Up close Search [ ] * Tech + All Tech + Amazon + Apple + Facebook + Google + Microsoft + Samsung + Business + Creators + Mobile + Policy + Security + Transportation * Reviews + All Reviews + Buying Guides + Deals + Gift Guide + Laptops + Phones + Headphones + Tablets + Smart Home + Smartwatches + Speakers + Drones * Science + All Science + Space + Energy + Environment + Health + COVID-19 * Entertainment + All Entertainment + Games + TV Shows + Movies + Audio * AI * Cars + All Cars + Electric Cars + Autonomous Cars + Ride-Sharing + Scooters + Other Transportation * Features * Videos + All Videos + YouTube + TikTok + Instagram * Podcasts + All Podcasts + Decoder + The Vergecast * Newsletters + All Newsletters + Command Line + Installer + Notepad + Verge Deals * Store Subscribe * * * * * The Verge logo. Google rejected giving publishers more choice to opt out of AI Search Comments Drawer * News Google rejected giving publishers more choice to opt out of AI Search Google chose to 'silently update' publisher controls with 'no public announcement.' Google chose to 'silently update' publisher controls with 'no public announcement.' by Jess Weatherbed May 21, 2025, 4:48 PM UTC * * * 236780_Google_AntiTrust_Trial_Custom_Art_CVirginia__0000_4 236780_Google_AntiTrust_Trial_Custom_Art_CVirginia__0000_4 Publishers have to opt out of Search entirely to avoid their content being used in AI Overviews. Illustration by Cath Virginia / The Verge Jess Weatherbed Jess Weatherbed is a news writer focused on creative industries, computing, and internet culture. Jess started her career at TechRadar, covering news and hardware reviews. Google didn't want to give publishers the choice to keep their content out of AI Search results because it's "evolving into a space for monetisation." That's according to a newly disclosed internal document, spotted by Bloomberg, which reveals that Google had discussed offering publishers more granular control over how website data would be used in AI Search features instead of the illusion of choice they eventually received. The document, written by Google Search executive Chetna Bindra, was released during the US antitrust trial into Google's online search monopoly. The access to its search engine data gives Google a huge advantage in AI development over rivals like Perplexity and OpenAI. But Google's AI Overviews and AI Mode can be detrimental to the websites they source from by reducing clickthroughs, incentivizing publishers to keep their content out of AI summaries and related features if given the choice. One of the suggestions in the documents that Google considered a "hard red line" would enable publishers to prevent Google's AI models from referencing their data in real time, but not opt out of being used to train features like AI Overviews generally. Another option, labeled as "likely unstable," suggested that no additional controls should be added, and that publishers can opt out of being indexed on Search entirely "if not satisfied." A screenshot taken of Trial Exhibit-PXR0026 in the US v. Google case. Here are some of the options that could have been provided to publishers. Image: Google A court hearing on May 2nd revealed that publishers are facing that ultimatum. While Google introduced a way for publishers to opt out of AI training in 2023, Google DeepMind vice president of product Eli Collins said it doesn't apply to search-specific AI products like AI Overviews. The only way for publishers to avoid AI Overviews sucking up their content is to opt out of being crawled by Googlebot -- which stops their website being indexed for Search altogether. When AI Overviews rolled out last year, Google decided to "silently update" the information about publisher controls with "no public announcement," according to the document. Guidance on how to word the update also suggests that Google intentionally made it harder for publishers to know what they were actually opting out of to avoid getting "into the details of distinction" between training for Gemini, AI Overviews, and other AI models. "Do what we say, say what we do, but carefully," Bindra said in the document. Google says that this document was an early list of options it was considering as AI search was evolving, and doesn't reflect the decisions it ultimately made. "Publishers have always controlled how their content is made available to Google as AI models have been built into Search for many years, helping surface relevant sites and driving traffic to them," Google spokesperson Peter Schottenfels said in a statement to The Verge. "New search features like AI Overviews have led to more searches, which creates new opportunities for sites to be discovered." The wording that Google currently uses is more upfront, saying that publishers who flag their content not to be used for AI Overviews and AI Mode will also keep it out of "all forms of search results." See More: * AI * Google * Law * News * Policy * Tech More in this stream See all Eddy Cue is fighting to save Apple's $20 billion paycheck from Google Lauren FeinerMay 7 Comment Icon Bubble Apple's Eddy Cue: 'You may not need an iPhone 10 years from now' Wes Davis and Lauren FeinerMay 7 Comment Icon Bubble Google searches are falling in Safari for the first time ever -- probably because of AI Emma Roth and Lauren FeinerMay 7 Comment Icon Bubble Most Popular Most Popular 1. The 15 biggest announcements at Google I/O 2025 2. Google's future is Google Googling 3. OpenAI is buying Jony Ive's AI hardware company 4. We tried on Google's prototype AI smart glasses 5. Google made an AI coding tool specifically for UI design Installer A weekly newsletter by David Pierce designed to tell you everything you need to download, watch, read, listen to, and explore that fits in The Verge's universe. Email (required) [ ] Sign Up By submitting your email, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Notice. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply. Advertiser Content From Sponsor Logo This is the title for the native ad Sponsor thumbnail More in News News publishers call Google's AI Mode 'theft' News publishers call Google's AI Mode 'theft' Microsoft adds over 50 'Retro Classics' to Game Pass Microsoft adds over 50 'Retro Classics' to Game Pass Windows 95 chime composer Brian Eno denounces Microsoft for its ties to Israeli government Windows 95 chime composer Brian Eno denounces Microsoft for its ties to Israeli government Chevy expands 2026 Silverado EV lineup with Trail Boss addition Chevy expands 2026 Silverado EV lineup with Trail Boss addition Google has a new tool to help detect AI-generated content Google has a new tool to help detect AI-generated content Toyota's new Rav4 plug-in hybrid lets you fast charge the battery Toyota's new Rav4 plug-in hybrid lets you fast charge the battery News publishers call Google's AI Mode 'theft'News publishers call Google's AI Mode 'theft' News publishers call Google's AI Mode 'theft' Emma RothTwo hours ago Comment Icon Bubble Microsoft adds over 50 'Retro Classics' to Game PassMicrosoft adds over 50 'Retro Classics' to Game Pass Microsoft adds over 50 'Retro Classics' to Game Pass Wes DavisTwo hours ago Comment Icon Bubble Windows 95 chime composer Brian Eno denounces Microsoft for its ties to Israeli governmentWindows 95 chime composer Brian Eno denounces Microsoft for its ties to Israeli government Windows 95 chime composer Brian Eno denounces Microsoft for its ties to Israeli government Mia SatoTwo hours ago Comment Icon Bubble Chevy expands 2026 Silverado EV lineup with Trail Boss additionChevy expands 2026 Silverado EV lineup with Trail Boss addition Chevy expands 2026 Silverado EV lineup with Trail Boss addition Andrew J. HawkinsTwo hours ago Comment Icon Bubble Google has a new tool to help detect AI-generated contentGoogle has a new tool to help detect AI-generated content Google has a new tool to help detect AI-generated content Jay Peters7:52 PM UTC Comment Icon Bubble Toyota's new Rav4 plug-in hybrid lets you fast charge the battery Toyota's new Rav4 plug-in hybrid lets you fast charge the battery Toyota's new Rav4 plug-in hybrid lets you fast charge the battery Umar Shakir7:52 PM UTC Comment Icon Bubble Advertiser Content From Sponsor Logo This is the title for the native ad Top Stories 5:12 PM UTC OpenAI is buying Jony Ive's AI hardware company 11:30 AM UTC Google's future is Google Googling 6:41 PM UTC Did WhatsApp really need Meta? 12:00 PM UTC The pursuit of better drugs through orbital space crystals May 20 We tried on Google's prototype AI smart glasses May 20 The 15 biggest announcements at Google I/O 2025 The Verge logo. * * * * * * Contact * Tip Us * Community Guidelines * About * Ethics Statement * How We Rate and Review Products * Cookie Settings * Terms of Use * Privacy Notice * Cookie Policy * Licensing FAQ * Accessibility * Platform Status (c) 2025 Vox Media, LLC. All Rights Reserved