https://www.wsj.com/arts-culture/books/bright-circle-and-margaret-fuller-the-rise-of-the-transcendental-woman-1bacdb10 Skip to Main Content Explore Our Brands * WSJ * ----------------------------------------------------------------- * Barron's * ----------------------------------------------------------------- * MarketWatch * ----------------------------------------------------------------- * IBD * ----------------------------------------------------------------- * * ----------------------------------------------------------------- Buy Side from WSJ The Wall Street Journal * English Edition Edition[English ] * Print Edition * Video * Audio * Latest Headlines * More More[Other Products from WSJ] * Latest * World * Business * U.S. * Politics * Economy * Tech * Markets & Finance * Opinion * Arts * Lifestyle * Real Estate * Personal Finance * Health * Style * Sports The Wall Street Journal * Latest * World * Business * U.S. * Politics * Economy * Tech * Markets & Finance * Opinion * Arts * Lifestyle * Real Estate * Personal Finance * Health * Style * Sports SectionsMy Account * + Home + Latest + World + Business + U.S. + Politics + Economy + Tech + Markets & Finance + Opinion + Arts + Lifestyle + Real Estate + Personal Finance + Taxes + Health + Style + Sports + Print Edition + Video + Audio + Latest Headlines * More + Buy Side from WSJ + The Journal Collection + WSJ Shop + WSJ Wine * Latest * World + Main + Africa + Americas + Asia + China + Europe + Middle East + India + Oceania + Russia + U.K. + Science + Anthropology + Biology + Environment + Physics + Space & Astronomy + World Video + Obituaries * Business + Main + Airlines + Autos + C-Suite + Deals + Earnings + Energy & Oil + Entrepreneurship + Telecom + Retail + Hospitality + Logistics + Media + CFO Journal + CIO Journal + CMO Today + Logistics Report + Risk & Compliance + WSJ Pro Bankruptcy + WSJ Pro Central Banking + WSJ Pro Cybersecurity + WSJ Pro Private Equity + WSJ Pro Sustainable Business + WSJ Pro Venture Capital + Heard on the Street + Journal Reports + Business Video + Business Podcast * U.S. + Main + Climate & Environment + Education + Law + College Rankings 2025 + U.S. Video + What's News Podcast * Politics + Main + Elections + National Security + Policy + Politics Video * Economy + Main + Central Banking + Consumers + Housing + Jobs + Trade + Global + WSJ Pro Bankruptcy + WSJ Pro Central Banking + WSJ Pro Private Equity + WSJ Pro Venture Capital + Capital Account + Economic Forecasting Survey + Economy Video * Tech + Main + AI + Biotech + Cybersecurity + Personal Technology + Keywords by Christopher Mims + Personal Tech by Joanna Stern + Family & Tech by Julie Jargon + Personal Tech by Nicole Nguyen + CIO Journal + The Future of Everything + Tech Video + Tech Podcast * Markets & Finance + Main + Banking + Commodities & Futures + Currencies + Investing + Regulation + Stocks + Heard on the Street + Capital Account by Greg Ip + The Intelligent Investor by Jason Zweig + Tax Report by Laura Saunders + Streetwise by James Mackintosh + CFO Journal + Markets Video + Your Money Briefing Podcast + Market Data Home + Companies + U.S. Stocks + Commodities + Bonds & Rates + Currencies Market Data + Mutual Funds & ETFs + Investment Banking Scorecard * Opinion + Main + Gerard Baker + Sadanand Dhume + Allysia Finley + James Freeman + William A. Galston + Daniel Henninger + Holman W. Jenkins + Andy Kessler + William McGurn + Walter Russell Mead + Peggy Noonan + Mary Anastasia O'Grady + Jason Riley + Joseph Sternberg + Kimberley A. Strassel + Editorials + Commentary + Future View + Houses of Worship + Cross Country + Letters to the Editor + The Weekend Interview + All Things with Kim Strassel Newsletter + All Things with Kim Strassel Podcast + Potomac Watch Podcast + Foreign Edition Podcast + Free Expression Podcast + Opinion Video + Notable & Quotable * Arts + Main + Books + Film + Fine Art + History + Music + Television + Theater + Architecture Review + Art Reviews + Book Reviews + Film Reviews + Television Reviews + Theater Reviews + Masterpiece Series + Music Reviews + Dance Reviews + Opera Reviews + Exhibition Reviews + Cultural Commentary + WSJ Puzzles + What To Watch + Arts Calendar * Lifestyle + Main + Careers + Cars + Fitness + Food & Cooking + Relationships + Travel + Workplace + On Wine by Lettie Teague + Work & Life by Rachel Feintzeig + Carry On by Dawn Gilbertson + On The Clock by Callum Borchers + Elizabeth Bernstein + Turning Points by Clare Ansberry + WSJ Puzzles + Recipes * Real Estate + Main + Commercial Real Estate + Luxury Homes * Personal Finance + Main + Retirement + Savings + Credit + Taxes + Mortgages + The Intelligent Investor by Jason Zweig + Tax Report by Laura Saunders + Streetwise by James Mackintosh * Taxes * Health + Main + Healthcare + Pharma + Wellness + Your Health by Sumathi Reddy * Style + Main + Beauty + Design + Fashion + Off Brand by Rory Satran + My Monday Morning * Sports + Main + Baseball + Basketball + Football + Golf + Hockey + Olympics + Soccer + Tennis + Jason Gay WSJ Logo 'Bright Circle' and 'Margaret Fuller': The Rise of the Transcendental Woman Share Resize --------------------------------------------------------------------- Listen (5 min) Advertisement BEST OFBooks & Arts in Review Spring Reading Is Here The Best Books of March Best in Children's Books The 10 Best Books of 2024 This copy is for your personal, non-commercial use only. Distribution and use of this material are governed by our Subscriber Agreement and by copyright law. For non-personal use or to order multiple copies, please contact Dow Jones Reprints at 1-800-843-0008 or visit www.djreprints.com. https://www.wsj.com/arts-culture/books/ bright-circle-and-margaret-fuller-the-rise-of-the-transcendental-woman-1bacdb10 1. Arts & Culture ----------------------------------------------------------------- 2. Books ----------------------------------------------------------------- 3. Bookshelf 'Bright Circle' and 'Margaret Fuller': The Rise of the Transcendental Woman Never mind Hawthorne and Thoreau-- the women of mid-19th century New England had their own ambitions for writing and life. By Christoph Irmscher Share Resize --------------------------------------------------------------------- Listen (5 min) Margaret FullerMargaret Fuller Photo: National Portrait Gallery, Smithsonian Institution Mary Moody Emerson, Ralph Waldo Emerson's aunt, was once asked whether she wanted tea, coffee or chocolate. She replied: "All." Would she, wondered her hostess, want them in separate cups? No, said Mary, "all together." A silly reply, a "crotchet," opines the writer Randall Fuller. But his deeply satisfying "Bright Circle: Five Remarkable Women in the Age of Transcendentalism" is a tribute to a set of 19th-century women who made an art of contrarian thinking. They had strong reasons to do so, as the most brilliant of them, Margaret Fuller (no relation to the author, I believe), asserted, with stabbing irony: "Ye cannot believe it, men; but the only reason why women ever assume what is more appropriate to you, is because you prevent them from finding out what is fit for themselves." Grab a Copy Bright Circle: Five Remarkable Women in the Age of Transcendentalism By Randall Fuller Oxford University Press 416 pages We may earn a commission when you buy products through the links on our site. Buy Book Amazon Barnes & Noble Books a Million Bookshop [im-3636294] The five New England women featured in "Bright Circle"--Mary Moody Emerson, Elizabeth Peabody, her sister Sophia Peabody, Lydia Jackson (later Emerson) and Margaret Fuller--did indeed want it "all together," and preferably all at once. At a time when women were mostly barred from college, they found other ways of extending their educations. As Mr. Fuller, a professor of American literature at the University of Kansas, informs us, Margaret Fuller grew up reading the classics in Italian, Spanish and French; Elizabeth Peabody knew as much about theology as a Harvard Divinity School student; while Sophia Peabody's determination to be a painter triumphed over her splitting headaches. "When she closed her eyes at night," writes Mr. Fuller, "she saw splashes of color, shadows and light." Social opprobrium didn't faze these women. Mary Moody Emerson wore shroudlike garments by day and slept on a bed shaped like a coffin--her nightly memento mori. The members of Mr. Fuller's quintet had a surefire way of alienating their male contemporaries. Composing a series of articles about the "Hebrew Scriptures" for the Christian Examiner, Elizabeth Peabody reinterpreted Eve's reaching for the apple in paradise as a legitimate quest for knowledge. Andrews Norton, the Examiner's editor, ended the series. For the poet Henry Wadsworth Longfellow, Margaret Fuller simply was that "dreary woman," his response to a caustic review in which she had marveled that people would even bother to call Longfellow a plagiarist. In her view, it was painfully obvious that so much of his poetry was "derived from the works of others." Grab a Copy Margaret Fuller: Collected Writings By Margaret Fuller; edited by Brigitte Bailey, Noelle A. Baker and Megan Marshall Library of America 850 pages We may earn a commission when you buy products through the links on our site. Buy Book Amazon Barnes & Noble Books a Million Bookshop [im-8627625] Copyright (c)2025 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 87990cbe856818d5eddac44c7b1cdeb8 --------------------------------------------------------------------- Videos --------------------------------------------------------------------- Most Popular News --------------------------------------------------------------------- Most Popular OPINION --------------------------------------------------------------------- Further Reading image opinion Who's 'Ripping Off' Whom in the Economy? image opinion A Poor Presidential Precedent on Due Process image opinion Why Are America's Closest Allies Democracies? image opinion When Tariffs Raked In Revenue for Washington image opinion Trump Endangers Our Most Lucrative Exports Advertisement * The Wall Street Journal * English Edition Edition[English ] * Subscribe NowSign In * Back to Top << WSJ Membership * The Journal Collection * Subscription Options * Why Subscribe? * Corporate Subscriptions * WSJ Higher Education Program * WSJ High School Program * Public Library Program * WSJ Live * Commercial Partnerships Customer Service * Customer Center * Contact Us * Cancel My Subscription Tools & Features * Newsletters & Alerts * Guides * Topics * My News * RSS Feeds * Video Center * Watchlist * Podcasts * Visual Stories Ads * Advertise * Commercial Real Estate Ads * Place a Classified Ad * Sell Your Business * Sell Your Home * Recruitment & Career Ads * Digital Self Service More * About Us * Content Partnerships * Corrections * Jobs at WSJ * News Archive * Register for Free * Reprints & Licensing * Buy Issues * WSJ Shop * Dow Jones Press Room * Dow Jones Smart Money * WSJ Membership Benefits * Customer Center * Cancel My Subscription * Legal Policies * Facebook * Twitter * Instagram * YouTube * Podcasts * Snapchat * Google Play * App Store Dow Jones Products * Barron's * BigCharts * Dow Jones Newswires * Factiva * Financial News * Mansion Global * MarketWatch * Risk & Compliance * Buy Side from WSJ * WSJ Pro * WSJ Video * WSJ Wine * The Times * Privacy Notice * Cookie Notice * Copyright Policy * Data Policy * Terms of Use * Your Ad Choices * Accessibility * Copyright (c)2025 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Back to Top << English Edition Edition[English ] --------------------------------------------------------------------- * Facebook * Twitter * Instagram * YouTube * Podcasts * Snapchat WSJ Membership * The Journal Collection * Subscription Options * Why Subscribe? * Corporate Subscriptions * WSJ Higher Education Program * WSJ High School Program * Public Library Program * WSJ Live * Commercial Partnerships Customer Service * Customer Center * Contact Us * Cancel My Subscription Tools & Features * Newsletters & Alerts * Guides * Topics * My News * RSS Feeds * Video Center * Watchlist * Podcasts * Visual Stories Ads * Advertise * Commercial Real Estate Ads * Place a Classified Ad * Sell Your Business * Sell Your Home * Recruitment & Career Ads * Digital Self Service More * About Us * Content Partnerships * Corrections * Jobs at WSJ * News Archive * Register for Free * Reprints & Licensing * Buy Issues * WSJ Shop * Dow Jones Press Room * Dow Jones Smart Money * WSJ Membership Benefits * Customer Center * Cancel My Subscription * Legal Policies * Dow Jones Press Room * The Times * Google Play * App Store --------------------------------------------------------------------- Sign In Copyright (c)2025 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Copyright (c)2025 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved This copy is for your personal, non-commercial use only. Distribution and use of this material are governed by our Subscriber Agreement and by copyright law. For non-personal use or to order multiple copies, please contact Dow Jones Reprints at 1-800-843-0008 or visit www.djreprints.com.