https://www.ft.com/content/7de594be-605c-407e-bf63-fb119d2513bc Accessibility helpSkip to navigationSkip to contentSkip to footer * Sign In * Subscribe Open side navigation menuOpen search bar SubscribeSign In Search the FT[ ]SearchClose search barClose * Home * World Sections + World Home + Middle East war + Global Economy + UK + US + China + Africa + Asia Pacific + Emerging Markets + Europe + War in Ukraine + Americas + Middle East & North Africa Most Read + UK distances itself from Macron ceasefire proposal + What Tesla's tarnish tells us about America Inc + How big is the stock market's America bubble? + Europe has bought Zelenskyy some time + Trump renews attacks on Zelenskyy over US backing against Russia * US Sections + US Home + US Economy + Investing in America + US Companies + US Politics & Policy + US Presidential Election 2024 Most Read + What Tesla's tarnish tells us about America Inc + How big is the stock market's America bubble? + Europe has bought Zelenskyy some time + Trump renews attacks on Zelenskyy over US backing against Russia + How Trump's tariffs threaten an iconic US pick-up truck * Companies Sections + Companies Home + Energy + Financials + Health + Industrials + Media + Professional Services + Retail & Consumer + Tech Sector + Telecoms + Transport Most Read + What Tesla's tarnish tells us about America Inc + European defence shares jump as blistering rally gathers pace + How Trump's tariffs threaten an iconic US pick-up truck + TSMC to unveil $100bn investment in advanced manufacturing in the US + Deutsche Bank clashed with ECB over bad loan losses * Tech Sections + Tech Home + Artificial intelligence + Semiconductors + Cyber Security + Social Media Most Read + TSMC to unveil $100bn investment in advanced manufacturing in the US + Peter Thiel-backed fintech Ramp nearly doubles valuation to $13bn + Chief of Microsoft-backed UK tech unicorn Builder.ai steps down + Anthropic's valuation triples to $61.5bn in bumper AI funding round + UK AI start-up Wayve accelerates global expansion plans * Markets Sections + Markets Home + Alphaville + Markets Data + Crypto + Capital Markets + Commodities + Currencies + Equities + Wealth Management + Moral Money + ETF Hub + Fund Management + Trading Most Read + What Tesla's tarnish tells us about America Inc + How big is the stock market's America bubble? + European defence shares jump as blistering rally gathers pace + Crypto prices jump as Trump names tokens included in strategic reserve + Trump confirms he will impose 25% tariffs on Mexico and Canada on Tuesday * Climate * Opinion Sections + Opinion Home + Columnists + The FT View + The Big Read + Lex + Obituaries + Letters Most Read + What Tesla's tarnish tells us about America Inc + Europe has bought Zelenskyy some time + How to respond to the realities of a more dangerous world + The US Congress is missing in action + Ugly showdown or lovefest, Trump is all about the message * Lex * Work & Careers Sections + Work & Careers Home + Business School Rankings + Business Education + Europe's Start-Up Hubs + Entrepreneurship + Recruitment + Business Books + Business Travel + Working It Most Read + The one thing you needed to do last week + From Death Star to Raccoon Feet: have quirky meeting room names gone too far? + BAE chief in line for bonus boost under 'golden handcuffs' pay deal + Food to go? The question facing Unilever's new 'human tornado' chief + Business school professors' picks * Life & Arts Sections + Life & Arts Home + Arts + Books + Food & Drink + FT Magazine + House & Home + Style + Puzzles + Travel + FT Globetrotter Most Read + 'Anora' triumphs with 5 Oscars including Best Picture + Monica Lewinsky takes back her own story in arresting podcast Reclaiming + Prada edges closer to buying Versace for about EUR1.5bn + Patek Philippe's Cubitus was an outrage - now it's a bestseller + Oscars actors embrace 'method dressing' with daring looks * HTSI MenuSearch * Home * World * US * Companies * Tech * Markets * Climate * Opinion * Lex * Work & Careers * Life & Arts * HTSI Financial Times SubscribeSign In Search the FT[ ]SearchClose search barClose FT Alphaville Banks Add to myFT [ ]Get instant alerts for this topic Manage your delivery channels hereRemove from myFT Banking's critical functions are vanishing into the cloud It's 9pm -- do you know where your data is? * [https] * Banking's critical functions are vanishing into the cloud on x (opens in a new window) * Banking's critical functions are vanishing into the cloud on facebook (opens in a new window) * Banking's critical functions are vanishing into the cloud on linkedin (opens in a new window) * Banking's critical functions are vanishing into the cloud on whatsapp (opens in a new window) * Save * Banking's critical functions are vanishing into the cloud on x (opens in a new window) * Banking's critical functions are vanishing into the cloud on facebook (opens in a new window) * Banking's critical functions are vanishing into the cloud on linkedin (opens in a new window) * Banking's critical functions are vanishing into the cloud on whatsapp (opens in a new window) * Save Daniel Davies PublishedMarch 3 2025 Jump to comments sectionPrint this page Unlock the Editor's Digest for free Roula Khalaf, Editor of the FT, selects her favourite stories in this weekly newsletter. There are some things in global finance which you really shouldn't look at too closely if you value your sanity. Repo and money markets would definitely be one. But even the banking system's funding arrangements are benign compared to the Lovecraftian horror of their IT outsourcing, because there's no central bank to guarantee a happy ending. As one senior bank supervisor put it a few years ago, there is no such thing as a database provider of last resort. In other words, Hell is empty, and all the demons are in the ECB Outsourcing Register. The annual "horizontal review" from the ECB's Banking Supervision committee was published last week. Do you want to know what proportion of "critical functions" are not compliant with basic regulatory guidelines? It's just under 10 per cent. The average number of "critical" service providers per large bank? Fifty-eight per cent. What's the average number of subcontractors on the average banking industry outsourcing contract? Four and a bit. What proportion of critical outsourcing providers would be "easy" to replace in the event of a problem? Just 17.7 per cent, although the good news is that the proportion which would be "impossible" to replace is now 8.6 per cent -- the remainder are apparently "difficult". [https](c) ECB Whatever the opposite of "setting your mind at rest" might be, that's what it does to consider the extent to which the European banking system (and it's unlikely that the US or UK are any better) relies on a complicated web of supply chains for software-as-a-service, offsite data centres and other euphemisms for "other people's computers". It's all driven by the growth of cloud computing, of course -- cloud now makes up more than a fifth of the total, having grown 13.5 per cent in the last year (and the ECB's report is based mainly on data as of the end of 2023, so it is likely to be even more important now). [https](c) ECB The growing role of cloud contracts has meant that European banks are, more than ever, dependent not only on a small number of outsourcing providers (30 firms account for half the total spend), but on non-EU firms. Within these top-30 firms, slightly more than 50 per cent of contracts are with companies whose ultimate parent is a US corporation. [https](c) ECB Which raises a bit of an issue for Europe, as it starts to worry about strategic independence in a world of heightened geopolitical tension. As Henry Farrell and Abe Newman pointed out in their book Underground Empire, the US controls a number of systems of "weaponised interdependence", of which two of the most important are the global dollar banking system and the internet. However, it seems that the interaction of finance and distributed computing might have created a third; the Euro area banking system (including the payment rails over which any future central bank digital currency will have to run) is highly dependent on server farms which might be physically located in Europe, but whose owners might ultimately answer to a foreign power. If you're looking for a crumb of comfort, it might be that the regulatory definition of a "critical function" in this context is quite expansive; it doesn't necessarily mean that an executive order could switch off the whole European financial system. But the trouble with the system as it's currently set up is that it's practically impossible to say anything about the true level of risk with any degree of confidence. (* Editorial note to pedants: the FT style guide says data is singular.) Copyright The Financial Times Limited 2025. All rights reserved. Reuse this content (opens in new window) CommentsJump to comments section Promoted Content Follow the topics in this article * European companies Add to myFT * Global Economy Add to myFT * Banks Add to myFT * Technology Add to myFT * European Central Bank Add to myFT Comments Useful links Support View Site TipsHelp CentreContact UsAbout UsAccessibilitymyFT Tour CareersSuppliers Legal & Privacy Terms & ConditionsPrivacy PolicyCookie PolicyManage CookiesCopyright Slavery Statement & Policies Services Share News Tips SecurelyIndividual SubscriptionsProfessional SubscriptionsRepublishingExecutive Job SearchAdvertise with the FT Follow the FT on XFT ChannelsFT Schools Tools PortfolioFT AppFT Digital EditionFT EditAlerts HubBusiness School RankingsSubscription ManagerNews feedNewslettersCurrency Converter Community & Events FT Live EventsFT ForumsBoard Director Programme More from the FT Group Markets data delayed by at least 15 minutes. (c) THE FINANCIAL TIMES LTD 2025. FT and 'Financial Times' are trademarks of The Financial Times Ltd. The Financial Times and its journalism are subject to a self-regulation regime under the FT Editorial Code of Practice. [px] Close side navigation menuEdition:International UK Search the FT[ ]Search Subscribe for full access Top sections * Home * WorldShow more World + Middle East war + Global Economy + UK + US + China + Africa + Asia Pacific + Emerging Markets + Europe + War in Ukraine + Americas + Middle East & North Africa * USShow more US + US Economy + Investing in America + US Companies + US Politics & Policy + US Presidential Election 2024 * CompaniesShow more Companies + Energy + Financials + Health + Industrials + Media + Professional Services + Retail & Consumer + Tech Sector + Telecoms + Transport * TechShow more Tech + Artificial intelligence + Semiconductors + Cyber Security + Social Media * MarketsShow more Markets + Alphaville + Markets Data + Crypto + Capital Markets + Commodities + Currencies + Equities + Wealth Management + Moral Money + ETF Hub + Fund Management + Trading * Climate * OpinionShow more Opinion + Columnists + The FT View + The Big Read + Lex + Obituaries + Letters * Lex * Work & CareersShow more Work & Careers + Business School Rankings + Business Education + Europe's Start-Up Hubs + Entrepreneurship + Recruitment + Business Books + Business Travel + Working It * Life & ArtsShow more Life & Arts + Arts + Books + Food & Drink + FT Magazine + House & Home + Style + Puzzles + Travel + FT Globetrotter * Personal FinanceShow more Personal Finance + Property & Mortgages + Investments + Pensions + Tax + Banking & Savings + Advice & Comment + Next Act * HTSI * Special Reports FT recommends * Alphaville * FT Edit * Lunch with the FT * FT Globetrotter * #techAsia * Moral Money * Visual and data journalism * Newsletters * Video * Podcasts * News feed * FT Schools * FT Live Events * FT Forums * Board Director Programme * myFT * Portfolio * FT Digital Edition * Crossword * Our Apps * Help Centre * Subscribe * Sign In