https://www.wired.com/story/thomson-reuters-ai-copyright-lawsuit/ Skip to main content Open Navigation Menu WIRED Thomson Reuters Wins First Major AI Copyright Case in the US * Security * Politics * Gear * The Big Story * Business * Science * Culture * Ideas * Merch More Search * Security * Politics * Gear * The Big Story * Business * Science * Culture * Ideas * Merch * Podcasts * Video * Newsletters * Magazine * Travel * Steven Levy's Plaintext Column * WIRED Classics from the Archive * Events * WIRED Insider * WIRED Consulting * Coupons Kate Knibbs Business Feb 11, 2025 3:50 PM Thomson Reuters Wins First Major AI Copyright Case in the US The Thomson Reuters decision has big implications for the battle between generative AI companies and rights holders. NEW YORK NEW YORK FEBRUARY 7 The Thomson Reuters billboard is seen on top of the building where keep its editorial... Thomson Reuters' offices in Times Square, New York City.Photograph: Eduardo MunozAlvarez/Getty Images Save Save Thomson Reuters has won the first major AI copyright case in the United States. In 2020, the media and technology conglomerate filed an unprecedented AI copyright lawsuit against the legal AI startup Ross Intelligence. In the complaint, Thomson Reuters claimed the AI firm reproduced materials from its legal research firm Westlaw. Today, a judge ruled in Thomson Reuters' favor, finding that the company's copyright was indeed infringed by Ross Intelligence's actions. "None of Ross's possible defenses holds water. I reject them all," wrote US District Court of Delaware judge Stephanos Bibas, in a summary judgement. Thomson Reuters and Ross Intelligence did not immediately respond to requests for comment. The generative AI boom has led to a spate of additional legal fights about how AI companies can use copyrighted material, as many major AI tools were developed by training on copyrighted works including books, films, visual artwork, and websites. Right now, there are several dozen lawsuits currently winding through the US court system, as well as international challenges in China, Canada, the UK, and other countries. Notably, Judge Bibas ruled in Thomson Reuters' favor on the question of fair use. The fair use doctrine is a key component of how AI companies are seeking to defend themselves against claims that they used copyrighted materials illegally. The idea underpinning fair use is that sometimes it's legally permissible to use copyrighted works without permission--for example, to create parody works, or in noncommercial research or news production. When determining whether fair use applies, courts use a four-factor test, looking at the reason behind the work, the nature of the work (whether it's poetry, nonfiction, private letters, et cetera), the amount of copyrighted work used, and how the use impacts the market value of the original. Thomson Reuters prevailed on two of the four factors, but Bibas described the fourth as the most important, and ruled that Ross "meant to compete with Westlaw by developing a market substitute." Thomson Reuters spokesperson Jeffrey McCoy applauded the ruling in a statement emailed to WIRED. "We are pleased that the court granted summary judgment in our favor and concluded that Westlaw's editorial content created and maintained by our attorney editors, is protected by copyright and cannot be used without our consent," he wrote. "The copying of our content was not 'fair use.'" Even before this ruling, Ross Intelligence had already felt the impact of the court battle: The startup shut down in 2021, citing the cost of litigation. In contrast, many of the AI companies still duking it out in court, like OpenAI and Google, are financially equipped to weather prolonged legal fights. Still, this ruling is a blow to AI companies, according to Cornell University professor of digital and internet law James Grimmelmann: "If this decision is followed elsewhere, it's really bad for the generative AI companies." Grimmelmann believes that Bibas' judgement suggests that much of the case law that generative AI companies are citing to argue fair use is "irrelevant." Chris Mammen, a partner at Womble Bond Dickinson who focuses on intellectual property law, concurs that this will complicate AI companies' fair use arguments, although it could vary from plaintiff to plaintiff. "It puts a finger on the scale towards holding that fair use doesn't apply," he says. Update 2/11/25 5:09 ET: This story has been updated to include additional comment from Thomson Reuters. You Might Also Like ... * Our latest scoop reveals the young, inexperienced engineers aiding Elon Musk's government takeover * In your inbox: Will Knight's AI Lab explores advances in AI * Nvidia's $3,000 'personal AI supercomputer' * Big Story: The school shootings were fake. The terror was real * Event: Join us for WIRED Health on March 18 in London [undefined] Kate Knibbs is a senior writer at WIRED, covering the human side of the generative AI boom and how new tech shapes the arts, entertainment, and media industries. Prior to joining WIRED she was a features writer at The Ringer and a senior writer at Gizmodo. She is based in ... Read more Senior Writer * Topicsartificial intelligenceCopyrightlawsuitmachine learningPolicy Reuters Read More The Best Posture Correctors to Straighten You Up The Best Posture Correctors to Straighten You Up You're hunched over your desk and phone for hours. We rounded up gadgets, a DIY trick, and even some yoga advice to help you straighten up. Boutayna Chokrane The 6 Best Sunrise Alarms to Help You Rise and Shine The 6 Best Sunrise Alarms to Help You Rise and Shine If you want to wake up with the sun but aren't a morning person, these bedside devices can simulate a sunrise whenever you want to rouse for the day (and a sunset, too). Nena Farrell Protect and Charge Your Apple Watch With Our Favorite Accessories Protect and Charge Your Apple Watch With Our Favorite Accessories You finally caved and bought an Apple Watch. These are our favorite straps, screen protectors, chargers, and cases to go with it. Adrienne So Our Favorite Paper Planners for Organizing Your Life Our Favorite Paper Planners for Organizing Your Life Digital tools are not always superior. Here are some WIRED-tested agendas and notebooks to keep you on track. Nena Farrell The 31 Best Movies on Max (aka HBO Max) Right Now The 31 Best Movies on Max (aka HBO Max) Right Now Blue Velvet, Sons of Ecstasy, and Beetlejuice Beetlejuice are just a few of the movies you should be watching on Max this month. Jennifer M. Wood The Best Kindles to Take Your Library Anywhere The Best Kindles to Take Your Library Anywhere Here's how Amazon's ebook readers stack up--and which one might be right for you. Brenda Stolyar The Best Wireless Chargers to Refuel Your Phone (or Watch) The Best Wireless Chargers to Refuel Your Phone (or Watch) Stop fumbling for cables in the dark. These WIRED-tested stands and pads will take the hassle out of refueling your phone, wireless earbuds, and watch. Julian Chokkattu The Best Running Underwear to Beat Burn on Your Bits The Best Running Underwear to Beat Burn on Your Bits Running outside your comfort zone doesn't have to be uncomfortable. Here are the best WIRED-tested underwear, balms and anti-chafe solutions. Kieran Alger The Best Coffee Subscriptions to Keep You Wired The Best Coffee Subscriptions to Keep You Wired These services deliver freshly roasted, delicious coffee picks right to your door--each with its own twist. Scott Gilbertson The 46 Best Shows on Max (aka HBO Max) Right Now The 46 Best Shows on Max (aka HBO Max) Right Now The Pitt, Somebody Somewhere, and Dune: Prophecy are just a few of the shows you need to be watching on Max this month. Jennifer M. Wood The King of Ozempic Is Scared as Hell The King of Ozempic Is Scared as Hell Now that Novo Nordisk is the world's weight-loss juggernaut, will it have to betray its first patients--type 1 diabetics? Virginia Heffernan A Spymaster Sheikh Controls a $1.5 Trillion Fortune. He Wants to Use It to Dominate AI A Spymaster Sheikh Controls a $1.5 Trillion Fortune. He Wants to Use It to Dominate AI Tahnoun bin Zayed al Nahyan--the UAE's chess-obsessed, jiujitsu-loving intelligence chief--controls vast sums of sovereign wealth. America's AI giants are scrambling for a piece of it. Bradley Hope WIRED WIRED is where tomorrow is realized. It is the essential source of information and ideas that make sense of a world in constant transformation. The WIRED conversation illuminates how technology is changing every aspect of our lives--from culture to business, science to design. The breakthroughs and innovations that we uncover lead to new ways of thinking, new connections, and new industries. More From WIRED * Subscribe * Newsletters * FAQ * WIRED Staff * WIRED Education * Editorial Standards * Archive * RSS * Accessibility Help Reviews and Guides * Reviews * Buying Guides * Mattresses * Electric Bikes * Soundbars * Streaming Guides * Wearables * TVs * Coupons * Code Guarantee * Gift Guides * Advertise * Contact Us * Manage Account * Jobs * Press Center * Conde Nast Store * User Agreement * Privacy Policy * Your California Privacy Rights (c) 2025 Conde Nast. All rights reserved. WIRED may earn a portion of sales from products that are purchased through our site as part of our Affiliate Partnerships with retailers. The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Conde Nast. Ad Choices Select international site United States * Italia * Japon * Czech Republic & Slovakia * * * * * *