https://freegovinfo.info/node/14747/ Free Government Information (FGI) Because Government information needs to be free * About * FGI Library * Guide to "unreported" docs * Less Access... * LostDocs * StateDocs * Best Titles Ever! * About * FGI Library * Guide to "unreported" docs * Less Access... * LostDocs * StateDocs * Best Titles Ever! Search [ ] Search Home >> Library >> The government information crisis is bigger than you think it is Our mission Free Government Information (FGI) is a place for initiating dialogue and building consensus among the various players (libraries, government agencies, non-profit organizations, researchers, journalists, etc.) who have a stake in the preservation of and perpetual free access to government information. FGI promotes free government information through collaboration, education, advocacy and research. The government information crisis is bigger than you think it is By James A Jacobs in Library, post on January 28, 2025. [This post is adapted from our forthcoming book, Preserving Government Information: Past, Present, and Future.] Today we want to clarify something important about preserving government information. There is a difference between the government changing a policy and the government erasing information, but the line between those two has blurred in the digital age. When a new president is inaugurated, one expects new policies. The number of changes and the speed of change may vary for different administrations, but we expect that every administration will be different in some ways from its predecessor. After all, that is part of the reason we have elections. Also, information that the government publishes is updated all the time, not just when administrations change. Laws and regulations are added and amended and rescinded, new economic and environmental and census data are collected and published, government recommendations to the public (like the Department of Agriculture's "food pyramid" guidance) are revised. Changes in government information are normal in a democracy. Because change is normal, it is essential to preserve government information - even "non-current" and "out of date" information - in order to document those changes. This is not a new idea, but a long-accepted principle of democracy. Citizens need a record of what a government's stated values were and when they changed, what actions it took and when it took them, what data it collected and generated at specific points in time, and so forth. It is important to preserve even information that later proves to be inaccurate in order to document what the government knew and when it knew it. Because published government information is the evidence for a democracy, its preservation is essential. In the era in which government information was published in paper formats, preservation of that information relied on libraries. The information was distributed to FDLP libraries based on the needs of the communities that those libraries served. Beginning in 1962, Regional FDLs received and retained all the paper publications in the FDLP system. When new information superseded or replaced old information, the old information was not erased or discarded; it was preserved in Regional FDLs and in every FDL whose community valued that older information. In the print era, it was taken for granted that, once government information was released to the public, it would not be withdrawn or altered or lost.^1 In the digital age, government publishing has shifted from the distribution of unalterable printed books to digital posts on government websites. Such digital publications can be moved, altered, and withdrawn at the flick of a switch. Publishing agencies are not required to preserve their own information, nor to provide free access to it. Some digital government information is actively preserved by GPO, NARA, and the Library of Congress. Some government-collected data are preserved by law or by tradition. But the laws that allow this are weak and government preservation of government information suffers from large gaps. Non-government projects (notably the Internet Archive and the End-of-Term Archive) use web harvesting to attempt to acquire and store government information, but these projects are, by their nature, incomplete and their long-term guarantees of access are fragile. As a result of all this, the public can no longer assume that any given piece of government information will not be withdrawn or altered or lost. The early actions of the incoming Trump administration (as well as the actions of the first Trump administration) have brought the vulnerability of digital information to the public's attention (see our previous post "Federal information scrubbing has begun") and the public is rightfully worried. That vulnerability is, however, not limited to this administration. Digital government information was being lost before President Trump. The current crisis of imminent loss of information exists not only because government information is being changed, but because it is being erased. The erasure is possible because of the gaps in the current preservation infrastructure. The scale of loss and alteration of information under Trump may prove to be unprecedented and certainly requires immediate short-term action. But librarians and archivists and citizens should use this current crisis to demand more than short-term solutions. A new distributed digital preservation infrastructure is needed for digital government information. James A. Jacobs James R. Jacobs 1. Even when information was withdrawn for some reason, there was a record of the withdrawals. (See this spreadsheet listing withdrawn documents 1981 - 2018, collated from GPO's no-longer published "Administrative Notes" newsletter.) | Related CC BY-NC-SA 4.0 This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License. Tags: Data loss, digital preservation, government information policy, Preservation of government information, Trump administration - Federal information scrubbing has begun. Please support the End of Term Archive and Environmental Data Governance Initiative (EDGI) --------------------------------------------------------------------- Leave a comment Cancel reply Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked * [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] Comment * [ ] Name * [ ] Email * [ ] Website [ ] [ ] Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. You can also subscribe without commenting. [Post Comment] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] D[ ] This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed. Latest Posts * The government information crisis is bigger than you think it is * Federal information scrubbing has begun. Please support the End of Term Archive and Environmental Data Governance Initiative (EDGI) * Maryellen Trautman * Senators Markey and Hirono and Representative Adams introduce Public Archives Resiliency Act * Good Forbes piece on the End of Term crawl Latest Comments * James R. Jacobs on Federal information scrubbing has begun. Please support the End of Term Archive and Environmental Data Governance Initiative (EDGI) * James R. Jacobs on Down a few rabbit holes in search for a historic pamphlet on Fascism * Kathleen Cunningham on Down a few rabbit holes in search for a historic pamphlet on Fascism * Gretchen Gehrke on EDGI's new public comments initiative * James R. Jacobs on Reference question and the saga of chasing down a Congressionally mandated report * James R. Jacobs on Down a few rabbit holes in search for a historic pamphlet on Fascism * Cass Hartnett on Down a few rabbit holes in search for a historic pamphlet on Fascism * James R. Jacobs on Beautiful video on the history of fire lookouts - and fire! - highlights lots of US govt publications and records * James R. Jacobs on Down a few rabbit holes in search for a historic pamphlet on Fascism * Jeremy Darrington on Down a few rabbit holes in search for a historic pamphlet on Fascism Blogroll * ASU Gov Docs * beSpacific * Best. Titles. Ever. (Tumblr) * Center for Effective Government * Every CRS Report New Reports RSS Feed * FDLP Desktop * FDLP News & Events * FullTextReports * GISIG UW-SLIS: Gov Info, Sources, Data & Docs * Government Book Talk * Government Information Network (Canada) * Government Information News from Fondren Library, Rice University * GPO [twitter] * INFOdocket * Information Observatory * Libraries+ Network * Library Babel Fish by Barbara Fister * NARA records express * Open The Government * Secrecy News * SLA GovInfo [twitter] * StatFountain * Sunlight Foundation * University of Washington Gov Pubs Finds Archives Archives [Select Month ] Meta * Log in * Entries feed * Comments feed * WordPress.org Archives Archives [Select Month ] [Green_9] * Home * Contact FGI * FDLP library locator * Chat w/ a govinfo librarian * Find govinfo * Thanks GreenGeeks! Powered by WordPress / Academica WordPress Theme by WPZOOM