https://nymag.com/intelligencer/article/meta-wants-more-ai-bots-on-facebook-and-instagram.html Alert Icon Double Right Chevrons Close Icon * Intelligencer * The Cut * Vulture * The Strategist * * Curbed * Grub Street * Magazine Subscribe to the Magazine Give a Gift Subscription Buy Back Issues Current Issue Contents New York Shop Subscribe to New York Magazine * Subscribe * Sign In * Account Profile Sign Out Menu Menu Close Close * Politics * Business * Technology * Ideas * About Intelligencer * Newsletters * New York App Like Us Follow Us * NYMag.com * New York Magazine * Intelligencer * Vulture * The Cut * The Strategist * Grub Street * Curbed Search [ ] Subscribe Give A Gift Menu Menu Close Close * Politics * Business * Technology * Ideas * About Intelligencer * Newsletters * New York App Like Us Follow Us * NYMag.com * New York Magazine * Intelligencer * Vulture * The Cut * The Strategist * Grub Street * Curbed Leave a Comment Search [ ] Things you buy through our links may earn Vox Media a commission. screen time Dec. 31, 2024 Meta's Big Bet on Bots Why AI friends are coming to Facebook and Instagram. Portrait of John Herrman By John Herrman, a tech columnist at Intelligencer Formerly, he was a reporter and critic at the New York Times and co-editor of The Awl. [a2c532c324bf9eb7c599b8f9565068f013-topimage-moshed] Photo-Illustration: Facebook [a2c532c324bf9eb7c599b8f9565068f013-topimage-moshed] Photo-Illustration: Facebook Among Meta's many resolutions for the new year -- making augmented reality and the metaverse happen, positioning itself to absorb TikTok refugees if the app gets banned, cracking open Apple's platforms to get more access to user data, and attriting its competition in artificial intelligence with breathtaking spending -- one stands out as plain weird: filling its social-media platforms with bots. According to the Financial Times: The Silicon Valley group is rolling out a range of AI products, including one that helps users create AI characters on Instagram and Facebook, as it battles with rival tech groups to attract and retain a younger audience. "We expect these AIs to actually, over time, exist on our platforms, kind of in the same way that accounts do," said Connor Hayes, vice-president of product for generative AI at Meta. "They'll have bios and profile pictures and be able to generate and share content powered by AI on the platform . . . that's where we see all of this going," he added. The company has been talking about this for a while, to somewhat bewildered responses from the general public. The simplest explanation for what it's doing is that the company has invested a lot in building generative AI models and would like to get a return on its investment through its most lucrative products: If there's any economically productive way for Meta to plug AI tools into Facebook, Instagram, and WhatsApp, it'll consider it. But Meta, a company with no qualms about chasing, copying, and acquiring its way into trends, is also reacting here. It bought SocialAI, a Twitter-ish "social network" where users' "feeds" and "comment sections" are filled entirely with bots playing different characters. At the same time, it's surely noticed that its platforms are already filling with AI slop anyway and that some of this slop was creating a lot of engagement, meaning that, in the ways that matter most to Meta, it's not really slop at all. The company also clearly noticed the rise of Character.ai, the popular -- but possibly doomed -- lawsuit magnet of an app in which young users create and chat and act out fictional scenarios with AI characters. Still, Meta's framing here is unique to the company. It's by far the leading American social-network firm, with more than a billion actual people using its products around the world to interact with one another. Practically everyone in tech is trying practically everything with AI, but Meta, the suggestion goes, is in a singular position to populate shared human spaces with synthetic characters, and it seems to think it'll work. As galling as this might sound to a casual Facebook user -- after years of characterizing fake and automated profiles as spam, it's okay now if Meta is running the accounts and they're a little more convincing? -- it has the benefit of sounding somewhat new and novel. Maybe these personas really will be engaging enough to post and respond alongside your friends, family, co-workers, and celebrities in your existing social-media feeds; maybe social-media feeds are the right place to encounter highly specific chatbots; maybe these chatbots can be entertaining or even helpful in the context of the apps users already check multiple times per day. It might not be a convincing story, but it's a story: There are increasingly intelligent bots among us, and they're joining social media. The main benefit of this story is that, like a lot of AI products -- it's right there in the name! -- it anthropomorphizes the underlying technology. A less compelling but perhaps more honest and useful way to characterize Meta's impulse here is as the next step in a long process of automation and social mediation. When Facebook and Instagram were new, the content you encountered wasn't just created by people you knew or chose to follow -- it carried with it legible and obvious evidence of provenance. If you saw something from someone you didn't follow or intend to interact with, it was because someone you know chose to share it; if you posted something, you could mostly assume it would be seen by people who intended to see it, and maybe by more people they intended to show it to. Well before the rise of TikTok, which mostly replaced follow/follower relationships with opaque algorithmic distribution, but especially after it, Facebook and Instagram have leaned hard into subtler forms of automation: content recommendations; people recommendations; unexplained stuff appearing in feeds, as Reels, or bugging users in notifications. The result is platforms where users are consuming more content but in some cases producing less, spaces that function less like social networks than like targeted advertising systems for everything. A lot of formerly social aspects of a platform like Facebook, in other words, have already been automated and replaced with machine learning, but each step in this direction has been subtle and somewhat concealed: You don't really know, and certainly aren't clearly told, why Meta assumes this or that Instagram Reel is something you want to see, or why one thing appears above another in an algorithmically sorted feed. The idea of introducing AI characters into Meta's platforms is in some ways distinct and new -- we're talking about not just automating content curation and promotion here but, in some cases, actual creation -- but can also be understood as a way to rebrand an effective but alienating overhaul that's been a decade in the making. With many AI products -- from ChatGPT to a customer-support bot -- the performance of personhood, which is a bit of a misleading magic trick even when done carefully, is at least as important as raw capabilities. Meta can claim it's building technology to create social-media agents that can exist on its platforms "in the same way that accounts do," and maybe it'll turn out to be right. But Meta's AI characters are also a way to slap a more friendly, humanlike face on a long, bloodless campaign of social automation. Sign Up for John Herrman column alerts Get an email alert as soon as a new article publishes. Email [ ] [Sign up] This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply. Vox Media, LLC Terms and Privacy Notice By submitting your email, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Notice and to receive email correspondence from us. Tags: * john herrman * screen time * technology * artificial intelligence * meta * facebook * instagram * More Show Leave a Comment Meta's Big, Weird Bet on AI Bots Things you buy through our links may earn Vox Media a commission. Most Viewed Stories 1. Will Democrats Ever Reckon With Their Biden Groupthink? 2. When Will Trump Take Office? On MLK Day, Unfortunately. 3. The Mayoral Race Has Begun. Everyone Is Frozen. 4. If Johnson Can't Win Speaker Election, D.C. Grinds to a Halt 5. When Chatbots Choose Violence 1. Will Democrats Ever Reckon With Their Biden Groupthink? 2. The Mayoral Race Has Begun. Everyone Is Frozen. 3. When Chatbots Choose Violence 4. If Johnson Can't Win Speaker Election, D.C. Grinds to a Halt 5. When Will Trump Take Office? On MLK Day, Unfortunately. Editor's Picks * [9fbce1799d] the discourse Will Democrats Ever Reckon With Their Biden Groupthink? Will Democrats Ever Reckon With Their Biden Groupthink? * [2d8c746b16] screen time When Chatbots Choose Violence When Chatbots Choose Violence * [8c09d63c26] celebrity shopping What Christian Siriano Can't Live Without What Christian Siriano Can't Live Without Sign In to Comment THE FEED 4:27 p.m. early and often early and often Unlike McConnell, John Thune Will Be Trump's Willing Accomplice By Ed Kilgore Despite all the drama over warring House Republicans, Trump's radical legislative agenda will mostly be shaped by Thune's compliant Senate. 3:47 p.m. magalopolis magalopolis Who Is Lara Trump? Donald's Daughter-in-Law, Explained By Margaret Hartmann Everything to know about the aspiring politician, activewear entrepreneur, and music star. 2:45 p.m. early and often early and often Johnson Wins Reelection As Speaker After Initially Failing on First Ballot By Ed Kilgore The Speaker won back two of three lost Republican votes, and now we wait to see what horrendous concessions he made to get them. Most Popular 1. Will Democrats Ever Reckon With Their Biden Groupthink? By Ross Barkan 2. When Will Trump Take Office? On MLK Day, Unfortunately. By Margaret Hartmann 3. The Mayoral Race Has Begun. Everyone Is Frozen. By David Freedlander 4. If Johnson Can't Win Speaker Election, D.C. Grinds to a Halt By Ed Kilgore 5. When Chatbots Choose Violence By John Herrman 1. Will Democrats Ever Reckon With Their Biden Groupthink? By Ross Barkan 2. The Mayoral Race Has Begun. Everyone Is Frozen. By David Freedlander 3. When Chatbots Choose Violence By John Herrman 4. When Will Trump Take Office? On MLK Day, Unfortunately. By Margaret Hartmann 5. If Johnson Can't Win Speaker Election, D.C. Grinds to a Halt By Ed Kilgore 12:23 p.m. health health Surgeon General Calls for Cancer Warning Labels on Alcohol By Nia Prater In a new advisory, Dr. Vivek Murthy warned that drinking carries an increased risk of cancer and called for beverage labels to include a warning. 12:07 p.m. early and often early and often Carter's State Funeral May Be Biden's Last Big Moment By Ed Kilgore President Biden will deliver a eulogy for Carter on January 9 -- with his rival and successor Donald Trump in the audience. 6:00 a.m. the discourse the discourse Will Democrats Ever Reckon With Their Biden Groupthink? By Ross Barkan The party and its allies were both blind and dishonest. Grappling with that fact is hard but necessary. 5:00 a.m. screen time screen time When Chatbots Choose Violence By John Herrman Disturbing new lawsuits show what a family-scale AI apocalypse might look like. 1/2/2025 bourbon street attack bourbon street attack FBI Believes Bourbon Street Suspect Acted Alone: Live Updates By Intelligencer Staff The U.S.-born citizen who perpetrated the attack announced on social media beforehand that he was inspired by ISIS. 1/2/2025 tremendous content tremendous content Melania Trump Doesn't Know the Real 'Y.M.C.A.' Dance Either By Margaret Hartmann She debuted her own version on New Year's Eve, throwing up a lone Y while gracefully mimicking her husband's "Trump Dance." 1/2/2025 the city politic the city politic The Mayoral Race Has Begun. Everyone Is Frozen. By David Freedlander There are lots of candidates, and plenty of scandal and drama -- but mostly there is waiting. 1/2/2025 what we know what we know What We Know About the Cybertruck Explosion at Trump's Las Vegas Hotel By Chas Danner Investigators are still trying to determine the motive of the driver, who was killed in the apparently intentional blast. 1/2/2025 early and often early and often If Johnson Can't Win Speaker Election, D.C. Grinds to a Halt By Ed Kilgore Nothing can happen in Washington, not even Trump's inauguration, until the House elects a Speaker. There are no votes to spare for Johnson. 1/1/2025 year in review year in review New York's 20 Most-Read Stories of 2024 By The Editors The articles that captured your attention the most this year, from age-gap relationships to Amazon scams. 12/31/2024 second acts second acts The Ex-Tennis Stars Grinding It Out on the Pickleball Tour By Caira Conner Genie Bouchard and other semi-boldfaced names are finding that tennis success doesn't always translate to glory on a smaller court. 12/30/2024 just asking questions just asking questions How Worried Should We Be About the Latest Bird-Flu Mutation? By Matt Stieb A virologist explains that why this probably isn't the big one -- but that it's a sign of bad things happening with the virus. 12/30/2024 what we know what we know Who's Winning the MAGA-Musk Civil War? By Chas Danner Last week, a big rift formed between Trump's tech allies and MAGA nativists. Here, where things stand. 12/30/2024 unnatural disasters unnatural disasters 5 Unanswered Questions About the South Korea Plane Crash By Jeff Wise A bird strike alone should not have been catastrophic. 12/30/2024 screen time screen time The Chaos Lurking in Apple's Most-Popular Apps List By John Herrman Stability has reigned for a while, but next year promises to change all that. 12/29/2024 remembrance remembrance Jimmy Carter's Legacy: Imperfect Greatness By Ed Kilgore His postpresidential greatness is what will be remembered. But he was a shrewder politician than people realize. 12/28/2024 screen time screen time The Future of AI Shouldn't Be Taken at Face Value By John Herrman Why AI is so expensive and OpenAI's pursuit of AGI is all about money. 12/27/2024 royals royals How Are King Charles & Kate Middleton Doing? Latest Health Updates. By Margaret Hartmann Here's the latest on Charles and Kate's cancer battles, and how the royals are coping. 12/27/2024 tremendous content tremendous content Everything We Know About Trump's Budding DJ Career By Margaret Hartmann The president-elect moonlights as a disc jockey at Bedminster and Mar-a-Lago ... which basically means he blasts "Y.M.C.A." and show tunes off an iPad. 12/27/2024 i regret to inform you i regret to inform you When Will Trump Take Office? On MLK Day, Unfortunately. By Margaret Hartmann The depressing coincidence, explained. 12/27/2024 america's mayor america's mayor Can Donald Trump Pardon Rudy Giuliani? By Margaret Hartmann Trump's regaining pardon power in 2025 probably won't help his former lawyer with his many messy legal cases. Email [ ] [Submit] You\'ll receive the next newsletter in your inbox. *Sorry, there was a problem signing you up. [ ] [] By submitting your email, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Notice and to receive email correspondence from us. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply. or Already a subscriber? Sign In What is your email? This email will be used to sign into all New York sites. By submitting your email, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy and to receive email correspondence from us. Enter your email: [ ] Please enter a valid email address. Submit Email or Connect with Google Connect with Facebook Sign in | Subscribe Today Sign In To Continue Reading Create Your Free Account edit email Sign in with Facebook Sign in with Google [pizza ] Choose a password to create an account: Enter your password orsign in with a different email [ ] [ ] Forgot Password? Password must be at least 8 characters and contain: * Lower case letters (a-z) * Upper case letters (A-Z) * Numbers (0-9) * Special Characters (!@#$%^&*) This password will be used to sign into all New York sites. By submitting your email, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy and to receive email correspondence from us. Sign In Create Account You're in! As part of your account, you'll receive occasional updates and offers from New York, which you can opt out of anytime. Continue Reading or Already a subscriber? Sign In What is your email? This email will be used to sign into all New York sites. By submitting your email, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy and to receive email correspondence from us. Enter your email: [ ] Please enter a valid email address. Submit Email or Connect with Google Connect with Facebook Sign in | Subscribe Today Sign In To Continue Reading Create Your Free Account edit email Sign in with Facebook Sign in with Google [pizza ] Choose a password to create an account: Enter your password orsign in with a different email [ ] [ ] Forgot Password? Password must be at least 8 characters and contain: * Lower case letters (a-z) * Upper case letters (A-Z) * Numbers (0-9) * Special Characters (!@#$%^&*) This password will be used to sign into all New York sites. By submitting your email, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy and to receive email correspondence from us. Sign In Create Account You're in! As part of your account, you'll receive occasional updates and offers from New York, which you can opt out of anytime. Continue Reading Already a subscriber? Sign In View Account Log Out Already a subscriber? Sign In View Account Log Out Gift Scout Promotional Image [ ] * please try a longer search Like Us Follow Us Follow Us * About Intelligencer * About New York Magazine * Newsletters * Help * Contact * Press * Media Kit * We're Hiring * Privacy * Terms * Ad Choices * Accessibility * Do not sell or share my personal data intelligencer is a Vox Media Network. (c) 2025 Vox Media, LLC. All rights reserved.