https://thenewstack.io/what-happens-to-relicensed-open-source-projects-and-their-forks/ TNS OK SUBSCRIBE Join our community of software engineering leaders and aspirational developers. Always stay in-the-know by getting the most important news and exclusive content delivered fresh to your inbox to learn more about at-scale software development. EMAIL ADDRESS REQUIRED [ ] SUBSCRIBE RESUBSCRIPTION REQUIRED It seems that you've previously unsubscribed from our newsletter in the past. Click the button below to open the re-subscribe form in a new tab. When you're done, simply close that tab and continue with this form to complete your subscription. RE-SUBSCRIBE The New Stack does not sell your information or share it with unaffiliated third parties. By continuing, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. Welcome and thank you for joining The New Stack community! Please answer a few simple questions to help us deliver the news and resources you are interested in. FIRST NAME REQUIRED [ ] LAST NAME REQUIRED [ ] COMPANY NAME REQUIRED [ ] COUNTRY REQUIRED [Select ... ] ZIPCODE REQUIRED [ ] Great to meet you! Tell us a bit about your job so we can cover the topics you find most relevant. What is your job level? REQUIRED [Select ... ] [ ] Which of these most closely describes your job role? REQUIRED [Select ... ] [ ] How many employees are in the organization you work with? REQUIRED [Select ... ] What option best describes the type of organization you work for? REQUIRED [Select ... ] [ ] Which of the following best describes your organization's primary industry? REQUIRED [Select ... ] [ ] LINKEDIN PROFILE URL [ ] Welcome! We're so glad you're here. You can expect all the best TNS content to arrive Monday through Friday to keep you on top of the news and at the top of your game. What's next? Check your inbox for a confirmation email where you can adjust your preferences and even join additional groups. Follow TNS on your favorite social media networks. Become a TNS follower on LinkedIn. Check out the latest featured and trending stories while you wait for your first TNS newsletter. PREV 1 of 2 NEXT VOXPOP As a JavaScript developer, what non-React tools do you use most often? Angular 0% Astro 0% Svelte 0% Vue.js 0% Other 0% I only use React 0% I don't use JavaScript 0% Thanks for your opinion! Subscribe below to get the final results, published exclusively in our TNS Update newsletter: [ ] SUBMIT [ ] Search More Results ARCHITECTURE Open Source Cloud Native Ecosystem Containers Edge Computing Microservices Networking Serverless Storage ENGINEERING AI Large Language Models Frontend Development Software Development API Management Python JavaScript TypeScript WebAssembly Cloud Services Data Security OPERATIONS Platform Engineering Operations CI/CD Tech Careers Tech Culture DevOps Kubernetes Observability Service Mesh CHANNELS Podcasts Ebooks Events Newsletter TNS RSS Feeds THE NEW STACK About / Contact Sponsors Advertise With Us Contributions PODCASTS EBOOKS EVENTS NEWSLETTER CONTRIBUTE ARCHITECTURE ENGINEERING OPERATIONS Open Source Cloud Native Ecosystem Containers Edge Computing Microservices Networking Serverless Storage What Happens to Relicensed Open Source Projects and Their Forks? Dec 27th 2024 7:30am, by Dawn Foster Rust Will Explode, SBOMs Will Be Duds: Open Source Predictions Dec 27th 2024 5:05am, by Dan Lorenc AI, Hardware and Open Models: Headed in the Linux Direction Dec 26th 2024 7:42am, by Agam Shah How Falco Brought Real-Time Observability to Infrastructure Dec 26th 2024 5:52am, by Heather Joslyn Kubernetes, Rust, Linux and DOS? The Year in Open Source Dec 24th 2024 8:24am, by David Cassel Kubernetes 1.32 Aces API Conformance Testing Dec 11th 2024 2:00pm, by Joab Jackson MapLibre: How a Fork Became a Thriving Open Source Project Dec 5th 2024 8:30am, by Heather Joslyn AWS Launches New AI Agents To Simplify Legacy Migrations Dec 4th 2024 11:30am, by Loraine Lawson How Startups Can Thrive With Borderless Data Strategies Dec 4th 2024 10:00am, by Apu Pavithran DIY Kubernetes Is a Recipe for Mayhem Dec 3rd 2024 10:00am, by Tobi Knaup Year in Review: Containers Get Smaller, Faster, More Secure Dec 19th 2024 1:50pm, by Joab Jackson Amex's FaaS Uses WebAssembly Instead of Containers Dec 19th 2024 9:01am, by B. Cameron Gain 2025 Web Hosting Trends That Could Affect Frontend Developers Dec 19th 2024 7:00am, by Loraine Lawson ScaleOps Adds Predictive Horizontal Scaling, Smart Placement Dec 3rd 2024 6:00am, by Susan Hall Deploy a Virtual Machine With Oracle's Open Source VirtualBox Nov 30th 2024 7:00am, by Jack Wallen Why Red Hat Had To Improve the Edge Developer Experience Nov 25th 2024 8:08am, by B. Cameron Gain KubeEdge Extends Cloud Native Beyond the Data Center Oct 15th 2024 9:00am, by Joab Jackson Integration of AI With IoT Brings Agents to Physical World Oct 8th 2024 7:46am, by Janakiram MSV From VMs to AI: How Edge Computing Is Evolving Sep 13th 2024 3:54am, by Ben Cohen The New 2GB Raspberry Pi 5: Another Option for Linux Sysadmins Sep 2nd 2024 9:00am, by Damon M. Garn Microservices Testing Cycles Are Too Slow Dec 18th 2024 7:00am, by Arjun Iyer Why Your Microservice Integration Tests Miss Real Problems Dec 4th 2024 6:00am, by Arjun Iyer Improve Microservices With These New Load Balancing Strategies Nov 8th 2024 3:00am, by Dhruv Kumar Seth How To Fail at Microservices Nov 1st 2024 3:00am, by Ashley Davis Shift Left Meets Kafka: Testing Event-Driven Microservices Oct 30th 2024 1:00pm, by Arjun Iyer OpenVPN or WireGuard? A Detailed Performance Breakdown Nov 28th 2024 6:00am, by Edward Viaene Deciphering the Open Systems Interconnection Model Nov 25th 2024 7:25am, by Laura Santamaria VMware Cloud Foundation Could Bring Price Relief Nov 25th 2024 6:00am, by B. Cameron Gain P99 Conf: 3 Ways to Squash Application Latency Nov 22nd 2024 1:02pm, by Joab Jackson Stop Losing Users: The Load-Balancing Fix Your Website Needs Nov 21st 2024 11:30am, by Derek Kiely Use These Two Approaches To Deploy ML Models on AWS Lambda Dec 18th 2024 11:04am, by Gaurav Mittal Pinecone Revamps Retrieval Capabilities for Its Vector Database Platform Dec 2nd 2024 7:00pm, by Jelani Harper Running AI Models Without GPUs on Serverless Platforms Nov 25th 2024 1:37pm, by Rak Siva Why Infrastructure Must Be Serverless in the AI Age Nov 20th 2024 11:00am, by Nikita Shamgunov Why Platform Engineers Are Embracing WebAssembly for Serverless Oct 30th 2024 10:00am, by Matt Butcher Defining Low Data Loss, Downtime Tolerances in Kubernetes Dec 20th 2024 9:00am, by Janet Wi Navigating the Path From Redis to Valkey Dec 20th 2024 8:00am, by Martin Visser Open Source Innovation Comes to Time-Series Data Compression Dec 18th 2024 9:05am, by Carlos Rolo Revolutionizing Storage: The Role of GPUs in Modern Infrastructure Nov 20th 2024 6:32am, by Daniel Clydesdale-Cotter MinIO Unveils AIStor: A Potential Object Storage Game-Changer Nov 13th 2024 8:30am, by Steven J. Vaughan-Nichols AI Large Language Models Frontend Development Software Development API Management Python JavaScript TypeScript WebAssembly Cloud Services Data Security AI, Hardware and Open Models: Headed in the Linux Direction Dec 26th 2024 7:42am, by Agam Shah Cerbrec: A Framework for Python Devs Without AI Experience Dec 23rd 2024 9:14am, by Alex Williams Developer Guide to the CrewAI Agent Framework for Python Dec 23rd 2024 6:00am, by Janakiram MSV Developers Testing More, JetBrains Study Finds Dec 21st 2024 5:00am, by Loraine Lawson and Lawrence E Hecht CodeGate: Open Source Tool Secures AI Coding Assistants Dec 20th 2024 12:00pm, by Steven J. Vaughan-Nichols Navigating the Complexity of Legacy Code with Generative AI Dec 26th 2024 9:05am, by Sid Misra Stop Treating Your LLM Like a Database Dec 19th 2024 12:09pm, by Sean Falconer Mastering OpenAI's Realtime API: A Comprehensive Guide Dec 19th 2024 10:06am, by Oladimeji Sowole How To Add Tool Support to AI Agents for Performing Actions Dec 17th 2024 9:00am, by Janakiram MSV Supercharge Your RAG App With Agentic Hybrid Search Dec 17th 2024 6:39am, by Ryan Michael The Year in JavaScript: Top JS News Stories of 2024 Dec 27th 2024 6:30am, by Loraine Lawson Web Development Trends in 2024: A Shift Back to Simplicity Dec 23rd 2024 8:00am, by Richard MacManus Top Dev Tools and Web Developer Trends of 2024 Dec 21st 2024 8:00am, by David Eastman Developers Testing More, JetBrains Study Finds Dec 21st 2024 5:00am, by Loraine Lawson and Lawrence E Hecht 2025 Web Hosting Trends That Could Affect Frontend Developers Dec 19th 2024 7:00am, by Loraine Lawson Donald Knuth's 2024 Christmas Lecture: 'Strong' Memories Dec 25th 2024 6:00am, by David Cassel The Best MacOS Terminal Emulation Programs for Developers Dec 23rd 2024 7:00am, by Damon M. Garn Developers Testing More, JetBrains Study Finds Dec 21st 2024 5:00am, by Loraine Lawson and Lawrence E Hecht Why Agentic AI Could Be Doomed To Fail, and 3 More AI Predictions for 2025 Dec 20th 2024 11:00am, by Barr Moses Qodo: A Multi-Agent Code Platform to Write, Test and Review Code Dec 19th 2024 3:00pm, by Alex Williams Developers Are Key to Stopping Rising API Security Threat Dec 23rd 2024 12:05pm, by Loraine Lawson API World: 4 API Development Tips To Drive Business Impact Dec 6th 2024 9:00am, by Lori Marshall API Mocking Is Essential to Effective Change Management Nov 29th 2024 10:00am, by Israel Tetteh The Tidal Wave of API Drift: Use Mocking To Stay Afloat Nov 22nd 2024 7:00am, by Israel Tetteh Developers: Mastodon and Bluesky Want Your Twitter Bots Nov 18th 2024 12:00pm, by Richard MacManus Cerbrec: A Framework for Python Devs Without AI Experience Dec 23rd 2024 9:14am, by Alex Williams Developer Guide to the CrewAI Agent Framework for Python Dec 23rd 2024 6:00am, by Janakiram MSV Kubernetes End-to-End Testing Using Testcontainers and Python Dec 12th 2024 10:00am, by Manish Saini 5 Python Libraries Every Data Engineer Should Know Dec 6th 2024 5:00am, by Jack Wallen Circumventing Python's GIL With Asyncio Dec 3rd 2024 9:00am, by Jessica Wachtel The Year in JavaScript: Top JS News Stories of 2024 Dec 27th 2024 6:30am, by Loraine Lawson Web Development Trends in 2024: A Shift Back to Simplicity Dec 23rd 2024 8:00am, by Richard MacManus Angular Shares 'Potential Ideas' for 2025 Improvements Dec 14th 2024 6:00am, by Loraine Lawson 5 Technical Trends To Help Web Developers Stand Out in 2025 Dec 10th 2024 8:00am, by Alexander T. Williams 5 JavaScript Libraries You Should Say Goodbye to in 2025 Dec 7th 2024 8:00am, by Alexander T. Williams The Year in JavaScript: Top JS News Stories of 2024 Dec 27th 2024 6:30am, by Loraine Lawson How OOP Developers Can Get To Know TypeScript Through Deno Oct 19th 2024 8:00am, by David Eastman Configure Microservices in NestJS: A Beginner's Guide Oct 11th 2024 12:00pm, by Zziwa Raymond Ian Why ChatGPT Shifted From Next.js To Remix: Some Theories Sep 14th 2024 8:05am, by Loraine Lawson Is React Now a Full Stack Framework? And Other Dev News Aug 31st 2024 5:00am, by Loraine Lawson Rust Will Explode, SBOMs Will Be Duds: Open Source Predictions Dec 27th 2024 5:05am, by Dan Lorenc The Feds Push WebAssembly for Cloud Native Security Dec 20th 2024 6:49am, by B. Cameron Gain and Alex Williams Amex's FaaS Uses WebAssembly Instead of Containers Dec 19th 2024 9:01am, by B. Cameron Gain Angular Shares 'Potential Ideas' for 2025 Improvements Dec 14th 2024 6:00am, by Loraine Lawson Dapr Graduates CNCF and Connects to WebAssembly Nov 22nd 2024 8:00am, by B. Cameron Gain Why All the Major Cloud Platforms Are the Same Dec 19th 2024 6:06am, by Rak Siva What Do You Lose When You Abandon the Cloud? Dec 18th 2024 10:22am, by Charles Humble Address Common Machine Learning Challenges With Managed MLflow Dec 16th 2024 12:03pm, by Oyedele Tioluwani Your Data Stack Is Outdated -- Here's How to Future-Proof It Dec 11th 2024 11:00am, by Vinoth Chandar Hybrid IT Is Emerging as the Solution to AI's Rising Cost Dec 9th 2024 10:30am, by Jennifer Curry Hendrickson Amazon's Bedrock Can Now 'Check' AI for Hallucinations Dec 17th 2024 11:51am, by Loraine Lawson The Future of AI (And Travel) Relies on Synthetic Data Dec 15th 2024 8:00am, by Shiyi Pickrell Apache Pinot Brings Real Time Analysis to Columnar Data Dec 13th 2024 1:11pm, by Joab Jackson Your Data Stack Is Outdated -- Here's How to Future-Proof It Dec 11th 2024 11:00am, by Vinoth Chandar Who's the Bigger Villain? Data Debt vs. Technical Debt Dec 6th 2024 12:00pm, by Pascal Desmarets How Falco Brought Real-Time Observability to Infrastructure Dec 26th 2024 5:52am, by Heather Joslyn Developers Are Key to Stopping Rising API Security Threat Dec 23rd 2024 12:05pm, by Loraine Lawson DevOps and Security: How To Build Resilient Pipelines Dec 23rd 2024 10:00am, by Alexander Simonov Vuls: A Free, Open Source Vulnerability Scanner for Linux Dec 21st 2024 7:00am, by Jack Wallen CodeGate: Open Source Tool Secures AI Coding Assistants Dec 20th 2024 12:00pm, by Steven J. Vaughan-Nichols Platform Engineering Operations CI/CD Tech Careers Tech Culture DevOps Kubernetes Observability Service Mesh How to Solve Backstage Plugin Isolation Problems With ETL Dec 19th 2024 8:00am, by Roi Talpaz and Sooraj Shah Is Your Internal Developer Platform Missing Orchestration? Dec 13th 2024 11:00am, by Jennifer Riggins 6 Steps To Shift Platform Engineering From Reactive to Proactive Dec 13th 2024 8:00am, by Justin Reock What Makes the Ideal Platform Engineer? Dec 12th 2024 8:00am, by Sooraj Shah 4 North Star Metrics for Platform Engineering Teams Dec 11th 2024 8:23am, by Jennifer Riggins Kubernetes Is Taking Over: Deploy Smarter With 4 New Techniques Dec 26th 2024 12:59pm, by Anne Fernandez Infrastructure as Code in 2024: Why It's Still So Terrible Dec 26th 2024 7:00am, by Joab Jackson Defining Low Data Loss, Downtime Tolerances in Kubernetes Dec 20th 2024 9:00am, by Janet Wi A Starter's Framework for an Automation Center of Excellence Dec 19th 2024 2:00pm, by Joseph Mandros How cert-manager Got to 500 Million Downloads a Month Dec 19th 2024 11:09am, by Heather Joslyn AI-Generated Code Requires a 'Trust and Verify' Approach Dec 23rd 2024 9:00am, by Manish Kapur Mastering OpenAI's Realtime API: A Comprehensive Guide Dec 19th 2024 10:06am, by Oladimeji Sowole Why All the Major Cloud Platforms Are the Same Dec 19th 2024 6:06am, by Rak Siva How Harness' Continuous Delivery Helps Vitamin e-Tailer Bloom Dec 17th 2024 8:00am, by Joab Jackson Three Software Development Challenges Slowing AI Progress Dec 9th 2024 8:01am, by Sabrina Farmer Software Developers Are Becoming Critical Members in The US Space Force Dec 19th 2024 1:00pm, by Rachel Brooks Why Are So Many Developers Out of Work in 2024? Dec 12th 2024 12:00pm, by Heather Joslyn When Prompt Injections Attack: Bing and AI Vulnerabilities Dec 1st 2024 6:00am, by David Cassel Modernizing the Developer Experience With AI Nov 29th 2024 8:00am, by Sabrina Farmer Why Businesses Are Rethinking IT Providers and Shifting to Strategic Partnerships Nov 19th 2024 8:31am, by Chuck Bratton What Happens to Relicensed Open Source Projects and Their Forks? Dec 27th 2024 7:30am, by Dawn Foster Donald Knuth's 2024 Christmas Lecture: 'Strong' Memories Dec 25th 2024 6:00am, by David Cassel Rhino Linux Is One of the Most Innovative Linux Distros Dec 21st 2024 6:00am, by Jack Wallen Software Developers Are Becoming Critical Members in The US Space Force Dec 19th 2024 1:00pm, by Rachel Brooks Elementary OS: A Linux Distro Easy To Use and Easy on the Eyes Dec 15th 2024 7:00am, by Jack Wallen Kubernetes Is Taking Over: Deploy Smarter With 4 New Techniques Dec 26th 2024 12:59pm, by Anne Fernandez Infrastructure as Code in 2024: Why It's Still So Terrible Dec 26th 2024 7:00am, by Joab Jackson DevOps and Security: How To Build Resilient Pipelines Dec 23rd 2024 10:00am, by Alexander Simonov Puppet's Open Source Community Plans to Fork the Program Dec 20th 2024 9:00am, by Steven J. Vaughan-Nichols Generative AI Is Just the Beginning -- Here's Why Autonomous AI is Next Dec 16th 2024 1:00pm, by Gil Pekelman Kubernetes Is Taking Over: Deploy Smarter With 4 New Techniques Dec 26th 2024 12:59pm, by Anne Fernandez Kubernetes, Rust, Linux and DOS? The Year in Open Source Dec 24th 2024 8:24am, by David Cassel Defining Low Data Loss, Downtime Tolerances in Kubernetes Dec 20th 2024 9:00am, by Janet Wi How cert-manager Got to 500 Million Downloads a Month Dec 19th 2024 11:09am, by Heather Joslyn Securely Deploy and Run Multiple Tenants on Kubernetes Dec 13th 2024 9:00am, by Dhiraj Sehgal How Falco Brought Real-Time Observability to Infrastructure Dec 26th 2024 5:52am, by Heather Joslyn Observability and AI: New Connections at KubeCon Dec 5th 2024 10:30am, by Heather Joslyn and Lawrence E Hecht Modernizing Observability: The Shift From DIY ELK to SaaS Dec 3rd 2024 8:00am, by Asaf Yigal Trust Me: Consolidate Your Monitoring Stack Nov 29th 2024 7:00am, by Sainag Nethala How AI Log Analysis Is Shaping Observability's Future Nov 22nd 2024 10:00am, by Asaf Yigal The Feds Push WebAssembly for Cloud Native Security Dec 20th 2024 6:49am, by B. Cameron Gain and Alex Williams Tetrate, Bloomberg Collaborate on Envoy-Based AI Gateways Oct 7th 2024 2:00pm, by Steven J. Vaughan-Nichols Istio 1.23 Drops the Sidecar for a Simpler 'Ambient Mesh' Aug 19th 2024 12:59pm, by Joab Jackson Can Cilium Be a Control Plane Beyond Kubernetes? Jul 28th 2024 6:00am, by Alex Williams 6 Tips to Integrate Container Orchestration and APM Tools May 20th 2024 11:03am, by Chris Cooney 2024-12-27 07:30:50 What Happens to Relicensed Open Source Projects and Their Forks? event, Open Source / Tech Culture What Happens to Relicensed Open Source Projects and Their Forks? Contributor impact varies after projects adopt more restrictive licenses, finds CHAOSS research on Elasticsearch, Redis, Terraform and their forks. Dec 27th, 2024 7:30am by Dawn Foster Featued image for: What Happens to Relicensed Open Source Projects and Their Forks? Featured image by Ursula Gamez on Unsplash. Many popular open source projects are owned and driven by a single company, and in today's difficult economic climate, those companies are under increasing pressure to deliver a strong return on their investments. One response to this pressure has been relicensing popular open source projects to more restrictive licenses in the hopes of generating more revenue. In some cases, relicensing has resulted in a hard fork of the original project. These relicensing events and their forks can be disruptive to the organizations and individuals using and contributing to affected open source projects. Several companies have relicensed their open source projects in the past few years, so the CHAOSS project decided to look at how an open source project's organizational dynamics evolve after relicensing, both within the original project and its fork. Our research compares and contrasts data from three case studies of projects that were forked after relicensing: Elasticsearch with fork OpenSearch, Redis with fork Valkey, and Terraform with fork OpenTofu. These relicensed projects and their forks represent three scenarios that shed light on this topic in slightly different ways. The following summarizes what we found when we looked at the data, and you can dive into the details about these six projects in the paper, presentation and data we shared at the recent OpenForum Academy Symposium. Elasticsearch and OpenSearch Almost all contributions to the original Elasticsearch project came from employees of the relicensing company (Elastic), and the fork was created by new contributors and owned by a single company (Amazon). Elasticsearch Elasticsearch was an open source project under the Apache 2.0 license until Feb. 3, 2021, when the project was relicensed under the Server Side Public License (SSPL) and the Elastic License. On Aug. 29, 2024, it again became an open source project when Elastic announced it was adding the GNU Affero General Public License (AGPLv3) as an additional licensing option, but there isn't yet enough data to include this in the analysis. Both before and after the relicense, contributors to the Elasticsearch repository were mostly Elastic employees; they consistently made over 95% of the lines added to and deleted from Elasticsearch, with almost no participation from contributors outside of Elastic. As a result, the 2021 relicense had little to no impact on contributors, but there was a bigger impact on the users or consumers of Elasticsearch who were forced to decide whether to continue using it, and if so, under which of the two available licenses. OpenSearch OpenSearch was forked from Elasticsearch on April 12, 2021, under the Apache 2.0 license, by the Amazon Web Services (AWS) team so that it could continue to offer this service to its customers. OpenSearch was owned by Amazon until September 16, 2024, when it transferred the project to the Linux Foundation. As with Elasticsearch, most contributions to the OpenSearch repository came from Amazon employees, however, to a lesser extent and with increases in organizational diversity over time. In the first year of the fork, a small number of Amazon employees made 80% of total additions and 91% of total deletions to the code. Only two people who didn't work for Amazon made 10 or more commits, making up 7% of additions and 4% of deletions. In the final year of the fork under Amazon's ownership (before the project was moved under the Linux Foundation), its organizational diversity improved, with 63% of additions and 64% of deletions coming from Amazon employees who made 10 or more commits. Six people who didn't work for Amazon made 10 or more commits, making up 11% of additions and 13% of deletions. In summary, the contributors are mostly from Amazon, but organizational diversity is gradually improving. Terraform and OpenTofu Almost all contributions to the relicensed Terraform project came from employees of the company (HashiCorp), and the fork (OpenTofu) was created by new contributors as a foundation project. Terraform Terraform was under the open source Mozilla Public License v2.0 (MPL 2.0) until Aug. 10, 2023, when it was relicensed along with HashiCorp's other open source projects (e.g., Vagrant, Vault) to the Business Source License (BSL). Similar to Elasticsearch, the Terraform repository had very few contributors who weren't HashiCorp employees. In the year before and the year after relicensing, there were only two contributors to Terraform who were not affiliated with HashiCorp, and they both made a very small number of contributions. Since there were so few contributions from outside of the company, there was no substantial impact on the contributor community from the relicensing event, so the only people affected would likely have been Terraform users. OpenTofu OpenTofu was forked from Terraform on Aug. 25, 2023, by a group of users as a Linux Foundation project under the MPL 2.0. These users were starting from scratch with the codebase since no contributors to the OpenTofu repository had previously contributed to Terraform. Contributions came from 31 people at 11 organizations who made five or more contributions to the OpenTofu repository in the first year. The most substantial contributions came from Spacelift, whose employees made over half of the additions and deletions. Employees from Env0 and Scalr have also made a few contributions, so there is some organizational diversity across the project. Redis and Valkey The relicensed project (Redis) had significant numbers of contributors who were not employed by the company, and the fork (Valkey) was created by those existing contributors as a foundation project. Redis The Redis project was an open source project under the Berkeley Software Distribution 3-clause (BSD-3) until March 20, 2024, when the project was relicensed under the Redis Source Available License (RSALv2) and the SSPLv1. This was contrary to the 2018 Redis blog post stating that the Redis open source project would always remain under the BSD license. The Redis project differs from Elasticsearch and Terraform in the number of contributions to the Redis repository from people who were not employees of Redis. In the year leading up to the relicense, when Redis was still open source, there were substantial contributions from employees of other companies: Twice as many non-Redis employees made five or more commits, and about a dozen employees of other companies made almost twice as many commits as Redis employees made. In the six months after the relicense, all of the external contributors from companies (including Amazon, Alibaba, Tencent, Huawei and Ericsson) who contributed over five commits to the Redis project in the year prior to the relicense stopped contributing. In sum, Redis had strong organizational diversity before the relicense, but only Redis employees made significant contributions afterward. Valkey Valkey was forked from Redis 7.2.4 on March 28, 2024, as a Linux Foundation project under the BSD-3 license. The fork was driven by a group of people who previously contributed to Redis with public support from their employers. Within its first six months, the Valkey repository had 29 contributors employed at 10 companies, and 18 of those people previously contributed to Redis. Valkey has a diverse set of contributors from various companies, with Amazon having the most contributors. Next Steps This is the first step in a much larger research project underway within the CHAOSS Data Science Working Group. To date, we've only looked at the primary repository and organizational affiliation data for each project, so we're working toward including more repositories and additional metrics to better understand the project health dynamics within these projects. We also might expand to look at other projects that were forked after being relicensed. Looking at all of these projects together, we see that the forks from relicensed projects tend to have more organizational diversity than the original projects. This is especially true when the forks are created under a neutral foundation, like the Linux Foundation, rather than forked by a single company. It is still too early to understand the ultimate success or failure of these projects -- both the original and the fork. The new forks have more organizational diversity, and projects with greater organizational diversity tend to be more sustainable. However, we don't yet know if this will be true for these projects, especially for companies that continue struggling to meet their investors' expectations. CHAOSS will take part in State of Open Con, a conference covering open source software, open hardware, open data, open standards and AI openness on Feb. 4 and 5 in London. Alex Williams, founder and publisher of The New Stack, will moderate a track on the future of open source. TRENDING STORIES YOUTUBE.COM/THENEWSTACK Tech moves fast, don't miss an episode. Subscribe to our YouTube channel to stream all our podcasts, interviews, demos, and more. SUBSCRIBE Created with Sketch. [Dawn-Foste] Dawn Foster works as the director of data science for the CHAOSS project where she is also a board member and maintainer. She is an OpenUK board member and co-chair of the CNCF Contributor Strategy Technical Advisory Group. She has... Read more from Dawn Foster SHARE THIS STORY TRENDING STORIES The New Stack is a media sponsor of State of Open Con 25, which contributed this post. Amazon is also a sponsor of The New Stack. TNS owner Insight Partners is an investor in: Spacelift. SHARE THIS STORY TRENDING STORIES TNS DAILY NEWSLETTER Receive a free roundup of the most recent TNS articles in your inbox each day. [ ] SUBSCRIBE The New Stack does not sell your information or share it with unaffiliated third parties. By continuing, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. ARCHITECTURE Open Source Cloud Native Ecosystem Containers Edge Computing Microservices Networking Serverless Storage ENGINEERING AI Large Language Models Frontend Development Software Development API Management Python JavaScript TypeScript WebAssembly Cloud Services Data Security OPERATIONS Platform Engineering Operations CI/CD Tech Careers Tech Culture DevOps Kubernetes Observability Service Mesh CHANNELS Podcasts Ebooks Events Newsletter TNS RSS Feeds THE NEW STACK About / Contact Sponsors Advertise With Us Contributions roadmap.sh Community created roadmaps, articles, resources and journeys for developers to help you choose your path and grow in your career. Frontend Developer Roadmap Backend Developer Roadmap Devops Roadmap (c) The New Stack 2024 Disclosures Terms of Use Advertising Terms & Conditions Privacy Policy Cookie Policy FOLLOW TNS * *