https://phys.org/news/2024-12-critics-fans-perpetuate-album-myth.html Phys.org Topics * Week's top * Latest news * Unread news * Subscribe [ ] Science X Account [ ] [ ] [*] Remember me Sign In Click here to sign in with or Forget Password? Not a member? Sign up Learn more * Nanotechnology * Physics * Earth * Astronomy & Space * Chemistry * Biology * Other Sciences * Medical Xpress Medicine * Tech Xplore Technology [INS::INS] * * share this! * 8 * Twit * Share * Email 1. Home 2. Other Sciences 3. Social Sciences * * * --------------------------------------------------------------------- December 3, 2024 Editors' notes This article has been reviewed according to Science X's editorial process and policies. Editors have highlighted the following attributes while ensuring the content's credibility: fact-checked trusted source proofread Critics, not fans, perpetuate the failed second album myth, study shows by Eric Hamilton, University of Florida rock band Credit: Harrison Haines from Pexels After a debut hit, many bands often find their follow-up album panned: further evidence of the curse of the "sophomore slump," critics say. But it might just be critics saying that. That's according to a new study that discovered that the sophomore slump effect--where a band's second album is exceptionally bad compared to their first and third records--only crops up among professional critics, not fans. "If every music critic has heard of a sophomore slump and everyone knows it happens, they might be convinced to over-apply it in their reviews," said Gregory Webster, Ph.D., the R. David Thomas Endowed Professor of Psychology at the University of Florida and co-author of the new study in the journal Psychology of Music. "We suspect it's a kind of social conformity, which we see in a lot of social groups." Webster and his co-author, University of Hannover Professor of Educational Science Lysann Zander, Ph.D., analyzed thousands of albums rated by professional critics and amateur fans. Both critics and fans said that bands' albums generally got worse over time. But critics were exceptionally harsh with the second album, which was an outlier in this downward trajectory. A band's sophomore slump? A figment of music critics, study finds. A sample of 32 artists' album ratings as rated by professional music critics (thin gray lines) and the average artist for the entire sample (thick red line). Note the "sophomore slump" decrease between the first and second album for the average artist. Credit: Gregory Webster "It's only critics that show substantial evidence of a sophomore slump bias, whereby they are giving artists' second albums unusually low reviews compared to their first and third albums," Webster said. "Fans show no evidence of a sophomore slump bias." [INS::INS] Webster and Zander expected that fan ratings would reflect a broader consensus about a band's true performance. Fans aren't pressured by the same social norms as professional critics. And with ratings from thousands of fans, the researchers could average across a large group to find more reliable ratings. A band's sophomore slump? A figment of music critics, study finds. A sample of 32 artists' album ratings as rated by fans (thin gray lines) and the average artist for the entire sample (thick blue line). Note the absence of a "sophomore slump" decrease between the first and second album for the average artist. Credit: Gregory Webster The study's origins go back to Webster's high school days, when his friends sarcastically titled their second album "Sophomore Slump," and introduced Webster to the supposed curse of mediocrity. Webster and Zander--herself a semi-professional musician in addition to an academic--had to wait until the internet's crowdsourced reviews provided a comparison against professional critics. That doesn't mean it was easy. Webster had to manually enter online review data on more than 4,000 albums. So he popped on his high-school favorite, Pink Floyd's Dark Side of the Moon, and got to work. More information: Gregory D. Webster et al, Burning out, fading away, and the sophomore slump: Critics' versus fans' ratings of music artists' album quality over time, Psychology of Music (2024). DOI: 10.1177/03057356241289076 Provided by University of Florida Citation: Critics, not fans, perpetuate the failed second album myth, study shows (2024, December 3) retrieved 23 December 2024 from https: //phys.org/news/2024-12-critics-fans-perpetuate-album-myth.html This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only. --------------------------------------------------------------------- Explore further We date and marry people who are attractive as we are, new analysis finds --------------------------------------------------------------------- 8 shares * Facebook * Twitter * Email Feedback to editors * Featured * Last Comments * Popular Potential-based goals may hold key to struggling college students' academic success 3 hours ago 0 Number of cats and dogs exposed to cocaine has increased significantly since 2019, study finds 6 hours ago 0 Two Earth-sized exoplanets orbiting nearby star detected 8 hours ago 0 New superionic conducting electrolyte could enhance stability of all-solid-state lithium metal batteries Dec 22, 2024 1 The genomic journey of modern and archaic humans may be older than we thought Dec 21, 2024 0 --------------------------------------------------------------------- [gif] Months after Marshall Fire, returning Colorado residents struggle with health and air quality 1 hour ago [gif] Ants prove superior to humans in group problem-solving maze experiment 1 hour ago [gif] Algebraic geometry offers fresh solution to data center energy inefficiency 3 hours ago [gif] Potential-based goals may hold key to struggling college students' academic success 3 hours ago [gif] Leaves' resilience to raindrops offer insights into energy harvesting potential 4 hours ago [gif] Twisted Edison: Filaments curling at the nanoscale produce light waves that twirl as they travel 4 hours ago [gif] Researchers develop tool to fast-track measurement of protein interactions for drug discovery 4 hours ago [gif] Solar geoengineering could save 400,000 lives a year 5 hours ago [gif] Biologists studying apples discover structural cell protein also directly regulates gene transcription 5 hours ago [gif] Machine learning speeds up prediction of materials' spectral properties 5 hours ago --------------------------------------------------------------------- Relevant PhysicsForums posts Cover songs versus the original track, which ones are better? 1 hour ago Favorite songs (cont.) 3 hours ago Who is your favorite Jazz musician and what is your favorite song? Dec 22, 2024 Why are ABBA so popular? Dec 21, 2024 Interesting anecdotes in the history of physics? Dec 13, 2024 Talent Worthy of Wider Recognition Dec 11, 2024 More from Art, Music, History, and Linguistics --------------------------------------------------------------------- [INS::INS] * Related Stories [gif] We date and marry people who are attractive as we are, new analysis finds Jun 27, 2024 [gif] Similarities in movie review content by critics and general users impact movie sales, study shows Oct 7, 2022 [gif] How our shared need for belonging made May the 4th a sacred Star Wars holiday May 2, 2023 [gif] Calculating disease risk in individuals with previous disease Sep 13, 2023 [gif] Abba: Who actually likes them? Sep 7, 2021 [gif] Fans love musicians' personalities as much as their music Jul 2, 2020 * Recommended for you [gif] Potential-based goals may hold key to struggling college students' academic success 3 hours ago [gif] Avoiding customer backlash: Study highlights importance of transparency in return policy changes 8 hours ago [gif] Plumbing poverty: More people living without running water in US cities since global financial crisis Dec 19, 2024 [gif] How UFO sightings can help measure public attention and economic patterns Dec 19, 2024 [gif] String figures shed light on cultural connections and the roots of mathematical reasoning Dec 17, 2024 [gif] Study suggests union membership leads to a longer life Dec 17, 2024 Load comments (1) Let us know if there is a problem with our content Use this form if you have come across a typo, inaccuracy or would like to send an edit request for the content on this page. For general inquiries, please use our contact form. For general feedback, use the public comments section below (please adhere to guidelines). Please select the most appropriate category to facilitate processing of your request [-- please select one -- ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] Your message to the editors [ ] Your email (only if you want to be contacted back) [ ] Send Feedback Thank you for taking time to provide your feedback to the editors. Your feedback is important to us. However, we do not guarantee individual replies due to the high volume of messages. E-mail the story Critics, not fans, perpetuate the failed second album myth, study shows Your friend's email [ ] Your email [ ] [ ] I would like to subscribe to Science X Newsletter. Learn more Your name [ ] Note Your email address is used only to let the recipient know who sent the email. Neither your address nor the recipient's address will be used for any other purpose. The information you enter will appear in your e-mail message and is not retained by Phys.org in any form. [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] Your message [ ] Send Newsletter sign up Get weekly and/or daily updates delivered to your inbox. You can unsubscribe at any time and we'll never share your details to third parties. [ ] Subscribe More information Privacy policy Donate and enjoy an ad-free experience We keep our content available to everyone. Consider supporting Science X's mission by getting a premium account. Remove ads Maybe later Medical Xpress Medical Xpress Medical research advances and health news Tech Xplore Tech Xplore The latest engineering, electronics and technology advances Science X Science X The most comprehensive sci-tech news coverage on the web Newsletters [ ] Subscribe Science X Daily and the Weekly Email Newsletter are free features that allow you to receive your favorite sci-tech news updates in your email inbox Follow us * * * * * * * * Top * Home * Search * Mobile version * Help * FAQ * About * Contact * Science X Account * Premium Account * Archive * News wire * Android app * iOS app * RSS feeds * Push notification (c) Phys.org 2003 - 2024 powered by Science X Network Privacy policy Terms of use E-mail newsletter [ ] Subscribe Follow us * * * * It appears that you are currently using Ad Blocking software. What are the consequences? x Quantcast