https://www.ft.com/content/151eb482-6415-48a8-bf3f-baed00018c4e

Accessibility helpSkip to navigationSkip to contentSkip to footer

  * Sign In
  * Subscribe

Open side navigation menuOpen search bar
 
SubscribeSign In
Search the FT[                    ]SearchClose search bar
  * Home
  * World
    Sections
      + World Home
      + Middle East war
      + Global Economy
      + UK
      + US
      + China
      + Africa
      + Asia Pacific
      + Emerging Markets
      + Europe
      + War in Ukraine
      + Americas
      + Middle East & North Africa
    Most Read
      + Starmer claims people with shares do not count as 'working
        people'
      + Reeves confirms change to UK fiscal rules to help fund PS20bn
        of annual investment
      + How squeezing the rich through tax may backfire
      + Putin signals North Korean troops are in Russia
      + Europe's economy poised to fall further behind US, IMF warns
  * US
    Sections
      + US Home
      + US Economy
      + Investing in America
      + US Companies
      + US Politics & Policy
      + US Presidential Election 2024
    Most Read
      + Europe's economy poised to fall further behind US, IMF warns
      + The west only listens to what it wants to hear from Moscow
      + Trump takes lead over Harris on US economy in final FT poll
      + Could 'feral 25-year-olds' win the US election for Kamala
        Harris?
      + The tragedy of a 50-50 America
  * Companies
    Sections
      + Companies Home
      + Energy
      + Financials
      + Health
      + Industrials
      + Media
      + Professional Services
      + Retail & Consumer
      + Tech Sector
      + Telecoms
      + Transport
    Most Read
      + US approves lithium project in push to break China's grip on
        EV minerals
      + How an ex-Goldman banker built a $10bn private credit 'whale'
        -- and now may sell it
      + Partner pay at top US law firms jumps to record $1.4mn
      + Tesla shares leap 22% after Musk predicts sales rebound
      + Trudeau to slash Canada's migrant numbers in bid to shore up
        his government
  * Tech
    Sections
      + Tech Home
      + Artificial intelligence
      + Semiconductors
      + Cyber Security
      + Social Media
    Most Read
      + Tesla shares leap 22% after Musk predicts sales rebound
      + Tesla is not a car company but it does a good impersonation
      + Could 'feral 25-year-olds' win the US election for Kamala
        Harris?
      + NHS staff use WhatsApp 'constantly' to share private patient
        data
      + Corporate wizards out-magic the muggles
  * Markets
    Sections
      + Markets Home
      + Alphaville
      + Markets Data
      + Crypto
      + Capital Markets
      + Commodities
      + Currencies
      + Equities
      + Wealth Management
      + Moral Money
      + ETF Hub
      + Fund Management
      + Trading
    Most Read
      + US approves lithium project in push to break China's grip on
        EV minerals
      + How an ex-Goldman banker built a $10bn private credit 'whale'
        -- and now may sell it
      + BlackRock leads opposition to new US limits on bank ownership
      + Putin's alternative to 'weaponised' dollar fails to excite
        Brics partners
      + Strong US economy and 'Trump trade' drive dollar rally
  * Climate
  * Opinion
    Sections
      + Opinion Home
      + Columnists
      + The FT View
      + The Big Read
      + Lex
      + Obituaries
      + Letters
    Most Read
      + How squeezing the rich through tax may backfire
      + My fiscal rules will provide the stability on which growth
        depends
      + The west only listens to what it wants to hear from Moscow
      + Tesla is not a car company but it does a good impersonation
      + The tragedy of a 50-50 America
  * Lex
  * Work & Careers
    Sections
      + Work & Careers Home
      + Business School Rankings
      + Business Education
      + Europe's Start-Up Hubs
      + Entrepreneurship
      + Recruitment
      + Business Books
      + Business Travel
      + Working It
    Most Read
      + UK civil servants told to work three days a week in the
        office
      + Too many women excel at their jobs but are ignored for top
        roles
      + Japan's stock market is producing too many 'punycorns'
      + Why AI is the key to unlocking leadership opportunities for
        women
      + AI-powered productivity tools that can make life harder
  * Life & Arts
    Sections
      + Life & Arts Home
      + Arts
      + Books
      + Food & Drink
      + FT Magazine
      + House & Home
      + Style
      + Travel
      + FT Globetrotter
    Most Read
      + Inside Israel's fight to make fathers of its dead soldiers
      + Beefy Boys, Cheltenham: best burger I can remember 
      + The Room Next Door -- Tilda Swinton and Julianne Moore face
        death with grace and humour
      + Pattaraphan Salirathavibhaga's guide to Bangkok
      + Trump II: the military threat to Europe
  * HTSI

MenuSearch

  * Home
  * World
  * US
  * Companies
  * Tech
  * Markets
  * Climate
  * Opinion
  * Lex
  * Work & Careers
  * Life & Arts
  * HTSI

Financial Times
SubscribeSign In
Search the FT[                    ]SearchClose search bar
    Israel launched a dozen attacks on UN troops in Lebanon, says
    leaked report

Subscribe to unlock this article

Limited time offer

Save 40% on Standard Digital

was $468 now $279 for your first year, equivalent to $23.25 per
month. Make up your own mind. Build robust opinions with the FT's
trusted journalism. Take this offer before 24 October.

Take this offerWhat's included

  * Global news & analysis
  * Expert opinion
  * FT App on Android & iOS
  * FT Edit app
  * First FT: the day's biggest stories
  * 20+ curated newsletters
  * Follow topics and set up personalized alerts
  * FT Videos & Podcasts
  * 10 monthly gift articles to share

Explore more offers.

[primary_pr]

Trial

$1 for 4 weeks

Then $75 per month. Complete digital access to quality FT journalism.
Cancel anytime during your trial.

Select
What's included

  * Global news & analysis
  * Expert opinion
  * FT App on Android & iOS
  * FT Edit app
  * FirstFT: the day's biggest stories
  * 20+ curated newsletters
  * Follow topics & set alerts with myFT
  * FT Videos & Podcasts
  * 20 monthly gift articles to share
  * Lex: FT's flagship investment column
  * 15+ Premium newsletters by leading experts
  * FT Digital Edition: our digitised print edition

[primary_pr]

Premium Digital

$75 per month

Complete digital access to quality FT journalism with expert analysis
from industry leaders. Pay a year upfront and save 20%.

Select
What's included

  * Global news & analysis
  * Expert opinion
  * FT App on Android & iOS
  * FT Edit app
  * FirstFT: the day's biggest stories
  * 20+ curated newsletters
  * Follow topics & set alerts with myFT
  * FT Videos & Podcasts
  * 20 monthly gift articles to share
  * Lex: FT's flagship investment column
  * 15+ Premium newsletters by leading experts
  * FT Digital Edition: our digitised print edition

[primary_pr]

Print

Save over 65%
$99 for your first year

FT newspaper delivered Monday-Saturday, plus FT Digital Edition
delivered to your device Monday-Saturday.

Select
What's included

  * Weekday Print Edition
  * FT Weekend
  * FT Digital Edition
  * Global news & analysis
  * Expert opinion
  * Special features
  * Exclusive FT analysis

Terms & Conditions apply

Explore our full range of subscriptions.

For individuals
Discover all the plans currently available in your country
DigitalPrintPrint + Digital
For multiple readers
Digital access for organisations. Includes exclusive features and
content.
FT Professional
Check whether you already have access via your university or 
organisation.

Why the FT?

See why over a million readers pay to read the Financial Times.

Find out why

Useful links

Support

View Site TipsHelp CentreContact UsAbout UsAccessibilitymyFT Tour
Careers

Legal & Privacy

Terms & ConditionsPrivacy PolicyCookie PolicyManage CookiesCopyright
Slavery Statement & Policies

Services

Share News Tips SecurelyIndividual SubscriptionsProfessional
SubscriptionsRepublishingExecutive Job SearchAdvertise with the FT
Follow the FT on XFT ChannelsFT Schools

Tools

PortfolioFT AppFT Digital EditionFT EditAlerts HubBusiness School
RankingsSubscription ManagerNews feedNewslettersCurrency Converter

Community & Events

FT Live EventsFT ForumsBoard Director Programme

More from the FT Group

Markets data delayed by at least 15 minutes. (c) THE FINANCIAL TIMES
LTD 2024. FT and 'Financial Times' are trademarks of The Financial
Times Ltd.
The Financial Times and its journalism are subject to a
self-regulation regime under the FT Editorial Code of Practice.
[px]
Close side navigation menuEdition:International
UK
Search the FT[                    ]Search
Subscribe for full access

Top sections

  * Home
  * WorldShow more World
      + Middle East war
      + Global Economy
      + UK
      + US
      + China
      + Africa
      + Asia Pacific
      + Emerging Markets
      + Europe
      + War in Ukraine
      + Americas
      + Middle East & North Africa
  * USShow more US
      + US Economy
      + Investing in America
      + US Companies
      + US Politics & Policy
      + US Presidential Election 2024
  * CompaniesShow more Companies
      + Energy
      + Financials
      + Health
      + Industrials
      + Media
      + Professional Services
      + Retail & Consumer
      + Tech Sector
      + Telecoms
      + Transport
  * TechShow more Tech
      + Artificial intelligence
      + Semiconductors
      + Cyber Security
      + Social Media
  * MarketsShow more Markets
      + Alphaville
      + Markets Data
      + Crypto
      + Capital Markets
      + Commodities
      + Currencies
      + Equities
      + Wealth Management
      + Moral Money
      + ETF Hub
      + Fund Management
      + Trading
  * Climate
  * OpinionShow more Opinion
      + Columnists
      + The FT View
      + The Big Read
      + Lex
      + Obituaries
      + Letters
  * Lex
  * Work & CareersShow more Work & Careers
      + Business School Rankings
      + Business Education
      + Europe's Start-Up Hubs
      + Entrepreneurship
      + Recruitment
      + Business Books
      + Business Travel
      + Working It
  * Life & ArtsShow more Life & Arts
      + Arts
      + Books
      + Food & Drink
      + FT Magazine
      + House & Home
      + Style
      + Travel
      + FT Globetrotter
  * Personal FinanceShow more Personal Finance
      + Property & Mortgages
      + Investments
      + Pensions
      + Tax
      + Banking & Savings
      + Advice & Comment
      + Next Act
  * HTSI
  * Special Reports

FT recommends

  * Alphaville
  * FT Edit
  * Lunch with the FT
  * FT Globetrotter
  * #techAsia
  * Moral Money
  * Visual and data journalism
  * Newsletters
  * Video
  * Podcasts
  * News feed
  * FT Schools
  * FT Live Events
  * FT Forums
  * Board Director Programme

  * myFT
  * Portfolio
  * FT Digital Edition
  * Crossword
  * Our Apps

  * Help Centre
  * Subscribe
  * Sign In