https://www.siliconvalley.com/2024/10/07/h-1b-visa-company-supplying-thousands-of-tech-workers-to-silicon-valley-discriminated-against-non-indians-jury-finds/ Skip to content All Sections Subscribe Now 78degF Wednesday, October 9th 2024 Today's E-Edition Home Page Close Menu * Business * Technology * Commercial Real Estate * Housing * Marketplace * The Mercury News * SUBSCRIBE NOW Close Menu Morning Report in your inbox! Sign Up Silicon Valley Technology | H-1B visa: Company supplying tech workers to... Share this: * Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) * Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window) * Click to print (Opens in new window) * * Subscribe Account Settings Contact Us Log Out Spoof a user [ ] Morning Report in your inbox! Sign Up * Subscribe [ ] Search 78degF Wednesday, October 9th 2024 Today's E-Edition Technology * Business * Technology * Commercial Real Estate * Housing * Marketplace * The Mercury News Business Technology SUBSCRIBER ONLY Technology | H-1B visa: Company supplying thousands of tech workers to Silicon Valley discriminated against non-Indians, jury finds Non-Indians 'benched' then fired, lawsuit claimed Share this: * Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) * Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window) * Click to print (Opens in new window) * By Ethan Baron | ebaron@bayareanewsgroup.com | Bay Area News Group UPDATED: October 9, 2024 at 10:13 a.m. A company that supplies thousands of workers for Silicon Valley's technology industry and other Bay Area employers intentionally discriminated against non-Indian workers, a jury has found. The jury verdict against Cognizant, founded in Chennai and now headquartered in New Jersey, came Friday in a class-action lawsuit that revolved around claims the firm abused the H-1B visa process. The visa is intended for workers with specialized skills, and Silicon Valley tech firms rely on it heavily to secure top talent and also to obtain workers for lower-level jobs via Cognizant and other staffing firms. Three U.S.-born workers described in the lawsuit as "Caucasian" -- Vartan Piroumian of California, Christy Palmer of Arizona and Edward Cox of Texas -- sued Cognizant in U.S. District Court in Los Angeles in 2017. Another plaintiff described as Caucasian, Jean-Claude Franchitti, a green card holder from France, joined as a plaintiff later. The lawsuit claimed Cognizant ousted many non-Indian workers by first taking them off projects and "benching" them without work, then keeping them benched until firing them in accordance with a company policy. Cognizant said Monday it was "disappointed with the verdict" and would appeal. "We provide equal employment opportunities for all employees and have built a diverse and inclusive workplace that promotes a culture of belonging in which all employees feel valued, are engaged and have the opportunity to develop and succeed," the company said. "Cognizant does not tolerate discrimination and takes such claims seriously." Federal government data show Cognizant obtains H-1B visas for hundreds of Indian citizens to work in Bay Area jobs per year, said Ron Hira, a Howard University professor who studies the visa and testified for the plaintiffs in the lawsuit. Data from 2023 show Cognizant placed H-1B holders at Bay Area employers ranging from Google, Meta and Apple to PG&E, Kaiser Permanente and Walmart. The H-1B has become a political flashpoint. Critics point to abuses including replacement of U.S. workers by visa holders, while the tech industry lobbies to boost the annual cap on new visas past 85,000. The most recent research, by the Bay Area Council, showed nearly 60,000 foreign citizens on the H-1B were approved to work for Bay Area companies in 2019. The vast majority are from India. Because of Cognizant's preference for Indian workers, it seeks as many visas as possible, and the company has become a top recipient of H-1B visas by submitting visa applications tied to "jobs that do not exist," the lawsuit alleged. Rules for the H-1B require companies applying for it to have a job the visa holder will fill, Hira noted. Obtaining visas for non-existent jobs "crowds out companies that are looking for the one real worker that they want," Hira said. Piroumian, a highly experienced software engineer, started at Cognizant in 2012 and "was repeatedly removed from positions servicing Cognizant clients prematurely and replaced with less qualified, Indian ... employees," the lawsuit alleged. In mid-2017, the company "benched" him, then, following company policy to terminate employees after more than five weeks on the bench, fired him six weeks later, the lawsuit claimed. Cox, also with decades of experience, started at Cognizant in 2014, and was benched in January 2017, the lawsuit said. He interviewed for several open roles in the company, but "less qualified Indian ... employees were selected," and he was fired while benched that April, the lawsuit alleged. Palmer, hired in 2012, had not been benched, but also was "repeatedly removed" from projects and replaced with Indian workers, including after a forced transfer from Tucson, Arizona to California, and after another transfer requested by Cognizant from California to Phoenix, the lawsuit alleged. Palmer also claimed she was deliberately excluded from most team meetings, and the few times she was invited, Indian managers would turn their backs on her when she spoke, the lawsuit claimed. She alleged that discrimination and a hostile work environment forced her to resign in 2016. Franchitti, with a PhD in computer science, was hired in 2007, and in his nine years at Cognizant as a director an executive, witnessed the company's preference for Indians on visas, the lawsuit claimed. When he secured new business for the company, his manager "would staff the client projects with visa-holding employees from India, rather than non-Indian members of Mr. Franchitti's group who were already in the U.S. and available for this work," the lawsuit alleged. Franchitti was fired in 2016 after complaining repeatedly that he was being made to sign hundreds of fraudulent invitation letters supporting H-1B visa applications for jobs that didn't exist, the lawsuit claimed. The allegedly fraudulent letters are part of Cognizant's scheme to secure vast numbers of H-1B visas and build a "robust inventory" of Indian nationals to be placed in U.S. companies when opportunities arise, the lawsuit alleged. "These individuals are given first -- if not exclusive -- preference for new U.S. positions, as they become available," the lawsuit claimed. "Non-Indians are disproportionately relegated to the bench, as jobs are given to ... Indians." Most of Cognizant's U.S. workforce are on visas, the majority in jobs for which there is "an abundance of capable and qualified U.S. workers who can do the work and want the jobs," Hira said. The jury recommended that the court hit Cognizant with punitive damages. Originally Published: October 7, 2024 at 4:26 p.m. Share this: * Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) * Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window) * Click to print (Opens in new window) * Most Popular Most Popular * Now that homebuyers are on the hook for paying agent commissions, some ask: Is this worth it? Now that homebuyers are on the hook for paying agent commissions, some ask: Is this worth it? * H-1B visa: Company supplying thousands of tech workers to Silicon Valley discriminated against non-Indians, jury finds H-1B visa: Company supplying thousands of tech workers to Silicon Valley discriminated against non-Indians, jury finds * Lender seizes big San Jose office building in grim sign of market woes Lender seizes big San Jose office building in grim sign of market woes * Approval of Kaiser Permanente's new hospital seen as win-win for San Jose's residents and its economy Approval of Kaiser Permanente's new hospital seen as win-win for San Jose's residents and its economy * California tax preparer sentenced to 6 years in prison for $28 million IRS scheme California tax preparer sentenced to 6 years in prison for $28 million IRS scheme * Troubled San Jose housing tower switches gears from sales to rentals Troubled San Jose housing tower switches gears from sales to rentals * Big tech company extends real estate shopping spree in East Bay Big tech company extends real estate shopping spree in East Bay * Office vacancy levels soar to record highs in biggest Bay Area markets Office vacancy levels soar to record highs in biggest Bay Area markets * VTA picks downtown San Jose office tower for transit agency's new HQ VTA picks downtown San Jose office tower for transit agency's new HQ * With jobs and city services at stake, why are the terms of the Oakland Coliseum sale being changed? With jobs and city services at stake, why are the terms of the Oakland Coliseum sale being changed? Trending Nationally * Category 4 Hurricane Milton spawning tornadoes ahead of Florida landfall * WATCH LIVE: Hurricane Milton webcams capture scene across Florida * 5 killed in plane crash on California's Catalina Island * Sean 'Diddy' Combs appeals detention in sex trafficking case * Colorado Supreme Court dismisses transgender cake case on technicality More in Technology * SUBSCRIBER ONLY Real Estate | VTA picks downtown San Jose office tower for transit agency's new HQ * SUBSCRIBER ONLY Business | Major San Jose job hub eyes business improvement district status to improve safety, reduce blight * SUBSCRIBER ONLY Approval of Kaiser Permanente's new hospital seen as win-win for San Jose's residents and its economy * SUBSCRIBER ONLY Real Estate | Office vacancy levels soar to record highs in biggest Bay Area markets * 2024 * October * 7 Silicon Valley * News Alerts + Today's e-Edition + Email Newsletters + Mobile Apps * Member Services + Subscribe + Manage Subscriptions + Archive Search + Reprints + Sitemap * Contact Us + Join our Team + Privacy Policy + Accessibility * Marketplace + Jobs + Real Estate + Lottery * Classifieds + Public Notices + Advertise With Us + Network Advertising * Subscribe Now * Terms of Use * Accessibility * Cookie Policy * Cookie Preferences * California Notice at Collection * Notice of Financial Incentive * Do Not Sell/Share My Personal Information * Powered by WordPress.com VIP Copyright (c) 2024 MediaNews Group Bay Area News Group Close