https://www.asahi.com/ajw/articles/15406598 Skip to content Your browser does not support JavaScript, or it is disabled.Please check the site policy for more information. The Asahi Shimbun | Asia & Japan Watch * [ ] [Search] * Twitter * Facebook Language * Ri Ben Yu * English * HOME * What's New * National Report * Politics * Business * Asia & World + China + Korean Peninsula + Around Asia + World * Sci & Tech * Culture + Style + Food + Movies + Manga & Anime + People * Travel * Sports * Opinion + Editorial + Vox Populi + Views * Special The Asahi Shimbun > National Report > article Safety costs for nuclear plants in Japan now stand at 6 trillion yen THE ASAHI SHIMBUN September 27, 2024 at 07:00 JST * Share * Tweet list * Print Photo/Illutration Tohoku Electric Power Co.'s Onagawa nuclear power plant in Onagawa, Miyagi Prefecture, in March 2023 (Asahi Shimbun file photo) Costs for anti-terrorism and other safety measures to restart idle reactors in the aftermath of the 2011 Fukushima nuclear disaster now stand at more than 6 trillion yen ($41 billion), an Asahi Shimbun survey found. The outlays incurred by the nation's 11 utilities have significantly undermined the cost advantage of nuclear power generation, experts say. Some sites face situations that are peculiar to them alone, which ramped up the overall total. The Asahi Shimbun has maintained an annual check on outlays for safety measures since 2013. Revised regulatory standards drawn up by the nation's nuclear watchdog after the 2011 disaster obliged the 11 utilities to take steps at their facilities against earthquakes and tsunami and guard against terrorist attacks. The results of an Asahi questionnaire in July showed that total costs borne by utilities reached 6.15 trillion yen. The eye-watering sum was in part due to increased expenditures by Chugoku Electric Power Co. and Hokkaido Electric Power Co. compared with the previous year. Chugoku Electric is planning to restart the No. 2 reactor at its Shimane nuclear power plant in Matsue in December. In addition, the No. 3 reactor now under construction at the facility is undergoing screening by the Nuclear Regulation Authority. For these reasons, the utility's safety costs increased by 220 billion yen to 900 billion from a year earlier. Hokkaido Electric logged an increase of 39.6 billion yen from the previous year by investing 261.8 billion yen to erect a coastal levee to block tsunami at its Tomari nuclear plant in Hokkaido. TOUGHER CRITERIA To date, 12 reactors at six nuclear power plants operated by Kansai Electric Power Co., Shikoku Electric Power Co. and Kyushu Electric Power Co. have been brought back online. Based on responses to the Asahi Shimbun survey, safety costs per reactor for the three operators are estimated at around 200 billion yen, which includes spending for the compulsory introduction of anti-terrorism equipment. The costs of enhanced security at reactors now moving toward resuming operations following NRA screening are expected to be far higher. For example, putting a reactor into operation at the Shimane plant entails an outlay of 300 billion yen. The figure excludes additional expenses mandated by the NRA for anti-terrorism measures. Tohoku Electric Power Co. intends to shell out 710 billion yen to reactivate the No. 2 reactor at its Onagawa nuclear power plant in Miyagi Prefecture around November. Tohoku Electric explained that forecasts of stronger earthquake and tsunami are pushing up costs for reactor restarts compared with earlier outlays. All six reactivated plants are projected to be able to withstand maximum tsunami heights of under 10 meters. The strongest possible temblor is expected to churn less than 1,000 gals--a measure of tremor acceleration--at these facilities. In sharp contrast, it has been assumed that the Onagawa nuclear power plant could be hit by tsunami up to 23.1 meters in height, with the strongest quake estimated at 1,000 gals. This led to building an anti-wave levee standing 29 meters above sea level. The Shimane nuclear power plant also has a levee standing 15 meters above sea level to protect the premises from tsunami with a maximum potential height of 11.9 meters and the strongest possible tremor of 820 gals. "Differences in countermeasures against tsunami and earthquakes can have a grave impact on total spending," noted Satoshi Sato, a former engineer at a reactor manufacturer, referring to the staggering 100 billion yen or more required to construct an anti-tsunami levee. Sato pointed out that enhancing the seismic resistance of piping and equipment is apt to be costly because the procedure is so complicated. Several other reactors currently undergoing inspection for potential restarts are expected to face severe earthquakes and tsunami in the future. Sato stressed that safety measures for some nuclear power plants "may become particularly expensive as well from now on." The ballooning costs could lessen the competitiveness of nuclear power generation. The government's 2021 cost prediction for each power source considered nuclear electricity plants that had applied to the NRA for screening. Safety measure expenses per reactor were estimated at around 200 billion yen, a sum that was utilized to determine the cost of building a new nuclear power plant. (This article was written by Keitaro Fukuchi and Fumi Yada.) Related News * [178a6c68f1] Backfitting rule on nuclear safety could strain utilities' finances March 17, 2020 * [b8add300ff] Kyushu Electric halts 2nd reactor after anti-terror deadline missed May 21, 2020 * [6b51ba9c27] Nuclear reactor in Shimane capital clears safety inspection September 16, 2021 * [c6688de755] Court retracts NRA approval of safety measures at nuclear plant December 4, 2020 * Share * Tweet list * Print * * Trending Now (*) Last 24 hours ( ) Last 7 days 1. Photo/Illutration Ishiba wins LDP presidential election in runoff over Takaichi 2. Photo/Illutration SUMO/ Rising star Onosato grapples with 'topknot challenge' 3. Photo/Illutration Factory-turned Nintendo Museum fuses history and play 4. Photo/Illutration Court acquits Hakamada of murder, 58 years after his arrest 5. Photo/Illutration Execution timing for condemned inmates remains a mystery 6. Photo/Illutration VOX POPULI: Hakamada's long-awaited acquittal came 58 years too late 7. Photo/Illutration BASEBALL/ Perseverance pays off for team, coach at Kyoto International 8. Photo/Illutration LDP to pick new leader to replace outgoing Prime Minister Kishida 9. Photo/Illutration Safety costs for nuclear plants in Japan now stand at 6 trillion yen 10. Photo/Illutration Same-sex marriage backed by CDP candidates while LDP mostly silent 1. Photo/Illutration Japan-U.S. team wins Ig Nobel prize for anal breathing study 2. Photo/Illutration As sales of Japan temples and shrines surge, a crackdown on bad-faith buyers 3. Photo/Illutration SUMO/ Onosato wins fall tourney in Tokyo, handing him ozeki status 4. Photo/Illutration Japan issues tsunami warning after 5.9 magnitude quake near Torishima island 5. Photo/Illutration China reveals little about boy's killing; fears rise about frayed ties 6. Photo/Illutration 4 arrested over abusing JR tourist pass for unlimited travel 7. Photo/Illutration Same-sex marriage backed by CDP candidates while LDP mostly silent 8. Photo/Illutration Refrigerators are at the center of this nearly 30-year squabble 9. Photo/Illutration Mischievous cat becomes local sensation at Kochi 'soba' shop 10. Photo/Illutration Noda wins presidential election of main opposition CDP Letters from Death Row TOWARDS EQUALITY Videos * [mqdefault] Spent nuclear fuel arrives in Aomori amid local concerns September 26, 2024 * [mqdefault] Factory-turned Nintendo Museum fuses history and play September 26, 2024 * [mqdefault] Death toll from record rain on Noto Peninsula increases to 9 September 25, 2024 Recommended * Photo Sakura Sentiments Stories about memories of cherry blossoms solicited from readers * Photo Taste of Life Cooking experts, chefs and others involved in the field of food introduce their special recipes intertwined with their paths in life. * Photo Diplomatic Documents A series based on diplomatic documents declassified by Japan's Foreign Ministry * Photo Hanako's Tragedy A series on the death of a Japanese woman that sparked a debate about criminal justice policy in the United States * Photo Memories of Nikkei Americans A series about Japanese-Americans and their memories of World War II * Photo Memories of Hiroshima and Nagasaki Here is a collection of first-hand accounts by "hibakusha" atomic bomb survivors. Asahi Shimbun on Twitter Learning English * Asahi Weekly In-house News and Messages Link * The New York Times BACK TO TOP * About Us * Site Policy * Privacy * Copyright * Contact Us * Transmission of user information to external service providers( Li Yong Zhe Qing Bao noWai Bu Song Xin ) Copyright (c) The Asahi Shimbun Company. All rights reserved. No reproduction or republication without written permission.