https://techcrunch.com/2024/09/22/matt-mullenweg-calls-wp-engine-a-cancer-to-wordpress-and-urges-community-to-switch-providers/ TechCrunch Logo Login * Search * Startups * Venture * Apple * Security * AI * Apps * Events * Startup Battlefield * More + Fintech + Cloud Computing + Layoffs + Hardware + Google + Microsoft + Transportation + EVs + Meta + Instagram + Amazon + TikTok + Newsletters + Podcasts + Partner Content + Crunchboard Jobs + Contact Us Search [ ] Enterprise Matt Mullenweg calls WP Engine a 'cancer to WordPress' and urges community to switch providers Paul Sawers 11:15 AM PDT * September 22, 2024 Comment Matt Mullenweg attends TechCrunch Disrupt NY 2014Image Credits: Brian Ach / Stringer via Getty Automattic CEO and WordPress co-creator Matt Mullenweg unleashed a scathing attack on a rival firm this week, calling WP Engine a "cancer to WordPress." Mullenweg criticized the company -- which has been commercializing the open source WordPress project since 2010 -- for profiteering without giving much back, while also disabling key features that make WordPress such a powerful platform in the first place. For context, WordPress powers more than 40% of the web, and while any individual or company is free to take the open source project and run a website themselves, a number of businesses have sprung up to sell hosting services and technical expertise off the back of it. These include Automattic, which Mullenweg set up in 2005 to monetize the project he'd created two years previous; and WP Engine, a managed WordPress hosting provider that has raised nearly $300 million in funding over its 14-year history, the bulk of which came via a $250 million investment from private equity firm Silver Lake in 2018. It's worth noting that Automattic has a history in backing WordPress hosting companies, having invested in WP Engine itself way back in 2011, while Mullenweg also spoke at WP Engine's conference just last year. Moreover, Automattic also bought a majority stake in WordPress hosting company Pressable back in 2016, as well as Gridpane in 2022. But speaking this week at WordCamp US 2024, a WordPress-focused conference held in Portland, Oregon, Mullenweg pulled no punches in his criticism of WP Engine. Taking to the stage, Mullenweg read out a post he had just published to his personal blog, where he points to the distinct "five for the future" investment pledges made by Automattic and WP Engine, with the former contributing 3,900 hours per week, and the latter contributing just 40 hours. While he acknowledged that these figures are just a "proxy," and might not be perfectly accurate, Mullenweg said that this disparity in contributions is notable, as both Automattic and WP Engine "are roughly the same size, with revenue in the ballpark of half-a-billion [dollars]." Mullenweg has levelled criticism at at least one other big-name web host in the past, accusing GoDaddy of profiteering from the open source project without giving anything meaningful back -- more specifically, he called GoDaddy a "parasitic company" and an "existential threat to WordPress' future". In his latest offensive, Mullenweg didn't stop at WP Engine, he extended his criticism to the company's main investor. "The company [WP Engine] is controlled by Silver Lake, a private equity firm with $102 billion in assets under management," Mullenweg said. "Silver Lake doesn't give a dang about your open source ideals, it just wants return on capital. So it's at this point that I ask everyone in the WordPress community to go vote with your wallet. Who are you giving your money to -- someone who's going to nourish the ecosystem, or someone who's going to frack every bit of value out of it until it withers?" In response to a question submitted by an audience member later, asking for clarity on whether Mullenweg was asking WordPress users to boycott WP Engine, he said that he hoped every WP Engine customer would watch his presentation, and when it comes to the time when they're renewing their contracts, they should think about their next steps. "There's some really hungry other hosts -- Hostinger, Bluehost Cloud, Pressable etc, that would love to get that business," Mullenweg said. "You might get faster performance even switching to someone else, and migrating has never been easier. That's part of the idea of data liberation. It's, like, one day of work to switch your site to something else, and I would highly encourage you to think about that when your contract renewal comes up, if you're currently a customer with WP Engine." 'A cancer to WordPress' In response to the brouhaha that followed the talk, Mullenweg published a follow up blog post, where he calls WP Engine a "cancer" to WordPress. "It's important to remember that unchecked, cancer will spread," he wrote. "WP Engine is setting a poor standard that others may look at and think is ok to replicate." Mullenweg said that WP Engine is profiting off the confusion that exists between the WordPress project and the commercial services company WP Engine. "It has to be said and repeated: WP Engine is not WordPress," Mullenweg wrote. "My own mother was confused and thought WP Engine was an official thing. Their branding, marketing, advertising, and entire promise to customers is that they're giving you WordPress, but they're not. And they're profiting off of the confusion." Mullenweg also said that WP Engine is actively selling an inferior product, because the core WordPress project stores every change that is made to allow users to revert their content to a previous version -- something that WP Engine disables, as per its support page. While customers can request that revisions be enabled, support only extends to three revisions, which are automatically deleted after 60 days. WP Engine recommends that customers use a "third-party editing system" if they need extensive revision management. The reason for this, according to Mullenweg, is simple -- saving money. "They disable revisions because it costs them more money to store the history of the changes in the database, and they don't want to spend that to protect your content," Mullenweg contends. "It strikes to the very heart of what WordPress does, and they shatter it, the integrity of your content. If you make a mistake, you have no way to get your content back, breaking the core promise of what WordPress does, which is manage and protect your content." TechCrunch has reached out to WP Engine for comment, and will update here when we hear back. This article was updated with additional context on Automattic's previous investment in rival WordPress hosting companies, including WP Engine. More TechCrunch Get the industry's biggest tech news Explore all newsletters TechCrunch Daily News Every weekday and Sunday, you can get the best of TechCrunch's coverage. Startups Weekly Startups are the core of TechCrunch, so get our best coverage delivered weekly. TechCrunch Fintech The latest Fintech news and analysis, delivered every Tuesday. TechCrunch Mobility TechCrunch Mobility is your destination for transportation news and insight. Email address (required) [ ] Subscribe By submitting your email, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Notice. Tags Enterprise, TC Venture SoftBank's Masayoshi Son has been planning his comeback Anthony Ha 2 hours ago A new Financial Times profile of Mayayoshi Son opens with SoftBank CEO seeming to hit bottom, staring at his "ugly" face on Zoom and telling himself, "I have done nothing... SoftBank's Masayoshi Son has been planning his comeback Enterprise Matt Mullenweg calls WP Engine a 'cancer to WordPress' and urges community to switch providers Paul Sawers 5 hours ago Automattic CEO and WordPress co-creator Matt Mullenweg unleashed a scathing attack on a rival firm this week, calling WP Engine a "cancer to WordPress." Mullenweg criticized the company -- which... Matt Mullenweg calls WP Engine a 'cancer to WordPress' and urges community to switch providersImage Credits: Brian Ach / Stringer via Getty Biotech & Health Synex founder, once detained at the border with a 80-pound magnet, is building portable MRIs to test glucose Margaux MacColl 6 hours ago Synex Medical just raised $21.8 million to build a portable MRI capable of testing glucose and other important molecules without the need to extract blood. Synex founder, once detained at the border with a 80-pound magnet, is building portable MRIs to test glucose AI Yup, Jony Ive is working on an AI device startup with OpenAI Anthony Ha 6 hours ago Jony Ive, the legendary designer who left his full-time role at Apple five years ago, is working on a new startup with OpenAI and its CEO Sam Altman. The collaboration... Yup, Jony Ive is working on an AI device startup with OpenAI Transportation Pedego's Cargo e-bike: Sporty, stylish and powerful for $4,000 Rebecca Bellan 7 hours ago The Pedego's Cargo e-bike is marketed as a powerful and sporty ride that's geared towards parents toting kids around town and anyone who needs to schlep heavy gear. I spent... Pedego's Cargo e-bike: Sporty, stylish and powerful for $4,000 Startups Ibotta's CEO explains why startups shouldn't try to time the IPO market Rebecca Szkutak 8 hours ago The IPO market has not roared back in 2024 as many investors hoped it would -- not yet, at least. Elevated interest rates (this week's 50 bps rate cut notwithstanding)... Ibotta's CEO explains why startups shouldn't try to time the IPO market Apps A guide to iOS 18's hidden features and smaller updates Ivan Mehta 9 hours ago We put together a list of some of our favorite under-the-radar features that you might have missed. A guide to iOS 18's hidden features and smaller updates Featured Article Linus Torvalds explains why aging Linux developers are a good thing Linux's luminary linchpin, Linus Torvalds, says that despite longstanding reports of burnout in the open source software development realm, Linux is as strong as ever. Paul Sawers 10 hours ago Linus Torvalds explains why aging Linux developers are a good thing Security The TechCrunch Cyber Glossary Lorenzo Franceschi-Bicchierai Zack Whittaker 10 hours ago This glossary includes some of the most common terms and expressions we use in our articles, and explanations of how -- and why -- we use them. The TechCrunch Cyber Glossary Featured Article Some startups are going 'fair source' to avoid the pitfalls of open source licensing The fair source concept is designed to help companies align themselves with the "open" software development sphere, without encroaching into existing licensing landscapes. Paul Sawers 11 hours ago Some startups are going 'fair source' to avoid the pitfalls of open source licensing AI Google CEO Sundar Pichai announces $120M fund for global AI education Anthony Ha 1 day ago Speaking Saturday at the UN Summit of the Future, Google CEO Sundar Pichai described AI as "the most transformative technology yet" and announced a new fund for AI education and... Google CEO Sundar Pichai announces $120M fund for global AI education Social X reverses course in Brazil Anthony Ha 1 day ago It seems that Elon Musk-owned social network X (formerly Twitter) is backing down from a confrontation with Brazil's Supreme Court. The New York Times reported on a new court filing... X reverses course in Brazil Social Amazon says no to remote work Cody Corrall 1 day ago Amazon CEO Andy Jassy is calling for a full return to office at the start of 2025. For the last 15 months, employees have been expected to work in the... Amazon says no to remote work Hardware Qualcomm may be trying to buy Intel Anthony Ha 1 day ago Chipmaker Qualcomm is trying to buy rival Intel, according to multiple reports. The Wall Street Journal broke the news late Friday that Qualcomm had approached Intel about a takeover. The... Qualcomm may be trying to buy Intel Startups India's Oyo acquires Motel 6 for $525M Anthony Ha 1 day ago One of India's largest startups, budget hotel company Oyo, has reached a deal to acquire G6 Hospitality, which operates Motel 6. Oyo says it will pay Blackstone Real Estate $525... India's Oyo acquires Motel 6 for $525M Climate Electric outboard startup Pure Watercraft is selling itself for parts Devin Coldewey 1 day ago A tough market seems to have put an end to Pure's ambitions. Electric outboard startup Pure Watercraft is selling itself for parts Gadgets Moksha, the gamified meditation device, makes breath work exercises more engaging Lauren Forristal 1 day ago Moksha's meditation tool aims to kick traditional breath work exercises to the curb. As most breathing tools on the market are designed to do, Moksha aims to help train you to... Moksha, the gamified meditation device, makes breath work exercises more engaging Featured Article Tesla Superchargers: All the EV brands that have access EV owners of GM vehicles like the Chevrolet Silverado EV and Cadillac Lyriq will now officially have access to Tesla's Superchargers. Rebecca Bellan 1 day ago Tesla Superchargers: All the EV brands that have access Apps Shelf is a social network based on the media you consume Jagmeet Singh 1 day ago Shelf lets you show what you listen to, play, read and watch online through your dedicated digital storefront. Shelf is a social network based on the media you consume Government & Policy The EU's 10 biggest antitrust actions on tech Natasha Lomas 1 day ago While it's fair to say the EU's antitrust tech enforcement outcomes have varied, one lasting legacy is that some of these major cases served as inspiration for the bloc's Digital... The EU's 10 biggest antitrust actions on tech Social Elon Musk threatened with SEC sanctions for failing to appear in court Kyle Wiggers 2 days ago Elon Musk, the CEO of X and various other companies with the letter "X" in their names, is in regulators' crosshairs after skipping testimony this month in an investigation related... Elon Musk threatened with SEC sanctions for failing to appear in court Venture Adam Neumann's startup Flow opens co-living community in Saudi Arabia Marina Temkin 2 days ago Flow, Adam Neumann's co-living startup, opened a compound with 238 apartments in Saudi Arabia's capital, Riyadh, and Forbes has some details. The opening included an Aztec-themed hot chocolate ceremony and... Adam Neumann's startup Flow opens co-living community in Saudi Arabia Media & Entertainment Musk dodged Brazil's X ban by 'coincidence,' says Cloudflare CEO Maxwell Zeff 2 days ago X went back online in Brazil earlier this week, three weeks after Elon Musk's platform was blocked under orders from Brazil's Supreme Court. That prompted Brazil's top court to fine... Musk dodged Brazil's X ban by 'coincidence,' says Cloudflare CEO Space Cards Against Humanity sues Elon Musk's SpaceX for trespassing Rebecca Bellan 2 days ago Cards Against Humanity (CAH) is suing Elon Musk's space exploration company, SpaceX, for $15 million after it allegedly dumped construction equipment all over the game company's private land in Texas. ... Cards Against Humanity sues Elon Musk's SpaceX for trespassing AI Grok's image generator, Black Forest Labs, is raising $100M at a $1B valuation, say sources Ingrid Lunden 2 days ago Black Forest Labs, an image GenAI startup that only came out of stealth two months ago, has closed a a monster new round, sources say. Grok's image generator, Black Forest Labs, is raising $100M at a $1B valuation, say sources Gadgets Here are the hottest product announcements from Apple, Google, Microsoft and others so far in 2024 Christine Hall Henry Pickavet 2 days ago We've poked through the many product announcements made by the biggest tech companies and product trade shows of the year, so far, and compiled them into this list. Here are the hottest product announcements from Apple, Google, Microsoft and others so far in 2024 Hardware Apple breaks down iPhone 16 repair process Brian Heater 2 days ago Apple published step-by-step instructions for swapping out the new handset's battery. Apple breaks down iPhone 16 repair process Government & Policy The 25 battery tech startups that just got a piece of $3B in federal funds Rebecca Bellan 2 days ago This tranche of funding went to startups across 14 states, but there were certain winners that will see the bulk of the expected 18,000 jobs to be created as a... The 25 battery tech startups that just got a piece of $3B in federal funds Hardware The iPhone 16 launches today without its most hyped feature: Apple Intelligence Ivan Mehta 2 days ago The iPhone 16 officially goes on sale Friday. But for its earliest adopters, it arrives with a fundamental compromise baked into the deal. Put simply, this is not the iPhone... The iPhone 16 launches today without its most hyped feature: Apple Intelligence Security Internet surveillance firm Sandvine says it's leaving 56 'non-democratic' countries Lorenzo Franceschi-Bicchierai 2 days ago Sandvine sold its internet surveillance products to authoritarian regimes, including Belarus, Egypt, Eritrea, the United Arab Emirates, and Uzbekistan. Internet surveillance firm Sandvine says it's leaving 56 'non-democratic' countries About * TechCrunch * Staff * Contact Us * Advertise * Crunchboard Jobs * Site Map Legal * Terms of Service * Privacy Policy * RSS Terms of Use * Privacy Placeholder 1 * Privacy Placeholder 2 * Privacy Placeholder 3 * Privacy Placeholder 4 * Code of Conduct * About Our Ads Trending Tech Topics * Apple Intelligence * Cruise Robotaxis * Amazo Video Generator * iOS 18 * Snap Spectacles * Tech Layoffs * ChatGPT * Facebook * X * YouTube * Instagram * LinkedIn * Mastodon * Threads (c) 2024 Yahoo. All rights reserved. Powered by WordPress VIP