https://www.theverge.com/2024/6/28/24188391/microsoft-ai-suleyman-social-contract-freeware Skip to main content The Verge logo.The Verge homepage * The Verge homepageThe Verge logo./ * Tech/ * Reviews/ * Science/ * Entertainment/ * AI/ * MoreMenu The Verge logo. Menu * Microsoft/ * Tech/ * Policy Microsoft's AI boss thinks it's perfectly OK to steal content if it's on the open web Microsoft's AI boss thinks it's perfectly OK to steal content if it's on the open web / Mustafa Suleyman has a curious understanding of copyright law on the web. By Sean Hollister, a senior editor and founding member of The Verge who covers gadgets, games, and toys. He spent 15 years editing the likes of CNET, Gizmodo, and Engadget. Jun 28, 2024, 8:26 PM UTC Share this story * * * If you buy something from a Verge link, Vox Media may earn a commission. See our ethics statement. 2023 Concordia Annual Summit - September 18 Photo by Riccardo Savi/Getty Images for Concordia Summit Microsoft AI boss Mustafa Suleyman incorrectly believes that the moment you publish anything on the open web, it becomes "freeware" that anyone can freely copy and use. When CNBC's Andrew Ross Sorkin asked him whether "AI companies have effectively stolen the world's IP," he said: I think that with respect to content that's already on the open web, the social contract of that content since the '90s has been that it is fair use. Anyone can copy it, recreate with it, reproduce with it. That has been "freeware," if you like, that's been the understanding. Microsoft is currently the target of multiple lawsuits alleging that it -- and OpenAI -- are stealing copyrighted online stories to train generative AI models, so it may not surprise you to hear a Microsoft exec defend it as perfectly legal. I just didn't expect him to be so very publicly and obviously wrong! Related * AI companies have all kinds of arguments against paying for copyrighted content * The text file that runs the internet * The RIAA versus AI, explained * The scary truth about AI copyright is nobody knows what will happen next I am not a lawyer, but even I can tell you that the moment you create a work, it's automatically protected by copyright in the US. You don't even need to apply for it, and you certainly don't void your rights just by publishing it on the web. In fact, it's so difficult to waive your rights that lawyers had to come up with special web licenses to help! Fair use, meanwhile, is not granted by a "social contract" -- it's granted by a court. It's a legal defense that allows some uses of copyrighted material once that court weighs what you're copying, why, how much, and whether it'll harm the copyright owner. That certainly hasn't kept many AI companies from claiming that training on copyrighted content is "fair use," but most haven't been as brazen as Suleyman when talking about it. Speaking of brazen, he's got a choice quote about the purpose of humanity shortly after his "fair use" remark: What are we, collectively, as an organism of humans, other than a knowledge and intellectual production engine? Suleyman does seem to think there's something to the robots.txt idea -- that specifying which bots can't scrape a particular website within a text file might keep people from taking its content. He says: There's a separate category where a website, or a publisher, or a news organization had explicitly said 'do not scrape or crawl me for any other reason than indexing me so that other people can find this content.' That's a grey area, and I think it's going to work its way through the courts. But robots.txt is not a legal document. It, not fair use, is the social contract that's been with us since the '90s -- and yet some AI companies appear to be ignoring it, too. Microsoft partner OpenAI is reportedly among those ignoring it. Disclosure: Vox Media, The Verge's parent company, has a technology and content deal with OpenAI. Most Popular Most Popular 1. Uber will pay you $1,000 to ditch your car for five weeks ----------------------------------------------------------------- 2. What SCOTUS just did to broadband, the right to repair, the environment, and more ----------------------------------------------------------------- 3. Here comes a Meta Ray-Bans challenger with ChatGPT-4o and a camera ----------------------------------------------------------------- 4. More YouTube Premium plans are coming ----------------------------------------------------------------- 5. Microsoft's AI boss thinks it's perfectly OK to steal content if it's on the open web ----------------------------------------------------------------- Verge Deals / Sign up for Verge Deals to get deals on products we've tested sent to your inbox weekly. Email (required)[ ]Sign up By submitting your email, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Notice. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply. From our sponsor Advertiser Content FromSponsor logo Sponsor thumbnail More from Microsoft * ChatGPT logo in mint green and black colors.ChatGPT logo in mint green and black colors. The Center for Investigative Reporting is suing OpenAI and Microsoft * A hands-on photo of Microsoft's 13.8-inch Surface Laptop.A hands-on photo of Microsoft's 13.8-inch Surface Laptop. Windows on Arm puts Intel on notice * Illustration of Fire TV Sticks and an Xbox appIllustration of Fire TV Sticks and an Xbox app Xbox Cloud Gaming is coming to Amazon's Fire TV Sticks in July * An illustration of a hand holding up a wallet in front of a yellow background filled with money-related icons.An illustration of a hand holding up a wallet in front of a yellow background filled with money-related icons. Know the price-matching policies for Best Buy, Target, Walmart, and others * Advertiser Content FromSponsor logo The Verge logo. * Terms of Use * Privacy Notice * Cookie Policy * Consent Management * Licensing FAQ * Accessibility * Platform Status * How We Rate and Review Products * Contact * Tip Us * Community Guidelines * About * Ethics Statement The Verge is a vox media network * Advertise with us * Jobs @ Vox Media (c) 2024 Vox Media, LLC. All Rights Reserved