https://www.politico.eu/article/eu-council-cancels-vote-on-encryption-breaking-child-sexual-abuse-law/ * Skip to main content Advertisement Menu Search for: [ ] Submit Edition: Europe * Europe * UK * France * Germany * US * + Policy areas o Agriculture and Food o Central Banker o Competition and Industrial Policy o Cybersecurity and Data Protection o Defense o Energy and Climate o Energy and Climate UK o Energie et Climat France o Financial Services o Financial Services UK o Health Care o Mobility o Paris Influence o Sustainability o Technology o Technology UK o Trade o Trade UK * + Newsletters o Berlin Bulletin o Berlin Playbook o Brussels Playbook o China Watcher o Digital Bridge o Dimanchissime o EU Election Playbook o EU Influence o Global Playbook o Global Policy Lab: Living Cities o London Influence o London Playbook o Playbook Paris o POLITICO Confidential o Sunday Crunch * + Podcasts o EU Confidential o Politics at Jack and Sam's o Power Play o Westminster Insider o Berlin Playbook -- Der Podcast + Opinion o All Opinion o Beyond the Bubble o Club Med o Declassified o From Across the Pond o Unpacked * + Featured Series o Bots and ballots o COP28 o Living Cities o POLITICO 28 o Qatargate files + Poll of polls o Elections in Europe o European Parliament election + Politico Live o See All Future Events o About our events * + Apps o Apple Store o Google Play Store + More Info o About Us o Media Solutions o POLITICO Studio o Press o Print Edition o Contact Us o Jobs o Careers at POLITICO POLITICO Pro Europe * Europe * UK * France * Germany * US Log In POLITICO Pro * Home * Latest news * EU election results * France elections * UK general election * War in Ukraine * Newsletters * Podcasts * Poll of Polls * Policy news * Events 1. News 2. Cybersecurity and Data Protection EU cancels vote on child sexual abuse law amid encryption concerns Countries clash over how to safeguard privacy when rooting out illegal pictures and grooming on private chat apps. Share * Share options * Copy Link * EMail * Twitter * WhatsApp * Linkedin Free article usually reserved for subscribers European Parliament session in Strasbourg European Commission Vice President Vera Jourova said Thursday the Commission's original proposal meant "that even encrypted messaging can be broken for the better protection of children." | Ronald Wittek /EFE via EPA June 20, 2024 12:29 pm CET By Clothilde Goujard A vote scheduled today to amend a draft law that may require WhatsApp and Signal to scan people's pictures and links for potential child sexual abuse material was removed from European Union countries' agenda, according to three EU diplomats. Ambassadors in the EU Council were scheduled to decide whether to back a joint position on an EU regulation to fight child sexual abuse material (CSAM). But many EU countries including Germany, Austria, Poland, the Netherlands and the Czech Republic were expected to abstain or oppose the law over cybersecurity and privacy concerns. "In the last hours, it appeared that the required qualified majority would just not be met," said an EU diplomat from the Belgian presidency, which is spearheading negotiations until end June as chair of the EU Council. Advertisement Advertisement The draft law, proposed in 2022, has drawn controversy for potentially forcing messaging apps to scan all images and links to find and report child abuse material and conversations between potential offenders and minors, known as grooming. Privacy groups have cried foul over the law, saying it effectively breaks end-to-end encrypted messaging. European Commission Vice President Vera Jourova said Thursday the Commission's original proposal meant "that even encrypted messaging can be broken for the better protection of children." The Belgian Council presidency has been trying for the last six months to solve a deadlock among EU countries to move negotiations forward to finalize the law. Some EU heavyweights like Germany and Poland have backed privacy experts' warnings that it threatens privacy. Others like Ireland and Spain have insisted on the need for a strong law to monitor online content amid a spike in child sexual abuse material since the pandemic. Under the Belgians' plan, obtained by POLITICO earlier, messaging apps would scan pictures and links when users upload them via their services, and users would be informed of this under the terms and conditions. Users who refused the regime would be blocked from sending pictures and links. Highly secure apps using end-to-end encryption like WhatsApp, Signal and Messenger would also have to respect such measures. The draft proposal however exempted "accounts used by the State for national security purposes." Once EU countries agree on a joint position, they will still have to negotiate the final version of the law with the European Parliament and European Commission. Parliament has taken a more privacy-friendly stance in its own version of the law adopted in November 2023. Advertisement Advertisement Related Tags Apps Cybercrime Cybersecurity Data protection Encryption Human rights Illegal content Intelligence Law enforcement Media Platforms Privacy Regulation Social Media Related Countries Austria Belgium France Germany Ireland Poland Spain The Netherlands Related Organizations European Council European Parliament Our readers read next French PM lashes out at leftist leader Melenchon after antisemitic assault French PM lashes out at leftist leader Melenchon after antisemitic assault 11 HRS ago 3 mins read Centrists from US to Germany move right on immigration Centrists from US to Germany move right on immigration 17 HRS ago 12 mins read Scorched-earth summer: Biden, Sunak and Macron go negative Scorched-earth summer: Biden, Sunak and Macron go negative 17 HRS ago 8 mins read A more humane approach to asylum is in Europe's interest Opinion A more humane approach to asylum is in Europe's interest 20 HRS ago 5 mins read More from Clothilde Goujard Von der Leyen postpones report critical of Italy's media crackdown Von der Leyen postpones report critical of Italy's media crackdown Commission chief staying mum on rule-of-law issues as she seeks Italy's support for second term. Jun 19 4 mins read Von der Leyen buries report slamming Italy as she seeks Meloni's vote Von der Leyen buries report slamming Italy as she seeks Meloni's vote European Commission president trying not to stir the pot on media freedom, four officials said. Jun 16 9 mins read EU scrutinizing media freedom in Italy, rule-of-law chief Jourova says EU scrutinizing media freedom in Italy, rule-of-law chief Jourova says New rule-of-law concerns could trouble Commission's von der Leyen as she eyes Rome's support for a second term as president. Jun 4 4 mins read Orban leads the way in EU election advertising By the numbers Orban leads the way in EU election advertising Among the biggest spenders is Hungarian PM Viktor Orban's Fidesz party. Jun 2 11 mins read * + Facebook + Twitter + YouTube * App Store * Play Store * + Policy o Agriculture and Food o Central Banker o Competition and Industrial Policy o Cybersecurity and Data Protection o Defense o Energy and Climate o Energy and Climate UK o Energie et Climat France o Financial Services o Financial Services UK o Health Care o Mobility o Paris Influence o Sustainability o Technology o Technology UK o Trade o Trade UK * + Newsletters o Berlin Bulletin o Berlin Playbook o Brussels Playbook o China Watcher o Digital Bridge o Dimanchissime o EU Election Playbook o EU Influence o Global Playbook o Global Policy Lab: Living Cities o London Influence o London Playbook o Playbook Paris o POLITICO Confidential o Sunday Crunch * + Podcasts o EU Confidential o Politics at Jack and Sam's o Power Play o Westminster Insider o Berlin Playbook -- Der Podcast + Opinion o All Opinion o Beyond the Bubble o Club Med o Declassified o From Across the Pond o Unpacked * + Featured Series o Bots and ballots o COP28 o Living Cities o POLITICO 28 o Qatargate files + Subscriptions o POLITICO Pro o Print Edition o Research and analysis division * About us * Contact us * Privacy Policy * Cookie Policy * Media Solutions * Research and Analysis Division * Press * Print Edition * Jobs * Careers at POLITICO * Ts&Cs * FAQs * Manage Privacy Settings