https://themarkup.org/hello-world/2024/05/18/librarians-are-waging-a-quiet-war-against-international-data-cartels Investigations and Tools * Amazon's Advantage * Organ Failure * Blacklight * Pixel Hunt * Citizen Browser * Privacy * Languages of Misinformation * Still Loading * Machine Learning * Working for an Algorithm Search term [ ] * About Us * Donate * Awards * Have a Tip? * Team * Show Your Work * Jobs * Newsletters * Events * Facebook * Twitter * Instagram * Mastodon * RSS Feed Skip navigation Menu The Markup Donate * About Us * Donate Challenging technology to serve the public good. Librarians Are Waging a Quiet War Against International "Data Cartels" By Tara Garcia Mathewson May 18, 2024 08:00 ET Viewable online at https://themarkup.org/hello-world/2024/05/18/ librarians-are-waging-a-quiet-war-against-international-data-cartels Hello World Librarians Are Waging a Quiet War Against International "Data Cartels" Digital collections put library patrons' privacy at risk By Tara Garcia Mathewson May 18, 2024 08:00 ET Wide-angle interior photograph of students studying in a college library The Bancroft Library, on the campus of the University of California, Berkeley Jay L. Clendenin/Getty Images Share This Article Copy Link Republish Subscribe to Hello World Hello World is a weekly newsletter--delivered every Saturday morning--that goes deep into our original reporting and the questions we put to big thinkers in the field. Browse the archive here. Enter your email address [ ] Subscribe Please complete this CAPTCHA to help us ensure our subscription list is not abused. hCaptcha accessibility Hi all, Tara here, The Markup's education reporter. You may have read my story about how college students are tracked by one system or another near constantly as they study and move around campus. I focused on a community college in Southern California and a student there who is particularly troubled by the digital privacy sacrifices required to pursue a degree. One part of campus I barely touched on was the library, and that's why I'm back in your inboxes today. Photo of Eric Natividad, wearing a backpack, looking straight into the camera Machine Learning He Wanted Privacy. His College Gave Him None A Markup examination of a typical college shows how students are subject to a vast and growing array of watchful tech, including homework trackers, test-taking software, and even license plate readers November 30, 2023 08:00 ET Libraries have long been bastions of privacy. In fact, the American Library Association first put a right to privacy into its Bill of Rights in 1939. Librarians have since stood up time and again, refusing to keep records of what people borrow and thwarting occasional government interest in obtaining that sort of information. Yet while privacy is at the heart of many librarians' work, it is becoming increasingly difficult to guarantee. At a university today, someone doing research through a library is just as likely to access materials in digital as in physical form. And, Markup readers, you know that means new avenues for tracking. Eliza Bettinger, a librarian at Cornell University, is among those with concerns. "For intellectual freedom, you have to have some degree of privacy to explore ideas," Bettinger told me. She is a member of the Library Freedom Project, a coalition of librarians focused on patron privacy in an era of digital surveillance. At Cornell, international students have asked Bettinger how they can keep their home governments from finding out what they're reading on campus. Lucky for them, and any other students worried that their interests could be exposed, circulation records aren't saved or shared at Cornell. This means students can check out physical books and keep their browsing habits private. They can also browse the web and many library databases from library computers without needing to sign in. The university has even taken steps to preserve their privacy when they log in remotely to access digital library resources like academic journals and databases--a harder task, on the technical side. For intellectual freedom, you have to have some degree of privacy to explore ideas. Eliza Bettinger, librarian, Cornell University Bettinger and two co-authors described why and how to follow Cornell's lead in a recent paper for the Licensing Privacy Project, which advocates for securing library patrons' digital privacy through contract negotiations with vendors. Most universities don't. They share personally identifiable data like usernames and email addresses with companies that sell databases of academic journals and other library resources, one of the practices Bettinger and her co-authors say cedes ground to "corporate data cartels whose interest is less to support rich discovery experiences than to enclose the research process within siloed and surveilled profit-making systems." Sounds extreme, right? Well, companies that got their start as academic publishers have spent the last several decades transforming themselves into hugely profitable data analytics firms. Elsevier, for example, owns ScienceDirect, the premier database of peer-reviewed journals. It is a subsidiary of RELX, a global data broker that also owns LexisNexis and collects massive databases of personal information it then sells to government agencies and businesses to use in algorithms for things like policing, insurance, and banking. There are concerns the company could add library data directly to that mix. (If you want to go further down this rabbit hole, check out Sarah Lamdan's book, Data Cartels, which delves deeply into the web of surveillance and data analytics at the heart of both RELX's and Thomson Reuters' business models.) Report Deeply and Fix Things [support_wo] Because it turns out moving fast and breaking things broke some super important things. Give Now Like the Licensing Privacy Project, the open-access advocacy group SPARC has also focused on contracts as a source of leverage. A paper SPARC commissioned analyzing contracts with Elsevier noted that "user tracking that would be unthinkable in a physical library setting now happens routinely through publisher platforms." Nick Shockey, SPARC's director of programs and engagement, told me this sort of tracking has been allowed to spread because higher ed administrators haven't shifted to see publishing companies like Elsevier for what they are now: tech companies. "With the largest tech companies, there's an increased level of awareness of privacy risks," Shockey said. But academic publishers don't yet get the skepticism they deserve. SPARC is among those trying to set the record straight. Stay tuned for more from me on privacy and surveillance in the education space. And reach out if you have any tips! Tara Garcia Mathewson P.S. Hello World is taking a break next week for Memorial Day Weekend. Look for us in your inboxes on Saturday, June 1. We don't only investigate technology. We instigate change. Your donations power our award-winning reporting and our tools. Together we can do more. Give now. Donate Now You just read Librarians Are Waging a Quiet War Against International "Data Cartels" From the series -- Hello World Share This Article Copy Link Republish Credits * Headshot of Tara Garcia Mathewson Tara Garcia Mathewson Investigative Reporter Design and Graphics * Gabriel Hongsdusit Engagement * Xinyan Fu Editing * Ryan Tate Close Republish Librarians Are Waging a Quiet War Against International "Data Cartels" We're happy to make this story available to republish for free under the conditions of an Attribution-NonCommercial-No Derivatives Creative Commons license. Please adhere to the following: * Notify us: Please email us at republish@themarkup.org to let us know if you've republished the story. * Give prominent credit to The Markup and its journalists: Credit our authors at the top of the article and any other byline areas of your publication. * Do not edit the article: The complete, unaltered article text must be published. If you wish to translate the article, please contact us for approval. * Access to the article must remain free: Do not sell access to this article or place it behind a paywall, but you can republish our articles on sites with ads. * Images may not be available for republication: Not all of the imagery used in articles published on our site are licensed under Creative Commons. Some images are from commercial providers who do not allow their images to be republished without permission or payment. If you wish to use any image from our articles, email us at republish@themarkup.org for guidance. * Use the provided HTML to republish this article on your site: Simply copy the HTML that we have provided and publish it as is on your website. The provided HTML snippet includes all text formatting and hyperlinks, the author byline, and credit to The Markup. If the HTML code for The Markup credit image is incompatible with your CMS, let us know if you remove it. [Some placeholder tex] Copy HTML The Latest Illustration of a person signing an application form while another, with a browser for a head, holds the form; the browser-person is secretly passing a folder to a Facebook logo-shaped opening behind their back Pixel Hunt Mortgage Brokers Sent People's Estimated Credit, Address, and Veteran Status to Facebook More than 200 national and regional lenders share sensitive user data with Facebook. Experts say it might be illegal May 15, 2024 05:00 ET Collage of the featured images of the six stories that won the 2024 Awards of Excellence from the Society for News Design Inside The Markup The Markup Wins Six Awards of Excellence from the Society for News Design The global contest recognizes excellence in visual storytelling, design, and journalism May 14, 2024 08:00 ET Over-the-shoulder photo of a person using a laptop displaying a ChatGPT conversation Hello World This Journalism Professor Made a NYC Chatbot in Minutes. It Actually Worked Jonathan Soma on the power and pitfalls of AI and chatbots May 11, 2024 08:00 ET Return to The Markup's homepage Your contributions help us investigate how technology influences our society. Donate * About Us * Our Donors * Ethics Policy * Events * Board of Directors * Jobs * Team * Have a Tip? * Newsletters * A Letter from the President * Awards * Privacy Policy * Terms of Use * Facebook * Twitter * Instagram * Mastodon * RSS Feed Sign up to get the Hello World newsletter in your inbox every Saturday. Enter your email address [ ] Subscribe Please complete this CAPTCHA to help us ensure our subscription list is not abused. hCaptcha accessibility