https://www.dezeen.com/2024/04/11/tretten-bridge-collapse-norway-timber/ * Magazine * Awards * Jobs * Events Guide * Showroom * School Shows * Courses Follow: * Architecture * Interiors * Design * Technology * Series * Features * Interviews * Opinion * News * Lookbooks * Talks * Videos * Podcasts * About * Comments * Newsletters * Preferences * Submit a story * Advertise * Privacy notice * Contact Dezeen Magazine Next story clear Follow: * Series * Interviews * Opinion * Talks * Videos * Newsletters * Architecture * Interiors * Design * Technology * Magazine * Awards * Jobs * Events Guide * Showroom * School Shows * Courses Search results: Read more: Refine your search: Cats Aftermath of the Tretten Bridge collapse seen from above "Strong focus on aesthetics" contributed to collapse of Norway timber bridge Share: Nat Barker | 11 April 2024 Leave a comment An official report into the collapse of a 10-year-old mass-timber bridge in Norway in August 2022 has criticised the structure's design and construction. Two drivers had to be rescued after the Tretten Bridge, over the Gudbrandsdalslagen river in the Oyer area of southern Norway, gave way as a heavy goods vehicle was crossing. Completed in only 2012, the glulam-and-steel truss bridge was designed by Norwegian architecture studio Plan Arkitekter and engineering firm Norconsult for the Norwegian Public Roads Administration (NPRA). A recent report by the Norwegian Safety Investigation Authority (NSIA) was critical of parties involved in the bridge's construction and management. Norway bridge collapseNorway bridge collapseTretten Bridge collapsed in August 2022 as a lorry was crossing "The investigation has shown that inadequate caution was exercised in the planning, design, inspection and approval of Tretten Bridge, with respect to the risk factors linked to its unconventional design," the report said. "A short construction period, span lengths and reuse of existing foundation were framework conditions for the planning of the bridge," it continued. "These framework conditions, combined with the choice of material and a strong focus on aesthetics, contributed to the structure not being robust." Failings over 2016 bridge collapse An earlier report concluded that the bridge most likely collapsed as a result of block shear failure - a type of fracture - in one of its timber diagonal members that had become weak over time. Tretten Bridge was designed while building regulations in Norway were in transition from a national system to European codes. Provisions for this transitional period enabled the project to follow the older national standards, which unlike the Eurocodes did not account for block shear failure. "In retrospect, all the involved parties can be criticised for selecting and accepting regulations that proved to have a serious shortcoming (block shear failure)," the NSIA said. Tretten Bridge collapse aftermathTretten Bridge collapse aftermath Made from glued laminated timber and steel, the bridge had a main span of 70 metres The report also dealt with investigations of Tretten Bridge carried out after the collapse of the similarly constructed Perkolo Bridge in 2016. It found that despite "serious faults" being identified at Tretten Bridge around that time, little action was taken by the Norwegian roads authority. Guide to bridgesGuide to bridges Read: The Dezeen guide to bridge design and architecture "This represents a system failure in the NPRA, reflecting a lack of knowledge about block shear failure, as well as shortcomings in the bridge management system and risk management," the report said. "The NSIA believes that Tretten Bridge should either immediately have been closed or traffic restrictions imposed in 2016 when finding over-utilisation in relation to block shear in several of the bridge's connections," it added. Six safety recommendations have been issued based on the investigation, which the NSIA said provide lessons for relevant organisations in Norway and abroad. These include reviewing the process for regulating and approving road-related structures and their materials in Norway and clarification of building regulations. Collapse mass timber bridgeCollapse mass timber bridgeAn official investigation has criticised the design and management of the bridge Tretten Bridge was 148 metres long and 10.5 metres wide, with a main span of 70 metres. A report produced by Plan Arkitekter and Norconsult in 2013 gave the bridge a life expectancy of 100 years. "As far as the Accident Investigation Board is aware, there are no wooden and steel truss bridges in the world that are comparable to Tretten Bridge," said the NSIA report (translated from Norwegian). "The bridge was special both in terms of span length and asymmetry, trusses in the same direction and the combination of wood and steel." Aesthetics "not a governing topic" The NPRA is currently undertaking steps to improve bridge safety. Four similar bridges to Tretten Bridge will reportedly be rebuilt following inspections carried out after its collapse. Nine of 14 timber bridges that were closed following the incident remained shut or still had restrictions in place as of last month. Plan Arkitetker has designed many of Norway's wooden bridges. "If you read the conclusion from NSIA you will see that the collapse of the Tretten Bridge was caused by deficient regulations (national code) for building timber structures at the time of planning/ construction," the studio's Yngve Aartun told Dezeen in a statement. Tretten Bridge in Norway before it collapsedTretten Bridge in Norway before it collapsedTretten Bridge stood for just 10 years before it collapsed. Photo by Jan-Tore Egge "When new regulations (Eurocode) in 2016 revealed a few critical weak joints nothing was done to improve these joints," he continued. "The bridge had a normal time schedule for engineering and construction. The aesthetics was decided by structural and constructional considerations and not a governing topic to decide the structure in the planning process." NPRA director general Ingrid Dahl Hovland said the authority is "well underway" with measures to address bridge safety. "We are in the process of signing off on the first measures," she said. "We want to ensure that any nuances between the safety recommendations from NSIA and the package of measures are captured. This work has top priority." Norconsult did not respond to a request for comment. The photography is courtesy of the NSIA unless otherwise stated. Read more: * Wooden architecture * Truss bridges * Mass timber * Glued laminated timber * Building regulations * Architecture * Norway * Bridges * Infrastructure * News Subscribe to our newsletters Your email address [ ] [Next] Dezeen Debate Our most popular newsletter, formerly known as Dezeen Weekly. Sent every Thursday and featuring a selection of the best reader comments and most talked-about stories. Plus occasional updates on Dezeen's services and breaking news. [ ] Dezeen Agenda Sent every Tuesday and containing a selection of the most important news highlights. Plus occasional updates on Dezeen's services and breaking news. [ ] Dezeen Daily A daily newsletter containing the latest stories from Dezeen. [ ] New! Dezeen In Depth Sent on the last Friday of every month, Dezeen in Depth features original feature articles, interviews and opinion pieces that delve deeper into the major stories shaping architecture and design. [ ] Dezeen Jobs Daily updates on the latest design and architecture vacancies advertised on Dezeen Jobs. Plus occasional news. [ ] Dezeen Jobs Weekly Weekly updates on the latest design and architecture vacancies advertised on Dezeen Jobs. Plus occasional news. [ ] Dezeen Awards News about our Dezeen Awards programme, including entry deadlines and announcements. Plus occasional updates. [ ] Dezeen Events Guide News from Dezeen Events Guide, a listings guide covering the leading design-related events taking place around the world. Plus occasional updates. [ ] Dezeen Awards China News about our Dezeen Awards China programme, including entry deadlines and announcements. Plus occasional updates. [ ] We will only use your email address to send you the newsletters you have requested. We will never give your details to anyone else without your consent. You can unsubscribe at any time by clicking on the unsubscribe link at the bottom of every email, or by emailing us at [email protected]. For more details, please see our privacy notice. [Yes please!] [No thank you] Thank you! You will shortly receive a welcome email so please check your inbox. You can unsubscribe at any time by clicking the link at the bottom of every newsletter. Share and comment Share: Leave a comment More * Architecture * Interiors * Design * Technology More bridges * "Ancient glacial landscapes" inform Toronto Port Lands Bridges by Grimshaw"Ancient glacial landscapes" inform Toronto Port Lands Bridges by Grimshaw "Ancient glacial landscapes" inform Toronto Port Lands ... * Suspended bridges connect round cabin hotels in MexicoSuspended bridges connect round cabin hotels in Mexico Suspended bridges connect round cabin hotels in Mexico * Ehl & Koumar Architekti unveils footbridge with cantilevered viewpoints in LitomyslEhl & Koumar Architekti unveils footbridge with cantilevered viewpoints in Litomysl Ehl & Koumar Architekti unveils footbridge with cantilevered ... * Kilometres of suicide-deterrent nets installed under Golden Gate BridgeKilometres of suicide-deterrent nets installed under Golden Gate Bridge Kilometres of suicide-deterrent nets installed under Golden ... * Frankey installs "world's tallest canal bridge" between two Amsterdam buildingsFrankey installs "world's tallest canal bridge" between two Amsterdam buildings Frankey installs "world's tallest canal bridge" between two ... * Provencher Roy mixes recycled glass into concrete of sculptural Quebec bridgeProvencher Roy mixes recycled glass into concrete of sculptural Quebec bridge Provencher Roy mixes recycled glass into concrete of ... * "A manifesto of modernity in a Baroque city" says commenter"A manifesto of modernity in a Baroque city" says commenter "A manifesto of modernity in a Baroque city" says commenter * Stvanice Footbridge in Prague designed as a "sculpture in the city"Stvanice Footbridge in Prague designed as a "sculpture in the city" Stvanice Footbridge in Prague designed as a "sculpture in ... * * * * * * * * Comments Visit our comments page | Read our comments policy Top architecture stories Most popular Most recent 1. 1"Strong focus on aesthetics" contributed to collapse of Norway timber bridge 2. 2Workshop Architecture Inc creates "raw and unvarnished" prefab home 3. 3MNY Arkitekter completes "down-to-earth" house for two sisters in Finland 4. 4Margine draws on Salento's vernacular architecture for Casa Ulia 5. 5Henning Larsen tops World of Volvo with "forest-like canopy" [gif][tretten-br][gif][unfinished][gif][sq-two-sis][gif] [sq-margine][gif][sq-world-o] 1. 1Detroit skyscraper becomes city's second-tallest building 2. 2RAD+ar encloses tropical Frame Garden with mirrored panels in Indonesia 3. 3Humanise campaign creates "boring alter-egos" of UK landmarks 4. 4Dezeen video documents reconstructed spire at Notre-Dame 5. 5Study finds botanical gardens offer "greater cooling effect" than parks[gif][detroit-sh][gif][frame-gard][gif][thomas-hea] [gif][notre-dame][gif][sq-global-] Collcoll hides stairs and seats in pixellated wooden structure at Pricefx office [gif][sqcollcoll-pixellated-wooden-pricefx-offi] Uchronia founder designs own home as "love letter to French craft" Uchronia-designed apartmentUchronia-designed apartment Terra AI "compass" enables users to take phone-free walks Terra AI compass by Panter & Tourron and Modem Works DesignTerra AI compass by Panter & Tourron and Modem Works Design Fala Atelier transforms Porto warehouse into "house of many faces" House of many faces by Fala Atelier in PortoHouse of many faces by Fala Atelier in Porto Subscribe SubscribeSubscribe Subscribe to our newsletters Your email address [ ] [Next] LoadingLoading Dezeen Debate Our most popular newsletter, formerly known as Dezeen Weekly. Sent every Thursday and featuring a selection of the best reader comments and most talked-about stories. Plus occasional updates on Dezeen's services and breaking news. [ ] Dezeen Agenda Sent every Tuesday and containing a selection of the most important news highlights. Plus occasional updates on Dezeen's services and breaking news. [ ] Dezeen Daily A daily newsletter containing the latest stories from Dezeen. [ ] New! Dezeen In Depth Sent on the last Friday of every month, Dezeen in Depth features original feature articles, interviews and opinion pieces that delve deeper into the major stories shaping architecture and design. [ ] Dezeen Jobs Daily updates on the latest design and architecture vacancies advertised on Dezeen Jobs. Plus occasional news. [ ] Dezeen Jobs Weekly Weekly updates on the latest design and architecture vacancies advertised on Dezeen Jobs. Plus occasional news. [ ] Dezeen Awards News about our Dezeen Awards programme, including entry deadlines and announcements. Plus occasional updates. [ ] Dezeen Events Guide News from Dezeen Events Guide, a listings guide covering the leading design-related events taking place around the world. Plus occasional updates. [ ] Dezeen Awards China News about our Dezeen Awards China programme, including entry deadlines and announcements. Plus occasional updates. [ ] We will only use your email address to send you the newsletters you have requested. We will never give your details to anyone else without your consent. You can unsubscribe at any time by clicking on the unsubscribe link at the bottom of every email, or by emailing us at [email protected]. For more details, please see our privacy notice. [Yes please!] [No thank you] Thank you! You will shortly receive a welcome email so please check your inbox. You can unsubscribe at any time by clicking the link at the bottom of every newsletter. Vitra "willing to take risks" over changing products' appearance to improve sustainability, says CEO Nora Fehlbaum Portrait of Nora Fehlbaum by Tom ZioraPortrait of Nora Fehlbaum by Tom Ziora "Tiny homes are not the big solution to homelessness that we need" Tiny homes in Los AngelesTiny homes in Los Angeles Popular jobs Featured jobs 1. 1Senior designer/design lead at Ben Thompson 2. 2FF&E designer at Robert Angell Design International 3. 3Director of business development at Creative Machines 4. 4Project architect at TDO 5. 5Communication manager at Snohetta[gif][ben-thomps][gif] [Robert-Ang][gif][creative-m][gif][TDO-logo-2][gif][Snohetta-4] 1. 1Director of business development at Creative Machines 2. 2Part 3 or architectural designer at Project London 3. 3Project architect at Harper Latter Architects 4. 4Senior architect at Snohetta 5. 5Junior lighting designer at Gravity Design Associates[gif] [creative-m][gif][project-lo][gif][Snohetta-4][gif][Gravity-De] Eight chocolate-brown interiors that look good enough to eat Shadow House, Australia, by Grotto Studio with chocolate brown walls Shadow House, Australia, by Grotto Studio with chocolate brown walls Eight home interiors where mezzanines maximise usable space Dumbo loft with mezzanineDumbo loft with mezzanine Milan design week 2024 guide Illustration of people outside Duomo di MilanoIllustration of people outside Duomo di Milano Dezeen Jobs [gif][RHS--300x300] Highlights * Purple Hibiscus Installations Pink-wrapped Barbican Installations Pink-wrapped Barbican * [sq2-bulgari-octo-finissimo-ul] Watches World's thinnest watch Watches World's thinnest watch * Two women working in an office News Foster gender pay gap widens News Foster gender pay gap widens * Cosway Street housing block by Bell Phillips Housing Fluted housing block Housing Fluted housing block * The Line mega-city at Neom News The Line scaled back News The Line scaled back * La Hoya Park by Kauh ArquitecturaLa Hoya Park by Kauh Arquitectura Parks and gardens Historic park restoration Parks and gardens Historic park restoration * White, blue and black Ombak chairs with armrests by Sungai Design White, blue and black Ombak chairs with armrests by Sungai Design Chairs Plastic-bag chair Chairs Plastic-bag chair * Sprout Ruben & Marjolein by WoonpioniersSprout Ruben & Marjolein by Woonpioniers Houses Bio-based home Houses Bio-based home * Toy Storey by WallmakersToy Storey by Wallmakers Indian houses House built from toys Indian houses House built from toys * Social Housing Revival with 50 overlaidSocial Housing Revival with 50 overlaid Social Housing Revival 50 social housing architects Social Housing Revival 50 social housing architects * Kingston Villa by Fletcher Crane ArchitectsKingston Villa by Fletcher Crane Architects Residential architecture and interiors Richmond Park brick home Residential architecture and interiors Richmond Park brick home * Terra AI compass by Panter & Tourron and Modem Works DesignTerra AI compass by Panter & Tourron and Modem Works Design Gadgets AI "compass" Gadgets AI "compass" * Photosynthetica by EcoLogicStudioPhotosynthetica by EcoLogicStudio Product design Algae-powered air purifier Product design Algae-powered air purifier * Exterior of Aquatics Centre for the Paris 2024 Olympic Games Exterior of Aquatics Centre for the Paris 2024 Olympic Games Paris 2024 Olympic Games Olympic Games aquatics centre Paris 2024 Olympic Games Olympic Games aquatics centre * Gaetano PesceGaetano Pesce News Gaetano Pesce dies News Gaetano Pesce dies Share: * Newsletters * Comments * Submit a story * Advertise * Privacy notice * Contact * Series * Interviews * Opinion * Talks * Videos * Architecture * Interiors * Design * Technology * Magazine * Awards * Jobs * Events Guide * Showroom * School Shows * Courses